Showing posts with label Bad Faith - Third Party Claims. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bad Faith - Third Party Claims. Show all posts

Thursday, April 23, 2020

Another Court Rules: No Coverage, No Bad Faith



In the case of NVR, Inc. v. Mutual Benefit Ins. Co., No. 2:19-cv-26-NR (W.D. Pa. March 13, 2020 Ranjan, J.), the court issued another decision in which it was held that, if there is no coverage under a policy, there can be no bad faith as well.

The insured, NVR, was a company that developed and built homes.  When a number of landslides in western Pennsylvania damaged a number of homes, NVR was sued by the homeowners.  NVR filed this lawsuit against the carrier seeking coverage and a defense under insurance policies issued to an engineering company and under which NVR was listed as an additional insured.  However, the coverage under the policy to additional insureds was found to be limited.

In this matter, the court determined that there was no coverage due to NVR as an additional insured and, as such, ruled against NVR on its breach of contract and declaratory judgment claims. The court then ruled that the bad faith claims also failed as a result.

As to the additional insured’s statutory bad faith claim, the court more specifically noted that, where there is no duty to defend, there can be no statutory bad faith claim against the carrier.

NVR attempted to avoid a total dismissal by asserting that it still had a valid common law bad faith claim to pursue.

However, the court noted that the only common law bad faith cause of action available in Pennsylvania arises out of claims pertaining to the insurance contract itself.  The court noted that where, as here, a contract claim is found to be invalid, then the common law bad faith claim must also be dismissed as well.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Lee Applebaum, the writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law Blog for bringing this case to my attention. Attorney Applebaum is with the Philadelphia law firm of Fineman, Krekstein & Harris.

Friday, October 18, 2019

Corrected Link for Jones v. Ritchie Case

Yesterday's Tort Talk blog post reviewed the case of Jones v. Ritchie, No. 4983-Civil-2019 (C.P. Monroe Co. Sept. 2, 2019 Williamson, J.), the court dismissed common law and statutory bad faith claims against a carrier on the grounds that no contractual relationship existed between the carrier and the plaintiffs.

The Link to the decision was incorrect. Here is the corrected LINK.

I apologize for any confusion and thank you for reading Tort Talk.




Thursday, October 17, 2019

No Valid Direct Claim of Bad Faith Can Be Asserted By Third Parties Against Carrier If Not Party to Insurance Contract


In the case of Jones v. Ritchie, No. 4983-Civil-2019 (C.P. Monroe Co. Sept. 2, 2019 Williamson, J.), the court dismissed common law and statutory bad faith claims against a carrier on the grounds that no contractual relationship existed between the carrier and the plaintiffs.
By way of background, the plaintiff was allegedly injured as a result of a rear-end accident allegedly caused by a defendant driver.  The vehicle operated by the defendant driver was rented by a co-defendant. That co-defendant who rented the vehicle that was being operated by the defendant driver at the time of the accident was covered under a personal automobile insurance policy issued by the carrier who filed the Preliminary Objections in this matter.   

As such, the plaintiffs were strangers to the insurance policy issued by the insurance company that they sued in this matter. 

In granting the Preliminary Objections of the insurance on the common law and statutory bad faith claims presented by the plaintiffs, the court initially cited to several cases that have held that the common law claims for bad faith on the part of insurance companies are not recognized in Pennsylvania.   As such, the common law bad faith claims asserted by the plaintiffs were denied on that additional basis.   

Relative to the plaintiff’s statutory bad faith claims, the court emphasized that under 42 Pa. C.S.A. §8371, it was required that the plaintiff pursue an action under an insurance policy and that the claims presented involve claims that the carrier had acted in bad faith “toward the insured.”   

Judge Williamson emphasized that the bad faith statute provides that a carrier has a duty to the person it has insured.  The court otherwise noted that “[t]here is no statutory duty for an insurance company to act in good faith as to third parties.” [other citations omitted].  

Given that the plaintiffs in this matter were not a party to the insurance company’s contract, the court found that the plaintiff had no basis upon which to bring a statutory bad faith claim against that carrier.  

As such, the insurance company was dismissed from this matter as a party defendant.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK