Showing posts with label Employers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Employers. Show all posts

Sunday, June 12, 2022

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Notes That Direct and Vicarious Theories May Be Pursued Against Employer For Negligence by Employee


In the motor vehicle accident case of Shaver v. Levelle, No. 21-CV-2465 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 26, 2022 Nealon, J.), the defendant-motorist’s employer filed preliminary objections seeking to dismiss plaintiff’s claims for negligent entrustment, hiring, and training as legally insufficient since the motorist admitted that he was an employee of the employer at the time of the accident. 

Judge Nealon reviewed the law on this issue in detail and noted that several federal district courts and at least one common pleas court have, in the past, dismissed claims against employers for negligent hiring, training, and supervision in cases of admitted agency, and have done so on the basis that no Pennsylvania appellate court has ever held that a plaintiff may simultaneously pursue claims against an employer for vicarious liability and direct liability in cases where an employer-employee relationship is admitted. 

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County


















Judge Nealon found that those previous court decisions that have gone the other way on this issue were negated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's decision in Scampone v. Highland Park Care Center, LLC, 57 A.3d 582 (Pa. 2012), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected the argument that a plaintiff is barred from pursuing a direct negligence claim against a corporate employer if it acknowledges that the employee was acting within the course of employment at the time of the tort.  That Court concluded that “direct and vicarious theories of liability are grounded in distinct policies and serve complementary purposes in the law of torts,” and that they may be “asserted either concomitantly or alternately” even in cases of undisputed agency. 

Judge Nealon found that, since the federal and state trial court rulings cited by the defendant-employer “are contrary to the Supreme Court reasoning in Scampone,” the Defendant's preliminary objection was overruled.

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Superior Court Rules That Employers Need Not Notify Employees of Rejection of UIM Coverage Under Employer's Policy (Non-Precedential)

In the non-precedential decision by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the case of Derr v. National Fire Ins. Co. of Hartford, No. 1340 EDA 2019 (Pa.Super. Feb. 6, 2020 Nichols, J., Murray, J., and Colins, J.)(Op. by Colins, J.), the appellate court rejected a claim that public policy interests requires notification to all employees regarding an employer's rejection of UIM coverage be valid under the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law.

Anyone wishing to review this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Matthew D. Vodzak of the Philadelphia law firm of Fowler, Hirtzel, McNulty & Spaulding, LLC, for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, December 26, 2018

Employer Liability for Data Breach Reviewed by Pennsylvania Supreme Court



In the case of Dittman v. UPMC, No. 43 WAP 2017 (Pa. Nov. 21, 2018), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the duty of an employer to safeguard sensitive personal information of employees. 

The court ruled that an employer has a legal duty to use reasonable care to safeguard an employee’s sensitive personal information stored by the employer on internet/accessible computer systems.  

The court additionally noted that recovery in negligence for these types of purely pecuniary damages raised in this type of case are permitted under the economic loss plan since the recovery asserted is based upon an application of an existing duty to a novel factual scenario as opposed to imposing a new affirmative duty requiring consideration of other factors under Pennsylvania law.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority Opinion written by Justice Baer may click this LINK.  Chief Justice Saylor's Concurring and Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.

Source:  “Court Summaries by Timothy L. Clawges,” Pennsylvania Bar News (Dec. 17, 2018)