Showing posts with label Photographs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Photographs. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 12, 2025

Summary Judgment Granted in Alleged Trip and Fall Case Based on Trivial Defect Doctrine


In the case of Klobusnik v. Cafaro Company, No. 2021-CV-11132 (C.P. Erie Co. Dec. 31, 2024 Walsh, J.), the court granted the Defendant mall summary judgment in a slip and fall case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was walking on the premises and alleged that her foot hit the edge of a lifted tile on the floor which allegedly caused her to fall down.

After reviewing the record before it, the court noted that the Plaintiff presented photographic evidence purportedly showing a raised tile in the area where she fell. However, the Plaintiff admitted that she did not know exactly where she fell. The Plaintiff asserted that she tripped over the tile in the photograph or a similar tile.

The record revealed that the photograph of the tile in question showed a ruler with both metric and imperial units stationed in the grout line between two (2) tiles. The imperial measurement was below the “0” inch line. The metric measurement was at the “1” millimeter line.

As such, the court granted summary judgment after finding that the Plaintiff’s claims were barred by the trivial defect doctrine. The court also found that the Plaintiff’s claims were barred by the fact that the Plaintiff could not identify the exact tile that caused her to fall. The court noted that the evidence fairly suggested that it was just as likely that the Plaintiff had tripped over the grip of her own shoe on the tile, as opposed to catching her foot on the edge of an allegedly raised tile.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney William C. Wagner of the Erie, PA law firm of Marnen, Mioduszewski, Bordonaro, Wagner & Sinnott, LLC for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Mitchell Luo on www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, February 6, 2025

Vehicle Damages Photos From Accident Were Not Authenticated and, Therefore, Not Allowed


In the case of Moore v. Nordland, June Term, 2020, No. 01679 (C.P. Phila. Co. Nov. 19, 2024 Turner, J.), the court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion asking the Superior Court to affirm the trial court Order denying the Defendant’s Motion for Post-Trial Relief following a motor vehicle accident.

A primary issue in this case raised by the Plaintiff was whether the court erred in precluding photographs of the vehicle that were involved in the accident.

According to the Opinion, during cross-examination, both Plaintiffs confirmed that they could not recall or remember if the photographs of the vehicles presented to them fairly and accurately depicted the condition of the vehicles following the accident. Accordingly, the court found that, based upon the testimony of the Plaintiff, the Defendant was unable to authenticate the photographs.

During the direct examination of the Defendant, defense counsel again attempted to authenticate the photographs. However, when asked whether the photographs depicted the way to the Plaintiff’s vehicle following the accident, the Defendant testified, “Yes, I mean, there’s nothing different from what I’m seeing in these pictures compared to what I saw there on Cheltenham Avenue,” where the accident happened. The Defendant also testified that the photograph of the Plaintiffs’ vehicle “looks like the exact same vehicle that I was in the accident with that afternoon–evening.”

The trial court judge wrote in her Opinion that the Defendant failed to testify that the photographs fairly and accurately depicted the vehicles following the accident. Rather, the Defendant only testified that the vehicle in the photograph was the same vehicle he was in the accident with. The court noted that the Defendant was unable to confirm that the photographs fairly and accurately depicted the damage, or lack of damage, to the vehicles following the accident.

Based upon the testimony of all of the parties, the court found that the photographs were not properly authenticated and, as such, did not allow the Defendant to admit the photographs into evidence or to publish them to the jury.

In so ruling, the court cited to “Pa. R.E. 901(a), which pertains to authentication of evidence. The court additionally cited to the case of Com. v. Loughnane, 128 A.2d 806, 814 (Pa. 2015), for the proposition that a photograph “may be authenticated by testimony from a person who has sufficient knowledge that the photograph fairly and accurately reflects what the proponent is purporting the photograph to reflect.” 

Here, the court noted that, while photographs of vehicles were certainly relevant, and may be admissible, in this case, the Defendant failed to properly authenticate the photographs. The court additionally noted that, “most importantly,” there was no testimony as to who took the photographs, when the photographs were taken, and whether any repair work had been done to the cars following the accident but before the photos were taken.

Also of note with regards to this decision, the court found that the Plaintiffs’ testimony regarding the accident, their injuries, and the residual impact of the injuries on the injured Plaintiff’s life, along with the Plaintiff’s expert testimony, provided the jury with sufficient testimony and evidence to make a determination as to whether or not the limited tort Plaintiffs’ injuries were “serious” such that the pierced the limited tort threshold.

Here, there is evidence that the Plaintiffs sustained soft tissue injuries to her cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spine regions along with disc protrusions and herniations in her neck and mid-back and low back. The court also noted that the Plaintiffs testified in detail as how the injuries impacted their everyday lives.

Accordingly, the trial court requested the appellate court to affirm the trial court’s denial of the Defendants’ Motion for Post-Trial Relief in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 16, 2025).

Source of image:  Photo by Victor Moragriega on www.pexels.com.

Wednesday, April 19, 2023

Court Precludes Admissibility of Exemplar Pictures of a Surgery That Plaintiff Did Not Even Have



In the case of Crump v. Goldsleger, Aug. Term, No. 01434 (C.P. Phila. Co. Jan. 4, 2023 Powell, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion addressing various issues following a motor vehicle accident trial in which a defense verdict was entered.

Of note was the trial court’s conclusion that it properly denied Plaintiff’s request to admit evidence of photographs that did not pertain to any of the Plaintiff’s injuries. The court found that such evidence was not relevant or probative on the issues presented.

More specifically, in this case, the court noted that the Plaintiff’s credibility had been called into question as the Plaintiff attempted to introduce into evidence pictures of a knee surgery that were not pictures of the Plaintiff’s knee. It was also noted that the pictures did not depicted a type of surgery that was completed on the Plaintiff.

The court noted that, since the photographs of the knee that the Plaintiff sought to introduce were not actually pictures of the Plaintiff’s knee, the court found that the evidence was irrelevant in that any minimal probative value of the picture was severely outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.  The court noted that the only purpose of the photos appeared to be to shock the jury and to attempt to garner sympathy for the Plaintiff.

The court also asserted in its Rule 1925 Opinion that it had properly excluded the expert testimony of the Plaintiff's expert, Dr. Lance Yarus, where the expert had noted a "suspected" knee injury based upon a tele-medicine meeting with the Plaintiff.   The court found that such testimony did not meet the reasonable degree of medical certainty standard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Feb. 28, 2023).

Wednesday, April 13, 2022

Trivial Defect Doctrine Found Not To Apply on Private Property



In the case of Ramsey v. Buchanan Auto Park, Inc., No. 1:16-CV-01879-CCC (M.D. Pa. March 7, 2022 Connor, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part, post-trial motions in a slip and fall case after a verdict was entered in favor of the Plaintiff.

In one notable ruling, the court held that the trivial defect jury instructions that were developed in the context of public sidewalks was not applicable in the context of alleged defects on private property that allegedly injured business invitees.

The court noted that, in any event, this topic of liability was adequately covered by the jury instructions under which the jury was advised that, in order for the Plaintiff to recover, the property must have a condition which amounted to an unreasonable risk of harm to the Plaintiff.

This decision is also notable in that the Court found that photographs of the area where the Plaintiff fell that were taken in 2017 were admissible even though there were slight variations in the conditions of the area since the Plaintiff's 2014 fall down event.  The Court noted that the photos were authenticated by a witness and that any variations were pointed out to the jury by the witness and in the jury instructions.  

The court otherwise noted that damages for lost wages awarded by a jury is not necessarily excessive merely because the award exceeds the amount of the worker’s compensation lien. The court noted that the lien is not a cap on the Plaintiff’s claim for past wage loss.

However, the court did find that the award entered by the Plaintiff for the Plaintiff’s claim for loss of future earnings was against the weight of the evidence where the Plaintiff failed to present any evidence in this regard.

The court ordered a new trial on the issue of damages after finding that the jury may have erroneously included non-economic damages in its future earnings award.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's Order can be viewed HERE


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reid Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, December 4, 2020

Here's A Case To Use If They Refuse to Produce Photographs (But Note: It's Marked Non-Precedential)



In the case of Colton v. West Penn Power Co.,  1791 WDA 2019 (Pa. Super. Oct. 15, 2020 Shogan, J., McLaughlin, J., and Musmanno, J.) (Op. by Musmanno, J.)(Non-Precedential), the Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that photographs of the site where the Plaintiff died taken by agents of the law firm representing a Defendant in a wrongful death action are not to be considered “communications” under the attorney/client privilege and, therefore, must be produced in discovery.

According to the Opinion, the widow of the decedent filed a lawsuit alleging that her husband was killed as a result of the alleged negligence of the Defendants. The court noted that the case arose out of an incident involving a brush fire that erupted in a wooded area near the decedent’s property. Firefighters responded and extinguished the fire. However, while the firefighters were clearing their equipment from the scene, the decedent walked into the area and came into contact with a fallen powerline, which electrocuted him to death. 

During the course of discovery, the Plaintiff requested photographs to be produced by the Defendant. The Defendant asserted that the photographs were protected by the attorney/client privileged and/or the attorney work product doctrine. 

The Superior Court agreed with the trial court’s findings that the photographs at issue were merely a depiction of the accident scene and did not constitute anything that the client or an agent of the client was “communicating” to counsel. 

The appellate court additionally indicated that it was not persuaded by the Defendant’s contention that the photographs revealed the attorney’s agent’s impressions of the scene. It was noted that the photographs, in the absence of any notations by counsel or the counsel’s agents, did not provide any more factual information about the scene of the accident that could be deemed to be privileged.. 

In the end, the Defendants were required to produce the photographs in discovery. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this Non-Precedential decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article: “Photos of Accident Scene Not ‘Communications’ Protected by Privilege: Court,” by P.J. D’Annunzio Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Oct. 27, 2020).




Have settlement talks stalled in your case.  Please consider scheduling a Mediation with CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES to bring your case to a close.

Contact dancummins@CumminsLaw.net or at 570-319-5899 to schedule your Mediation.