Showing posts with label Prisoner Plaintiff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prisoner Plaintiff. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 5, 2026

Court Sees Former Prisoner Plaintiff's Civil Rights Claims as Plausible and Allows Them to Proceed Forward


In the case of Walton v. Lackawanna County, No. 3:25-CV-02461-MEM (M.D. Pa. July 7, 2026 Mannion, J.), the court denied a municipality’s Motion to Dismiss a former prisoner Plaintiff’s civil rights claims.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was pursuing §1983 civil rights claims, along with other disability claims, relative to allegations that, during a period of incarceration at the Lackawanna County Prison, the Plaintiff was prevented from securing the small plunger-like devices he allegedly required to remove his scleral contact lenses each day for his condition of keratoconus.  The Plaintiff alleged that, due to the fact that he was allegedly prevented from securing the plunger devices, he could not remove his scleral contact lenses, and suffered injuries to his eyes as a result.

After the filing of the Complaint, the municipality filed a Motion to Dismiss the Plaintiff’s various claims, including claims of municipal liability, deliberate indifference claims, and claims of liability under various disability laws.

After reviewing the record before him and applying the allegations against the standard of review, Federal Court Judge Malachy E. Mannion found that the Plaintiff had stated plausible causes of action in all respects. As such, the Defendant’s Motion was denied and the case was allowed to proceed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.



Tuesday, July 9, 2024

Eastern District Court Finds Spoliation of Evidence Relative to Failure To Preserve Video After Plaintiff's Attorney Requested Preservation


In the case of Peronace v. City of Philadelphia, No. 2:23-CV-03943-KSM (E.D. Pa. April 16, 2024 Marston, J.), the court denied the city’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a prisoner’s rights case involving Monell issues.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged that he had sustained multiple seizures while incarcerated and that the correctional officers delayed in providing him with medical assistance.

As part of this decision, the court addressed a Motion for Sanctions filed by the Plaintiff under an allegation that the prison officials intentionally failed to preserve video footage from outside of the prisoner’s cell.

The court reviewed this motion under F.R.C.P. 37(e) and found that, because the city should have known to preserve the video footage after receiving correspondence from an attorney for the Plaintiff to do so, and because there was no evidence that the city took any such steps, let alone reasonable steps to preserve the video footage, the court found that the videos were spoliated.

In terms of what sanction to impose, the court reviewed the factors set out under Rule 37(e) and ruled that, since it found that the city intentionally allowed relevant video footage to be overwritten by the video surveillance system, and considering the prejudice to the Plaintiff, the court fashioned a sanction and ruled that a jury may be instructed that the Defendant intentionally failed to preserve the disputed video evidence and that, therefore, the jury may presume that the lost video footage was unfavorable to the Defendant.

In a different portion of this Opinion, the court denied the city Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment after finding that issues of fact and testimonial differences existed on the case presented.

However, after finding that the Plaintiff did not submit evidence of any custom or policy of correctional officers violating inmates’ constitutional rights in the ways that the officers allegedly violated Plaintiff’s rights in this case, the court found that the city could not be held liable under the policy or custom prong of Monell. However, the court did find that the case against the city based upon an alleged failure of the city to supervise its correctional officers could proceed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Jeffrey D. Schmidt of the Feasterville, PA law firm of Rovner, Allen, Rovner, Zimmerman and Schmidt for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, May 31, 2024

Pro Se Prisoner's Civil Rights Claims Related to COVID-19 Vaccine Dismissed


In the case of Jones v. Employees of the DOC of Pa at SCI-Phoenix, No. 2:22-CV-02386-CMR (E.D. Pa. March 22, 2024 Rufe, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court dismissed a prisoner pro se Plaintiff’s §1983 Civil Rights litigation based on allegations related to medical treatment that the Plaintiff received while in prison.

The Plaintiff asserted that he suffered from adverse side effects after he was injected with a COVID-19 vaccine and the needle was allegedly injected too deep and struck a nerve, allegedly resulting in nerve damage. The Plaintiff alleged Eighth Amendment violations.

The Defendants moved to dismiss, which motion was granted.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff filed an administrative grievance within the prison prior to pursuing this litigation. In that grievance, he asserted deliberate indifference to the Plaintiff’s medical needs and violation of the Eighth Amendment. The grievance was denied. Thereafter, the Plaintiff filed suit.

The court granted the Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss after finding that the Plaintiff was provided treatment for his alleged symptoms. The court additionally noted that the record did not reveal any indication that the Defendants had intentionally inflicted pain or insisted on treatment that the Defendants allegedly knew would be painful, in effective, or risky.

The court additionally confirmed the well-settled law that disagreements over medical treatment provided to prisoners in prison could not rise to the level of a constitutional violation under the Eighth Amendment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer Federal Case Alert” Law.com (April 18, 2024).

Source of image:  Photo by Hakan Nural on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, February 27, 2024

Commonwealth Court Allows Pro Se Prisoner's Slip and Fall Claim To Go Forward



In the case of Pritchard v. Meintell, No. 49 C.D. 2022 (Pa. Cmwlth. Jan. 10, 2024 Jubelirer, P.J., Cannon, J., and Ceisler, J.) (Op. by Jubelirer, P.J.), the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court reversed in part and affirmed in part a lower court’s decision sustaining a Defendant’s demurrer to a prisoner pro se Plaintiff’s slip and fall action on the basis of sovereign immunity.

According to the Opinion, the appellate court found that the trial court erred in finding that the real estate exception did not apply. The trial court was also found to have erred in ruling that sovereign immunity barred the pro se prisoner’s action for his slip and fall injuries.

The court noted that, in alleging that the Defendants failed to maintain the slip/resistant surface on which he slipped, the inmate had adequately alleged an injury that was caused by a dangerous condition of Commonwealth real estate.

The court otherwise found that the inmate’s other negligence claim that were not connected to the negligent maintenance claim were barred under Pennsylvania law.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 30, 2024).

Monday, October 2, 2023

Third Circuit Rules that Federal Tort Claims Act Does Not Incorporate Certificate of Merit Requirements


In the case of Wilson v. U.S., No. 22-1940 (3d Cir. Aug. 21 2023 Chagares, C.J., Bibas, J., and Matey, J.) (Op. by Chagares, C.J.), the Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a district court erred in granting summary judgment to the government based upon the failure of a pro se prisoner to produce an expert report in a medical malpractice action.

The court ruled that the Federal Tort Claims Act did not incorporate the Certificate of Merit requirement found under Pa. R.C.P. 1042.3.

The appellate court also noted that the pro se prisoner Plaintiff did not otherwise have an adequate opportunity to seek out an expert or to conduct discovery due to his circumstances as an inmate during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Sept. 21, 2023).