Showing posts with label Warnings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Warnings. Show all posts

Thursday, January 30, 2025

Western District Federal Court of Pennsylvania Addresses Products Liability Claims In a Prescription Medical Device Litigation


In the case of Blair v. Abbvie, Inc., No. 2:23-CV-1871 (W.D. Pa. Jan. 9, 2025 Ranjan, J.), the court granted a Motion to Dismiss in a prescription medical device litigation.

In this decision, the Western Federal District Court confirmed that Pennsylvania’s across-the-board application of the Restatement §402A, comment k, as precluding strict liability design defect claims, but not strict liability manufacturing defect claims.

The court also ruled that, similarly, given that the elements of implied warranty claims are identical to strict liability claims, the Plaintiff’s implied warranty claims were dismissed.

The court also ruled in this case that the manufacturing defect claims asseted by the Plaintiff were inadequately pled because the claims did not reveal either any specific problem with the device or how the device allegedly failed. The court noted that the availability of a malfunction theory manufacturing defect claim does not exclude excuse failure to plead the circumstances of the alleged malfunction.

The court also ruled that the negligent design and warning claims were inadequately pled because the Plaintiff did not identify the design defect, anything about the manufacturing process, or what information should have been given to his medical providers.

Based on these issues, the trial court granted the Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.




Thursday, September 8, 2022

Federal Court Addresses Potiential Liability of Drug Manufacturer in Products Liability Case


In the case of DiCair v. Gilead Sci., Inc., No. 21-CV-5486 (E.D. Pa. July 12, 2022 Schiller, J.), the court ruled that negligent failure-to-warn and strict liability product claims against a pharmaceutical manufacturer were barred as a matter of Pennsylvania law.  As such, a Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss was granted in part and denied in part.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant designed and manufactured a prescription medication sold under the trade name of Harvoni which was used to treat Hepatitis C. 

The Plaintiff’s decedent was prescribed the medication and, after taking the medication, was diagnosed with a form of liver cancer. The Plaintiff’s decedent passed away thereafter.

The Plaintiff filed this lawsuit alleging a failure to warn and design and manufacturing defect claims under both negligence and strict liability. The Plaintiffs claimed that the decedent’s development of cancer was caused by his use of the medication.

The court dismissed the negligent failure-to-warn claim, noting that it was well-settled Pennsylvania law that pharmaceutical companies do not owe a duty to warn the public. Rather, manufacturers of medications are only required to warn prescribing doctors of the risk of the medications.  The court cited to the learned intermediary doctrine which holds that drug manufacturers are only required to direct required drug safety warnings to physicians who, in turn, are required to relay the same to patients.

However, the court declined to dismiss the Plaintiff’s negligent design and manufacturing defect theories, finding that the Plaintiff had asserted a valid cause of action that the Defendants had allegedly negligently designed and manufactured the medication.

Lastly, the court did dismiss the Plaintiff’s strict liability claims after holding that strict liability claims against prescription drug manufacturers were barred by Pennsylvania products liability law.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 12, 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Anna Shvets on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, December 10, 2020

Summary Judgment Granted In Products Liability Case



Summary Judgment was granted to various Defendants in the strict liability case of Zielinski v. Mega Mfg., Inc.,  No. 2:18-CV- 05113-JDW (E.D. Pa. Oct. 9, 2020 Wolfson, J.). 

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff’s decedent died in a workplace accident when a table on which he was loading metal sheets upended the sheets fell upon the Plaintiff and killed him. 

The Plaintiff was working at a manufacturing plant and was using a machine to stamp sheet metal. 

The record indicated that, when the manufacturing plant had purchased the machine, the Defendant machine manufacturer informed the facility that it had to supply tables and material handling devices to be used with the stamping machine. The manufacturer prepared specifications to guide the design of such a table. However, it was emphasized in the Opinion that that manufacturer did not build, certify, or otherwise take responsibility for the creation of the table. 

The manufacturing plant where the decedent worked bought a table from a Co-Defendant. It was indicated that the Co-Defendant’s specifications called for the table to be anchored to the floor. However, the manufacturing plant did not do so and instead installed casters. At the time of the incident, the decedent was transferring sheets to the table when the table tipped and the sheets of metal fell upon the decedent. 

The court noted that there was no evidence presented as to what caused the table to upend. 

The decedent’s wife had filed a wrongful death and survival action against, in part, both the manufacturer of the machine and the manufacturer of the table under claims for strict liability and negligence. 

In entering summary judgment, the court noted that the manufacturer’s product, which was the machine used to stamp sheet metal, did not injure the decedent. It was also noted that that Defendant did not manufacture, supply, sell, or even recommend the particular table that upended. 

The court found that Pennsylvania law did not hold that manufacturer of the stamp machine strictly liable for failing to warn under the circumstances presented. It was additionally noted that that manufacturer did not have the duty to warn just because it had recommended the size of the table needed to make its machine work. Furthermore, that manufacturer Defendant did not require its customers to use any type of material tables and it was noted that workers could also simply stack materials on the floor or onto a forklift. 

The court additionally noted that the Plaintiff did not offer any evidence that the alleged defeat with the stamp machine, or any lack of any warning, was the proximate cause of the decedent’s death. 

The court additionally ruled that the Plaintiff’s claims against the maker of the table failed because that Defendant did not manufacture the table with casters or approve the change to the use of the table by the manufacturing plant. 

The court noted that, even if the table caused the decedent’s death, it was not the same type of table that that Defendant had sold to the facility since it had been modified. The court additionally noted that the manufacturing plant’s modifications to the table fell under the warnings about the use of the table. 

As stated, summary judgment was granted in favor of both Defendants. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Oct. 27, 2020).

Tuesday, July 24, 2018

Summary Judgment Granted in Part and Denied in Part Under Tincher Analysis


In the case of Mercurio v. Louisville Ladder, Inc., No. 3:16-CV-412 (M.D. Pa. May 31, 2018 Mariani, J.), the court granted summary judgment in part and denied it in part in a design defect products liability case. 

The case arose out of a Plaintiff's fall from a ladder.

In this decision, the court noted that the admissibility of the Plaintiff’s design defect expert required a Daubert hearing on the Defendant's Motion in Limine seeking to preclude the Plaintiff's expert from testifying. 

The court additionally found that there was no basis for the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion that the warnings on the product at issue were defective.  The court noted that the expert’s opinion in this regard was a spur of the moment comment during depositions.    The court additionally found that the Plaintiff’s expert was not qualified to evaluate the warnings at issue.  

Judge Robert D. Mariani
M.D. Pa.
Judge Mariani also concluded that, under the new post-Tincher law, compliance with industry standards by the defense is evidence that a jury may consider as relevant to a product’s risk/utility defect test.  

The court also reaffirmed that the Azzarello case was overruled by the Tincher decision.  

Judge Mariani also confirmed that, under the current status of Pennsylvania products liability law, there is no longer a bright line between negligence and strict liability theories in a given case.  

In the end, the court denied the Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment relative to the design defect and breach of implied warranty claims.  However, the court did grant the Defendant summary judgment on the claims of a manufacturing defect, inadequate warning, and breach of express warranty.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  Here is a LINK to the companion Order entered in the case.

I send thanks for Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith Law Firm in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania for bringing this case to my attention.  

Friday, July 6, 2018

Summary Judgment Reversed in Alleged Misuse of a Safety Harness in a Products Liability Case


In its recent decision in the case of Zimmerman v. Andrew, No. 662 WDA 2017 (Pa. Super. June 1, 2018 Bowes, J., Panella, J. and Stabile, J.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed a trial court’s entry of summary judgment in favor of a Defendant in a products liability case.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was injured when a safety harness he was utilizing while cutting down a tree allegedly failed when the Plaintiff was 35 feet up in a tree and the Plaintiff fell to the ground and sustained personal injuries.  

The record before the court indicated that the Plaintiff had gone to the home of his friend to cut down a dead tree at the request of the friend.   The friend had obtained the harness from another friend who had purchased the harness but never used it.   The harness came with paper instructions.  

The Plaintiff skimmed the instructions but did not thoroughly read the instructions.   The Plaintiff also admittedly saw a warning label on the harness itself but did not read it completely.  

The Plaintiff, who had limited personal experience using a harness in construction work and from seeing them used on television programs featuring people cutting trees, thought the use of the harness was self-explanatory.  

However, the Plaintiff and his friend put the harness on the Plaintiff backwards.  

Thereafter, when the Plaintiff utilized the harness to bear his weight high up in the tree, the harness failed and the Plaintiff fell to the ground.  

The Plaintiff sued the manufacturer of the harness under claims of strict product liability, negligence, and breach of warranty.  

The Plaintiff more specifically alleged that the harness was sold with insufficient strength and durability such that it was unreasonably dangerous.  The Plaintiff also asserted that the harness was sold with inadequate warnings regarding the proper use of the device.  

In its defense, the Defendant asserted the defenses of misuse of the product and comparative negligence.  

More specifically, the Defendant asserted that the harness was intended for use on construction projects by workers trained on how to use it and that the Plaintiff’s use of the device in a tree without training was a misuse, not an intended use, and further was not foreseeable.  The defense also asserted that the Plaintiff was wearing the harness backwards.

The trial court had entered summary judgment after finding that “[t]here is absolutely nothing that we would make a manufacturer think that” someone would use the product as the Plaintiff did and that “it would be a waste of time to take this to a jury” because the jury would have to find in favor of the Defendant if they followed the court’s instructions as to the law.  

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reviewed the current status of Pennsylvania strict liability law under §402A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts as well as under general negligence principles given the Plaintiff’s separate claims in this regard.   The Superior Court confirmed that, under the current status of Pennsylvania law, the Plaintiff’s use of the harness in an unforeseeable or highly reckless manner could serve to defeat the Plaintiff’s §402A claim.  

Citing to Reott v. Asia Trend, Inc., 55 A.3d 1088, 1097 (Pa. 2012), the Superior Court noted that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had recognized that product misuse and highly-reckless conduct are affirmative defenses to a strict liability claim.   According to Reott, to establish a misuse of the product, the Defendant must show that the use was “unforeseeable or outrageous.”  

The Reott court had noted that highly reckless conduct is akin to evidence of misuse and requires the Defendant to prove that the Plaintiff would have been injured despite the curing of the alleged product defect, or that the misuse of the product by the plaintiff was so extraordinary and unforeseeable as to constitute a superseding cause.  

The court in this Zimmerman case went on to note, citing other precedent, that it is “well-settled that a plaintiff’s misuse of a product cannot be grounds for granting summary judgment in favor of the manufacturer under a designed defect theory unless it is established that the misuse solely caused the accident while the design defect did not contribute to it.”   See Op. 8. [emphasis in Zimmerman].

In this Zimmerman decision, the court pointed to various issues of fact, along with issues raised by the parties' experts, to  conclude that the Plaintiff tendered sufficient evidence that, if accepted by the jury, would establish that the harness was defective, that the Defendant was negligent in the product’s design and instructions, and that these deficiencies were a proximate cause of the Plaintiff’s injuries.  

As such, the Superior Court found that it was error for the trial court to rule on the record before it that the Plaintiff’s misuse of the harness was the sole cause of the accident. 

The Superior Court also ruled that there were material issues of fact relative to the negligence issues such that the Plaintiff’s negligence claims should also be allowed to proceed to the jury.  

In light of the its other conclusions, the Superior Court additionally allowed the Plaintiff’s breach of warranty claim to also proceed to the jury.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Kenneth T. Newman of the Pittsburgh office of Thomas Thomas & Hafer for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, March 23, 2016

Post-Tincher Products Decision out of Eastern District of PA

In the case of Hatcher v. SCM Group North America, Inc., No. 15-1630 (E.D. Pa. March 1, 2016 Schiller, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court addressed Post-Tincher products liability issues in a case in which a machinist Plaintiff alleged injuries to three (3) fingers while working with an industrial woodworking sawing machine.  

According to the Opinion, on the front of the machine, there was a warning label that stated, in capital letters, “DON’T RUN THE MACHINE WITHOUT NECESSARY SAFETY GUARDS.”  

The court additionally noted that the operation and maintenance manual that came with the machine explained in detail how to use and assemble the safety guards, including a fence system and the blade guard.   The manual contained the warning, “Before starting machine, make sure all guards are in place.”  

At the time of the incident, the blade guard was not in use.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had been hired three (3) months before the accident to operate the subject machine.   However, the record before the court indicated that the Plaintiff had only used the machine once before the accident. 

Moreover, the Plaintiff had not received any formal training on the machine, aside from a demonstration with verbal instructions by the primary operator of that machine.  That demonstration with instructions took place on the date of the incident.  

The record confirmed that, prior to the accident, neither the Plaintiff, nor the primary operator of the machine had ever read the operating manual.  The Plaintiff also admitted that he never read the capital letters warning on the machine.    

Additionally, the Plaintiff and the primary operator of the machine, as well as other individuals, each testified that they never knew that a blade guard even existed for the machine.  

Other evidence indicated that the company had not had any problems with the machine since purchasing it at an auction over twenty-five (25) years before.   The primary operator, and another individual, testified that they still believed, despite the accident, that the machine was safe to use even without a blade guard.  

The Opinion also noted that the Plaintiff asserted that the blade guard would have prevented his injury and that he would not have used the machine without the blade guard if he had known it existed.  

The case came before the court on a summary judgment motion by the Defendant.  

The court noted that the Plaintiff initially presented four (4) claims in the Complaint:

                        (1)       Breach of Expressed and Implied Warranty;

                        (2)       Defective Manufacturing;

                        (3)       Defective Design, and,

                        (4)       Failure to Warn.

 
The court noted that the Plaintiff conceded that there was no manufacturing defect.   The Plaintiff also conceded that the Defendant’s evidence established that the Plaintiff’s breach of warranty claim was time barred.  

The court also found that the Plaintiff failed to distinguish between the defective design claim and the failure-to-warn claim, offering no evidence to support an independent defective design claim.  

The court additionally found that the Plaintiff’s failure-to-warn claim failed because the danger of the spinning blades on the machine was open and obvious and the existing warnings adequately addressed the danger of operating the machine without safety guards.  

Accordingly, the court granted summary judgment to the Defendant on all of the claims presented.  

In so ruling, the court held that extended periods of safe product use establishes that the alleged lack of proper warnings did not make the product “unreasonably dangerous.”   In its decision, the court also applied the pre-Tincher rule that there is no duty to warn of risk that only arises when existing warnings are ignored.  

Anyone wishing to read this Hatcher Opinion online may click this LINK and the Order HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reid Smith for bringing this case to my attention.