Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 6, 2024

REPRINT -- THE ART OF MEDIATING: THE GOAL IS TO SETTLE, NOT WIN

The below article of mine providing tips on handling mediations was published in the October 17, 2017 edition of The Legal Intelligencer and is republished here with permission.


Should you need any assistance in mediating cases through the end of the year or beyond, I would be happy to help through Cummins Mediation Services.  Please contact me at dancummins@CumminsLaw.net for my resume, fee schedule or to arrange for a Mediation.  

Thank you.


The Art of Mediating: The Goal Is to Settle, Not Win

The Legal Intelligencer

October 17, 2017    

By

Daniel E. Cummins


With the uncertainty of what a jury will do in a particular case and the significant costs associated with trying a case to verdict, alternative dispute resolution proceedings in the form of mediations and arbitrations have been a rising trend across the commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

The following practice tips for nonbinding mediations may assist litigants in bringing their cases to a desired resolution.

Be Fully Prepared

All too often, parties may arrive at a nonbinding mediation without having provided the opposing party with all of the 
information necessary to allow for a successful mediation.

On the plaintiff's side, there are times where a plaintiff has not yet finalized the information pertinent to the economic damages claims, such as wage loss claims or medical expenses claims. At times, the parties are still waiting for the completion of the lengthy process associated with securing health care, Medicaid or Medicare liens.

It is advisable to postpone any mediation proceedings until this information has been secured and documented so as to allow the defense to complete its evaluation and arrive at the mediation with additional settlement authority. The production of such information also provides the plaintiff with ammunition to argue for a higher settlement of the claims presented.

On the defense side, it may be advisable not to proceed to an arbitration until all written discovery, depositions and expert review of the claims presented has been completed.

Plaintiffs allowing a case to proceed to mediation before such items have been accomplished may be faced with a defense asserting that there is no additional settlement authority to be discussed at the conference but that the case may be revisited after the completion of additional discovery efforts, such as an independent medical examination of the plaintiff. Plaintiffs can take away this argument by not agreeing to proceed to mediation until such discovery tasks are completed.

Written Submissions Are Important

When proceeding to a mediation, it is important to provide the mediator with a concise, but thorough, overview of the claims and defenses presented. A concise chronology of the facts of the underlying matter will inform the mediator as to the legal issues presented and provide an initial sense as to the value of the claims asserted.

Written submissions need not contain a recitation of every medical visit or diagnostic study completed. Rather, the highlights of the plaintiff's treatment following the accident will suffice.

On the defense side, a mediation memorandum can be utilized to raise and provide support for defenses on the liability issues, the causation question and the alleged extent of the injuries and damages presented. A defense mediation memorandum can also be utilized to emphasize the plaintiff's prior medical history so as to confirm that the case presented involves an aggravation of a pre-existing condition claim.

There is also no need to provide a mediator with voluminous written materials to review. Rather, litigators should emphasize the highlights of the case through documentary evidence. Rather than providing the mediator with complete medical records, it may be advisable to only submit the notes of the important office visits and notable reports of diagnostic films and studies.

Also, rather than submitting entire transcripts of depositions, the better practice may be to submit the cover page of the deposition transcript along with the pertinent pages that may have been cited in the mediation memorandum.

In addition to not overburdening the ­mediator with unnecessary information, presenting more concise documentation will also serve to keep the cost of the mediation down as the mediator will have less to review in preparation for the proceedings.

Oftentimes, the parties will submit their mediation memorandum and supporting exhibits to the arbitrator confidentially. The better practice is to disclose your materials to the opposing party in order that the opposing party may share the same with their client in order to let their client know of the weaknesses of the case presented and the strengths of the opponent's case.

Prepare Client and Claims Representative

Most plaintiffs and some claims representative are not familiar with how the mediation process works.

The better practice is to fully inform your client that, at a mediation, the mediator will likely have all of the parties in the room for an initial conference at which updates on the case presented can be provided. At the initial conference, both parties may also be invited to provide their overview of the case presented in order to let the opposing party know how the case is viewed by the opponent.

A plaintiff should be advised that he or she may be requested by the mediator at this initial conference to provide an update as to the client's condition and treatment. In this regard, a plaintiff who admits to improvement in his or her condition with the treatment provided to date adds to the credibility of that litigant. An injured party who contends that there has been no improvement whatsoever in his or her condition despite years of treatment may have their overall credibility called into question by the opponent.

If a plaintiff is reluctant to admit improvement, the plaintiff can add the proviso of that, while he or she may have improved somewhat over time, the injuries have not resolved and continue to limit the plaintiff in his or her everyday activities of daily living.

The client should be advised that, once the initial conference is completed, the mediator will likely put each party in a separate room and commence the negotiations by traveling back and forth between the rooms in a continuing effort to bring the parties closer together towards an amicable resolution of the claims presented.

The parties should also be made aware that there may be a reiteration of the same points over and over with different emphasis on different points at different times during the course of the mediation. This is all a part of the process of helping each side of the litigation to fully understand and appreciate the pros and cons of the claims and defenses presented.

The client and the claims representative should also be advised that the mediator has been selected to preside over this mediation because that person has experience in evaluating the claims presented in the jurisdiction in which the case is pending. It should be noted to the parties that a mediator typically does not provide the parties with his concrete evaluation of the case presented as the job of the mediator is not to evaluate the case. Rather, the mediator's function is to facilitate negotiations between the parties towards a settlement figure that each party may not be entirely happy with but are satisfied enough to agree to conclude the matter.

Listen to What the Mediator Is Saying

When engaging in a mediation, parties may get so wrapped up in their own position that they may fail to listen to the information being provided by the mediator after the mediator has met with the opposing side.

Listening to what the mediator is reporting from his last conference with the opposing party may send signals as to where the opposing party may be willing to proceed in its next step.   Listening to such information may also assist the party hearing the information in formulating their next step in the negotiation process.

Be Clear on What Can Be Disclosed

At various times during a mediation, a party may disclose information to the mediator that the party does not wish to be disclosed to the opposing counsel.

When disclosing information to the mediator that a party does not wish to be revealed to the other side, that party should be clear in its statement to the mediator that such information should be kept confidential. Mediators will keep this information confidential to keep your trust.

The provision of such confidential information may assist the mediator in understanding certain aspects of the case and why a party may be taking a particular position on a particular issue. The disclosure of such information to the mediator confidentially may, in the end, assist the mediator in massaging the other side closer toward a settlement figure.

Willingness to Negotiate

Obviously, the success of any mediation depends upon the willingness of each party to negotiate reasonably. In addition to emphasizing the strong points of one's case, the credibility of the parties will be enhanced by that party's concession with respect to the weak points of their case presented. An admission of the weak points of a case, with an associated explanation as to how that party plans to deal with those weak points at a potential trial, will provide the mediator with information to take to the other side in the continuing negotiations on the case presented.

When going into a mediation, clients and claims representatives should be made aware that the goal is not to "win" the case, but rather to settle the case and secure compensation or close a file. Shifting the parties' focus from winning to settling prior to going into the proceedings may make all the difference in the success of a mediation. •

Daniel E. Cummins is a partner and civil litigator with the Clarks Summit law firm of Cummins Law. His civil litigation blog, Tort Talk, can be viewed at www.TortTalk.com.  Attorney Cummins also provides Mediation services through Cummins Mediation Services.


570-319-5899

dancummins@CumminsLaw.net

Monday, January 31, 2022

ADR Provision in Trampoline Park's Participation Agreement Upheld But Not Provision for Attorney's Fees


In the case of Wearing v. Lyon Tamer, LLC, d/b/a Defy Scranton, No. 20-CV-233 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 24, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed the validity of an alternative dispute resolution clause contained in a participation agreement signed by the Plaintiff’s mother when the Plaintiff went to the Defendant’s trampoline park.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff filed this negligence action against a trampoline park operator for injuries suffered by the Plaintiff while using a trampoline as a minor allegedly without any supervision or oversight.

The Defendant trampoline park operator filed Preliminary Objections. 

With the Preliminary Objections, the Defendant sought to stay this litigation and compel the Plaintiff to submit to mediation and non-binding arbitration in compliance with the participation agreement executed by the Plaintiff’s mother as a condition for the minor to enter and use the trampoline park. 

The Defendant also sought to recover counsel fees and costs under a separate provision in the participation agreement which allowed the Defendant to recover such damages “to the extent permitted by law” in seeking to enforce the mediation and non-binding arbitration provision.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County


After reviewing the law of Pennsylvania regarding such agreements and applying the law to the terms of the participation agreement before him, Judge Nealon granted the Preliminary Objections seeking a stay of the tort action given that there was a valid agreement of the parties to participate in alternative dispute resolution. 

However, the court denied the request for attorneys’ fees and costs after finding that the provision in the participation agreement in this regard was unreasonably favorable to the trampoline park operator whose customers had no meaningful choice regarding the acceptance of that provision. The court found that that provision was unenforceable in this regard only due to this procedural and substantive unconscionability.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source:  Photo by Matheus Costa on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, April 15, 2020

Is It An Arbitration Award or Not?



In the case of Martinez v. Nationwide Ins. Co., No. 18-2972 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 18, 2020 Perkin, U.S.M.J.), the court denied a carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a UIM claim where there were issues of fact over whether the ADR proceedings resulted in a settlement recommendation or a binding arbitration award for less than the tortfeasor’s limits.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff proceeded in the third party auto accident matter to an alternative dispute resolution proceeding which resulted in an arbitrator entering a finding in favor of the Plaintiff for $22,500.00 after which the Plaintiff’s lawsuit was subsequently marked as settled, discontinued and ended.

Thereafter, the Plaintiff’s attorney responded to the carrier’s inquiries about the status of the arbitration of the third party matter. After receiving the arbitrator’s award, the Plaintiff’s counsel notified the carrier of the “settlement” via a Dailey-Sands letter with a request that the UIM carrier either approve the “settlement” or tender the amount of the “settlement” to preserve its subrogation rights.

The carrier filed a Motion for Summary Judgment in this matter asserting that the Plaintiff had received a binding arbitration award for less than the third party tortfeasor’s limits such that there was no valid UIM claim.

In this matter, the Federal Magistrate Judge found that there were issues to be resolved that prevented the entry of summary judgment.

The court agreed with the Plaintiff that the ADR proceedings merely resulted in a non-binding settlement recommendation from an arbitrator. The court noted that the arbitrator’s document used terms such as “recommendation” and “recommend” rather than language indicating that the arbitration award document was meant to be a binding arbitration award on the Plaintiff. 

The court additionally noted that, if the document was determined to be a settlement recommendation, then there would be no final judgment that would preclude the Plaintiff from litigating her damages under the doctrine of collateral estoppel.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Order related to this Opinion can be found HERE.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 3, 2020).





Thursday, April 24, 2014

Plaintiff Barred From Pursuing UIM Claim After Participating in Third Party Non-Binding ADR


In her recent April 9, 2014 decision in the Post-Koken case of Gallagher v. Ohio Casualty Ins. Co., No. 13-0168 (E.D. Pa. April 9, 2014), Judge Nitza I. Quinones Alejandro of the Federal District Court for the Eastern District found that a Non-Binding ADR Award precluded a UIM claim but is not collateral estoppel.

According to the Opinion, the third party portion of this case settled after a non-binding arbitration was held and the arbitrator entered a "settlement value" that was approximately $59,000.00 less than the third party liability limits.
 
The insured Plaintiff initially declined to accept the value determination by the arbitrator and proceeded with the third party case.  However, after the completion of some further discovery, the third party case settled for the same amount as the non-binding arbitrator's evaluation.
 
Despite settling the third party claim for substantially less than the tortfeasor's liability limits, the Plaintiff nevertheless commenced a UIM claim against the Plaintiff's own automobile insurance carrier.
 
The UIM carrier denied a UIM even claim existed given the non-binding arbitration value placed upon the case.
 
The insured Plaintiff filed suit.  The UIM carrier continued with its argument that the UIM case could not proceed because the third party was not an "underinsured" motorist under the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (MVFRL), the third party coverage was not exhausted, and the claim was barred by collateral estoppel.
 
The Court in Gallagher agreed that the third party was not an "underinsured" motorist as defined by the MVFRL. The only evidence of the other driver being underinsured was the policy limits and the settlement. The Court found that the insured Plaintiff failed to present any evidence that the damages could meet or exceed the third party liability limits of $100,000.
 
Since the only evidence was the arbitrator’s value, the court found that the third party cannot be "underinsured" and that, therefore, the insured Plaintiff could not present a UIM claim.
 
However, the Court noted that the UIM claim would not be otherwise barred by collateral estoppel because the non-binding arbitration did not result in a final judgment as required for that doctrine to apply.

The Trial Court's Opinion in Gallagher can be view at this LINK.  The companion court Order can be viewed HERE.

UPDATE:  This decision was affirmed on appeal by the Third Circuit on January 29, 2015.  However, the Third Circuit stated that its decision was "Not Precedential."  If you wish to see a copy of that Third Circuit opinion, please contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.



To review other Tort Talk posts on other cases addressing the application of the Collateral Estoppel Doctrine in the context of Post-Koken third party liability/UIM auto accident cases, click this LINK.


 

Monday, March 14, 2011

ADR TIPS FROM NOTED ARBITRATORS/MEDIATORS

TIPS TO IMPROVE CHANCES FOR SUCCESS AT ARBITRATION/MEDIATION PROCEEDINGS

An interview conducted by

Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire


With the ever-present backlog of trial calendars in the trial courts across Pennsylvania, more and more litigants are turning to alternative dispute resolution in the form of non-binding mediation or binding arbitration to bring their cases to a resolution. Of course, the uncertainty attendant with jury trials has also always been a great motivator for parties to move their cases into a mediation or a binding arbitration with confidential high/low parameters in place.

There is no better way to learn about what works and what doesn’t work during ADR proceedings than by asking questions of mediators/arbitrators that have presided over numerous ADR proceedings.

The following questions, seeking tips on how parties may improve their chances for success in ADR proceedings, were submitted for a response to noted attorney mediators/arbitrators, Richard Fine, James A. Gibbons, Tom Helbig, and Lucille Marsh.

1. WHAT TIPS WOULD YOU OFFER IN TERMS OF IMPROVING THE WRITTEN MEMORANDUM SUBMITTED FOR AN ARBITRATION/MEDIATION?

Richard Fine:

The written memorandum should be a simple, convincing presentation of the party's position; it should anticipate the opposing party's arguments on liability (in arbitrations) and damages, and should set forth clear responses to those arguments. Concentrate on the points that will put pressure on the opposing party.

If relying on case law, it should be summarized as well, but copies of relevant decisions should be provided with the memorandum. Don't expect your arbitrator or mediator to go to the books to find the cases you cite.

A brief description of any settlement negotiations that occurred between the parties prior to mediation should be included.

If setting forth a settlement figure, or range of figures, be sure to give the basis for arriving at that figure. Explain how you calculated your values. Include proof of any liens that must be satisfied, etc.

Consideration should be given to whether the memorandum is to be shared with the opposing party, or whether some or all of it should be for the mediator's eyes only.


Jim Gibbons:

Try to not parrot the medical records, especially if you are submitting the records too. Pay attention to your strengths, but don't ignore your weaknesses. Outline your settlement position and provide a rationale for your figures.

Tom Helbig:

For Arbitration – Make certain to address all the relevant facts and legal principles that support your position. My preference is for counsel to err on the side of providing too much information in the Memorandum. Remember the Arbitrator will generally review the written submissions both before and after the Hearing, and a well written Memorandum is another opportunity to persuade the Arbitrator.

For Mediation – An exhaustive Memorandum is not necessary since there will be more discussion of the case facts and issues during the Conference. Since settlement is the ultimate goal, however, it is important to provide to the Mediator your settlement position and outline the specific reasons supporting your present position.


Lucille Marsh:

A concise Mediation Memorandum setting forth the essential facts of the case, damages and any issues, pro or con, to liability or damages is very helpful. Eliminate puffing and the superfluous. If case is complex, a chronology/summary of events, i.e. medical treatment, is useful to the Mediator as a negotiating tool. Give the Mediator information which can be used to leverage with the other side. In Arbitration, where counsel must convince the Arbitrator of the merits, including all relevant facts, case law or argument supporting a claim or defense is highly effective in my opinion. Avoid arguing a position not supportable by the facts and law. Remember - a Mediator only facilitates a settlement whereas an Arbitrator must be influenced to decide the case in a party's favor.



2. WHAT TIPS WOULD YOU OFFER IN TERMS OF THE EXHIBITS TO BE SUBMITTED FOR AN ARBITRATION/MEDIATION?


Richard Fine:

The less paper you ask the mediator to look through, the better.

If you have already had an expert review medical records, or someone in your office has prepared a digest, summary or chronological chart of treatment, use that as your exhibit. If you feel that certain medical records are important for the arbitrator or mediator to see, tab or highlight the relevant portion.

If deposition testimony is being submitted, I prefer to have the entire transcript, but again relevant portions should be tabbed and highlighted for quick access.

Photographs should be clear and labeled on the back, preferably 5 X 7 or larger. Include the date each was taken. Don't present 5 or 6 when 1 or 2 will do the job.

At the proceeding itself, consider a well-thought-out Power Point presentation for your exhibits.


Jim Gibbons:

Highlighting helps attract attention; I have no problem with it. Don't submit unnecessary medical records. Submit the records that speak to the injuries at issue. If you're going to submit depo testimony, submit the entire transcript. I'd suggest in that instance, communication with
opposing counsel beforehand can avoid duplicate submissions.


Tom Helbig:

Make sure to reach an agreement with opposing counsel on the proposed exhibits before submitting them to the Arbitrator or Mediator. A recurring problem has been the submission of updated medical records and reports without providing them to opposing counsel, or documents obtaining objectionable hearsay statements, such as police reports, without a stipulation as to admission from opposing counsel. Submission of all medical records is unnecessary (e. g. every PT or primary care physician’s note); however, a complete medical chronology is helpful, especially for a comparison of an individual’s pre and post-accident medical condition.


Lucille Marsh:

In Mediation, since I do not need to be convinced of the merits of any party's position, only relevant and pertinent medical records, photos and portions of depositions need be supplied. Do not overwhelm the Mediator with paperwork. A short and concise summary of medical treatment is in my opinion far more effective than a stack of medical records. On the defense side I generally like to have a copy of any IME reports which I can compare to the Plaintiff's concise summary. On the other hand, in arbitration counsel needs to convince the fact finder that his/her position is the more correct one and all supportive, relevant medical reports, documents, photographs or statements should be utilized. In complex or catastrophic cases, a day in the life video or other visual aid illustrating how the accident occurred or product was defective is very effective.



3. IN ARBITRATIONS, WHAT IS YOUR POSITION ON THE VALUE OF CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY COUNSEL?


Richard Fine:

I welcome closing arguments and would always give parties the option, but never make them mandatory. Attorneys should remember their audience; the arbitrator does not need or want courtroom dramatics-- don't "hype" your case.

Be careful not to argue points that are clearly not supported by the evidence; sum up your case as succinctly as possible,


Jim Gibbons:

I welcome closing arguments in arbitrations, but counsel need to remember that the panel is not composed of lay people. Less theatrics have a bigger impact. I do not see any need for openings or closings in mediations.


Tom Helbig:

Absolute necessity and rarely, if ever, should be waived by counsel. Need not be lengthy or theatrical; rather I prefer counsel to elicit a concise summary of the credible evidence supporting his or her theory of the case and why the Arbitrator should decide in their favor on a particular issue (e. g. liability, damages, coverage).


Lucille Marsh:

Counsel should always be given the opportunity to make a closing argument. However, depending upon the complexity of the matter, a closing argument may or may not be of any value. If there is a legal issue, a closing argument should reference case law and facts which support the party’s position. Address any evidence that came up during the hearing that was not addressed or anticipated in the submitted Memorandum. Avoid arguing anything unsupported by the evidence as that will only adversely impact your credibility. Avoid arguing the obvious. Highlight the evidence that supports your position and/or nullifies your opponent’s position.



4. ANY TIPS ON HOW COUNSEL MAY BETTER PREPARE THEIR CLIENT AND/OR CLAIMS REPRESENTATIVE FOR PARTICIPATION IN ADR PROCEEDINGS?


Richard Fine:

Plaintiff's counsel should make certain that the client understands the purpose of the proceeding. Unrealistic expectations can derail a mediation. The client should be fully briefed ahead of time as to the nature and significance of any subrogation liens, Medicare or Welfare liens, and costs that need to be reimbursed from the proceeds of an award or settlement.

Claims representatives must understand that without full authority to settle, a mediation cannot succeed. Ideally, the individual with authority should be present in person. This helps to streamline the negotiating process, avoiding the need for repeated calls "to the company". Furthermore, the opportunity to meet the Plaintiff will allow the claims rep to assess how a jury might react to the individual.

If there is more than one defendant, discussions should be held with the claims representative in advance of the ADR proceeding as to how a settlement package might be put together---by what percentage or other method the ultimate pay-out should be split between them.


Jim Gibbons:

In mediations, counsel need to emphasize to their clients/adjusters that the tone is one of compromise. Parties must understand that there is a distinct possibility that what they want to pay/receive may not be what they will end up paying/receiving. Parties need to understand that the numbers at the beginning of the process will not be the numbers at the end of the process. Counsel also need to counsel patience. It is a process, and insisting on getting to the end at the beginning is counter-productive. It's not going to be over in an hour or two.


Tom Helbig:

For Mediation, it is important for the parties and claims representatives to clearly understand the Mediation process and its ultimate purpose, i. e., there must be a sincere desire to resolve the claim and not necessarily prove the other party is wrong. Must understand the Mediator is a facilitator and not a fact-finder; thus, if the parties and/or claims representatives are unwilling to fully discuss the case issues and potentially re-examine their positions, then Mediation should probably not be pursued.


Lucille Marsh:

Impress upon your client/representative the importance of the ADR. Point out the pros and cons of your case so that the client/representative enters the ADR fully aware of the uncertainties. Have your client assess both best case scenario and worst case scenario in discussing settlement range and settlement needs. Discuss in advance a realistic range of settlement you’re willing to consider. Be flexible. Make sure that your client/representative has the desire and willingness to participate in ADR - otherwise you are wasting your time and money.


5. DO YOU HAVE ANY MISCELLANEOUS TIPS FOR COUNSEL TO IMPROVE THEIR CHANCE FOR SUCCESS AT AN ADR PROCEEDING?


Richard Fine:

Simplify and organize!

Know your facts, know the applicable law, and whenever possible, know your mediator or arbitrator. Take his or her style and personality into account when presenting your case.

Remember the Boy Scout motto, and be prepared.


Jim Gibbons:

Obviously, having a claim rep in the room is ideal. Second best is having them available by phone. Come with authority. If you've had preliminary discussions prior to the mediation, don't raise the demand/lower the offer at the mediation.

Defense counsel: try and bring a proposed release with you to speed up the process of payment.

Plaintiffs' counsel: have a good handle on your costs to date; your client will likely ask how much goes into his/her pocket at the mediation. That can be a big help. If there is a lien, initiate contact with the lienholder prior to the mediation and try to get a conversation going about compromising the lien.


Tom Helbig:

PLAINTIFF - Don’t necessarily rely upon your client as the only witness to be called at the hearing. It may be helpful to enhance a pain and suffering or wage loss claim with the testimony of family members, friends, and/or co-workers. A relatively modest expenditure of time and money to present these corroborating witnesses may be beneficial.

DEFENDANT -Important hearing/conference items for the arbitrator/mediator’s consideration may include a medical chronology and all relevant pre and post-accident records; vehicle damage photographs; and subsequent accident/incident reports.


Lucille Marsh:

In Mediation, be candid with the Mediator when in private caucus. Confidentiality and trust are critical for any successful Mediation. Posturing in front of the Mediator (and your client) serves no purpose in advancing your case. A good Mediator will make it very clear that any strategy or confidential information you provide will never be revealed to your opponent and realistically discussing weaknesses as well as strengths of your case only enhances your credibility. Be fully prepared to quantify your damages with back up, i.e. medical bills; wage loss; economic analysis of lost future earnings or earnings capacity, etc.



BIOGRAPHIES


Richard Fine is currently a mediator and arbitrator associated with ADR Options, Inc.; Resolute Systems, Inc.; Settlement Systems, Inc.; and The Peacemakers. Mr. Fine, a cum laude graduate of the University of Pennsylvania who attended Washington University School of Medicine and received his juris doctor from Dickinson School of Law, began his career clerking for Judge Joseph Sloane of Philadelphia County. He then moved into private practice in Pennsylvania state courts and the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, as part of the firm now known as Fine, Wyatt & Carey, where he is presently the senior and managing partner. He has also been admitted to practice before the U.S. Supreme Court. Mr. Fine was appointed by Chief Judge Sylvia H. Rambo of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of PA to serve as a mediator under the Civil Justice Reform Act of 1990. He was also appointed by President Judge Chester T. Harhut to serve as a mediator for the Court of Common Pleas of Lackawanna County. A former board member and past president of the Lackawanna County Bar Association, Mr. Fine is also a member of the Wayne County Bar Association, the Pennsylvania Bar Association, the American Bar Association, the Association of Trial Lawyers of America, the Pennsylvania Defense Institute, the Pennsylvania Association for Justice, and the International Association of Defense Counsel. Mr. Fine has served in his community as a board member of the Jewish Community Center, the Jewish Federation, the Community Medical Center, Temple Hesed, and Allied Services; a trustee of Webster Towers; and a member of the Mellon Bank advisory board. He currently serves as a hearing committee member with the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and has lectured for the Lackawanna Bar Association, the Pennsylvania Bar Institute, and the Pennsylvania Association for Justice. Attorney Fine may be contacted at finerg@comcast.net.


Jim Gibbons provides mediation services in commercial, real estate, civil rights, personal injury and medical negligence cases throughout northeastern and central
Pennsylvania. He is certified by the U.S. District Court as a mediator and is
regularly appointed there and in the local county courts as a mediator and
arbitrator. He has spent his entire career in litigation in the state and
federal courts. Attorney Gibbons may be contacted at gibbonslawfirm@epix.net.


Thomas Helbig received his BA from the University of Scranton in 1977 and his JD from Seton Hall University School of Law in 1981. Following graduation, he served as a law clerk to US District Judge Richard P. Conaboy in the US Middle District of Pennsylvania for two years. Prior to beginning his solo practice in 2008, he was a partner in the Scranton law firm of Scanlon, Howley & Doherty for seventeen (17) years and, previous to that, in the Wilkes-Barre law firm of Hourigan, Kluger, & Quinn P.C. for nine (9) years. In addition to his private litigation practice, Mr. Helbig focuses his present practice on mediation and arbitration work. He was recently appointed to the position of Settlement Master in the Court of Common Pleas of Lackawanna County under newly revised Local Rule 212. He previously served as Interim Discovery Master in Lackawanna County, and also as a court-appointed Special Trial Master presiding over jury and non-jury trials. Over the last twenty-five (25) years, he has conducted numerous mediations and arbitrations in third party and first party civil cases.


Lucille Marsh is a partner in the firm of Kreder Brooks Hailstone LLP. She focuses her practice on insurance defense, civil litigation, mediation and family law. She is a graduate of Chatham College and Dickinson School of Law. She has been a Certified Mediator in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania since 1996 and provides private mediation/arbitration services. She is an Adjunct Instructor at Keystone College. Attorney Marsh is a member of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Lackawanna Bar Association and the Pennsylvania Defense Institute. She has served on various PBA Task Forces and Committees. She served as a member of the Third Circuit Lawyers’ Advisory Committee and Middle District CJRA Advisory Committee. Attorney Marsh may be contacted at Lmarsh@kbh-law.com.