Showing posts with label Consumer Expectation Test. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consumer Expectation Test. Show all posts

Thursday, December 22, 2022

Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann of Middle District Addresses Admissibility of Alleged Contributory Negligence of Plaintiff in Products Case



In the case of Cote v. Schnell Industries, No. 4:18-CV--1440 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 8, 2022 Brann, J.), the court addressed several issues with respect to the admissibility of alleged misconduct by a Plaintiff in a products liability case.

According to the Opinion, this case involved a machine involved in a workplace accident that nearly severed the Plaintiff's hand.

The court noted that a Plaintiff’s comparative negligence is not admissible in a strict liability action, except as a superceding cause where the Plaintiff is the sole cause of the accident. The court otherwise noted that negligence that relates to the product itself cannot be a sole cause.

Here, the court found that the Plaintiff’s conduct in putting his hand in a dangerous position in the product relates to the product and was, therefore, inadmissible to be used against the Plaintiff.

The court also noted that the Plaintiff’s conduct is not relevant to the consumer expectation or risk-utility factors applicable to a products liability action because these tests to determine a product defect are concerned with the actions of an “ordinary” person, and not any particular Plaintiff.

However, the court did note that evidence of a Plaintiff’s voluntary assumption of the risks, misuse of a product, or highly reckless conduct is admissible to prove the issue of causation.

Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann
M.D. Pa.


Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann stated that, under Pennsylvania law, the assumption of the risk doctrine requires a knowing and voluntary exposure of oneself to a known risk. The court found that his assumption of the risk doctrine is inapplicable where a Plaintiff was required to use equipment provided by an employer.

Judge Brann additionally noted that product misuse and highly reckless conduct involve a Plaintiff’s unforeseeable, outrageous, and extraordinary use of a product. Whether a Plaintiff’s conduct meets this standard is for a jury to decide.

However, because a Plaintiff’s misuse and highly reckless conduct cannot be a sole cause of the accident, the court found the evidence of such conduct was inadmissible. 

On another issue before the Court, Judge Brann additionally noted that the Defendants could not use a Motion In Limine as a belated substitute for a Rule 702 motion relative to the competency of an expert’s opinion.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE


I thank Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Court Allowed to Instruct Products Liability Jury on Both Risk-Utility Test and Consumer Expectation Test If Warranted by Evidence


In the case of Davis v. Volkswagen, No. 1405 EDA 2018 (Pa. Super. July 19, 2019 Bowes, J., McLaughlin, J., Stabile, J.) (Op. by McLaughlin, J.)(Stabile, J., Concurring), the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that the Lehigh County Court of Common Pleas did not commit any error in a products liability case when it instructed the jury on both the consumer expectation test and the risk-utility test that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court established in the case of Tincher v. Omega-Flex, even though the Plaintiff only litigated the case under the consumer expectation test.  

The court noted that, although the Plaintiff argued that the trial court judge should not have instructed the jury on both tests, Pennsylvania law under Tincher allowed jury instructions on both tests where evidence was presented by the defense at trial regarding the same.  

According to the Opinion, the defense put in evidence that, according to the trial court and the appellate court, put the risk-utility test at issue in this crashworthiness case.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majoirity Opinion of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.  The Concurring Opinion can be viewed HERE.

Source: Article - “Superior Court Addresses Post-‘Tincher’ Jury Instructions In Volkswagen Crashworthiness Case” by Max Mitchell in the Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 31, 2019).   




Monday, January 30, 2017

Pennsylvania Superior Court Addresses Post-Tincher Issues

In its recent post-Tincher decision in the case of High v. Pennsy Supply, Inc., No. 411 MDA 2016 (Pa. Super. Jan. 13, 2017 Ford Elliot, P.J.E., Shogan, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Stevens, P.J.E.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the Plaintiff’s claims that the trial court erred in refusing to allow a jury to decide as fact-finder whether wet concrete is a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to the consumer pursuant to the standard set forth in Tincher v. Omega Flex, 104 A.3d 328 (Pa. 2014).   The High court reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded for further proceedings.  

As noted by Attorney James M. Beck, a member of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith law firm and a writer of the excellent drug and device law blog, the court in this matter confirmed that Tincher “significantly altered the common law frame work for strict products liability claims in Pennsylvania.”  

Attorney Beck also noted that this court quoted Tincher’s description of the Azzarello standard as “confusing and impracticable, and in compatible with the basic principles of strict liability.”  

It was also noted that this decision confirmed that a jury should be the decider of the question of whether an alleged defect of a product is “unreasonably dangerous.”  In this regard, the Pennsylvania Superior Court in High stated that “whether a product is in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to the consumer is a question of fact that should generally be reserved for the fact-finder.”  

Attorney Beck also noted that the High court’s decision is notable in its statement that the product risks in question is “unknowable” to the objective “average or ordinary consumer” is an essential element of the consumer expectation approach.   This, according to Beck, arguably supports not only the relevance of the state of art at issue, but also that it is a Plaintiff’s burden to prove these elements under the consumer expectation test.  

Attorney Beck also noted that this opinion supports the admissibility of industry standards and products liability cases in post-Tincher matters.   The High court stated in its Opinion that a product’s “compli[ance] with industrial ASTM standards” is an appropriate subject of expert testimony in a products case.  

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck for bringing this case to my attention along with his analysis of the same.   Please be sure to check out his excellent DRUG AND DEVICE LAW BLOG.


The Majority Opinion of the Superior Court in High can be viewed online HERE.

Judge Shogan's Concurring and Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.


To review the Tort Talk post on the trial court's decision in High and to access the trial court's opinion by a Link, click HERE.

Wednesday, March 23, 2016

Recent Post-Tincher Decision of Note Out of the Western District

In the Western Federal District Court case of Rapchak v. Haldex Brake Products Corp., No. 2:13-CV-1307 2016 WL 1019534 (W.D. Pa. March 15, 2016 McVerry, J.), the court denied a defendant’s summary judgment motion in a Post-Tincher products liability case.

This matter arose out of a fatal incident involving a Plaintiff who was performing maintenance under his motorhome when the vehicle descended upon him.

The court concluded that the central question of whether adding a filter to an air flow system would have made the product harder to use because the filter would have to be changed too often was a question for the jury to determine. 

The court in Rapchak referred to the Wade factors for risk/utility and an “ordinary consumer” test for consumer expectation. 

Also, in a footnote, the court in Rapchack described one of Tincher’s “principal impacts” as being the elimination of the Azzarello negligence/strict liability dichotomy and the other being that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to adopt the Restatement (Third) of Torts relative to Pennsylvania Products Liability claims.  See n. 15.


Anyone wishing to review this case may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith, and the main blogger for the Drug and Device Law Blog  for bringing this case to my attention.