Monday, June 14, 2010
Excellent Article by Howard J. Bashman, Esq. on Preparing to Argue in the Appellate Courts
Preparing Effective Oral Arguments for Appellate Courts
by
Howard J. Bashman
The Legal Intelligencer
June 14, 2010
Upon Further Review
The Legal Intelligencer recently hosted a Continuing Legal Education course titled "Winning Litigation Strategies" at which I was fortunate to have been one of the speakers in that program's appellate litigation segment. The subject of my remarks was preparing for an appellate oral argument.
Typically, at the outset of my preparations to argue an appeal, I will re-read the parties' appellate briefs and the trial court's opinion. I will also again familiarize myself with the relevant case law and update my legal research to find any newly issued cases that were not cited in the briefs.
If the case involves more than one or two issues, it is usually a good idea to consider what issues should be the main focus of the oral argument and what issues can be omitted. Of course, the judges can ask questions about any issues in the case, and opposing counsel may decide to focus on additional issues, so a well-prepared advocate will be ready to address any of the issues involved, even those that were not going to be the central focus of his or her presentation.
One of the most important aspects of preparing for oral argument involves thinking about what are the weaknesses and vulnerabilities in your client's case, what sort of challenging questions the appellate judges could ask on those topics, and how best to respond directly to those questions. In addition, it is important to anticipate hypothetical questions from the judges, who are seeking to understand the scope or limits to the legal principles that you are asking the court to adopt or apply.
Appellate courts are in the business of announcing legal principles and deciding the limits of when and how those principles will apply. In other words, if the appellate court is considering whether to announce a rule of law in your case, the judges will legitimately be interested in anticipating if and how that rule of law would apply to other cases involving different facts. This is why appellate advocates must be prepared to respond to hypothetical questions at oral argument instead of simply seeking to evade them as not involving the facts of this particular case.
In reviewing the relevant case law, it is important to focus on whether those decisions are directly binding on the judges who will decide the appeal or are merely persuasive. For example, three-judge 3rd Circuit panels are bound by the rulings of other three-judge 3rd Circuit panels, but they will not be bound by the decisions of other federal appellate courts. Similarly, while a ruling of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania will bind both the Commonwealth Court and the Superior Court, a ruling of the Commonwealth Court will not bind the Superior Court, nor will a Superior Court ruling bind the Commonwealth Court.
If you are arguing your appeal before a court where the identity of the judges who will be hearing the oral argument is disclosed in advance, it is useful to research those judges' backgrounds and also to see whether any of them wrote the key cases on which the parties are relying. In addition, if you are intending to invoke the names of any of the judges at oral argument, it is useful to make sure in advance that you know the correct pronunciation.
If you have never argued before the particular court in which your appeal is pending, it is useful to attend an earlier argument session or listen to the court's oral arguments that are available over the Internet. The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals posts its oral argument recordings online, but Pennsylvania's state appellate courts do not. Indeed, in Pennsylvania's state appellate courts, the oral arguments are not officially recorded or transcribed, so whatever happens at oral argument exists thereafter only in the memories of the participants and observers.
Another thing that is useful to know in advance is whether and how the time remaining at oral argument is displayed to the advocate. At the 3rd Circuit, color-coded lights along with a digital clock allow the advocate to see precisely how much argument time remains. By contrast, at the Pennsylvania Superior Court, the presiding judge maintains a device that will beep when the time for argument has expired, but the advocate cannot see from the podium exactly how much time remains. In that latter situation, the advocate should be prepared to monitor his or her own argument time simply to ensure that the points that need to be made at argument are emphasized before all time has expired.
Inexperienced appellate advocates might view appellate oral argument as the perfect opportunity to deliver prepared remarks to the appellate judges, perhaps in the impassioned nature of a closing argument to the jury at trial, and thereby attempt to evade or ignore the questions posed from the bench. But, in actuality, there is no surer way to incur the wrath of the appellate court.
Questions from the bench should and indeed must be answered directly and promptly, instead of seeking to evade them or postpone them until later. Not every question is a hand-grenade; sometimes, appellate judges toss a lifeline. Be prepared to succinctly state the precise holding that you are asking the appellate court to reach. I do not mean that you should merely be able to state the outcome that you are seeking. Rather, you must be capable of stating the principle of law that will allow the court to reach that outcome.
From time to time judges will ask, "What's your best case for that proposition?" or, "Where can we find that in the record on appeal?" so you should also know at least a case or two that supports what you are arguing and where in the appellate record the key documents or testimony can be found. If you receive a question whose answer you simply do not know, it is better to honestly report that you don't know instead of giving a response that could inflict far greater harm on your case.
The best appellate oral arguments are the ones that are, in essence, a conversation between the judges and the lawyer. It is better to elicit and attempt to address whatever concerns the judges may have about the merits of your case while you still have the opportunity to do so than to cut off all questioning because you are speaking too quickly, too loudly, or too softly. It is also possible to convince the appellate court that the trial judge made a mistake or that the opposing party acted badly without having to be impolite at oral argument toward the trial judge or opposing counsel.
My final thought, for now, on the subject of delivering oral argument on appeal is that lawyers will become better at, and more confident in, delivering oral argument on appeal through experience. Lawyers who are well-prepared for appellate oral arguments, and who have thought about how to advance their client's case while dealing with any weaknesses and vulnerabilities in the case, will not only obtain the best results possible, but they may even actually enjoy their time at the lectern. •
Howard J. Bashman operates his own appellate litigation boutique in Willow Grove, Pa., and can be reached by telephone at 215-830-1458 and via e-mail at hjb@hjbashman.com. You can access his appellate Web log at http://howappealing.law.com/.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Tactic of "Offensive" Collateral Estoppel Rejected by Pennsylvania Superior Court
In Catroppa, State Farm provided the $50,000 in liability coverage to the tortfeasor defendant and was also coincidentally the UIM carrier that covered the injured party. There were also $50,000 in UIM benefits available. The trial court stayed the third party action so that the Plaintiff would be afforded the opportunity to complete her UIM hearing before a jury trial in the case.
The UIM arbitration hearing was held and the award was for $100,000. After the $50,000 third party credit was applied, the net award to the Claimant was $50,000.
The Defendant tortfeasor then sought to lift the stay in the third party matter to move forward with her case. However, the Plaintiff countered with a motion for summary judgment arguing that since both parties were State Farm insureds and since the Defendant tortfeasor was in privity with State Farm through the liability policy issued to her, the Defendant tortfeasor should be considered to have participated in the UIM hearing. Accordingly, the Plaintiff argued that the Defendant tortfeasor should be bound in the third party action by the UIM award since the State Farm arbitrator did not dissent and State Farm had assigned counsel to represent its interests.
Through the use of this tactic of "offensive" collateral estoppel by the Plaintiff, the trial court in Beaver County ruled that the State Farm insured tortfeasor was bound by the Plaintiff's State Farm UIM award. Summary judgment was entered against the Defendant tortfeasor for $50,000, her liability policy limit. Carlton appealed and briefs were filed including an amicus brief by the Pennsylvania Defense Institute.
The Superior Court reversed and remanded the case on the estoppel issue. The Superior Court noted that the element of collateral estoppel that the parties be the same in both actions was not met as the Defendant tortfeasor obviously was not a party to the UIM proceedings.
The Plaintiff attempted to get around this issue by arguing that, nevertheless, the tortfeasor was in privity with State Farm and, by virtue of this relationship, could be deemed to have been a participant in both proceedings. The Superior Court noted that, although the Defendant tortfeasor was in privity with State Farm by virtue of her liability policy with State Farm, she was not in privity with State Farm on the entirely separate UIM policy or contract of insurance State Farm had with the injured party.
The Superior Court was also influenced by the fact that the Defendant tortfeasor otherwise had no right to intervene in the UIM proceedings to protect herself from any award that might be entered in that matter.
Accordingly, the court in Catroppa held that the Defendant tortfeasor could not be bound by a determination from a proceeding to which she was not a party and to which she could not intervene or participate in to protect and defend her own interests.
As such the tactic of "offensive" collateral estoppel was rejected and the summary judgment entered in favor of the injured party was reversed.
A copy of this Opinion by the Superior Court can be viewed HERE.
Thanks to the Pennsylvania Defense Institute for bringing this case to my attention.
Monday, May 3, 2010
Federal Middle District Court Judge Caputo Reviews Value of Emotional Distress Claims
The case stemmed from a suit by a plaintiff who alleged that he was improperly suspended without any hearing from his post as an assistant fire chief when borough officials allegedly incorrectly concluded that the plaintiff lacked the necessary qualifications for the position.
Judge Caputo noted that the evidence showed that the plaintiff suffered emotional distress and an elevated blood pressure "for at least a few days" following the suspension.
The judge reviewed other similar emotional distress cases and noted that, where there is some emotional distress without lasting effects established in the case, the average award allowed by the courts was approximately in the range of $50,000.
Turning back to the facts of the Dee case, Judge Caputo found that the jury's award of $150,000 was "shocking to the judicial conscience," particularly where there was no evidence that the plaintiff changed in any lasting way, where it was confirmed that the plaintiff's blood pressure returned to a normal range within a few days, and where the plaintiff was allowed to continue with his employment with the fire department after only nine (9) days on suspension.
In addition to the Westlaw citation above, a copy of this case can be secured, for a small fee, by contacting the Pennsylvania Law Weekly's Instant Case Service at 1-800-276-7427 and giving them the PICS Case No. 10-1762.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Tips on the Practice of Law From Ferris Bueller
DANKE SCHOEN, FERRIS BUELLER:
Enlightening thoughts for lawyers – from a teen epic hero
by
Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
The recent telecast of the Academy Awards Ceremony, with its tribute to the late movie director John Hughes, brought back to mind many of the teen epic movies of the 1980s along with their famous characters. Perhaps none of these characters were as unforgettable as Ferris Bueller, played perfectly by Matthew Broderick, in Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, released in 1986.
For those who are not of the 80s teen generation or who are otherwise unfamiliar, this film followed a day in the life of high school senior Ferris Bueller, who decided to skip school and, instead, spend a beautiful spring day in downtown Chicago. Accompanied by his girlfriend and his best friend Cameron Frye, Ferris creatively avoids his school’s Dean of Students, his resentful sister, and his parents throughout the day. During the film, Ferris Bueller occasionally turns to the camera and explains to the audience his techniques and thoughts.
Some of those humorously enlightening thoughts of Ferris Bueller, as set forth below, could serve to assist in easing a few of the burdens of the law profession.
How could I possibly be expected to handle school on a day like this?
In the opening scenes of Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, Ferris awakes to clear blue skies with wispy clouds and bright sunshine—it’s a beautiful 70 degree spring day in Chicago. Ferris asks the above question and gets to work on his plan to get out of having to go to school.
How often have you heard another lawyer exclaim what a beautiful day it is outside and lament that he or she is “stuck in here” doing work?While it may not always be feasible to “pull a Ferris” and take advantage of all of a beautiful sunshiny day, perhaps lunch could be had at a nice outside spot followed by a leisurely stroll around the awaking greenery of spring to get some fresh air and clear your head for an hour or so.
On those rare occasions when an sudden, splendid day coincides with a lull in the calendar, see if you can take the day as a way to rejuvenate on a “mental health” day, spend time with family, or (keeping the boss happy) take a client out to the golf course.
They bought it. Incredible. One of the worst performances of my career, and they never doubted it for a second.
This is Ferris’ comment after he succeeds in persuading his parents that he is too ill that morning to be sent off to school. The lesson of course is not that fakery is good—rather, this comment shows that we can sometimes surprise ourselves with how persuasive we can be at times.
In trial, the key to being persuasive is to believe in one’s own objective in the trial and the theory of the case being presented to reach that objective. If the attorney does not entirely believe in the case presented the jury’s radar will certainly pick up on that lack of confidence and may reject it themselves.
An excellent tool to assist the attorney in persuasively presenting a theory of the case is the use of demonstrative evidence and, in this day and age, the use of PowerPoint presentations. A lawyer presenting his case at trial via repeated use of computer powered graphics versus a “talking head” attorney without exhibits is sure to have the upper hand in terms of persuasiveness with a jury.
As the fictional attorney Billy Flynn explains his trial strategy in the song “Razzle Dazzle” in the musical Chicago: “Give ‘em the old razzle dazzle…/Give ‘em an act with lots of flash in it / Then the reaction will be passionate….”
So razzle dazzle them at trial and your client may benefit even if he or she does not have the better evidence to present.
Do you realize that if we played by the rules right now we'd be in gym?
As he sets off and goes through with a day of playing hooky with his girlfriend and his best friend Cameron, Ferris becomes increasingly frustrated with how nervous and uptight his friend Cameron is about getting caught and utters this comment.
Attorneys are born to follow rules and the thought of not following the rules is repugnant. However, there may be times when taking calculated risks and throwing caution to wind may be in the best interest of a client while still playing within the rules and the law applicable to the case presented.
Taking the time to try to think outside of the box or do the unexpected could be the difference. For Ferris, this thinking led to the vast difference of him being at a Chicago Cubs day game catching a foul ball as opposed to being in gym class being forced to climb up a rope or something. In an attorney’s case, thinking outside of the box and taking risks on dispositive motions or at trial could be the substantial difference between winning a case or losing the case.
Not that I condone fascism, or any -ism for that matter. -Ism's in my opinion are not good. A person should not believe in an -ism, he should believe in himself. I quote John Lennon, "I don't believe in Beatles, I just believe in me." Good point there.
Believe in yourself and what you do and no one can doubt you or your motives. Enough said.
Cameron: Ferris, my father loves this car more than life itself.
Ferris: A man with priorities so far out of whack doesn’t deserve such a fine automobile.
This conversation takes place in the garage in Cameron’s parent’s house as the two teenagers look at Cameron’s father’s mint condition shiny red antique 1961 Ferrari GT California. With this comment young Ferris is wise beyond his years.
Sometimes the 24-7 relentlessness of the practice of law makes it is easy to lose sight of what’s important both in your practice and outside of your practice. Stopping on occasion to re-evaluate one’s status in life and re-prioritizing never hurts.
Maybe it will even help your outlook on life to take a moment to actually write down what is important to YOU in the grand scheme of your life and in terms of your goals both in and out of work. Then, don’t just push that paper aside, but make it a priority to put those thoughts into action--today, not tomorrow.
Life moves pretty fast. You don't stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.
Ferris looks right into the camera and hits you with this comment. So simply put and so true.
The law is really only one piece of our short lives. A balance between work and life outside of work should not only be sought but encouraged. Devoting all of one’s energies to the practice of law to the detriment of one’s family, social, or recreational life could lead to a burn out, not to mention great regret.
There’s no slowing down life and it seems the older we get the quicker it goes. So take moments to stop. Just stop. Look around. See what you see in your life and seize and enjoy the moments of your life.
Channeling a good portion of one’s time and energies instead to those important aspects of life outside of work may ultimately have the benefit of making one a happier person and therefore a more productive and less stressed lawyer.
Conclusion
I end this article as Ferris Bueller ended his movie as the last credits rolled up the screen: "You're still here? It's over! Go home! Go!"
Monday, April 26, 2010
Excellent Legal Writing Tips
I also highly recommend Garner's book with Justice Scalia called Making Your Case: The Art of Persuading Judges. This book not only provides writing tips but also oral argument tips.
Sunday, March 7, 2010
Cell Phone Use While Driving: Bringing Attention to Inattentive Drivers
Hang Up and Drive
Lawmakers and courts tackle the hazards of cellular phone use by drivers
Daniel E. Cummins
The Legal Intelligencer
February 22, 2010
A text message exchange between two drivers:
HI. HOW R U?
U R FUNNY! LOL! TSDMC!…OMG!! JUST IN ACDNT!! GR8!…UFB....IM OK…G2G….B4N…CYAL8R. WILL CALL U. BFF
[Translation at end of article].
There has been a great deal of attention paid to the hot topic of cell phone use and texting while driving, particularly among younger drivers. Whether all this talk results in any changes in the law on the topic remains to be seen.
FYI
"For your information," the U.S. Department of Transportation on Jan. 26 banned commercial truck drivers and bus drivers from texting while driving. Under the ban, commercial truck and bus drivers who text while driving may be subject to civil or criminal penalties and fines up to $2,750.
On the same day, the state House of Representatives approved legislation by a vote of 189 to 6 that bans the use of hand-held cell phones and texting devices by all motorists while driving. House Bill 2070 also amends Title 75 by making texting by junior drivers — ages 16 to 18 — a primary offense.
The bill makes violating the ban a primary offense in Pennsylvania, meaning that a driver could be pulled over by law enforcement for committing that offense alone. A lesser alternative being considered is making the violations a secondary offense, under which an officer could only enforce the law if the driver was first pulled over for another traffic violation.
The primary offense, as it currently stands in the proposed bill, would carry a $50 fine along with supplemental costs. The fine would be increased to $100 and supplemental costs if the violation occurred in a school zone, an active work zone, a highway safety corridor or in an emergency response zone.
HB 2070 will now move on to the state Senate for consideration. The Senate is likewise reviewing its own proposed legislation focused on younger drivers that would lengthen the time a new driver would have to practice before testing for a driver's license, limiting the number of teens in one vehicle and making the failure to wear a seat belt a primary offense for youths under age 18.
According to a Jan. 31 Scranton Times article by Robert Swift, the paper's Harrisburg bureau chief, the challenge for the legislators will be to merge the amendments dealing with teen drivers with the provisions pertaining to distracted drivers into one acceptable bill that would be approved by the Legislature and signed into law by the governor. Whether or not this can be accomplished remains to be seen.
"Quick Question:" Should a motor vehicle accident plaintiff be allowed to pursue punitive damages on a claim that the defendant driver was on a cell phone or texting at the time of the accident?
The topic of cell phone use by motorists also came up in a Jan. 14, opinion and order in the case of Linehan v. Jaludi. In that case, Judge Gregory H. Chelak of the Pike County Court of Common Pleas addressed the issue of whether a plaintiff may pursue a claim for punitive damages on the basis that the defendant was talking on cell phone allegedly to the point of distraction at the time of a car accident.
The plaintiff in Linehan was a police officer whose police vehicle was stopped on the side of the road with the flashing lights activated. Another vehicle was stopped in front of the plaintiff's police car. The defendant, while driving and allegedly talking on her cell phone, allegedly drifted off the roadway and crashed into the police car while the plaintiff police officer was inside of the car, allegedly resulting in injuries to the plaintiff.
The plaintiff police officer later filed a negligence complaint in which a punitive damages claim was asserted, in part, on the basis of the defendant using a cell phone at the time of the accident. The defendant filed preliminary objections.
Chelak sustained the defendant's preliminary objections and granted the motion to strike the claim for punitive damages. It was held that the allegations of the complaint — that the defendant was so distracted by her cell phone conversation that she crashed into the plaintiff's police car with its flashing lights — were insufficient, in and of themselves, to support the punitive damages claim at this initial posture of the case.
However, citing the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania case Pennington v. King as offering support for a punitive damages claim based upon a driver being distracted by cell phone use, the Pike County court noted that, if discovery turned out to confirm the cell phone use and distraction, by way of cell phone records or otherwise, the plaintiff would have the right to seek to amend the complaint in an effort to support the possibility of restating the punitive damages claim pursuant to Rule 1033. It remains to be seen if this issue will develop any further in that case.
S2S
"Sorry to say," but it does not appear that legislative or judicial action will have any significant, positive impact on driver behavior in terms of texting or cell phone use. Around the same time the above action was being taken by the Pennsylvania Legislature and courts on the issue of drivers distracted by hand-held communication devices, the Highway Loss Data Institute coincidentally released a new study Jan. 29 on the topic.
According to a Jan. 30 article by Joelle Tesser of The Associated Press, the study finds that state laws banning the use of hand-held devices to make a call or send text-message while driving have not resulted in fewer crashes.
Yet, other studies by the Highway Loss Data Institute, which is affiliated with the insurance industry and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, make it clear that driving while texting or using a cell phone is dangerous. One separate study, issued a few years ago by a group of University of Utah psychologists in the June 29, 2006 issue of Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, has gone so far as to find that using a cell phone while driving may be as dangerous as driving under the influence of alcohol.
According to the AP article, one suggested explanation for the failure of the ban on hand-held devices to decrease the number of accidents in states that currently have a ban (California, New York, Connecticut, and the District of Columbia), is that the ban on the use of hand-held devices may have had the opposite effect of actually increasing such dangerous conduct by drivers.
With these findings that government intervention on the issue of distracted drivers and bans on hand-held devices may not have any effect, or may even have a detrimental effect, other commentators, like well-known Philadelphia lawyer-pundit Michael Smerconish, have cautioned against governmental intervention. The fear is the creation of a "slippery slope logic" for banning or punishing cell phone use may easily be extended to bans or punishment related to distractions caused by eating, using a GPS, scanning the radio, adjusting the heat, putting on makeup, or other commonplace attention-grabbers. Smerconish joins the call for alternative solutions to the problem.
As Smerconish pointed out in his Jan. 31 article in The Philadelphia Inquirer, there is a push by the U.S. Department of Transportation upon the wireless industry for the creation of technology whereby these devices are somehow disabled from use while a person is driving. Smerconish also favors the development of these possible technological advances towards the creation of a hands-free device that is somehow safe for use while driving.
FWIW
"For what it's worth," there has been much recent discussion on this issue in Pennsylvania, but to date, no concrete changes. Whether any of these proposed changes would result in any change in driver behavior in any event remains questionable. For now, it's best to steer clear from these distracted drivers for your own safety.
Translation of text message:
Hi. How are you?
You are funny! Laugh out loud! Tears streaming down my cheeks!....Oh my God! Just got into an accident! Great! Un "freaking" believable! I am okay. Got to go. Bye for now. See you later. I will call you. Best Friends Forever. •
Daniel E. Cummins is a partner and civil litigator with the Scranton law firm of Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins. Cummins' civil litigation blog, "Tort Talk," may be viewed at http://www.torttalk.com/.
This article originally appeared in the February 22, 2010 edition of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly, a statewide legal news publication.(c) 2010 Incisive Media US Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All rights reserved. Please contact the author for permission to reprint or duplicate.
Monday, January 18, 2010
Like A Light Bulb Over My Head
One of quite a few enlightening moments that occurred while reading this book revolved around a lesson in writing the Question Presented section of a brief. I, like most lawyers, had been trained to write the question presented by a case in a single, often run-on sentence, which as the authors noted often turns into "a muddle" which causes the reader to "forget the question by the time we reach the question mark."
Justice Scalia and Mr. Garner note that instead of a Question Presented like this:
Whether there was a violation of the OSHA rule requiring every incident-investigation report to contain a list of factors that contributed to the incident, when the investigation report on the June 2002 explosion at the Vespante plant listed the contributing factors in an attachment to the report entitled "Contributing Factors," as opposed to including them in the body of the report?
The authors note that a better way to present the question would be to break the issue down into sentences like this:
OSHA rules require every incident-investigation report to contain a list of factors that contributed to the incident. The report on the June 2002 explosion at the Vespante plant listed the contributing factors not in the body of the report but in an attachment entitled "Contributing Factors." Did the report thereby violate OSHA rules?
In the above example instead of one 62-word sentence, you have three sentences averaging just 18 words. The information is presented in a clear and tight manner such that even readers unfamiliar with this area of law can easily understand the issue raised by the case.
Concisely, with regards to writing this section of a brief, the authors assert that the better strategy is indeed to break up the question presented into separate sentences that all total no more than 75 words or so at the most. The first couple of sentences or so should be designed to follow a chronological order telling the story in miniature fashion, followed by the pointed question that emerges from that story.
Perhaps a way to ease yourself into this new way of writing the issue presented may be to continue, at least initially, to write out the question the old-fashioned run-on sentence way and then go back and edit down to two to three sentences followed by the pointed question.
I think this new format of the Question Presented is excellent advice and I note that, if it's not only acceptable to, but highly recommended by, Justice Scalia, I would hope that the writing of issues presented in this fashion would be well-received and appreciated by Judges reading our briefs.
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
CAUTION: Lack of Recorded Voir Dire May Preclude Appellate Review of Objections Raised During Jury Selection
The Allen case arose out out of a motor vehicle accident that occurred in a municipal parking garage. In this Philadelphia County case, the local rules required counsel to request a recording of voir dire if they desired the same. Otherwise, the jury selection process was not recorded or transcribed. Plaintiff's attorney did not request a recording in this matter.
After trial, a defense verdict was entered and the plaintiff appealed, in part, on the grounds that the Philadelphia County trial court judge (Senior Judge Jelin) abused his discretion during the jury selection process by refusing to allow the plaintiff's attorney to question the potential jurors regarding their opinions on tort reform.
In his Rule 1925 Opinion on the issue, the trial court judge denied that he had restricted the plaintiff's attorney in any way from asking questions about tort reform during jury selection.
Thus, the appellate court was faced with an attorney asserting that the judge had acted erroneously during voir dire, a trial court judge who denied that he had restricted the attorney's efforts at questioning the jury in any way, and no transcript of the jury selection proceedings to determine who had the more accurate memory of how the events unfolded.
The Commonwealth Court noted that the plaintiff's attorney's attempt to rely upon other portions of the trial transcript that did referenced the ongoing arguments over the voir dire objections were insufficient to create a reviewable record on the issues presented.
In any event, in those portions of the transcripts, the trial judge was noted to repeatedly state on the record to the plaintiff's attorney that the attorney was "entirely inaccurate and...wrong" in his assertions that the trial judge had limited the voir dire questioning.
Elsewhere in the transcript, the trial judge told plaintiff's attorney, "I gave you every opportunity to ask appropriate questions, Counsel. You chose not to do so."
Surely, where the record on appeal only comes down to a judge's word against an attorney's word, an appellate court is more likely to side with the judge, if only to be able to uphold the trial court's decisions and avoid the need for a retrial, thereby furthering the interests of judicial economy in the overburdened court system.
In this case, the Commonwealth Court noted that, in the absence of any record of the actual voir dire questions at issue or the trial court's ruling on the same, the Commonwealth Court was unable to conclude that the trial court made improper rulings or abused its discretion. Accordingly, the trial court's denial of the plaintiff's post-trial motions was affirmed on appeal.
MORAL OF THE STORY:
ALWAYS ASK FOR A TRANSCRIPTION OF THE VOIR DIRE PROCEEDINGS IN ORDER TO FULLY PROTECT YOUR CLIENT'S INTERESTS
AT THE VERY LEAST, REQUEST THAT VOIR DIRE OBJECTIONS AND COURT RULINGS BE TRANSCRIBED
IF COURT REFUSES TO ALLOW ANY TRANSCRIPTION, PUT ON THE RECORD THAT THE REQUEST FOR A TRANSCRIPTION WAS MADE AND REJECTED BY THE COURT
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Another Recent Post-Koken Decision in Favor of Consolidation
As a reminder, "post-Koken" cases are those cases arising after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued an opinion in a case commonly referred to the "Koken" case (the name of one of the parties)--in that case, the PA Supreme Court ruled that carriers could do away with the arbitration clause and allow for UM/UIM cases to be litigated by way of a jury trial.
Ever since, the carriers have issued new policies without an arbitration clause and many auto accident cases have been filed with the cause of action against the defendant driver and the UIM claim being pursued in one lawsuit. Some defendants are objecting to being lumped in a case with an insurance company defendant. So far, the trial courts are keeping the cases together.
In her Order issued in the case of Serulneck v. Kilian and Allstate Fire and Cas. Ins. Co., 2008-C-2859 (Lehigh Co. April 9, 2009), Judge Carol K McGinley follows the trend of allowing post-Koken third party and UIM cases to proceed under the same caption. The Judge denied the tortfeasor defendant's Motion for Severance and, in her footnote to the Order, the Judge wrote:
"The entire cause of action, whether sounding in tort or contract, arises from the same set of facts. Defendant Allstate will be prejudiced if excluded in any litigation which fixes its liability."
Anyone wishing to receive a copy of this Order may contact me and I will be happy to email it to you. I am also in possession of a number of other post-Koken decisions from other counties as well.
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Assumption of Risk Defense Remains Viable in Pennsylvania
Sunday, June 7, 2009
A GUIDE TO DEPOSITIONS
A GUIDE TO DEPOSITIONS:
What it is, what to expect, and how to act.
By
Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
Many people who have been notified or subpoenaed to attend a deposition in a lawsuit do not even know what a deposition is. Simply put, a deposition is your giving of a statement, under an oath to tell the truth, regarding your knowledge, if any, of the subject matter of a lawsuit.
A deposition may also be described as a meeting, usually in the office of one of the attorneys involved, that you are required to attend by a court order to answer questions relevant to an ongoing litigation. There will be no judge or jury present. The proceeding is generally an informal and relaxed one, but is still considered to be serious in nature.
At the beginning of the meeting, the court reporter (the person hired by one of the attorneys to type up everything that is said) will ask the witness to raise their right hand and swear that they will agree to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
The witness will then be questioned by the opposing attorney or attorneys about any knowledge, if any, the witness may have regarding the subject matter of the lawsuit. If the person being questioned is represented by an attorney, your attorney will be sitting next to you during the deposition.
Prior to the deposition being completed, the person who will be questioned will usually have an opportunity to meet with their attorney to go over the ground rules of a deposition. Some of the ground rules, or tips, for a deposition are, as follows:
1. TELL THE TRUTH.
The number one rule of a deposition is to tell the truth. At the beginning of the deposition, the witness being questioned will be put under oath by the court reporter. The oath is the same as the oath that one may take before testifying in a courtroom. If you tell the truth and tell it accurately, you should have no fears in terms of responding to the attorney’s questions.
2. UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION.
If you do not hear or understand the question, politely tell the attorney that and ask him to repeat or rephrase the question. Attorneys are wordy and are routinely asked by witnesses to repeat or clarify the questions they ask. As such, the questioning attorney almost always will not be offended by your request for a rephrasing or repeating of the question.
It is important to note that, if you answer a question, it will be assumed that you heard it properly and understood the question. Therefore, it is important to speak up if you have not fully heard or understood the question presented.
3. LISTEN TO THE QUESTION AND ANSWER ONLY THAT QUESTION.
You should closely listen to the question and answer only the question presented. Answer the question and then stop. The quicker and to the point your answers are, the quicker the deposition will be concluded and you will be on your way.
4. DO NOT VOLUNTEER INFORMATION.
To repeat, listen to the question and answer only that question. The attorney will likely be asking every question under the sun regarding the subject matter. Let his questions elicit information rather than you volunteering information to the attorney. There is no need to assist the opposing attorney in doing his or her job.
Remember, as nice and as polite the other attorney is to you, he is representing your opponent in this lawsuit. Trust that it is the other attorney’s intention to use whatever information he gathers from you against you during his representation of the opposing party.
5. DON’T GUESS.
If you do not know the answer to a question presented or can not remember the answer, and that is the truth, simply say, “I don’t know,” or “I can’t remember.” Even the opposing counsel does not want you to guess at any question. Rather, he or she only wants to know what you know as you sit there at the deposition. You may be asked to provide specific information regarding times or distances. If you can provide a fair estimate as opposed to a guess, do so. If you can only guess in terms of a response, do not and simply say you are unable to provide an estimate in response to the question.
6. TAKE YOUR TIME.
Make sure you understand the question, think about your response, and present it in a concise fashion.
7. ONE PERSON SPEAKING AT A TIME.
For the benefit of the court reporter, who is typing every spoken word, it is requested that only one person at a time be speaking at a deposition. This also allows for a clear typewritten transcription of the testimony by the court reporter of questions by the attorney and answers by the witnesses, without overlapping testimony. Therefore, even if you anticipate where the attorney is going with his questions, please let him or her get the question out entirely before you begin your answer. The attorney will almost always extend the same courtesy of allowing you to complete your answer before moving onto the next question. The court reporter will appreciate this courtesy as well.
8. SPEAK UP AND SPEAK CLEARLY.
Speak loud enough and clearly so that everyone in the deposition room can understand your testimony.
9. EXPECT OBJECTIONS BY THE ATTORNEYS.
Expect the attorneys to object during the course of the deposition. If an attorney begins to assert an objection while you are speaking, stop speaking and wait for instructions to recommence your testimony.
10. BE COURTEOUS AND RESPECTFUL
Treat others how you wish to be treated. Do not lose your temper. Avoid jokes and wisecracks as a lawsuit is considered to be a serious matter. Do no respond to the attorney’s questions with questions of your own.
Remember, a main purpose of the deposition is for the other attorney to assess your demeanor and behavior so that he or she can assess whether or not you will be a good witness at trial that a jury will like and believe. Also keep in mind to be on your best behavior when you are in the presence of the opposing attorney even when you are not testifying as it is likely that the attorney will continue to be observing you and your conduct
As much as you may be upset about being involved in a lawsuit, being courteous, polite, and respectful is the best way to make a favorable impression on the opposing attorney, which will only serve to benefit your case. Your overall behavior at a deposition can affect your case just as much as your testimony.
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Lessons from the Godfather Trilogy
What I Learned From the Corleone Family:
Lawyers can find universal principles and practical advice in The Godfather films
By Daniel E. Cummins, Special to the Law Weekly
Few movies are as revered or have reached the iconic status in American culture as the movies that make up The Godfather trilogy. Obviously, the brilliant acting by numerous icons of American cinema and Francis Ford Coppola's direction play the major part in achieving that status. But perhaps even more appealing is the writing, which has generated many lines that can be considered not only quotable but also, in a broader sense, universal principles of life.
These universal principles are applicable to all walks of life from the mob underworld to our noblest of professions and can provide practical instruction to all who are open to such advice. An application of some of these universal principles to the practice of law offers some sound advice and instruction.
"It's not personal, Sonny. It's strictly business." Michael to Sonny in The Godfather
There may be nothing more important to the practice of law than the principle that decisions to be made should never be motivated by personal or emotional animus, but rather should always be the result of a sound, objective, business-like decision-making process. All too often, attorneys take the actions and adverse positions of opposing counsel personally and retaliate without first thinking through and formulating an appropriate response on an objective basis and in accordance with the law and facts of the case.
The practice of law has unfortunately deteriorated to the absurd and reprehensible extent that formal written rules of civility are apparently required in an effort to maintain order between counsel. It is questionable as to whether any other profession has or requires that basic rules of civility and courtesy be formally acknowledged or, worse yet, put in writing. A reason that such written rules may have become necessary for attorneys is that counsel are indeed ethically required to be zealous advocates for their client's causes of action, which, in turn, can unfortunately invite emotions and personal animosity into the decision-making process and in dealings with opposing counsel. The key, of course, is to rise above such personal issues and emotions and keep handling matters in a strictly business-like manner.
Litigating attorneys should also never take on the emotional trappings of their clients and should never let their personal opinions of opposing counsel or the quality of that attorney's case get in the way of an objective application of the law to the facts of the case presented. In the big picture, attorneys are the representatives of their respective clients who are engaged in a dispute that cannot be resolved amicably. The pros and cons of a case cannot be properly and professionally evaluated if one's judgment is clouded by emotionally charged and negative feelings toward another attorney, that attorney's client, or that attorney's case or argument. Accordingly, if you find yourself unable to separate yourself from an emotional opinion of the case, it may be wise to run the case by another attorney or, even better, a lay person for a fresh and objective viewpoint.
It is particularly important to remain objective when evaluating cases for settlement purposes and in engaging in settlement negotiations. Emotions have no place during settlement negotiations but can run high and get in the way of an objective evaluation of a case's range of value. Ultimately, in all cases, it's not personal, it's strictly business.
"Never hate your enemies – it affects your judgment." Michael to Vincent in The Godfather, Part III
A corollary to the general rule that negative emotions should have no place in the litigation process is that one should never allow matters to get personal with the opposition. When one allows their emotions to intrude into their dealings with opposing counsel, the ability to evaluate any and all issues that arise is clouded by such negative feelings.
As difficult as it may be, one must attempt to disassociate and cut out any negative feelings or animosity (even when such emotions may be warranted under the circumstances) toward opposing counsel, an opposing client, a judge or whomever one is dealing with. Only then can a proper evaluation and handling of the issue or case be completed.
For example, some attorneys may feel they are being personally attacked when they are presented with a motion to compel discovery responses. Obviously, in cases where there are no objections at issue, it must be considered that the motion may be warranted as such a motion would not have been necessary if the discovery responses had been timely produced. Consideration should also be given as to whether the attorney filing the motion was compelled to do so by a superior in his or her firm or by the client.
In terms of the attorney filing a discovery motion, it is obviously always good practice whenever possible to send a warning letter to opposing counsel of the intention to file a discovery motion at least 20 to 30 days ahead of time so as to allow time for the response to be produced. It is also good practice to agree to select another day to present the motion if the date selected is not good for the opposing counsel. In the end, all efforts should be made to resolve the discovery issue before burdening the court with petty and tangential issues to decide.
With all issues presented by a case, although sometimes easier said than done, one should not allow an emotional viewpoint to cloud one's evaluation of the case presented. This is not to say that an attorney shouldn't be passionate or should refrain from forcefully presenting her position on the case at hand. The key, rather, is to attempt to prevent any clouding of judgment by an emotional response to the case whether it be a positive or negative response. After all, remember what happened to Sonny Corleone when he allowed his emotions to cloud his judgment and get the best of him.
"Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer." Michael to Pentangeli in The Godfather, Part II
No advice may be as difficult to heed than the caution to keep your enemies or adversaries close. Unfortunately, there are some adversaries in the practice of law who thrive on petty confrontation and routinely taking matters to a personal, negative and vexatious level. Such attorneys seem to enjoy attempting to push the buttons of opposing counsel and disrupting the normally smooth handling of cases. While there is no place in the practice of law for such boorish behavior, there is usually no recourse against the same, and one must be prepared to deal with such attorneys effectively in order to provide his clients with the representation they are entitled to.
Fortunately, these types of attorneys are the exception and not the norm. It is best to remember that typically these troublesome attorneys are lacking in an important quality of some sort, whether it be of some personal nature or an inability or unwillingness to do the work required by the case, including but not limited to researching and understanding the applicable law and rules of procedure. Perhaps out of an unconscious fear or some feeling of inadequacy, such attorneys may be compelled to lash out and attempt to compensate in negative ways designed to deflect attention from these deficiencies by engaging in personal attacks or making the litigation process unnecessarily difficult. While the inherent notion of self-preservation compels us to steer clear of such attorneys wherever possible, we inevitably have to deal with them when a case calls upon us to do so.
One way to deal with such "enemies," or all adversaries for that matter, is to keep them close. This can best be accomplished by knowing the facts and the law of the case better than your adversary does. To get a quick initial grasp of the law of a case, one can turn to the Pennsylvania Law Encyclopedia. In terms of an analysis of almost all substantive and procedural issues that may arise in civil litigation, there is no better resource than Stephen Feldman's The Pennsylvania Trial Guide. Cases on point with yours may be found in the more specific Negligence Instant Case Finder by Glenn A. Troutman. Furthermore, in automobile accident and insurance litigation, one can quickly secure an understanding of the applicable law from a review of Milford Meyer's Pennsylvania Vehicle Negligence and Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Insurance 2d., by James R. Ronca, Leonard A. Sloane, David L. Lutz and Timothy A. Shollenberger, and edited by Bill Mabius.
In terms of the Rules of Civil Procedure and forms related thereto, there are no better resources than Goodrich-Amram 2d Procedural Rules Service With Forms and Dunlap-Hannah Pennsylvania Forms.
By having a full understanding of the facts and knowing the applicable law and rules of procedure at the commencement of a case, one can more effectively control a vexatious opposing counsel and move the case forward to its inevitable conclusion, whatever that may be. It is important to also remember that a case can only move forward by keeping opposing counsel close with continued communication.
As aggravating as opposing counsel may become in such dealings, it is best to remain in control of your own emotions and hit them with kindness, good humor and rational explanations supporting your position. Always confirm everything in writing with these types of attorneys as a further method to keep them under control. Again, a positive way to view such a difficult situation is to remember that each communication will move the parties one step closer to the eventual resolution of the case, at which point you will no longer have to deal with that attorney.
Thus, as enjoyable as the practice of law may be with your colleagues, the real challenge of the profession is to see your client's case through to its desired and just end by keeping your adversaries close and under control.
"Fredo, you're my older brother and I love you. But don't ever take sides, with anyone, against the family again. Ever." Michael to Fredo in The Godfather
The Rules of Professional Conduct require counsel to put their client's interests above all others in accordance with the law. An obvious principle, as expressed by Michael Corleone to his brother Fredo, is that one should never take actions or positions detrimental to the interests of the client unless, of course, you are ethically required to do so. Additionally, although the opposing case or client may be sympathetic, attorneys are ethically bound to put such emotions aside and to evaluate cases on an objective basis in the best interests of their own client. Expressions of doubt and/or a lack of confidence shown by an attorney in his or her own client's theory of the case or argument can be damaging and, at times, fatal.
A consequential benefit of an unwavering loyalty, confidence, and belief in your client and his or her cause of action is credibility in the eyes of opposing counsel, the judge, and/or the jury. If an attorney does not publicly and convincingly exhibit his or her own belief in the client's case, no one else will. Credibility of the attorney and of the case presented will also be enhanced by raising and explaining away any weaknesses of the case as opposed to attempting to hide or ignore the same.
Furthermore, part of fully representing your own client is placing yourself in the shoes of opposing counsel and immersing yourself into the facts of the case and the theory of the case from the other side's perspective. Unless and until you do so, you cannot fully appreciate the strengths and weaknesses of your own case.
Accordingly, when preparing your client for a deposition or trial testimony, you should submit the client to a possible cross-examination in an effort to prepare him or her for the same. While preparing for any oral argument for the court, one should first prepare the argument for your own client, and then compose the argument for the opposition. Only by doing so, can one see and address the problems and weak points in your own argument. Additionally, at oral argument (and at closing argument at trial), it is wise to end your argument by advising the judge of the opposing arguments that you anticipate will be made and then explain to the judge why such arguments should be rejected. In doing so, you will raise your credibility by showing that you are not steadfastly and blindly presenting only your side of the case, but rather presenting both sides of the case and attempting to convince the court or jury why your client's position is the fair and just position.
"I'm gonna make him an offer he can't refuse." Don Corleone to Johnny Fontaine in The Godfather
In terms of settlement negotiations, it may be said that you can not sell something to someone they do not want to buy. When negotiating with opposing counsel, one should again put themselves in the position of that opposing counsel or client and attempt to frame any settlement offers in the best light from that perspective.
For example, the value of settling a case now as opposed to after many more months of litigation or awaiting an opening in the court's schedule for a settlement conference or trial can be emphasized. The benefit of settling sooner in terms of interest on the settlement money or the effect on the potential for delay damages can be raised. Where the parties are engaged in a non-binding mediation and have reached an impasse, perhaps the offering of paying for the mediator's services by one party can spark further discussions to an ultimate resolution. By thinking of settlement from the other party's perspective and being creative and positive in framing your settlement offers, one may be able to effectuate a settlement of a case within one's range of value.
In trying to settle a case, it must be remembered that emotions have no place in negotiations. If at all possible, check any emotions generated by the case or your interactions with the opposition prior to entering into any settlement negotiations. All attempts should be made by both parties to participate in the settlement discussions in the most objective and business-like manner possible.
Attorneys should also take steps to control their clients and attempt to convince their clients to also put their emotions aside and to view the case in a business-like manner and in accordance with the attorney's advice as to the value of the case. Your client's reasonable and fair settlement position should be established prior to commencing negotiations and, if you are not able to reach a resolution on your terms, the parties should simply move on to the next step in the litigation process. One way or another, the case will inevitably conclude at some point.
"I have always believed helping your fellow man is profitable in every sense, personally and bottom line." Michael to reporters in The Godfather, Part III
Although Michael Corleone may have issued this statement with a sense of irony, it cannot be denied that helping your fellow man is indeed profitable in every sense. In addition to assisting all of our clients with their legal matters, an attorney may also profit on a personal level by taking on a pro bono case within the scope of their expertise wherever possible. Typically, an attorney may have their name placed on a list in the county's pro bono office with an identification of that attorney's area of expertise. In most cases, the pro bono office may call an attorney when a matter comes within that attorney's area of practice and the attorney may consider whether or not to take such a case after a conflicts check. Obviously, the handling of a pro bono case is not only looked upon favorably by all, but is also personally gratifying.
Equally gratifying is the participation in and completion of volunteer activities in the community. There is never a lack of opportunities to do so whether such volunteer participation be needed by the Young Lawyers' Division of your county bar, your church, your town, or any other entity.
In addition to the altruistic reasons in support of volunteering in the community, such activities have the consequent benefit as a source of networking and advertisement. By participating in charitable activities, one can come to know many different people as well as have your name or your firm's name disseminated to the public in a positive light. Participation in such activities may also go a long way in slowly but surely improving the always tarnished public image of attorneys.
Ultimately, by participating in volunteer activities and helping your fellow man, one can obtain a great sense of accomplishment and personal fulfillment comparable to none.
"[A] man who doesn't spend time with his family can never be a real man." Don Corleone to Johnny Fontaine in The Godfather
While the demands and pressure to bill an exorbitant number of required hours or to spend many hours developing plaintiff's cases is great in the practice of law, there is no opportunity to replace missed moments with one's family. Many an experienced attorney with grown children have lamented the times they missed when their children were infants and toddlers and the times they could not make a little league game or recital all because they were so engrossed with the practice of law. Life is short and there are no second chances to recover such priceless moments.
Whenever possible, a balance between work and life outside of work should be sought and encouraged. An attorney who spends most or all of his waking hours in the practice of law runs the significant risk of becoming a one dimensional person and ultimately burning out. It can be said that attorneys who develop their life outside of the practice of law, particularly with their families, but also in terms of their hobbies, recreational activities, and in exploring creative outlets, are more apt to have a higher productivity level when it comes to work.
Obviously, the practice of law is an extremely stressful 24/7 profession. Some attorneys proudly (and sadly) boast that they rarely take time off from work. Such an attitude may prove counter-productive in the end. Spending and enjoying more time with one's family will tend to serve as a release from the pressures of work and lessen one's overall stress level which, in the end, results in a more healthy lifestyle overall. A more healthy lifestyle, in turn, may render you a more productive and efficient attorney. In the end, all aspects of your life both in and out of work will benefit.
Conclusion
An understanding and application of the universal principles enunciated by the great characters in The Godfather Trilogy to one's practice can improve one's abilities and may also serve to ease the stress generated by the profession. All in all, with the practice of law as demanding as it is in and of itself, an effort should be made by attorneys to deal with each other in an objective and professional manner without descending into personal animosity and attacks. Ideally, we should treat others as we desire to be treated and should maintain positive arguments supported by the law and facts of the case as opposed to attempting to pursue or defend a claim through negative and emotionally charged tactics or personal attacks. In the words of Clemenza from The Godfather, we should metaphorically, "Leave the gun. Take the cannoli." In the end, by leaving behind a negative or personal handling of a file and instead taking positive business-like approach to all cases, the practice of law as a whole will benefit.
This article is reprinted here, with permission, from the August 29, 2005 issue of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly.(c) 2009 Incisive Media US Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All rights reserved. Please contact the author for permission to reprint or duplicate this article.

