Showing posts with label Settled Defendants. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Settled Defendants. Show all posts

Friday, February 27, 2026

Superior Court Addresses How To Address Settled Defendants at Trial


In its non-precedential decision in the case of Swank v. Rabkin Dermatopathology Laboratory, P.C., No. 342 WDA 2025 (Pa. Super. Dec. 15, 2025 Panella, P.J.E., McLaughlin, J., and Bender, P.J.E.) (Op. by Panella, P.J.E.), the court reversed the entry of judgment in favor of certain Defendants in a medical malpractice case and remanded the case back down for further proceedings.

According to the Opinion, this matter involved a delayed cancer diagnosis case.

Prior to trial, the Plaintiff reached a settlement with all parties except one and proceeded to trial against that last remaining party.

The Plaintiff, along with the settling Defendants, requested the trial court to dismiss the settling Defendants prior to trial because the remaining Defendant did not have any expert to provide an expert opinion against the settling Defendants. Moreover, the remaining Defendant did not file any crossclaim against the settled Defendants. Also, the Plaintiff did not have any expert testimony that was critical of the settling Defendants that would be presented at trial.  At the trial level, it was the Plaintiff’s position that it was legally impossible for there to be a prima facie case established against the settling Defendants and that, as such, those Defendants should be dismissed. 

The trial court disagreed and kept those settling Defendants in the case, relying upon the Fair Share Act in doing so.

As the case proceeded, the trial court did end up dismissing one of the settling Defendants after the Plaintiff’s case-in-chief was completed. The remaining other settled Defendants were dismissed just before closing arguments.

At trial, the Plaintiffs claimed that there was prejudice to the Plaintiff because the jury was left wondering why these Defendants were dismissed after they participated in the trial.

The jury ended up entering a defense verdict.  

The Plaintiff appealed and, in this Superior Court decision, the appellate court reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded the matter for further proceedings after finding that the trial court’s reliance upon Fair Share Act was misplaced.

Judge Panella, who wrote this Opinion, as well as the Fair Share Act case of Spencer v. Johnson, 249 A.3d 529 (Pa. Super. 2021), noted that the Superior Court has concluded that, for the “Fair Share Act to apply, the Plaintiff’s negligence must be an issue in the case.” See Op. at 13 citing Spencer, 249 A.3d at 559.

The court noted that, in this case, the Plaintiff’s negligence was not at issue in the case. As such, the court ruled that the trial court erred in relying upon the Fair Share Act to keep Defendants in the case.

The court otherwise noted that there is no absolute right to have settled Co-Defendants on a Verdict Sheet. Rather, the appellate court noted that a trial court must determine whether any evidence of the settled Co-Defendant’s liability exists in the case presented before deciding whether that party should be put on the Verdict Slip.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Carmen J. Nocera of the Pittsburgh law firm of Harry S. Cohen & Associates, P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image: Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko on www.pexels.com.

Friday, December 9, 2022

Court Addresses Ability of Non-Settled Defendant To Have Settled Defendants On the Verdict Slip



In the case of Williams v. Glenmaura Senior Living at Montage, LLC, No. 21-CV-1494 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 7, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court considered a motion filed by a Defendant doctor for reconsideration of the court’s previous Orders which discontinued the case as to other named Defendants which previous dismissal from the case of those Defendants was based upon those Defendants entering into earlier joint tortfeasor settlement agreements with the Plaintiff.

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a medical professional liability action against numerous Defendants related to a slip and fall event that occurred on the premises after which the alleged negligent treatment by the medical Defendants allegedly resulted in the death of the Plaintiff.

After reviewing Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 229 regarding the Discontinuance of actions, the court rejected the moving medical Defendant’s argument that the settled Defendants must remain in the case and on the Verdict Slip.

In this regard, the court found no evidence presented by the moving Defendant that warranted keeping the settling Defendants in the case. Of note, the court stated that there was no valid expert evidence that would be presented by the moving Defendants to keep the settled Defendants in the case. 

The court also noted that the moving Defendants reference to certain standard of care and causation opinions of one of the experts in the case was not admissible as such testimony constituted hearsay. The court reiterated the rule of law that one expert may not act as mere conduit or transmitter of the content of an admissible evidence or other expert opinion where the testifying expert does not bring to bear on it his own expertise or judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, November 21, 2022

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Rejects Request to Have Settled Defendants on Verdict Slip



In the case of Williams v. Glenmaura Senior Living at Montage, LLC, No. 21-CV-1494 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 7, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed a motion by certain Defendants in a medical malpractice case for reconsideration of the court’s previous Order granting certain settling Defendants’ Motion for Discontinuance from the case by virtue of the settling Defendants’ Joint Tortfeasor Agreements.

One of the non-settling Defendants wished to keep the settling Defendants in the case for purposes of the trial.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County

In his Opinion, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas confirmed that, in Pennsylvania, there is no absolute right to have settling Co-Defendants placed on a verdict slip.

Rather, under the applicable standard of review, the trial court is required to determine whether any evidence of a settling Co-Defendant’s liability exists before deciding whether to put that Co-Defendant on the verdict slip.

In terms of a medical malpractice action, Judge Nealon noted that expert testimony is required to establish the elements of a duty, breach, and causation and that, if expert testimony will not be presented at trial to establish a settling Defendant’s potential liability, then that settling Defendant should not be included on the verdict slip.

Judge Nealon noted that he had previously granted the voluntary Discontinuance of the settling Defendants in this matter in the absence of admissible expert testimony against those Defendants. The court also noted that any efforts by the Plaintiff to introduce expert testimony on the standard of care and causation would amount to hearsay in this case.

As such, the court found that it had previously properly granted the settling Defendants’ Motions for Discontinuance. The Motion for Reconsideration at issue here was, therefore, also denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.