Showing posts with label Vicarious Liability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vicarious Liability. Show all posts

Monday, June 8, 2026

Appellate Court Finds that Plaintiff's Med Mal Claims Were Sufficiently Stated in Complaint


In its non-precedential decision in the case of Dasilva v. Abington Memorial Hospital, No. 1707 EDA 2025 (Pa. Super. June 2, 2026 Kunselman, J., Nichols, J., and Sullivan, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the court reversed a trial court’s decision in a medical malpractice case sustaining the Preliminary Objections of the Defendant hospital dismissing the Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint with prejudice.

The trial court had dismissed the Plaintiff’s Complaint due to the alleged insufficiency of the factual allegations in the Second Amended Complaint. Primarily, the Defendants asserted, in part, that the Plaintiff’s allegations of negligence and agency were vague and/or insufficiently specific.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reinstated the medical malpractice action after finding that the Plaintiffs had plausibly alleged that the medical staff failed to properly monitor a patient who was experiencing a psychiatric episode by allowing the patient to leave the emergency room at which point he was then struck by a vehicle.

The appellate court concluded that the Plaintiffs had met the state’s fact-pleading standard by outlining key facts, including the Plaintiff’s mental state, the awareness of the hospital staff of the Plaintiff’s condition, and the alleged failure of the hospital staff to monitor or prevent the patient’s departure from the hospital.

The appellate court otherwise held that a Plaintiff need not identify any specific employees in the medical malpractice case in order to pursue vicarious liability claims against a hospital. The court noted that references contained in the Complaint to the emergency room staff were sufficiently specific to enable the Defendants to respond to the Complaint.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision of the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the Dasilva may click this LINK.

Source: Article – “Abington Hospital Must Face Med Mal Claims Over Patient’s ER Escape, Pa. Appellate Court Says,” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (June 4, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by National Cancer Institute on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, April 29, 2026

Court Addresses Various Pleadings Issues in a Medical Malpractice Case, Including Allegations of Recklessness


In the case of Limon v. Kontizer, No. 2025-CV-8657 (C.P. Lacka. Co. March 30, 2026 Powell, J.), the court addressed various Preliminary Objections filed by Defendants in a medical malpractice case.

According to the Opinion, this wrongful death medical malpractice case was filed relative to the Plaintiff’s decedent’s treatment in the form of an upper GI endoscopy. According to the Complaint, the Plaintiff alleged that the various medical Defendants failed to properly diagnose, treat, and prevent aspiration pneumonia, sepsis, and multi-organ dysfunction, all of which allegedly led to the Plaintiff’s decedent’s death.

In their Preliminary Objections, the Defendants sought the dismissal of claims for reckless conduct and punitive damages, as well as claims grounded in vicarious liability and negligence.

The court overruled all of the Preliminary Objections filed.

Relative to the claims of recklessness and for punitive damages, the court held that, under Pa. R.C.P. 1019(b), conditions of the mind, such as recklessness, may be alleged in a general fashion as long as negligence is pled.

The court additionally noted that the Complaint sufficiently asserted that the Defendants knowingly disregarded serious, life-threatening risk to the decedent. Accepting these allegations are true, the court concluded that the claims for punitive damages were legally sufficient.

With regards to the issues of vicarious liability, the court rejected the Defendants’ arguments that the Complaint was deficient for failing to identify specific agents or employees. The court noted that Pennsylvania law does not require a Plaintiff in a medical malpractice case to identify every individual agent at the pleadings stage. Rather, the court noted that it is sufficient to allege that the individuals acted within the scope of their employment or agency since the identity of every healthcare professional who was involved in the decedent’s treatment during the approximately one month period at issue could be readily ascertained by the Defendants from their own records.

The court further found that the Plaintiff sufficiently alleged that the Defendants had knowledge of, and allowed the alleged reckless conduct, thereby satisfying the heightened requirements for allegations of vicarious liability for punitive damages under the MCARE Act.

The court otherwise rejected the Defendant’s objections that the Plaintiff’s negligence claims were overly broad and vague.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Lackawanna Jurist (April 10, 2026).


Monday, December 1, 2025

Judge Powell of Lackawanna County Addresses Plethora of Issues Raised in Medical Malpractice Matter


In the case of Doyle v. Keyed, No. 2024-CV-9036 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Oct. 16, 2025 Powell, J.), the court issued a decision denying various Preliminary Objections filed in a medical malpractice action arising out of the death of an infant during a complicated delivery.

Of note, Judge Powell of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas overruled nearly all of the challenges submitted by the Defendants, including a request by Lehigh Valley Hospital-Pocono Defendants’ request to severe their case from the claims against the St. Luke’s Hospital Defendants.

The court additionally rejected one doctor’s claim that he could not be held vicariously liable for actions by the hospital staff that worked under him. The court noted that vicarious liability may attach in a medical malpractice case under the “captain-of-the-ship” doctrine or where the physician exercises actual control over the staff members.

The court noted that, because the Complaint in this matter alleged that the doctor at issue had directed and supervised others during the delivery, those allegations stated a viable theory of vicarious liability.

The court additionally upheld the Plaintiffs’ claims of direct and corporate negligence against various Defendants.

Judge Mark Powell
Lackawanna County


Judge Powell also overruled objections to the claim for punitive damages. The court found that the facts alleged could, if proven, constitute reckless disregard warranting punitive damages.

The court also noted that, given that mental state conditions may be alleged generally under Pa. R.C.P. 1019(b), such claims could survive the pleading stage.

The court also disagreed with the defense argument that childbirth procedures are not surgical acts requiring informed consent. The court noted that the allegations that the doctor failed to discuss surgical alternatives despite risk factors present stated a plausible informed-consent claim.

The court also allowed the Plaintiffs’ claims for negligent infliction of emotional distress to proceed. The court found that the Plaintiff-mother, having suffered a physical impact and having observed her child’s death, and the father, who witnessed the traumatic delivery and aftermath, both fit within the recognized categories of Plaintiffs permitted to pursue negligent infliction of emotional distress claims. In this regard, Judge Powell noted that observation of the results of negligent medical acts can satisfy the contemporaneous observation requirement in a medical malpractice context.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source:  Lackawanna Jurist (Oct. 31, 2025).


Source of image: Photo by Samuel Ramos on www.unsplash.com.


Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Superior Court Reviews Vicarious Liability of Domino's In MVA Case, And Whether Trial Court Decision on MSJ Remains Reviewable on Appeal After Entry of Verdict



In the case of Coryell v. Morris, No. 1977 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Jan. 31, 2025) (en banc) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that a Domino’s franchise relationship with the delivery driver’s employer created grounds for the pizza chain to be bound vicariously liable for the driver’s negligence during the course of a motor vehicle accident.

Some litigators viewed the court’s analysis in this case as setting up a framework for establishing a franchisor’s vicarious liability in cases involving alleged negligence on the part of a franchisee.

In this decision, the Superior Court found that there was sufficient evidence in the records to show that the franchiser exercised sufficient control over the franchisee to support the finding of vicarious liability.

Also of note was the fact that the Superior Court ruled that a jury’s resolution of the factual issues presented in the case, which involve, in part, factual disputes regarding Domino’s control over the franchisee, such findings by the jury rendered the propriety of the trial court’s summary judgment ruling moot. More specifically, the Superior Court in this case ruled that “[a] trial court’s denial of a fact-dependent pre-trial [motion for summary judgment] is not reviewable when the issue was subsequently resolved at trial.”

It is noted that, in the Dissenting Opinion, Judge King noted that the Superior Court should have decided that it remained capable of reviewing the trial court's denial of the pre-trial Motion for Summary Judgment given the confusion in the caselaw surrounding the issue at the time the trial court ruled on the motion.   

In the end, the Superior Court’s ruling in this case rendered Domino’s Pizza again responsible, at least in part, for the $2.3 million dollar judgment awarded to the Plaintiff motorcyclist who was struck by a Domino’s Pizza delivery driver’s vehicle.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Dissenting Opinion by Judge King can be viewed HERE.

Source: “Pa. Superior Court Rules Pizza Chain Liable For Franchisee Driver’s Crash” by Aleza Furman of the Legal Intelligencer (Feb. 4, 2025).

Wednesday, June 26, 2024

Demurrers to Medical Malpractice Complaint Overruled


In the case of Polanco v. Lehigh Valley Health Network, Inc., No. 2023-CV-1001 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 7, 2024 Nealon, J.), the court addressed various Preliminary Objections filed in a medical malpractice case.

This case involved a case brought by the parents of a child reportedly suffering from cerebral palsy and brain damage due to alleged medical malpractice by various Defendants.

The Defendants filed Preliminary Objections on various grounds including a demurrer to the parents’ vicarious liability claims, allegations of reckless conduct, and claims for punitive damages.

The hospital Defendant also raised challenges to the legal sufficiency of the parent’s vicarious liability claim due to the parents’ failure to identify the hospital’s agents by name and to specify their agency authority.

All of the Preliminary Objections asserted by the various Defendants were overruled by the court.

Generally speaking, the court found that the Plaintiff had alleged specific facts to support the claims presented. The court also found that the factual allegations in the Complaint clearly informed the various Defendants of the claims being asserted, summarize the key facts supporting those claims, and furnished adequate notice so as to enable the Defendant to file a responsive pleading.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Friday, December 29, 2023

Judge Nealon Addresses Procedural and Substantive Complaint Issues Regarding a Complaint in Med Mal Case


In the case of Healey v. Scranton Hospital Company, LLC, No. 23-CV-1793 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 20, 2023 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed various Preliminary Objections filed by Defendants in a medical malpractice case.

In part, the hospital Defendant filed Preliminary Objections in the nature of a demurrer to the Plaintiff’s vicarious liability claims for failing to identify its alleged agents by name and failing to specify their agency authority.

The hospital Defendant also filed Preliminary Objections against the Plaintiff’s corporate negligence claims for (1) neglecting to allege its notice of the claimed institutional deficiencies, and (2) asserting the corporate liability claims against it and a Co-Defendant LLC in the same Count in the Complaint.

Also at issue in this case was a demurrer filed by the hospitalist and the LLC employer to the vicarious liability and corporate negligence claim asserted against those parties. 

Those Defendants also sought to strike the Plaintiff’s allegations of gross negligence as well as allegations against “Defendants” as asserted in lump sum fashion in certain paragraphs without clarifying which particular Defendant is being referenced, among other issues.

The Court issued the following decisions in this Opinion.    

Judge Nealon noted that, since it is not necessary for a Plaintiff to establish a right to recover on a vicarious liability claim based upon the negligence of a specifically named employee, the demurrers to the Plaintiff’s vicarious liability claims premised on the conduct of unnamed agents was overruled.

The court otherwise also ruled that, while the Plaintiffs had alleged a viable claim for corporate liability against the hospital and the LLC employer, the Plaintiff had failed to state a cognizable corporate negligence claim against the individual hospitalist Defendant for institutional negligence.  As such, the corporate liability claim against the hospitalist was dismissed.

The court additionally sustained the Preliminary Objections regarding the combined allegations asserted in single pleadings against multiple Defendants..  The court ruled that the corporate liability claims against the hospital and the LLC employer were required to be alleged in self-sufficient separate Counts under separate, distinct headings in the Complaint in order to comport with Pa. R.C.P. 1019(a) and 1020(a).

The court additionally ruled that, pursuant to 40 P.S. §1303.505(b) and (c), the Plaintiff’s allegations of “gross” negligence were immaterial to the Plaintiff’s malpractice burden of proof and, as such, would be stricken as impertinent matter in accordance with Pa. R.C.P. 1028(a)(2).

The court otherwise noted that blanket references to “Defendants” in lump sum fashion in certain paragraphs in the Complaint were improper.

The Plaintiff was afforded an opportunity to amend the Complaint to correct these errors and other errors identified above.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, December 11, 2023

Punitive Damages Claims and Direct Liability Claims Against a Trucking Company Dismissed


In the case of Villagran v. Freightbull, Inc., No. 22-CV-2159 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 12, 2023 McHugh, J.), the court dismissed a Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages after finding that the Plaintiff did not present any evidence to satisfy Pennsylvania’s high standards for punitive damages.
This matter involved a fatal trucking accident.  The Plaintiff asserted both direct and vicarious liability claims against the company that employed the trucker.

The trucking company filed a motion for summary judgment relative to the punitive damages claims and the claims of direct liability asserted against the company relative to allegations of negligent hiring and supervision.

The trucking company noted that, if the punitive damages claim was dismissed then the direct claims of liability should be dismissed as well because, in the absence of punitive damages claims, the evidence to prove direct liability was both unnecessary and prejudicial.  

The court reiterated the settled law that an entitlement to punitive damages requires that conduct go beyond any type of negligence and instead include intentional, reckless, or malicious conduct. The law also required that the Defendant have a subjective appreciation of the relevant risk.

The court additionally noted that any conduct supporting a claim for punitive damages must have a role in causing the Plaintiff’s injuries.  Factually irrelevant conduct is not enough to support a claim for punitive damages.

In this regard, the court found that, there was nothing in the record to suggest that a Defendant’s safety director’s lack of qualification was usually for a family business or was otherwise egregious.

In this case, the court noted that the alleged failure to train the driver was factually irrelevant, since trip planning had nothing to do with the accident.

It was additionally noted that a videotape of the accident refuted the Plaintiff’s claim that the Defendant’s driver did not stop at the intersection. It was noted that the video also revealed no other basis for punitive damages.

The court otherwise ruled that a majority blanket rule barring direct negligent driver hiring and supervision claims where vicarious liability is admitted and punitive damages are not at issue was too extreme of a position. The court noted that rejecting such claims only when evidence would be excessively prejudicial under F.R.E. 303 is preferable.

In this case, the direct claims of liability were dismissed as the evidence would be unduly prejudicial to the Defendant. The court found that evidence of direct corporate negligence was minimal, peripheral, and factually unrelated to the subject accident in this matter.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


I thank Attorney James A. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, December 7, 2023

Superior Court Rules that It Can Review A Trial Court's Decision On a MSJ Even After a Jury Verdict


In the case of Coryell v. Morris, No. 1977 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Nov. 8, 2023 Bowes, J., King, J., and Pellegrini, J.) (Op. by Pellegrini, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the issue of whether an appellate court may review the propriety of a trial court’s denial of a Motion for Summary Judgment even after the case then proceeded to trial and a jury entered a verdict in favor of a Plaintiff in a personal injury case. The Superior court answered that question, in a split decision, in the affirmative.

This case arose out of a motor vehicle accident that involved a Domino’s Pizza delivery driver.

Before the trial, Domino’s moved for summary judgment, arguing that it could not be held vicariously liable because, under its franchise agreement, its relationship with the franchisee was that of an independent contractor/contractee rather than master-servant relationship.

The trial court had found that there were genuine issues of material fact involved on the question presented and, therefore, denied Domino’s Motion for Summary Judgment. 

Thereafter, the case went to trial and a jury found Domino’s vicariously liable and awarded damages. 

On appeal, the Superior Court ruled that it had the authority to review a trial court’s decision on a pre-trial Motion for Summary Judgment even after the case had proceeded to trial and a jury entered a verdict.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court reviewed the record before it and concluded that the franchise agreement did not give Domino’s day-to-day control over the franchisee and that, under these circumstances, the Superior Court agreed with Domino’s that it should have been granted summary judgment as there was no valid claim of vicarious liability.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  Judge Bowes Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.


Source: Article -- “Pa. Appeals Court Clears Domino’s From Paying $2.3M Delivery Driver Crash Verdict” By: Aleeza Furman Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 10, 2023).

Sunday, June 12, 2022

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Notes That Direct and Vicarious Theories May Be Pursued Against Employer For Negligence by Employee


In the motor vehicle accident case of Shaver v. Levelle, No. 21-CV-2465 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 26, 2022 Nealon, J.), the defendant-motorist’s employer filed preliminary objections seeking to dismiss plaintiff’s claims for negligent entrustment, hiring, and training as legally insufficient since the motorist admitted that he was an employee of the employer at the time of the accident. 

Judge Nealon reviewed the law on this issue in detail and noted that several federal district courts and at least one common pleas court have, in the past, dismissed claims against employers for negligent hiring, training, and supervision in cases of admitted agency, and have done so on the basis that no Pennsylvania appellate court has ever held that a plaintiff may simultaneously pursue claims against an employer for vicarious liability and direct liability in cases where an employer-employee relationship is admitted. 

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County


















Judge Nealon found that those previous court decisions that have gone the other way on this issue were negated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's decision in Scampone v. Highland Park Care Center, LLC, 57 A.3d 582 (Pa. 2012), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected the argument that a plaintiff is barred from pursuing a direct negligence claim against a corporate employer if it acknowledges that the employee was acting within the course of employment at the time of the tort.  That Court concluded that “direct and vicarious theories of liability are grounded in distinct policies and serve complementary purposes in the law of torts,” and that they may be “asserted either concomitantly or alternately” even in cases of undisputed agency. 

Judge Nealon found that, since the federal and state trial court rulings cited by the defendant-employer “are contrary to the Supreme Court reasoning in Scampone,” the Defendant's preliminary objection was overruled.

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, May 10, 2021

Judge Leeson of Eastern District Court Confirms No Direct Claim of Liability Against Trucking Company Recognized in Certain Cases




In the case of Carson v. Tucker, No. 5:20-CV-00399 (E.D. Pa. March 30, 2021 Leeson, J.), Judge Joseph F. Leeson, Jr. of the Eastern District Federal Court granted a Defendant trucking company’s Partial Motion for Summary Judgment.

This case arose out of a motor vehicle accident involving two (2) tractor trailers.

In the Motion before the court, the trucking Defendant’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment was being considered in a case where the Plaintiff filed negligence claims including both vicarious liability and direct liability claims. 

The trucking Defendants sought summary judgment only on the direct liability claims.

Judge Leeson noted that, under Pennsylvania law, in addition to vicarious liability for that actions of its employees, a corporation may also be subject to direct liability for a negligent entrustment, instruction, supervision, monitoring and hiring of its employees. 

However, Judge Leeson noted that, under the standard “nearly universally adopted” by federal district courts applying Pennsylvania law, a Plaintiff’s direct liability claim against the Defendant driver’s trucking company employer could not survive where the employer had admitted an agency relationship with the driver and where the Plaintiff did not have a viable claim for punitive damages. 

The court found that the Plaintiff’s claim of direct liability against the trucking company therefore failed as a matter of law under the circumstances presented in this case.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 15, 2021).

Friday, April 9, 2021

Federal Court Addresses Validity of Direct Claims of Liability Asserted Against Trucking Company



In the case of Miller v. M.H. Malueg Trucking, Co., LLC, No. 2:20-CV-00413-RJC (W.D. Pa. March 8, 2021 Colville, J.), the court granted a Defendant trucking company’s Motion to Dismiss a Plaintiff’s direct negligence claim against the trucking company arising out of a motor vehicle accident after the court found that the Plaintiff had conceded that she had not pled facts sufficient to support a claim for punitive damages that could serve as the predicate for a direct negligence claim against that trucking company.

The court noted that the parties had previously filed a Stipulation agreeing that the Defendant driver was an agent of the Defendant trucking company.

The Plaintiff had alleged in her Complaint that the Defendant trucking company was vicariously liable for the driver’s negligence and was also liable for negligent hiring, training, monitoring, and supervising the driver, for failing to ensure PennDOT regulations were followed, and was also negligent for failing to maintain a proper driver safety program for its drivers.

The Defendant moved to dismiss all direct claims of liability and did not move to dismiss the vicarious liability count.

Citing the case of Sterner v. Titus Transp., 2013 WL 6506591 (M.D. Pa. 2013)[other citations omitted], the court held in this Miller case that the claims of direct corporate negligence was subject to dismissal when the agency relationship was admitted and when the Plaintiff had not pled a basis for punitive damages.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 25, 2021).

Friday, September 4, 2020

Is Uber An Employer of Uber Drivers?



In the case of Lowman v. Unemployment Comp Bd. of Review, 41 EAP 2018 (Pa. July 24, 2020)(Op. by Donohue, J.) (Saylor, C.J. and Mundy, J., Dissenting), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held, as a matter of first impression, that Uber “controlled and directed the performance of Lowman’s services as a driver-for-hire” and that Mr. Lowman was not engaged in an independently established business.

Essentially, the Court found that the driver's work for Uber was completed within employment with Uber and not as an independent contractor. Uber's argument that the driver was acting in self-employment was rejected.

Some commentators note that this decision may have an impact in personal injury litigation in terms of whether a ride-sharing company can be sued in a motor vehicle accident case as an employer of the defendant driver.

Anyone wishing to review the majority Opinon of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court may click this LINK.

The dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney Dale Larrimore of the Philadelphia law firm of Larrimore & Farnish, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, August 17, 2020

Validity of Punitive Damages Claims in a Trucking Accident Case Addressed


In the case of Decker v. Ramos, No. 15-CV-7078 (C.P. Lacka. Co. July 16, 2020 Nealon, J.), the court addressed a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a trucking accident case. 

The Defendants sought to dismiss the tractor trailer driver as a named party since the employer admitted, for purposes of vicarious liability, that the driver was acting within the scope of his employment at the time of the accident. 

The court rejected this summary judgment request of the defense finding that, under the theory of respondeat superior, a primarily liable employee and a vicariously liable employer are not considered to be joint tortfeasors. The court also noted that the goal of vicarious liability is to provide a secondary fund of recovery if the employee-tortfeasor lacks the ability to pay. 

The court noted that Pennsylvania law permits an injured Plaintiff to sue both the primarily liable employee and the vicariously liable employer and to obtain a recovery from either party. The court stated that the defense did not cite any authority to the contrary involving cases where the employer concedes and agency relationship with the employee. As such, the Motion for Summary Judgment was denied in this regard. 

Judge Nealon also addressed other parts of the Motion for Summary Judgment raised by the defense seeking to secure a dismissal of punitive damages claims. 

On the one hand, the defense asserted that they were entitled to summary judgment on the punitive damages claims against the Defendant driver as the Plaintiff did not allege that the driver’s conduct at the time of the accident was reckless. Rather, the Plaintiff based their punitive damages claims against the Defendant tractor trailer driver on the single assertion that the driver had overstated his tractor trailer driving experience on his employment application. 

After finding that their record failed to show any evidence, or even any support for reasonable inference, that the driver knew or should have realized that there was a strong probability that harm to others may result to his misrepresentation on his employment application, the court held that there was insufficient evidence to sustain any punitive damages claim against the driver. As such, the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment was granted by the court in this regard in terms of any punitive damages claims against the tractor trailer driver. 

However, the court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment filed on behalf of the employer/trucking company with respect to the punitive damages claims after reviewing the evidence in the record in this regard. The court noted that, as noted, the record contained evidence that the driver exaggerated the extent of his prior tractor trailer experience on his employment application and there was also evidence that the trucking company allegedly failed to conduct any past employment investigation as required by federal regulations to verify the driver’s prior experience. 

It was also noted that there was evidence in the record that the employer allegedly disregarded industry standards by failing to terminate the driver, or at a minimum, compelling him to undergo remedial training after he was involved in his first preventable crash during his probationary period. It was otherwise noted that the subject accident was the tractor trailer driver’s third collision within his first month of employment with the company. 

The Plaintiff had also alleged in this matter that the employer ignored the federal requirements when the employer continued to allow the driver to operate its tractor trailers allegedly without first completing safety training that was clearly required by law. 

The court also confirmed that the Plaintiff had presented expert opinion evidence that the trucking company’s actions represented a recklessness indifference and reckless disregard to the safety of the motoring public. 

Based upon this evidence in the record, the court denied the defense Motion for Summary Judgment on the punitive damages claims asserted against the trucking company Defendant. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Friday, June 12, 2020

Apparent Case of First Impression: Allegheny County Court Allows Independent Negligence Claims Against a Trucking Company to Proceed In Conjunction With Vicarious Liability Claims



In the case of Reutzel v. DTA, L.P., No. GD 17-4735 (C.P. Alleg. Co. Feb. 25, 2020 Connelly, J.), Judge Patrick M. Connelly of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas denied the Defendants’ Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings seeking dismissal of all independent negligence claims against the employer-defendant in this motor vehicle accident case.

In his Opinion, Judge Connelly quoted to federal court decisions but noted that there was no state court authority on the issue presented of whether negligent hiring and supervision claims should be allowed to proceed in a state court case in a trucking accident case where the employer Defendant has agreed that there was an employer-employee relationship existing between the trucking company and the driver.

According to the Opinion, one of the defendant drivers was driving a tractor owned by MM Leasing as an employee of Defendant DTA, L.P.

The Plaintiff included claims of vicarious liability, respondeat superior liability, and master/servant responsibility against the employer of the defendant driver under theories of negligent entrustment, negligent hiring or retention, and negligent hiring or employment.

The employer Defendant filed Preliminary Objections seeking the dismissal of any independent negligence causes of action asserted by the Plaintiff against the employer Defendant. The employer Defendant asserted that these claims of independent negligence on the part of the employer should be dismissed because these claims offer no avenue for additional liability to the Plaintiff as the employer Defendant has admitted to an agency relationship will have them held liability if the driver is found to be negligent.

This state court judge noted that, although the federal courts have accepted such arguments by Defendant employers in this context and have dismissed negligent hiring and supervision claims where the employer concedes the employer-employee relationship, 

The rationale for this rule noted by the federal courts is that there would be nothing to be gained by allowing claims against both the employer and the driver to proceed, and it would be prejudicial due to the possible admission of evidence of prior accidents by the truck driver into evidence.

However, those federal courts have recognized an exception to that rule where a Plaintiff includes a punitive damages claim against the employer.

There is no indication that the Plaintiff in this matter asserted any punitive damage claims against the driver or employer in this case.

Judge Connelly emphasized that, under state court rules, Plaintiffs are permitted to plead claims in the alternative and that to allow these alternative theories of liability to proceed would serve complementary purposes of the law of torts of offering a plaintiff full opportunities to be fully compensated for the injuries alleged as allegedly caused by the parties involved.

Judge Connelly also suggested that the issue could be revisited at the trial stage to determine which claims the trial court judge would allow to proceed to verdict.

Anyone wishing to review this case may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Brad D. Trust of the Pittsburgh law office of Edgar Snyder & Associates, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, May 26, 2020

Parts of Medical Malpractice Claim Dismissed Due to Lack of Certificate of Merit; Punitive Damages Claim Allowed to Proceed



In the case of Kinard v. Butler Memorial Hospital, No.30002 of 2019, C.A. (C.P. Lawr. Co. March 11, 2020 Motto, P.J.), the court sustained in part and denied in part Preliminary Objections filed on behalf of various Defendants in a medical malpractice claim after finding, in part, that the Plaintiffs’ Certificate of Merit only supported the Plaintiffs’ claim for vicarious liability and not corporate negligence. 

According to the Opinion, the allegations of corporate negligence of the hospital was based upon negligent acts of the institution itself arising from the policies and actions or in-action of the institution, rather than any specific acts of any hospital employees. 

The court noted that the Certificate of Merit produced by the Plaintiffs only addressed the negligence of medical professionals providing treatment at the hospital and not any alleged institutional negligence. Given that the Certificate of Merit only addressed issues of vicarious liability, and not corporate negligence, the court sustained the Defendant’s Preliminary Objection with respect to the claim of corporate negligence. 

The Opinion is also notable in that the court found that the Complaint stated sufficient facts to allow the Plaintiffs’ punitive damages claim to go forward. 

The court also sustained Preliminary Objections filed on behalf of a nurse practitioner under the argument that the nurse practitioner only saw the Plaintiff once and that was for a different medical issue unrelated to the central claim presented in this case. The claim against the nurse practitioner was stricken from the Complaint. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 12, 2020).

Thursday, May 7, 2020

Judge Nealon Reiterates the Law of Identifying Agents of Hospital in Med Mal Complaints



In the case of Champi v. Geisinger Community Medical Center, No. 19-CV-1780(C.P. Lacka. Co. Feb. 20, 2020 Nealon, J.), the court denied Preliminary Objections filed by a Defendant hospital in this medical malpractice action.

The Defendants were arguing that, where the Plaintiff alleged negligent care at the Defendant hospital’s Scranton and Wilkes-Barre campuses but neglected to identify by name and with specificity which alleged agents who worked at the hospital were negligent, the Defendant was entitled to a dismissal.

This argument was rejected by the court under recent Pennsylvania Superior Court precedent in which it was held that a Plaintiff asserting a vicarious liability claim need not allege the identity of the agents by name.

As such, the court overruled the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections and directed the hospital to seek the requested information by way of pre-trial discovery efforts.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK

Friday, April 10, 2020

The Case of the Missing Email



In the case of Live Face On Web, LLC v. Merchants Insurance Group, No. 2:19-CV-00528-JDW (E.D. Pa. April 1, 2020 Wolfson, J.), the court addressed cross motions for summary judgment on claims involving request for declaratory judgment, breach of contract, statutory bad faith, negligence, and vicarious liability law.

This case was filed under allegations that an insured requested that a vehicle be added to an insurance policy and that the insurance agent failed to notify the carrier of the same. According to the Opinion, the insurance agent denied ever receiving the emailed request from the insured to add the vehicle.  The Court opened the Opinion by call this "the case of the missing email."

The claims against the carrier in this matter included claims of bad faith violations of the Unfair Insurance Practices Act and vicarious liability with regards to the insurance agent’s alleged negligence.

The court granted summary judgment on all claims except for the negligence claim. Notably, Judge Wolfson reaffirmed the rule of law that there is no private right of action against the carrier under the Unfair Insurance Practices Act.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Brigid Q. Alford of the Camp Hill, PA office of Marshall Dennehey for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, January 6, 2020

Court Addresses Liability of Medical Facilities in Med Mal Context



In the case of Williams v. Vigder, No. 11050-CV-2019 (C.P. Beaver Co. Nov. 7, 2019 Ross, J.), the court addressed Preliminary Objections filed against claims of corporate negligence asserted against a medical facility, along with other issues in a medical malpractice matter.

In this case, Plaintiffs filed corporate negligence claims against two medical facilities, one of which appeared to be a hospital. The Defendants asserted that the doctrine of corporate negligence is not applicable to hospitals or like entities which play a role in the administration of total health for their patients.

The court denied this position put forth by the Defendant for Preliminary Objections purposes in light of the more recent pronouncement of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Scampone v. Highland Park Care Center, LLC, 57 A.3d 583 (Pa. 2012).

The court in this Williams case noted that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the Scampone case stated “that a Defendant is not categorically exempt from liability simply because appellate decisional law has not specifically addressed a theory of liability in a particular context.” Scampone at 599.

The court in Williams noted that “[t]he Scampone court specifically held that entities, such as nursing homes (and by inference hospitals and other like groups (health care providers)) should not be held to be “categorically immune from direct liability claims.” Id. at 600.

Given that doubt existed as to whether the demurrer to the corporate negligence claim should be sustained in this matter, the court overruled the Preliminary Objections filed by the Defendants in the Williams case.

In this case, this Williams case, court also allowed the Plaintiff’s claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress to proceed under facts alleged that the Plaintiffs allegedly experience great emotional shock after being advised of concern by the medical providers for their unborn child’s life after previously being advised that the mother’s labor was proceeding without incident. In overruling this Preliminary Objection, the Williams court cited to the case of Toney v. Chester County Hospital, 961 A.2d 192 (Pa. Super. 2008).

Lastly, the court also overruled the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections against the Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages after finding that the Plaintiff’s allegations contained in their Complaint were sufficient to allow that claim to proceed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this case may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Michael Foley of the Foley Law Firm in Scranton, Pennsylvania for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

Catch-all Allegations Stricken From Complaint in Monroe County

In the case of Delgado v. Whitestone Care Center, No. 6369-CV-2018 (C.P. Monroe Co. Dec. 12, 2018 Zulick, J.), the court sustained a Defendant’s Preliminary Objections regarding vague catchall language in a Plaintiff’s negligence Complaint arising out of a trip and fall matter.   However, the court overruled the Defendant’s separate Preliminary Objection pertaining to the Plaintiff’s inability to specifically name individual employees at the Defendant’s business relative to the vicarious liability claims.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was allegedly injured when she tripped and fell while visiting her mother at the facility operated by the Defendants.  

The Defendants initially objected to a catchall allegation by the Plaintiff that the conduct of the Defendants was “otherwise careless” and which was “presently unknown to Plaintiff but which may be learned through the discovery” process or at trial.  

Judge Arthur L. Zulick
Monroe County

Judge Zulick agreed with the Defendants that this particular language of the Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint was too vague and did not constitute a concise statement of material facts as required by the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.   The language also found not to prevent a claim for relief. Moreover, the court stated that such language could also lead to late claims with insufficient notice for the Defendants to properly prepare the defense for trial.   As such, Judge Zulick struck these allegations from the Complaint.  

However, the court denied the Defendant’s separate Preliminary Objections relative to the Plaintiff’s vicarious liability claim.   The court rejected the Defendant’s objection that the Plaintiff did not identify or describe the alleged agents or employees who acts or omissions allegedly resulted in her injuries.  

Judge Zulick pointed to Pennsylvania case law involving unnamed employees or agent and noted that, simply because employees or agents were unnamed, or were referred to as a unit, did not preclude a claim against the employer if those unidentified individuals acted negligently during the course and scope of their employment.  

Judge Zulick otherwise stated that the identity of the agents or staff members who were working in a particular patient room on the date of the Plaintiff’s injury were known or ascertainable by the Defendants, or that such information could otherwise be obtained through the course of discovery.   Given that the allegations provided enough facts to enable the defense to prepare a proper answer and defense, the court denied this Preliminary Objection. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 15, 2019).  

Wednesday, September 12, 2018

Summary Judgment Granted in Claim That Employee Was Driving Drunk


In the case of Huff v. Moser, No. Civil 14-S-773(C.P. Adams Co. May 14, 2018 George, J.), Judge Michael A. George of the Adams County Court of Common Pleas issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Superior Court to affirm his entry of summary judgment in a fatal motor vehicle accident case.     

In his trial court decision, Judge George concluded that the Plaintiff’s Complaint failed to allege a viable claim for vicarious liability on the part of a Defendant employer for actions of the employee who allegedly struck and killed a victim while driving the company car under the influence of alcohol. 

The court ruled in this fashion as none of the negligence allegations involved conduct committed during the course and scope of the driver’s employment.   The court emphasized that there were no specific allegations in the Complaint that the Defendant driver was working or acting within the course and scope of his employment at the time of the accident.   

The court additionally noted that, even if the Plaintiff had properly pled a claim for vicarious liability on the part of the employer for the actions of the driver, there was a lack of any factual dispute that would entitle the case to proceed to a jury on the liability issues presented.  

More specifically, the court noted that it appeared to the Plaintiff’s claim that the employer had a duty to secure a vehicle from being operated by an unlicensed driver who had been expressly prohibited from operating the vehicle. Judge George stated that he had not located any case law which placed a duty upon one to take affirmative steps to avoid criminal acts of another where there was no obvious known risk of such criminal acts.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source:  “Digest of Recent Cases.”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 24, 2018).