In the case of
Hatcher
v. SCM Group North America, Inc., No. 15-1630 (E.D. Pa. March 1, 2016
Schiller, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court addressed Post-Tincher
products liability issues in a case in which a machinist Plaintiff alleged
injuries to three (3) fingers while working with an industrial woodworking sawing
machine.
According to the Opinion, on the front of the machine, there
was a warning label that stated, in capital letters, “DON’T RUN THE MACHINE
WITHOUT NECESSARY SAFETY GUARDS.”
The court additionally noted that the operation and
maintenance manual that came with the machine explained in detail how to use
and assemble the safety guards, including a fence system and the blade
guard.
The manual contained the warning,
“Before starting machine, make sure all guards are in place.”
At the time of the incident, the blade guard
was not in use.
According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had been hired three
(3) months before the accident to operate the subject machine.
However, the record before the court
indicated that the Plaintiff had only used the machine once before the
accident.
Moreover, the Plaintiff had
not received any formal training on the machine, aside from a demonstration
with verbal instructions by the primary operator of that machine.
That demonstration with instructions took place
on the date of the incident.
The record
confirmed that, prior to the accident, neither the Plaintiff, nor the primary
operator of the machine had ever read the operating manual.
The Plaintiff also admitted that he never
read the capital letters warning on the machine.
Additionally, the Plaintiff and
the primary operator of the machine, as well as other individuals, each
testified that they never knew that a blade guard even existed for the
machine.
Other evidence indicated that the company had not had any
problems with the machine since purchasing it at an auction over twenty-five
(25) years before.
The primary
operator, and another individual, testified that they still believed, despite
the accident, that the machine was safe to use even without a blade guard.
The Opinion also noted that the Plaintiff asserted that the
blade guard would have prevented his injury and that he would not have used the machine without the blade guard if he had known
it existed.
The case came before the court on a summary judgment motion
by the Defendant.
The court noted that the Plaintiff initially presented four
(4) claims in the Complaint:
(1)
Breach of Expressed and Implied
Warranty;
(2)
Defective Manufacturing;
(3) Defective Design, and,
(4) Failure to Warn.
The court noted that the Plaintiff conceded that there was
no manufacturing defect.
The Plaintiff
also conceded that the Defendant’s evidence established that the Plaintiff’s
breach of warranty claim was time barred.
The court also found that the Plaintiff failed to
distinguish between the defective design claim and the failure-to-warn claim,
offering no evidence to support an independent defective design claim.
The court additionally found that the Plaintiff’s
failure-to-warn claim failed because the danger of the spinning blades on the
machine was open and obvious and the existing warnings adequately addressed the
danger of operating the machine without safety guards.
Accordingly, the court granted summary judgment to the
Defendant on all of the claims presented.
In so ruling, the court held that extended periods of safe
product use establishes that the alleged lack of proper warnings did not make
the product “unreasonably dangerous.”
In its decision, the court also applied the pre-Tincher rule that there
is no duty to warn of risk that only arises when existing warnings are
ignored.
Anyone wishing to read this Hatcher Opinion online may click this LINK and the Order HERE.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia
office of Reid Smith for bringing this case to my attention.