Showing posts with label Discovery Issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Discovery Issues. Show all posts

Friday, July 17, 2026

Trial Court Addresses Protections Afforded by Mental Health Procedures Act Relative to Mental Health Records in Discovery


In the case of Morreck v. Karns, No. 2025-CV-1140 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 12, 2026 Minora, S.J.), the court addressed discovery issues in a motor vehicle accident case.

According to the court’s decision, the Plaintiff alleged physical injuries as a result of a motor vehicle accident but confirmed that she was not alleging any independent psychological injury as a result of the accident.

At issue in this matter was the Plaintiff’s objection to the Defendant’s subpoenas for medical records.   In the subpoenas, the Defendant specifically excluded from production any records concerning mental health or psychiatric treatment from either before or after the subject accident.

The Plaintiff objected to the subpoenas, raising concerns of a possible unintended release of information protected by privileges afforded by the Mental Health Protections Act, 50 Pa. C.S.A. §7111.

Senior Judge Carmen Minora
Lackawanna County


In his decision, Senior Judge Carmen D. Minora of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas confirmed that mental health records were indeed privilege under the MHPA. 

However, the court noted that a patient can waive the confidentiality protections under the MHPA where, as judged by an objective standard, the Plaintiff knew or reasonably should have known that the Plaintiff’s mental health would be placed directly at issue by the filing of a lawsuit.

However, here, where the Plaintiff had not placed her mental health at issue, the court found that the Plaintiff had not waived any confidentiality protections under the MHPA. 

As such, the court precluded discovery on any mental health treatment records and allowed discovery only of materials that were not protected under the privileges afforded under the MHPA.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Joshua J. Perry of the O’Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, PA for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, July 15, 2026

Superior Court Addresses the Parameters of the 'Common Interest Privilege' Under the Related Attorney-Client Privilege


In the case of Solid Waste Services, Inc. v. Ember Partners, LP, No. 1674 EDA 2025 (Pa. Super. June 9, 2026 Lazarus, P.J., Panella, P.J.E., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Panella, P.J.E.), the Superior Court addressed discovery issues in a civil litigation dispute.

A primary issue addressed was whether a trial court Order granting a Motion to Compel production of documents withheld by a Defendant should be affirmed.

On appeal, the Defendant that was subject to the Motion to Compel was relying upon the somewhat novel “common interest” privilege to contend that they were legally entitled to withhold certain requested documents under a related attorney-client privilege argument

On appeal, the Superior Court noted that it agreed with the trial court’s findings that, while there may have been a common interest between the applicable parties earlier in the negotiations and dealings between the parties, the record revealed that there was no evidence of a common interest at the times relevant to the subject lawsuit. 

The Superior Court also found that the Defendant that was subject to the Motion to Compel Order did not meet their burden of proving the existence of an agreement to share the common interests privilege at any time. 

Accordingly, the Superior Court affirmed the trial court finding that the common interest doctrine did not protect attorney-client communications shared with a third-party because the Defendant at issue failed to prove an agreement to pursue a shared legal strategy and also failed to show any continuing common legal interest at the relevant times in the lawsuit.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert, www.Law.com (June 30, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by Sasun Bughdaryan on www.unsplash.com.

Monday, April 20, 2026

Trial Court Addresses Duty of Counsel To Act Reasonably in Moving Forward With Discovery and Depositions


In the case of Knick v. Lehigh Valley Hospital, No. 2024-CV-3016 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan,. 30, 2026, Nealon, J.), the court addressed a second Motion filed by a Plaintiff to extend the deadlines for the completion of discovery and expert discovery, and to postpone the scheduled trial date, in a medical malpractice case.

In this Opinion, the court noted earlier admonitions from the court directing the parties to promptly initiate and complete their pre-trial preparations.

In their filings on this Motion, each party claimed that the opposing party was the reason for the delay. 

The court noted, however, that defense counsel produced emails and other communications between counsel reflecting that the Plaintiff made no attempt to schedule a single deposition for the first fourteen (14) months that the case was pending and that defense counsel had made many attempts to schedule depositions only to have Plaintiff’s counsel claim that they were unavailable and, on another occasion, to cancel the depositions that had been scheduled for mutually convenient dates.

The court noted that litigants and their counsel have an obligation to act reasonably in scheduling and conducting discovery depositions, and when attorneys are unavailable to complete pending legal matters in a timely fashion, the Rules of Professional Conduct require them to either (a) decline additional work, (b) seek assistance or (c) withdraw and allow another attorney to complete the work.

Ultimately, the court granted the Plaintiff’s Motion to Extend partially by allowing for deadlines to be modified in a limited fashion. However, the request to postpone the July of 2026 trial date was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, April 14, 2026

Superior Court Addresses Discoverability of Internal Post-Incident Investigative Reports in Medical Malpractice Case


In the case of Griffin v. The Bryn Mawr Hospital, No. 3361 EDA 2024, 2026 Pa. Super. 53 (Pa. Super. March 19, 2026 Bowes, J., Murray, J., and Beck, J.) (Op. by Beck, J.) (Concurring and Dissenting Op. by Murray, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed whether four internal documents created by the medical providers after the hospital allegedly mishandled fetal remains were protected from disclosure under Pennsylvania’s Medical Care Availability and Reduction of Error Act (MCARE) and the Federal Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act.

According to the Opinion, the case arose out of a lawsuit filed by parents who alleged that the hospital mistakenly cremated the placenta instead of their fetus and later admitted to a “mix up.”

During discovery, the hospital withheld four internal reports tied to its investigation. The hospital asserted that these documents were privileged patient-safety materials generated as part of its compliance and internal review processes.

In its Opinion, the court addressed how far hospitals can shield internal investigation documents from discovery under the above-referenced state and federal patient-safety laws.

The Superior Court majority ruled that the documents were not protected under MCARE. The court found that the MCARE statute applied only to events involving direct patient care and not post-treatment conduct. The court here found that the allegations in this case did not implicate any medical treatment issues.

With regards to the application of the federal law, the federal law under the PSQIA, this court entered a split decision. The court held that three of the documents at issue were shielded under the broader scope of the PSQIA law because they were created as part of the hospital’s internal patient safety evaluation system.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority's decision may click this LINK.

Judge Murray's Concurring and Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.


Source: Article – “Pa. Superior Court Splits On MCARE Patient-Safety Privilege Case,” By Tristin Hoffman of The Legal Intelligencer (March 25, 2026).


Source of image:  Photo by RDNE Stock Project on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, January 22, 2026

Superior Court Addresses Statutory Privilege Related to Patient Safety Reports In Med Mal Cases


In the case of Boyle v. Mainline Health, Inc., No. 2454 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Sept. 10, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., King, J., and Lane, J.) (Op. by King, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that a failure to provide a Patient Safety Report (PSRS) to the hospital’s Patient Safety Committee or governing board meant that the hospital could not rely upon the statutory privilege under the Medical Care Availability and Reduction of Error Act (MCARE). 

The court otherwise ruled that the creation of other records as part of a patient safety evaluation system did trigger the privilege under the Patient Safety and Healthcare Quality Improvement Act (PSQIA). As such, the discovery Order of the trial court was affirmed in part and reversed in part.

This matter arose out of a medical malpractice action in which the Plaintiff’s alleged that there child suffered birth injuries. During the discovery, the Plaintiffs sought documents related to the investigation of the baby’s delivery. 

In response, the Defendants produced a privilege log identifying four (4) responsive documents, the Patient Safety Occurrence Worksheet, the Situation Background Assessment/Recommendations, the Patient Safety Reporting System, and the Potential Compensible Event Report. The Defendants asserted that these documents were privileged under the MCARE Act and the PSQIA. 

The Plaintiff responded with a Motion to Compel.

After the trial court granted the Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel, the case went up on appeal. As noted, the Superior Court affirmed in part and reversed in part.  The Superior Court found that the Defendants did not meet their burden of establishing the PSRS report arose out of a matter reviewed by a patient safety committed or governing board pursuant to their Section 311(b) MCARE Act responsibilities.  As such, the Defendants were required to disclose the PSRS report.

The appellate court also reversed the portion of the trial court's Order finding that the Defendants failed to establish that the PSQIA privilege applied to certain other documents.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

The Concurring/Dissenting Opinion by Judge Lane can be viewed HERE.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert, www.Law.com (Sept. 30, 2025).


Source of image:  Photo by Thirdman on www.pexels.com

Monday, August 11, 2025

Superior Court Addresses Discoverability of Documents Under Patient Safety and Healthcare Quality Improvement Act in a Med Mal Case


In the case of Boyle v. Mainline Health, Inc., No. 2454 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. July 17, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., King, J., and Lane, J.) (Lane, J., Concurring and dissenting)(Maj. Op. by King, J.), the Superior Court ruled that reports created for the hospital’s patient safety organization constituted “deliberation or analysis of” the patient safety evaluation system. As such, the court ruled that these reports were privileged under the Patient Safety and Healthcare Quality Improvement Act. 

This case arose out of a medical malpractice lawsuit by the Plaintiffs seeking compensation for birth injuries sustained by their child.

During the course of discovery, the Defendants produced a privilege log regarding certain documents. The Plaintiff followed a discovery motion in response. The trial court granted the Plaintiff’s Motion.

On appeal, the Superior Court affirmed in part and reversed in part. As part of the ruling, the Superior Court noted that the Defendants had a patient safety plan, which established a patient safety committee under MCARE.

The court found other documents that were not privileged given that those documents did not arise from a matter reviewed by the patient safety committee.

However, noted above, the court did find that certain other documents fell within the scope of the statutory privilege provided under the Patient Safety and Healthcare Quality Improvement Act.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The concurring and dissenting Opinion issued by Judge Lane can be viewed HERE.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert,” www.Law.com (Aug. 6, 2025).

Thursday, July 31, 2025

Superior Court Reverses Trial Court Dismissal of a Matter as a Discovery Sanction


In its non-precedential decision in the case of Spigelmire v. Lehnhoff’s Landscaping, No. 1456 MDA 2024 (Pa. Super. July 1, 2025 Bowes, J., Olson, J., and Stabile, J.) (Op. by Stabile, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court overruled a trial court decision dismissing a personal injury case as a sanction for the Plaintiff’s discovery violations.

This case arose out of a slip and fall incident.

The Superior Court held that, while Plaintiff’s conduct was improper, that misconduct did not warrant as extreme consequence as a dismissal of the case.

During the course of the matter, one of the Defendants secured an Order compelling the Plaintiffs to produce records. When the Plaintiff still did not respond to the discovery requests thereafter, that Defendant filed a Motion for Sanctions. When Plaintiff’s counsel failed to appear at the sanctions hearing, the court ordered that the case be dismissed with prejudice.

Several days later, the Plaintiff requested the trial court to reconsider the dismissal, claiming that the Plaintiff missed the discovery deadline and the hearing on the Motion for Sanctions because her attorney failed to proper record and communicate the dates. The court denied the Motion for Reconsideration and the Plaintiff appealed. 

As noted, the Superior Court reversed, finding that the trial court abused its discretion in dismissing the matter.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.

Source: Article “Cases’ Dismissal Was Too Extreme Sanction For Plaintiff’s Discovery Violations, Pa. Appeals Court Says,” By Aleeza Furman of The Legal Intelligencer (July 2, 2025).


Source of image: Photo by Elena Mozhvilo on www.pexels.com.

Wednesday, May 14, 2025

Discovery Sanctions Entered Against Defendant Who Was Not Cooperating With Discovery Requirements


In the case of Jones v. STR8 FROM US, LLC, No. 2:24-CV-05370-GJP (E.D. Pa. April 23, 2025 Pappert, J.), the court entered a sanctions Order against the defense in a motor vehicle accident matter where the Defendant driver refused to speak with his defense counsel that were hired by the Defendant’s insurance carrier, refused to respond to the discovery requests and deadlines, and refused the efforts to complete his deposition.

After discovery Orders were entered, the Plaintiffs moved for sanctions pursuant to F.R.C. 37(b) related to the Defendant’s continued failure to obey the court’s discovery Orders.

In assessing the justification of any discovery sanctions, the court applied what is known as the Poulis factors, which are a series of six (6) separate factors that a trial court should review and apply before granting an award for sanctions. In this regard, the court cited the case of Poulis v. State Farm, 647 F.2d 863, 868 (3d Cir. 1984).

Judge Pappert noted that Rule 37 authorizes courts to sanction conduct that obstructs the completion of discovery. After reviewing the matter before him, Judge Pappert granted sanctions and precluded the Defendant from testifying at trial or offering evidence concerning how the car accident involving the Plaintiff occurred and/or who was at fault. 

The court also noted that, after reviewing the Poulis factors, it was also appropriate to strike all of the Defendant’s affirmative defenses that did not pertain to the issues of causation or damages.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: Article – “Judge Hobbles Trial Defense After Client Refuses To Cooperate With His Lawyers” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (April 24, 2025).

Wednesday, March 5, 2025

Trial Court Addresses Parameters for Completion of IME of a Plaintiff Who Resides Out of State


In the case of Seifert v. Whitfield, [Docket Number Not Provided in Decision] (C.P. Chester Co. May 16, 2024 Binder, J.), the court addressed a Defendant’s Motion to Compel a Plaintiff, who was a resident of Florida, to attend an independent medical examination to be performed by a physician located in Pennsylvania. The parties disputed whether the Defendant should bear the costs related to the travel to complete the IME.

The court noted that Pa. R.C.P. 4010 permits a party to require another party to attend an IME under appropriate circumstances. The Rule, however, is silent as to which party bears the cost related to traveling for an IME.

Relying upon case law from other similar situations, the court in this case ordered that the Defendants could require a Plaintiff to attend an IME within one hundred (100) miles of her own residence without having to pay the Plaintiff's costs related thereto.

The court found that the Defendant could also elect to require the Plaintiff to attend an IME in Pennsylvania, in which case, the Defendants would have to pay for the Plaintiff’s reasonable costs for flights, lodging and ground transportation.

The court also noted that the Defendants could require the Plaintiff to attend an IME in Pennsylvania on the day before trial, or on a day that the Plaintiff is visiting Pennsylvania, in which case, the Defendants would not have to pay for the Plaintiff’s cost related to attending the IME.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Feb. 13, 2025).

Source of image:  Photo by Cottonbro on www.pexels.com.

Monday, February 3, 2025

Discovery Sanctions Awarded


In the case of Hamilton Law Group P.C. v. Hardenstine, No. 1464-CV2020 (C.P. Monroe Co. Nov. 22, 2024 C. Daniel Higgins, Jr., J.), the court granted a Motion for Discovery Sanctions after the Defendants failed to obey a court Order regarding the production of discoverable documents.

The court found that the Defendants’ continued and willful refusal to supply timely and full responses to discovery, even after being ordered to do so, demonstrated disdain towards the court. The court found that appropriate sanctions were authorized by Pa. R.C.P. 4019(a).

The court reaffirmed the general law of Pennsylvania that the imposition of discovery sanctions is a matter that falls under the broad discretion of a trial court judge. Judge Higgins noted that the factors to be considered were (1) the prejudice endured by the non-offending party and the ability of the opposing party to cure any prejudice; (2) the non-complying party’s willfulness or bad faith in failing to provide the requested discovery, (3) the importance of the excluded evidence in light of the failure to provide discovery, and (4) the number of discovery violations by the defending party.

Here, the court granted the Motion for Sanctions and ordered the Defendants to pay $750.00 in attorneys’ fees to the Plaintiffs’ attorneys. The Defendants were also ordered to provide full and complete Responses to the Request for Production of Documents at issue within thirty (30) days.

The court otherwise noted that, if the Defendants again fail to comply, the Plaintiffs were invited to apply for additional sanctions, including attorney’s fees and, possibly incarceration.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 16, 2025).

Trial Court Grants Discovery Sanctions After Med Mal Defendant Led Plaintiff on Wild Goose Chase


In the case of Lapteff v. Abington Mem. Hosp., No. 2021-CV-00536 (C.P. Montg. Co. Nov. 15, 2024 Saltz, J.), the court entered an Order in favor of a Plaintiff in a medical malpractice claim on issues regarding alleged spoliation of evidence and discovery sanctions.

In this medical malpractice case, the Plaintiff filed a Motion for Sanctions relative to the Defendant hospital’s alleged spoliation of an audit trail for electronic medical records.

The court granted the motion in part by ordering the Defendant to pay the Plaintiffs’ attorney’s fees and costs in seeking the production of an audit trail after the Defendant only belated explained that the discovery requested was unnecessary because pertinent medical record updates were reflected on the records themselves.

The court otherwise denied the Plaintiff’s request for an entry of judgment in its favor given that the spoliation committed by the Defendant did not serve to prejudice the Plaintiffs’ ability to prove their case. This was because the details of any after-the-fact changes to the Plaintiff’s medical records were confirmed to be in the medical records themselves.

Nonetheless, the court found that the Plaintiffs were prejudiced by being led on a wild goose chase by the Defendant which had originally simply maintained that it had no responsive documents in its possession when the Plaintiff originally requested the medical record audit trail. At no time did the Defendant, early on, inform the parties or the court that an audit trail was not required because any changes would be noted on the face of the medical records themselves. This revelation was only made after the court invited the Plaintiffs to file a Motion for Sanctions.

The court noted that, whether the Defendant’s conduct was intentional or not, a timely disclosure would have saved the parties and the court from considerable needless effort.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert. (Jan. 8, 2025).


Source of image:  Photo by Cottonbro Studios on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, September 12, 2024

Federal District Judge Crafts Sanction for Discovery Violations


In the case of Domus BWW Funding, LLC v. Arch Ins. Co., No. 2:23-CV-00094-JDW (E.D. Pa. Aug. 12, 2024 Wolson, J.), the court issued discovery sanctions against the Defendant insurance company related to discovery issues and “sloppy” discovery responses by the carrier. The court declined to impose a monetary sanction and instead decided to create jury instructions regarding the carrier’s actions.

More specifically, the court noted that the deletion of emails during discovery was considered troubling but was also procedural as the insurance company underwent a company wide transition.

In the end, the carrier was hit for sanctions due to his “cavalier attitude” towards its discovery obligations after the carrier was found to have failed to preserve evidence related to the lawsuit.

The judge imposed sanctions under FRCP 37(e)(1) after finding that the Plaintiff was prejudiced by the carrier’s deletion of emails by an underwriter of the policy at issue. As a remedy, the court noted that it was craft appropriate jury instruction regarding evidence of the insurance company’s failure to preserve the emails.

In his decision, the court also faulted the Plaintiff for not bringing the issues to the attention of the court until a summary judgment motion was filed. The court noted that a post-hoc Motion for Sanctions is not the appropriate vehicle to address the prejudice of the insurance company’s negligent approach towards the discovery obligations.

Judge Wolson noted that, although the discovery may, at times, amount to drudgery that lawyers may not enjoy, lawyers have an obligation to take their discovery duties seriously.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE


Source: Article - “Citing ‘Sloppy’ Discovery, Pa. Federal Judge Imposes Sanctions on Insurance Carrier, Calls Out Counsel,” By Marianna Wharry of the Legal Intelligencer (Aug. 15, 2024).

Tuesday, February 6, 2024

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Orders a Plaintiff To Produce Various Items of Discovery in a Medical Malpractice Action


In the case of Healey v. Scranton Hospital Company, LLC, No. 23-CV-1793 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 12, 2024 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas granted a medical malpractice Defendant’s Moton to Compel a Plaintiff to provide various items in discovery.

According to the Opinion, this matter involved a medical malpractice action against a hospitalist, his employer, and a local hospital and involved allegations of the improper administration of opioid medication in the emergency room to the Plaintiff which allegedly caused the Plaintiff to suffer hypoxemic respiratory failure and cardiac arrest allegedly due to the Plaintiff’s documented history of obstructive sleep apnea.

With the Motion to Compel filed by the Defendants, the Defendants asserted that they had served discovery on the Plaintiffs seeking information and documents concerning potential witnesses and regarding Plaintiff’s past medical expenses, work history, medical treatment, health and disability insurance, income tax filings, Social Security Disability documents, documentation and information regarding Plaintiff’s past and future wage loss claims, and with respect to projected future medical expenses.

The Plaintiff responded to these inquiries by stating “to be supplied” or that the requested information and documentation would be provided “at the completion of discovery.” Certain Defendants filed a Motion to Compel more timely and complete responses from the Plaintiff.

Judge Nealon granted this motion noting that, during pre-trial discovery, litigants are obligated to provide to their adversaries relevant information and documentation that currently exist or are readily available. As such, the court ordered the Plaintiff to produce certain items of discovery at issue.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County 


However, Judge Nealon also noted that that evidence which requires expert review and formulation need not be produced until later in the discovery process and as required by Pa. R.C.P. 4003.5. Accordingly, the court ruled that, since the Plaintiff’s past loss of income, future loss of earning potential, and the projected medical expenses required expert analysis and calculations in medical malpractice actions, the Plaintiff was allowed to “seasonably provide” that information when he produced his expert witness reports in accordance with the court’s scheduling deadlines.

On a related discovery issue relative to the Defendants’ efforts to secure the Plaintiff’s Social Security Disability documentation, it was noted that an additional authorization was required from the Plaintiff to produce that information. Although the Plaintiff had previously responded in written discovery responses that he would sign the necessary authorization and that he had no objections to the Defendants securing this information, the Plaintiff refused to produce the executed authorization.

The court ordered the Plaintiff to produce an executed authorization to secure the Social Security Disability records given that the Plaintiff had previously indicated that this would be done and given that the Defendants were not seeking to obtain information privately from the Plaintiff’s treating physicians in violation of Pa. R.C.P. 4003.6.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, September 18, 2023

Just Because A Document is in the Cloud Doesn't Make it Accessible in Discovery


In the case of Edenfield v. ECM Energy Services, Inc., No. 999 MDA 2022 (Pa. Super. Aug. 1, 2023 Bowes, J., Lazarus, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reviewed a notable discovery issue and concluded that, despite the accessibility of electronic records stored by a party on the so-called cloud, state courts cannot order companies to compel documents stored on the cloud unless those companies have a sufficient link to Pennsylvania.

In this Opinion, the Pennsylvania Superior Court was presented with the question of whether electronic records stored in the cloud, without an established physical location in Pennsylvania, were located within Pennsylvania for purposes of Title 15 solely by virtue of being theoretically accessible from Pennsylvania.

In ruling that the documents did not have to be produced, the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld a decision out of the Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas in which that court had denied a Petition to Compel Inspection of Corporate Books and Records of a Party. 

The Superior Court noted that, to rule otherwise, would permit the courts to compel any business utilizing Quick Books or similar services to have to produce records in Pennsylvania despite the fact that there was no other connection to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The Superior Court stated that such a result was not contemplated by the law at issue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article: “Despite Accessibility, Storing Corporate Records in the Cloud Does not Create Pa. Jurisdiction, Superior Court Rules.” By: Riley Brennan. Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 2, 2023).

Source of image:  Photo by Miguel Pedroso on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, September 7, 2023

Information Not Subject To Discovery in Pennsylvania Simply Because It Is Stored Up In The Cloud


In the case of Edenfield v. ECM Energy Services, Inc., No. 999 MDA 2022 (Pa. Super. Aug. 1, 2023 Bowes, J., Lazarus, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reviewed a notable discovery issue and concluded that, despite the accessibility of electronic records stored by a party on the so-called Cloud, state courts cannot compel companies to documents stored on the Cloud unless those companies have a sufficient link to Pennsylvania.

In this Opinion, the Pennsylvania Superior Court was presented with the question of whether electronic records stored in the Cloud by a company without any established physical location in Pennsylvania, were located within Pennsylvania for purposes of Title 15 solely by virtue of being theoretically accessible from Pennsylvania.

In ruling that the documents did not have to be produced, the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld a decision out of the Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas in which that court had denied a Petition to Compel Inspection of Corporate Books and Records of an entity. 

The Superior Court noted that to rule otherwise would, for example, permit the courts to compel any business utilizing Quick Books or similar services to have to produce records in Pennsylvania simply because those records were stored in the Cloud and despite the fact that there was no other connection between that company and the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The court stated that such a result was not contemplated by the law at issue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: Article: “Despite Accessibility, Storing Corporate Records in the Cloud Does not Create Pa. Jurisdiction, Superior Court Rules.” By: Riley Brennan. Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 2, 2023).

Thursday, July 20, 2023

Federal Court Parameters on Scope of Permissible Discovery of Prior Incidents Reviewed


In the case if Birl v. Ski Shawnee, Inc., No. 3:22-CV-1598 (M.D. Pa. May 31, 2023 Carlson, Mag. J.), the court granted in part and denied in part a Motion to Compel discovery in a skiing accident case.

More specifically, the court found that a demand for the production of all documents and communications about all prior collision accidents on the Defendant’s property for over twenty (20) years was excessive.

However, the court also noted that a restriction of discovery to only the particular object that the Plaintiff collided with was also too narrow.

The court stated that judicial discretion on discovery issues is limited by valid claims of relevance and privilege. Relevance issues are to be tempered by principles of proportionality. Proportionality, in turn, is determined based upon temporal and topical aspects of the discovery dispute.

Magistrate Judge Carlson otherwise indicated that prior accidents are relevant if they occur under similar circumstances as presented in the pending case, and where such prior accidents are also relevant to the issue of notice on the part of the Defendant.

The court otherwise indicated that five (5) years is a common temporal limit on discovery.

In the end, the court granted the Plaintiff the right to discovery five (5) year records on all collision incidents.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of Image:  Photo by Mati Mango on www.pexels.com.

Monday, June 19, 2023

Fishing Expeditions Not Allowed in Discovery


In the case of Rotella v. Community Medical Center, No. 22-CV-3943 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 9, 2023 Nealon, J.), the court addressed the proper breadth and scope of subpoenas for a Plaintiff’s prior medical records in a medical malpractice action.

In this case, the Plaintiffs confirmed to the court that they had no objection to the Defendants seeking records regarding the injured Plaintiff’s condition at issue. It was also noted that the Defendants had already secured records on the Plaintiff dating back over twenty (20) years before the treatment which was the subject of this lawsuit.

The Plaintiff challenged additional subpoenas issued by the Defendants that sought any and all records from the time the Plaintiff’s birth for any and all conditions and illnesses.

It was the Plaintiff’s contention that the Defendants did not have good faith basis to request records of this magnitude. The Plaintiffs otherwise indicated that they did not object to any request of discovery for some reasonable prior time period, such as 3-5 years.

After reviewing the Rules of Civil Procedure and related case law on the responsibility of the trial court to oversee discovery between the parties, Judge Nealon noted that it is within the court’s broad discretion to determine the appropriate measures to ensure adequate and prompt discovery of information in a lawsuit. 

The court noted that, generally, discovery is to be liberally allowed with respect to any matter, not privileged, which is relevant to the case being tried. The court also noted that the relevancy standard applicable to discovery is broader than the standard used at trial for the admission of evidence. 

However, the court also noted that discovery requests must be reasonable, which is to be judged based upon the facts and circumstances of the case. The court is granted with authority to prohibit any discovery of matters which has been stated too broadly. Judge Nealon noted that, although discovery is to be liberally allowed as a general rule, “fishing expeditions” are not authorized under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County 


In colorful language, Judge Nealon noted that, as the court has observed with increasing frequency, “[w]hile a limited degree of ‘fishing’ is to be expected with certain discovery requests, parties are not permitted ‘to fish with a net rather than a hook or a harpoon.’” [citations omitted]. Applying the above law to this case, the court ruled that the subpoena served by the Defendants, as presented, were too broad.

The court did allow the Defendants to request records and materials for the period of ten (10) years prior a relevant date up to the present.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source of top image:  Photo by Chris F on www.pexels.com.




Monday, April 10, 2023

Pennsylvania Superior Court Reviews Discovery Issues Involving Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product Doctrine


In the case of Holland v. The Physical Therapy Inst., No. 1515 WDA 2021 (Pa. Super. March 17, 2023 Olson, J., Dubow, J., and Collins, J.), (Op. by Collins, J.) [non-precedential], the court addressed several discovery issues and the issue of whether an appeal from a discovery order is appropriate.

With regard to the ability of a party to appeal from a discovery order, the court noted that, generally, discovery orders are deemed interlocutory and are not immediately appealable, because they do not serve to dispose of the litigation in its entirety. 

Yet, discovery orders that require the disclosure of privilege materials are generally found to be appealable under Pa. R.A.P. 313 where the issue of privilege is separable from the underlying issues presented.

Based upon this rule of law, the court quashed the appeal in part and affirmed it in part and remanded the matter back to the trial court with further instructions.

On the substantive issues, the court noted that the appeal involved a six-part discovery order that required the Defendants to provide documents dealing with financial and investment-related matters as well as communications with counsel in this case involving a breach of contract action.

The Defendants asserted that the lower court erred by not conducting in-camera review of the disputed documents prior to making its ruling. The Defendants additionally asserted that the court committed various errors of law or abuses of discretion in its discovery order.

In this decision, the Pennsylvania Superior Court provided its latest review of the attorney-client privilege and the work product doctrine.

The Superior Court noted that the trial court, in finding that the Defendants had waived the attorney/client and the work-product privileges did not conduct any in-camera review of certain documents, despite having already conducted an in-camera review of other documents.

The court found that a remand was appropriate in light of this ambiguity. On remand, the trial court was directed to ascertain whether the Defendants waived the privileges noted and, to conduct an in-camera review of potentially privilege material before making a determination as to whether the documents at issue were indeed discoverable.

The Superior Court also noted that the trial court, on remand, must unequivocally determine whether allowing for punitive damages-related discovery is appropriate under the circumstances as required by Pa. R.C.P. 4003.7, which relates to discovery of financial information of a Defendant in a punitive damages case.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 20, 2023).

Wednesday, February 1, 2023

Court Rules That PennDOT May Not Release Medical Records Relied Upon By PennDOT to Decide Whether to Authorize an Indiviual to Be Licensed to Drive


In the case of Puricelli v. Com., Dept. of Transp., No. 42 M.D. 2022 (Pa. Cmwlth. Jan. 4, 2023) (Op. by Wallace, J.), the Commonwealth Court sustained Preliminary Objections filed by PennDOT in opposition to a matter involving a request by a Plaintiff injured in a motor vehicle accident case for the release of medical records PennDOT had obtained as part of the decision-making process of determining whether or not the Defendant driver should be authorized to be licensed in Pennsylvania to operate a motor vehicle.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant driver had secured an injury to his eye and the Plaintiff was attempting to determine if PennDOT had authorized the Defendant driver to be operating his vehicle at the time of the accident.

The court noted that, by statute, information received by the Department of Transportation for purposes of determining the competency of automobile drivers “shall be confidential and shall be used solely for the purpose of determining the qualifications of any person to drive a motor vehicle.” The statute additionally sets forth that such information cannot be “used as evidence in any civil or criminal trial.”

As such, the Commonwealth court ruled that the Plaintiff’s automobile accident victim was not permitted to obtain the medical records from PennDOT even though the Defendant driver had consented to the production of that information. The court noted that consent is not an exception to statutory mandates of confidentiality.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, January 24, 2023

Court Rejects Argument That Motion For Summary Judgment Is Premature Where Ample Time For Discovery Had Passed


In the case of Connell v. Zheng, No. 1696 of 2017 G.D. (C.P. Fay. Co. Aug. 15, 2022 Cordaro, J.), the court addressed a summary judgment motion in a food poisoning case filed against a Chinese restaurant.

According to the Opinion, the case involved the death of the Plaintiff’s decedent from complications of an infection caused by a bacteria typically found in shell fish that can be transmitted to humans through consumption of raw or undercooked shell fish. The Plaintiff was suing a Chinese restaurant and others involved for the injuries claimed.

The Motion for Summary Judgment at issue in this case was filed by an Additional Defendant relative to claims asserted by an original Defendant in a Joinder Complaint.

Of note, the original Defendants opposed the motion, in part, on the basis that discovery was still ongoing and that the Motion for Summary Judgment was, therefore, premature.

The court noted that, while an adverse party must be given adequate time to develop the case and that a Motion for Summary Judgment will be found to be premature if filed before the adverse party has completed discovery relevant to the motion in question, “the discovery period cannot extend indefinitely; parties must conduct discovery in a timely way and proceed with due diligence.”  See Op. at XI. [citations omitted].

Referring to the local rules of court, the judge in this matter ruled that ample time had been provided for the completion of relevant discovery. It was also noted that no party had moved for any different deadlines for the completion of discovery. It was additionally indicated by the court that the party opposing the Motion for Summary Judgment had not moved to compel any discovery.

As such, the court found that the parties did have adequate time to prepare and pursue relevant discovery. As such, the court deemed that discovery was complete relative to the motion in question.

In the end, the court found that the Defendants had not brought forward any evidence to support the facts essential to their cause of action against the Additional Defendants. As such, the court entered summary judgment in favor of the Additional Defendant.

Also notable in this decision is the court’s indication that non-binding case law can certainly be considered for its persuasive value.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Case Summaries.” By Timothy L. Clawges PBA News (December 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Drew Taylor on www.pexels.com.