Showing posts with label Bad Faith-Homeowner's Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bad Faith-Homeowner's Policy. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Court Denies Carrier's Motion For Summary Judgment on Residency Issue in Fire Loss Coverage Claim


In the case of Jackson v. Spinnaker Ins. Co., No. 2:22-CV-012244-NBF (W.D. Pa. Jan. 28, 2025 Fischer, J.), the court addressed a Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the defendant insurance carrier against claim for breach of contract and bad faith asserted by the Plaintiff relative to an homeowner’s policy and a fire loss. The court granted the defense motion as to the Plaintiff’s claim of bad faith but otherwise denied the motion.

The central question in this case was whether the Defendant insurance company had wrongfully refused to pay coverage for losses sustained by the Plaintiff’s after the Plaintiff's property was damaged in a fire.

The Defendant carrier had denied coverage on the grounds that the property was not the Plaintiff’s “residence,” and that the policy was void due to the Plaintiff’s material misrepresentation during the defense investigation. 

More specifically, the carrier asserted that the carrier falsely represented that the property was his primary residence and that it was not vacant and unoccupied. The Defendant carrier noted that the property lacked any electricity of sewer service.

The court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment on the breach of contract claims after finding, in part, that the policy in question did not restrict coverage to the Plaintiff’s primary residence. Rather, the court found that the policy expressly insured the identified property.

The court held that there was an issue of material fact as to whether or not the property was the Plaintiff’s residence. The Plaintiff had noted that he was sporadically sleeping at the property while completing renovations.

The court also found that the Defendant carrier had failed to establish that the Plaintiff made any statements regarding his residence at the property with knowledge of their alleged falsity or under an alleged deliberate intent to deceive.

The court otherwise denied the Defendant carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment on the bad faith claim after finding that the Defendant had a reasonable basis for denying coverage.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Federal Case Alert, www.Law.com (Feb. 20, 2025).


Source of image:  Photo by Andrew Gaines on www.unsplash.com.

Monday, January 22, 2024

Homeowner's Insurance Bad Faith Claim Dismissed


In the case of Qin v. Travelers Personal Ins. Co., No. 2:22-CV-03264-KNS (E.D. Pa. Dec. 15, 2023 Scott, J.), the court granted a Defendant carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a Plaintiff’s bad faith claim based upon the homeowner insurance carrier Defendant’s refusal to cover a loss because the property in question had been vacant for more than sixty (60) days prior to the date of the loss.

The court found that the Complaint lacked factual allegations to support the bad faith claim.

This case involved issues arising under a homeowner’s insurance policy.  The Plaintiff alleged that tenants had damaged a property that he owned.

The court found that the Plaintiff did not allege any facts to support a claim of bad faith and only made conclusory allegations. The court otherwise held that the allegations in the Complaint failed to satisfy the two prongs necessary to establish a bad faith claim, that being that the Defendant allegedly lacked a reasonable basis for denying benefits under the policy and that the carrier knew or recklessly disregarded its lack of a reasonable basis in denying the claim.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 5, 2024).


Source of image:  Photo by Tierra Mallorca on www.unsplash.com.

Monday, June 26, 2023

Judge Nealon Give Complaint Drafting Tips


In the case of Dolinak v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 2021-CV-1643 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 5, 2023 Nealon J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas reviewed the Rules of Civil Procedure regarding proper Complaint drafting in a case involving alleged weather-related damages allegedly sustained to the home of a State Farm insured.

Relative to the claims presented, the Plaintiff filed a Complaint against State Farm and State Farm filed Preliminary Objections stating that, based upon the allegations of the Complaint, it was not able to confirm exactly whether the Plaintiff was asserting simply a breach of contract claim and/or a bad faith claim.

Judge Nealon reviewed the pertinent Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, and the related case law, regarding Complaint drafting.

The court noted that Pa. R.C.P. 1020 provides that a Plaintiff may state in the Complaint more than one cause of action against the same Defendant and that such claims may be pled in the alternative.

However, under the related case law, a Plaintiff is required to present each claim in a self-sufficient separate count within the Complaint, which count is required to include allegations of facts in support of the particular claim asserted and the relief sought.

Here, the court noted that, even reviewing the allegations of Plaintiff’s Complaint as a whole, the Complaint did not provide State Farm with sufficient notice of the claims against which the carrier was required to defend.

As such, the court sustained the Preliminary Objections asserted by the Defendant but allowed the Plaintiff the right to file an Amended Complaint in which the Plaintiff was required to identify the claims asserted and the damages demanded in conformity with the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, June 30, 2021

Judge Munley of Lackawanna County Addresses Standard for Scandalous and Impertinent Matter in a Complaint

 In the case of Janiszewski v. Millville Mut. Ins. Co., No. 2021-CV-839 (June 2, 2021 Munley, J.), the court addressed Preliminary Objections filed by a Defendant in an insurance bad faith action in which the Defendants sought to strike internet reviews of the Defendant insurance company from the Complaint as scandalous and impertinent matter.   

After reviewing the record before the court in this property damage homeowner’s insurance claim, and applying the law relative to efforts to strike allegedly scandalous and impertinent information, the court denied the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections.   


In so ruling, the court cited to precedent confirming that, “[t]o be scandalous and impertinent, the allegations must be immaterial and inappropriate to the proof of the cause of action.”  See Op. at p. 4.


The court noted that, whereas here, the allegations in the Plaintiff’s Complaint are material, relevant, and supportive of the Plaintiff’s causes of action and where a Defendant cannot affirmatively show prejudice by the inclusion of the allegations, the allegations should not be stricken as scandalous or impertinent. 


As stated, the Preliminary Objections were denied here where the negative internet reviews that were referenced in the Complaint were related to denial of claims by the carrier, which the court felt would be material and pertinent to the Plaintiff’s bad faith causes of action contained in the Complaint at issue in this case.   


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.



Source of Image: Photo by Andrew Neel on Unsplash.com.








Wednesday, December 16, 2020

Dispute Under Homeowner's Policy Allowed to Proceed to Jury

 

In the case of Bloxham v. Allstate Ins. Co., No. 3:19-CV-00481 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 16, 2020, Mehalchick, M.J.), Federal Magistrate District Court Judgment, Karoline Mehalchick, denied the carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a breach of contract action arising out of a dispute under a homeowner’s insurance policy. 

According to the Opinion, after the Plaintiff sustained an accidental fire loss to his home and personal property, the carrier denied payment under the insurance policy on the grounds that the Plaintiff did not reside at the subject property and that the Plaintiff and/or the Plaintiff’s representatives allegedly provided material misrepresentations to the Defendant-carrier about residency. 

In opposition, the Plaintiff asserted that he did reside at the subject property and that no material misrepresentations were made as to the residency, ownership, or as to the condition of the property. 


Federal Magistrate Judge Mehalchick provided a thorough analysis of Pennsylvania case law on the definition of “residence” and concluded that the evidence presented in this case was sufficient to allow a reasonable jury to conclude that the Plaintiff did reside at the property at the time of the fire. As such, the carrier’s motion for summary judgment was denied in this regard. 

The court also reviewed the elements of a claim of misrepresentation relative to an insurance policy. After reviewing the same, the court found that the carrier failed to establish that the parties at issue had  knowingly made any false statements with regards to residency. It was also noted that the carrier failed to show that any such statements were made with a deliberate intent to deceive the carrier.

Also, given that the question as to whether the insured resided at the property was left for the jury’s determination, the court found that the carrier could not establish, at this stage of the litigation, whether any alleged misrepresentation about the insured’s residency was false. 

As such, summary judgment was also denied on the issue of allegations of material misrepresentations with regards to the policy. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Lee Applebaum of the Philadelphia law firm of Fineman Krekstein & Harris and writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law blog for bringing this case to my attention. 

Friday, September 25, 2020

Limitation of Actions Provision in Homeowner's Policy Upheld


In the case of Palek v. State Farm Fire and Cas. Ins. Co., No. 2:20-CV-170-JFC (W.D. Pa. Aug. 26, 2020 Conti, J.), the court granted the carrier’s Motion to Dismiss for failure to state a claim with regards to a breach of contract claim and a bad faith claim relative to the handling of a homeowner's insurance claim. 

The granting of the dismissal relative to the breach of contract claim was with prejudice but the granting of the dismissal with respect to the bad faith claim was without prejudice. The Plaintiff was granted twenty (20) days to file an Amended Complaint. 

As noted, this matter arose out of claims under a homeowner’s policy. According to the Opinion, the State Farm policy provided coverage for accidental and direct physical loss to, among other things, the in-ground swimming pool on the Plaintiff’s property. 

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs had emptied their swimming pool of water in order to perform routine maintenance. In doing so, they noticed damage to the swimming pool’s liner. They presented a claim for State Farm who eventually determined that the damage was not covered under the policy. The carrier asserted that the damage was caused by earth movement and, therefore, was excluded under the policy. 

The Plaintiffs filed a claim for breach of contract of the policy and a bad faith denial of benefits without a reasonable basis to do so. 

With regard to the breach of contract claim, the court agreed with State Farm that the Plaintiff’s claims were barred by the 1-year suit limitation provision contained in the policy. The court upheld this provision and found no evidence to support a finding of waiver or estoppel as raised by the Plaintiff.

The court additionally found that, even if the suit limitation provision did not apply, the alleged damages would be excluded under an application of the policy language. 

Relative to the bad faith claim, the court confirmed that a claim for bad faith is an independent cause of action separate from a contract claim. The court noted that the Plaintiff could proceed on the bad faith claim even where a contractual limitation period has been enforced and a breach of contract claim has been dismissed. Given that the Plaintiff had claims with respect to how the claim was handled, the court allowed the Plaintiff to provide more details in support of an alleged bad faith claim. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Mark A. Martini of the Pittsburgh office of the law firm of Robb Leonard Mulvihill, LLP for brining this case to my attention.

Monday, June 1, 2020

Wide-Ranging Discovery Allowed in Breach of Contract and Bad Faith Claim on a Homeowner's Policy


Senior Judge Carmen D. Minora of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas recently issued a notable discovery decision in the property damage homeowner's insurance breach of contract and bad faith case of Czaykowski v. Travelers Home and Marine Ins. Co., No. 19-CV-2928 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 29, 2020 Minora, J.).

The Opinion addresses a Motion for a Protective Order filed by the carrier against a Plaintiff's request for institutional discovery from the carrier related to Pennsylvania matters and matters from other states.

The Plaintiff's wide-ranging discovery requests included demands for the production of policy manuals used by the carrier, personnel files of claims representatives, bonus incentive program documents, performance reviews, record retention and destruction policies of the carrier, as well as the production of copies of any complaints filed with the Insurance Commissioner against the carrier, any disciplinary proceedings against the carrier in any state, and any similar property damage breach of contract lawsuits. 

The carrier asserted that it would cost $1 million dollars to undertake the efforts to respond to the above discovery requests.

The Plaintiffs also requested the production of reserves information relative to the case at hand.

Judge Minora was not convinced by the carrier's assertions of undue burden and denied the motion in large part. However, he limited his allowance of the Plaintiff's discovery requests to only cover information for a four year period, which was selected as that is the statute of limitations for a breach of contract action. The Judge allowed the Plaintiff to pick the beginning and end date for the four years of discovery they desired.

The Court also limited the scope of the Plaintiff's discovery requests to Pennsylvania matters and decided that the carrier did not have to produce documents from other states that might be responsive.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.