Showing posts with label Appeals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Appeals. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 25, 2026

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Addresses the Appeal Period for Appeals From Collateral Orders Where a Motion for Reconsideration Was Filed


In the case of Khalil v. Mary Jane Home Enrichment Center, Inc., No. 16 EAP 2025 (Pa. Aug. 5, 2026) (Op. by Donohue, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed issues relative to the time period within which an appeal may be filed from the entry of a collateral Order where a Motion for Reconsideration had been filed relative to that collateral Order.

The case arose out of a pro se dispute involving a landlord-tenant matter.

During the course of the case, pro bono counsel who had entered an appearance for the pro se tenant withdrew from the case after the completion of an Arbitration.

The tenant later challenged the withdrawal by the pro bono attorney, arguing that the attorney had not obtained leave of court to withdraw.

After a series of Motions, the trial court ultimately granted the pro bono attorney’s Motion to Withdraw as counsel. That amounted to the collateral Order at issue.

Following the entry of that collateral Order, the pro se tenant filed a Motion for Reconsideration which was denied.

The pro se litigant then filed a Notice of Appeal more than thirty (30) days after the entry of the collateral Order that had allowed the attorney to withdraw.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court quashed the appeal as untimely. The Superior Court explained that appeals from collateral Orders must be filed within thirty (30) days of the entry of that Order.

The Superior Court also ruled that neither a Motion for Reconsideration nor an Order denying that Motion for Reconsideration tolls or resets the appeal period.

The Superior Court also noted that the Order denying the reconsideration Motion was also not appealable in this case.

Further up the appellate ladder, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the rulings of the Superior Court.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed that a party must file a Notice of Appeal within thirty (30) days from the entry of a collateral Order in order to attempt an appeal. Otherwise, a party must wait until a final Order is entered before any appeal could be filed.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court additionally confirmed that the filing of a Motion for Reconsideration, or an Order denying that Motion for Reconsideration, does not affect the thirty (30) day deadline within which to attempt to file an appeal from a collateral Order.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Justia Daily Opinion Summaries (Aug. 6, 2026).

Tuesday, January 13, 2026

Not So Fast: Superior Court Quashes Appeal After Finding That Trial Court Order Was Not a Final Order


In the case of Henry v. Colangelo, 2025 Pa. Super. 265 (Pa. Super. Nov. 26, 2025 Kunselman, J., McLaughlin, J., and Lane, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court quashed an appeal after finding that the Order that the appellant had appealed from was not a final Order.

More specifically, although the trial court had certified an Order granting summary judgment against some but not all of the Defendants in a negligence and wrongful death suit as a final Order and immediately appealable, the Superior Court quashed the appeal after finding that the Order was not final and that an appeal would not facilitate resolution of the entire case.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Court Summaries” By Timothy L. Clawges, Pennsylvania Bar News (Dec. 22, 2025).

Thursday, October 2, 2025

Appellate Court Overrules Trial Court's Application of Archaic Local Rule

The Superior Court has ruled against another archaic local rule in its recent decision in the case of Biros v. U Lock, Inc., No. 113 WDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Aug. 1, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., Bowes, J., and King, J.) (Op. by Lazarus, P.J.).

In this matter, the court vacated the trial court Order out of the Common Pleas of Westmoreland County in which the trial court had denied, with prejudice, an appellant’s Motion to file her Pa. R.A.P. 1925(b) Concise Statement of Errors Complained of on Appeal, nunc pro tunc.  


The appellate court noted that the appellant had timely filed her Notice of Appeal but her otherwise compliant electronic filing was rejected by a County Prothonotary pursuant to a local rule of court requiring that notices of appeal be filed in person or by mail.  


The appellate court further held that the trial court lacked jurisdiction to deny the appellant’s Motion to Leave to File a Rule 1925(b) Statement while the appellant’s Petition for Allowance of Appeal to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania remain pending.  


The Superior Court noted that, Pa. R.C.P. 205.4(e)(2) bars any refusal of an otherwise compliant pleading for filing based upon a requirement of a local rule pertaining to the electronic filing of legal papers.  The court found that Westmoreland County’s requirement that notices of appeal could be filed only in person or by mail was such a local rule. 


Accordingly, the appellate court ruled that the appellant’s initial filing was properly and timely filed and was sufficient to initiate the appeal.  


As such, the appellate court vacated the trial court’s Order and remanded the case for further proceedings.  


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source:  The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert, www.Law.com (Aug. 19, 2025).


Source of image: Photo by Priyank V on www.unsplash.com.



Wednesday, January 3, 2024

Once Appeal is Filed Trial Court Loses Jurisdiction Over the Case


In its non-precedential decision in the case of Grady v. Nelson, No. 2115 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Nov. 20, 2023 Stabile, J., Dubow, J., Pellegrini, J.) (Op. by Stabile, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reaffirmed the rule of appellate procedure that, once a case goes up on appeal, the trial court loses jurisdiction to take further action until the case is remanded.

The Superior Court more specifically noted that the effort by the defense counsel to place a case on a trial list before the pleadings were even closed and any opportunity was allowed to conduct pre-trial proceedings as allowed under the Rules of Civil Procedure was improper. The court noted that it was improper for counsel for seek a trial listing while the appeal was pending given that the lower court did not have any jurisdiction to proceed further in the matter, subject to certain exceptions which were not applicable in this case.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article – “Court Scolds Counsel for Pursuing Case in Both Common Pleas, Appellate Systems” By Riley Brennan of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 28, 2023).

Friday, July 1, 2022

New Monetary Limit for Rule 1311.1 Appeals From Arbitrations Goes Into Effect Today

In an Order that goes into effect today, July 1, 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has put into place a new rule amending Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1311.1 to change the maximum limit of what a plaintiff may elect as the value of damages that they can recover in a trial on appeal from an arbitration award.

Under the old rule, that limit was set at $25,000.

Under the new rule, the maximum limit has been changed to "an amount equal to the jurisdictional limit for compulsory arbitration of the judicial district in which the action was filed."

While different judicial districts have differing jurisdictional limits for arbitration, that limit is capped at a maximum $50,000 under Section 7361 of the Judicial Code.

Research should be completed to confirm the jurisdictional limit in which the case is pending to determine the maximum amount that a plaintiff can claim at a jury trial in a case on appeal from an arbitration award as those limits can be different depending upon which County Court the case is pending in.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Order approving this amendment to the Rule can be viewed HERE.   The amended Rule 1311.1 can be viewed HERE.


Source:  Article:  "New Arb Appeal Awards Rule Aims to Reduce Apparent Defense Bias." by Aleeza Furman of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 31, 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Sasun Bughdarvan on www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, June 30, 2022

Trial Court Opines That Defendant's Appeal From Order Dismissing Defendant's Objections to Jurisdiction Should Be Quashed


In the case Galette v. New Jersey Transit, No. 200800610 (C.P. Phila. Co. May 31, 2022 Crumlish, J.), the trial court filed a Rule 1925 Opinion to the appellate court recommending the dismissal of the Defendant’s appeal from the trial court’s Order dismissing the Defendant’s objections to jurisdiction.

It was the position of the trial court that the Order dismissing the Defendant’s objection to jurisdiction was appealable only under Pa.R.A.P. 311(b) and that the requirements of that Rule had not been met. 

According to the Opinion, this matter arose out of a personal injury action filed by the Plaintiff against the Defendant New Jersey Transit, and another Defendant. According to the lawsuit, the Plaintiff was injured while sitting in a parked vehicle in the City of Philadelphia when that vehicle was allegedly struck by a bus operated by one of NJ Transit’s employees.

The Defendant, NJ Transit, objected to the court’s jurisdiction over it through a Motion to Dismiss. That Motion was denied and NJ Transit filed an appeal, which prompted this Opinion by the court.

The trial court noted that an Order denying a Motion to Dismiss is ordinarily interlocutory and, therefore, not appealable unless expressly made so by statute.

In its Opinion, the court cited to Pa.R.A.P. 311, which lists the interlocutory appeals that may be taken as a right, and Pa.R.A.P. 312, which allows for interlocutory appeals by permission.

Under Pa. R.A.P. 311(b), an appeal is allowed as a right when a trial court’s Order overruled Preliminary Objections to the trial court’s in personam or in rem jurisdiction and either the Plaintiff elected to treat the Order as final or the trial court stated in the Order that a substantial issue of jurisdiction existed.

Given that these requirements were not met, and given that the Defendant, NJ Transit, did not otherwise seek leave of court to file an interlocutory appeal, or request an Order stating that a substantial issue of jurisdiction was presented, the trial court noted that the appeal should be quashed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 7, 2022).




Thursday, June 2, 2022

New Monetary Limit for Rule 1311.1 Appeals From Arbitrations Set to Go Into Effect on July 1

In an Order that goes into effect on July 1, 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court will put into place a new rule amending Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1311.1 to change the maximum limit of what a plaintiff may elect as the value of damages that they can recover in a trial on appeal from an arbitration award.

Under the current rule, that limit was set at $25,000.

Under the new rule, the maximum limit will be changed to "an amount equal to the jurisdictional limit for compulsory arbitration of the judicial district in which the action was filed."

While different judicial districts have differing jurisdictional limits for arbitration, that limit is capped at $50,000 under Section 7361 of the Judicial Code.


Source:  Article:  "New Arb Appeal Awards Rule Aims to Reduce Apparent Defense Bias." by Aleeza Furman of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 31, 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Sasun Bughdarvan on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, February 16, 2022

Trial Court Says Appeal Should Be Quashed Because Party Did Not File Post-Trial Motions


In the case of Hernandez v. Grandview Hospital, No. 2018-CV-01736 (Bucks Co. Nov. 15, 2021 Mellon, J.), the court issued a Pa. R.A.P. 1925(a) Opinion in support of its decision granting a nonsuit in a medical malpractice case.

Of note, the trial court ruled that the Plaintiff’s appeal should be quashed because the Plaintiff took an appeal from the nonsuit entered in favor of the Defendant and did not first file any written Post-Trial Motions pursuant to the requirements of Pa. R.C.P. 227.1.  As such, the trial court requested that the appellate court quash this appeal.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 4, 2022).

Soure of image:  Photo by Gabriel Soto on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, December 28, 2021

Appeal Dismissed Where Trial Court Order Did Not Dispose of All Claims or All Parties

In the case of D’Angelo v. J.P. Morgan Chase Bank, N.A., No. 2007-0041-40 (C.P. Bucks Co. Oct. 15, 2021 Trauger, J.), the court issued a Rule 1925(a) Opinion in support of its previous Order in this case involving alleged forgeries on mortgages.

The court dismissed the Plaintiffs’ appeal from an Order granting one Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment as premature. The appeal was dismissed because the subject Order was found not to be a final Order where that Order did not dispose of all claims and/or all parties, and did not otherwise constitute an Order that was appealable under any of the other applicable exceptions or on an interlocutory basis.

The trial court requested that the Superior Court affirmed its decision in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec.1, 2021).



Wednesday, October 2, 2019

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Reaffirms General-Verdict Rule For Personal Injury Matters on Appeal



In the case of Shiflett v. Lehigh Valley Health, No. 43 MAP 2018 (Pa. Sept. 26, 2019) (Op. by Donohue, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that the Superior court erred in remanding a medical malpractice case for a new trial on damages when that decision by the Superior Court went against the “general-verdict rule” previously adopted by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs pursued this medical malpractice action in connection with injuries the Plaintiff allegedly suffered while in the hospital for knee surgery.

At trial, the Plaintiffs returned the verdict in favor of the Plaintiff awarding them in excess of $2 million dollars in damages.

On appeal the Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that one of the claims upon which the Plaintiffs prevailed was barred by the statue of limitations and should not have been submitted to the jury.  After finding that some portion of the jury’s damages award may have been based on that time-barred claim, the Superior Court remanded the case for a new trial on damages.   

Upon further appeal, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in this decision concluded that the Superior Court had erred in remanding the case for a new trial on damages given that, under the “general-verdict rule” adopted by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the case of Halper v. Jewish Family & Children’s Services,, 963 A.2d 1282 (Pa. 2009), the hospital waived any entitlement to a new trial on damages when the hospital failed to request a special Interrogatory on the verdict sheet that would have permitted the jury to allocate damages awarded on each claim.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of Justice Donohue's Majority Opinion in this decision may click this LINK.

The Dissenting Opinion by Justice Saylor can be viewed HERE.

Monday, July 15, 2019

Trial Court Rules that Appellate Issues Waived



In the case of U-Save Auto Rental of Lansdale, Inc. v. Highline Auto. Group, No. 2016-CV-06620  (C.P. Montg. Co. April 23, 2019 Rogers, J.), the trial court wrote a Rule 1925 Opinion for the appellate court asserting that the trial court’s decision that the Defendant had waived all issues on appeal should be upheld.  

This matter arose out of a breach of contract case involving a business consultation contract.   

In this matter, the Defendant failed to file a post-trial motion after a bench trial.   The court noted that the failure to file a post-trial motion under Pa.R.C.P. 227.1 generally resulted in a waiver of all issues on appeal.  

The trial court additionally noted that the Defendant failed to file a Concise Statement of Errors Complained of on Appeal in a timely fashion.   The court noted that, absent any applicable exception to the general rule, the failure to comply with the requirements of Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b), pertaining to the requirement to file Concise Statement of Errors on Appeal when ordered to do so by the court also resulted in an automatic waiver of all issues on appeal.  

In its Rule 1925 Opinion, the trial court urged the appellate court to quash the Defendants’ appeal.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source:  “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 21, 2019). 




Thursday, May 16, 2019

Pennsylvania Superior Court Issues Cautions For Preserving Record and Issues for Appeal


In the case of Hassel v. Franzi, No. 2019 Pa. Super. 109 (Pa. Super. April 8, 2019 Stevens, P.J.E., Olson, J., Dubow, J.) (Op. by Stevens, P.J.E.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court noted that a failure to include record citations in party’s statement of issues in appellate filings, so that the appellate court could establish that the objections asserted were made and what was objected to, amounts to a waiver of the issues on appeal.  

The Superior Court noted that “[i]t is axiomatic that when a court has to guess what issues a Defendant is appealing, that is not enough for meaningful review.”  See Op. at 12.  

In this regard, the court noted that this matter involved an eight (8) day trial and that the appellate only initially provided the court with notes of testimony from portions of the trial.   The Superior Court noted that the Superior Court’s Prothonotary completed an extensive effort to ascertain the remaining notes of testimony.   In its Opinion, the court reminded the appellant of its duty to ensure that the Superior Court receives all of the documents necessary to review the issues raised on appeal.   See fn. 1 at p. 13.    

The court additionally noted in this Opinion that any objections concerning an expert exceeding the scope of an expert report and/or the scope of direct examination must be specifically stated or will be considered to be waived on appeal.  

This case arose out of a medical malpractice action.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.  

Monday, December 10, 2018

Raising Too Many Issues On Appeal Will Dilute a Good Case and Will Not Save a Bad One

In the case of Berks Counseling Center v. Community Care, No. 898 MDA 2017 (Pa. Super. Nov. 7, 2018 Panella, J., Olson, J., Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Panella, J.)(Non-Precedential), the court chastised the appellant for “throwing in every conceivable point” in its appellate’s filings.  This case arose out of a dispute by the Plaintiff with one of its contractors.  

This case again provides the lesson that the appellate court frowns upon appeals containing many issues.   Here, the appellant raised eight (8) issues on appeal.

Judge Panella noted that the appellate court judges’ receptiveness of issues raised on appeal “declines as the number of assigned errors increases.”  

Judge Panella additionally noted in his opinion that “experience on the bench convinces [him] that multiplying assignments of error will dilute and weaken a good case and will not save a bad one.”   It was additionally noted that throwing in every possible point on appeal is distracting to judges and gives support to a presumption that none of the arguments raised has any merit whatsoever.  

Ultimately, the Superior Court ruled in favor of Berks Counseling Center and held that none of the issues raised on appeal by Community Care merited any relief.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source:  Article by PJ D’Annunzio entitled “Court Chastising Appellant for ‘Throwing In Every Conceivable Point,’”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 13, 2018).  

Commentary:  The Superior Court cautions in this Opinion that multiplicity of claims on appeal hints a lack of confidence in any one of the claims.  How ironic that the Court would issue this Opinion as a "Non-Precedential" Opinion as a listing of an Opinion as "Non-Precedential," as opposed to a published Opinion of precedence, also hints that perhaps the Court is not as confident in its Opinion.

It is respectfully submitted that, in this day and age of digital publication, the time has come for the Superior Court to publish all of its Opinions.  A concern that the publication of too many Opinions will fill too many books is not as strong of a concern anymore as the use of books is (unfortunately) becoming a thing of the past.  

Here's to hoping that the Superior Court changes its internal rules and opts to publish all of its Opinions so that the bench and bar may have more and more excellent appellate guidance on a wide variety of issues for the benefit of all.


What do you think?

Thursday, April 19, 2018

Appeal of Denial of Motion to Disqualify a Court Appointed Neutral Quashed


In the case of Haviland v. Kline & Specter, No. 1791 EDA 2017 (Pa. Super. March 22, 2018 Murray, J., McLaughlin, J., and Stevens, J.) (Op. by Murray, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the rules of pertaining to permissible appeals from the trial court. In this particular case, the question was whether a trial court’s denial of a motion to disqualify a court appointed neutral arbitrator was appealable.   The court ruled that it was not and, therefore, he appeal was quashed.  

This matter arose out of a dispute between law firms over fees.   In the trial court proceedings, the court appointed a neutral arbitrator to hear the matter.   One of the parties involved filed a motion to disqualify that arbitrator.   After the trial court denied the motion to disqualify the neutral arbitrator, the case was appealed.  

A main portion of this court’s Opinion dealt with whether the trial court’s denial of the motion to disqualify the arbitrator was appealable as a non-final order.   In this regard, the Superior Court stated that it was unable to locate any case directly on point. However, the court concluded that the case law addressing the interlocutory nature of pre-trial recusals of trial court judges to be persuasive and instructive.  

The court held that “an order denying a motion seeking the recusal or disqualification of an arbitrator, as with an order denying the recusal of a trial judge, is not a final order or an interlocutory order appealable as of right or as a collateral order.  

Given that the Superior Court found that the trial court’s Order denying a party’s motion to disqualify an arbitrator is not a final order or an interlocutory order appealable as of right or as a collateral order, the Superior Court quashed this appeal as it, therefore, did not have jurisdiction to the merits of the issue presented. 

Anyone wishing to read this case may click this LINK.






Friday, February 23, 2018

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Reviews Collateral Order Doctrine for Appeals


Tort Talkers may recall prior posts on the Lebanon County case of Shearer v. Hafer pertaining to whether a Plaintiff is entitle to have a representative present during portions of a neuropsychological IME. 

The Tort Talk post on the Superior Court's decision in this case can be viewed HERE.  The post on the trial court's decision can be viewed HERE.  Concisely, the Superior Court affirmed the trial court's order allowing a representative of the Plaintiff to be present during the preliminary interview phase of the neuropsychological evaluation, but not during the standardized testing portion of the evaluation.

Now comes the Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision recently handed down in this case on January 18, 2018 ruling that the Pennsylvania Superior Court erred in even considering the issue on appeal as the trial court's order was not an appealable order as of right under Pa.R.A.P. 313 where the trial court order only met one of the three prongs of the collateral order doctrine.  As such, the Superior Court's decision on the issue was vacated.

The Majority Opinion of the Court in Shearer v. Hafer, No. 93 MAP 2016 (Pa. Jan. 18, 2018), written by Justice Todd, can be viewed HERE.

Justice Wecht's Concurring Opinion can be viewed HERE.

Justice Mundy's Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.

This Opinion may be a good one to consult if you have a question on whether a trial court order is appealable under the collateral order doctrine under Pa.R.A.P. 313. 

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the rule of law that the collateral order doctrine is to be narrowly construed and that each of the three prongs to allow for an appeal must be clearly present.

The three prongs of the collateral order doctrine as set forth under Pa.R.A.P. 313(b) are:

(1) the order is separable from and collateral to the main cause of action

(2) the right involved in the order is too important to be denied review by the appellate court, and

(3) the question presented is such that if review is postponed until the final judgment of the case, the claim will be irreparably lost.




Monday, November 16, 2015

Electronic Filing of Record on Appeals Now Allowed

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has issued a November 13, 2015 Order, effective immediately, allowing for the electronic filing, transmission, and/or remand of a record on an appeal.

Here is a LINK to the Order.

Monday, January 26, 2015

Appeal of MSJ Order Quashed in Consolidated Case Where Not All Defendants Dismissed


In the recent Superior Court case of Malanchuk v. Tsimura, 2014 Pa. Super. 277, 1379 EDA 2012 (Dec. 17, 2014 Ford Elliot, P.J.E.), an en banc Court ruled in this construction accident personal injury case that the Plaintiff could not take an appeal from a Summary Judgment against a single Defendant when that negligence case was consolidated with a negligence case against another action where the other Defendant did not receive a Summary Judgment.

The court rejected the Plaintiff's argument that, although the separate claims against the separate Defendants were consolidated, the entry of summary judgments against one Defendant but not the other should be viewed as separate final Orders from the trial court capable of being appealed.

Rather the Malanchuk Court ruled that the Order appealed from was interlocutory in nature as the Order did not dispose of all parties or all claims.  The Plaintiff did not follow the required procedures to seek permission to file an appeal from an interlocutory Order.  As such the appeal was quashed.

I send thanks to the prevailing attorney Robert Horn of Connors Law in Exton, PA for bringing this case to my attention.

Anyone wishing to review this case may click this LINK.



Source of Image: xenonnet.blogspot.com

Friday, October 18, 2013

Copy of Campbell v. Safeco Decision Secured (Standard of Review of Appeal from Private UM Arbitration)

Monroe County Judge Williamson's Opinion in the case of Campbell v. Safeco on the issue of the standard of review from a privately agreed upon arbitration of an uninsured (UM) motorist claim was recently summarized here.

Judge Williamson held that, in the absence of a formal arbitration agreement, the case should be considered as if the parties submitted the matter to common law arbitration under 42 Pa. C.S.A. §7341.  Under that statute, an arbitrator’s decision could only be set aside if there was “clear, precise, and convincing evidence" that the parties were denied a hearing or that there was fraud, misconduct, corruption, or some other irregularity which caused the rendering of an unjust, inequitable award.  

Attorney Gerard J. Geiger of the Stroudsburg, PA law firm of Newman, Williams, Mishkin, Corveleyn, Wolfe & Fareri was kind enough to send me a copy of the Campbell v. Safeco decision and I thank him for that.  Anyone wishing to review the decision may click this LINK.

Commentary: Given how UIM and UM issues are typically handled in a similar fashion by the courts, one can anticipate a similar result in the context of an attempt to appeal from a privately agreed upon UIM arbitration as well.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Superior Court to Identify Authors of Unpublished Memorandum Opinions

The Pennsylvania Superior Court has announced that it will start the process of identifying the authors of its unpublished memorandum Opinions.

This move was made, in part, to allow attorneys to learn which Judge wrote the Opinion in the case argued before the court.

Generally speaking, when a Superior Court Opinion does not address a new issue, the author of that opinion can elect to issue the Opinion as a non-precedential, unpublished memorandum Opinion.  Given the thousands of cases the court addresses, it is a fairly common result that the court's Opinion is issued as a Memorandum Opinion.

Note that under Pa.R.A.P. 3519(b), a request can be made to the Superior Court by either the trial court judge or one of the attorneys involved in the matter that the Opinion be changed from a memorandum Opinion to a published Opinion.  According to the Rule, that request should be made within 14 days of the issuance of the Opinion.  The Rule also states that the decision on whether or not to grant the request is solely within the discretion of the Superior Court panel that decided the case.


Source: Article--"Superior Court to Identify Authors of Memorandums," by Ben Present in the 7/12/11 Legal Intelligencer.

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Tip for the Unwary

Here's a tip for the unwary: When appealing from a district magistrate proceeding on a breach of contract claim, don't forget to attach a copy of the contract to your Complaint to avoid a dismissal of the Complaint at the trial court level.

Such was the ruling in the Armstrong County Court of Common Pleas case of Painter v. Allegheny Graphics, Inc., PICS Case No. 09-2969 (C.P. Armstrong Aug. 3, 2009 Valasek, J. ). In Painter, the court applied Pa.R.C.P. 1019(i) which requires the attachment of the actual contract to the Complaint in breach of contract actions.



A copy of this case can be secured from the Pennsylvania Law Weekly's Instant Case Service by calling 1-800-276-7427 and giving the above PICS Case Number.