Showing posts with label Medicare Set-Asides. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medicare Set-Asides. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 3, 2016

Judge Mariani Remands Issue Regarding Carrier's Demand for Final Medicare Lien Letter Before Payment of Settlement Funds


In a decision handed down in the Federal Middle District Court of Pennsylvania case of Mikiewicz v. Hamorski and Erie Insurance Exchange, No. 3:15-CV-02426 (M.D.Pa. May 3, 2016 Mariani, J.), Judge Robert D. Mariani granted a Plaintiff's Motion for Remand in a case involving a carrier's demand that the Plaintiff secure and produce a final lien letter from Medicare prior to any need by the carrier to issue a settlement payment following a motor vehicle accident.

This matter was originally filed by the Plaintiff in the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas as a Petition assterting that the carrier's requirement that the Plaintiff satisfy certain conditions as part of the settlement, i.e. produce a final lien letter from Medicare, violated Pa.R.C.P. 229.1 which requires that settlement proceeds be paid within twenty days of the execution of a Release.

The Plaintiff followed that Petition with a Motion to Enforce the Settlement in the state court.  The same day that Motion was argued, the carrier filed an Answer to the Motion and also filed paperwork to remove the case to federal court.

The carrier asserted that removal was proper given that Plaintiff's claim involved a federal statute, the Medicare Secondary Payer Act ("MSPA"), thereby giving rise to federal question jurisdiction.  The carrier also asserted that removal was appropriate because the MSPA is an extraordinary statute that completely pre-empted state law.

The Plaintiff responded by filing the federal court Motion to Remand at issue.  As noted, the court granted the Plaintiff's Motion.

Judge Robert D. Mariani
M.D. Pa.
 
In so ruling, Judge Mariani found that the Plaintiff's claims did not arise under Federal law as asserted by the carrier.  Rather, the court found, the carrier raised federal law as a defense to the Plaintiff's claims.  The court noted that a defendant can not transform a matter into a federal question case by injecting a federal law defense into the matter for purposes of the removal issue.

Judge Mariani also rejected the carrier's contention that the MSPA completely preempted State law.  The court reviewed the "complete pre-emption doctrine" and found that the elements of that doctrine had not been met under circumstances presented in this matter.  Judge Mariani cited to several Third Circuit decisions holding that a state law cause of action that references or involves the MSPA or the Medicare statute is not removable to federal court because it does not raise a federal question.

Accordingly, the court granted the Plaintiff's Motion for Remand and sent the case back to state court.  In so ruling, the court also granted attorney's fees, costs and expenses after finding that the carrier lacked an objectively reasonable basis for the removal.  The court noted that not only had the carrier failed to cite case law in support of the removal, the court also pointed out that the carrier had been repeatedly sanctioned in the past for making similar unsuccessful arguments regarding the MSPA.

Anyone wishing to review Judge Mariani's opinion in Mikiewicz may click this LINK.

I send thanks to the prevailing Plaintiff's attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic, PA office of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, December 30, 2014

The 2014 Tort Talk Top Ten



THE 2014 TORT TALK TOP TEN
As another year winds down to an end, here's a look back at some of the top cases and trends of the year in the 2012 TORT TALK TOP 10:

10.  Prospect for Medicare Set-Asides in Third Party Lawsuits Dead

According to a press release from The American Association for Justice, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) withdrew its proposed rule in tort actions on future medicals called the “Medicare Secondary Payer and Future Medicals” rule.  According to the AAJ, this means that, currently, there is no future medicals rule pending from Medicare and the prospect of having to do Medicare Set-Asides in third party liability matters is now dead.


9.  Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens

In Lee v. Bower Lewis Thrower Architects, 2014 Pa.Super. 240 (Pa. Super. Oct. 22, 2014 Gantman, P.J., Bender, P.J.E., and Platt, J.)(Op. by Gantman, P.J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld a Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas judge’s ruling granting a Defendant’s Motion to Transfer under the Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens.   This case represents one of the first appellate decisions applying the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s recent Forum Non Conveniens ruling in the case of Bractic v. Rubendall.  

Anyone wishing to review the Pennsylvania Superior Court's decision in the Lee case, may click this LINK. 



8.  Right to Assign Bad Faith Claim Upheld

In Allstate Ins. Co. v. Wolfe, No. 39 MAP 2014 (Pa. Dec. 15, 2014)(Op. by Saylor, J.)(Castille, C.J, Dissenting Without Opinion), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that a third party defendant tortfeasor hit with an excess verdict in a trial on personal injuries arising out of a motor vehicle accident may assign to the plaintiff his potential rights to sue his own automobile liability insurance carrier for a bad faith refusal to settle the case prior to trial.
The Supreme Court's decision may viewed at this LINK.

7.  Exercise of Federal Court Jurisdiction Over Insurance Coverage Actions Clarified

The case of Reifer v. Westport Insurance Corporation, 751 F.3d 129 (3d Cir. April 29, 2014 Van Antwerpen, J.), has been touted as the Third Circuit Court of Appeal’s most important decisions on the exercise of federal jurisdiction in insurance coverage declaratory actions in recent times.  While the Third Circuit in the Reifer decision sympathized with the District Court’s “apparent frustration over the volume of such cases,” the Third Circuit stated that it was not aware of any authority to support a general proposition that an insurance company was barred from bringing declaratory judgment actions on the issue of coverage in federal court.  Rather, the Third Circuit Court stated that there is no bright line rule permitting the district courts to automatically abstain from hearing such cases unless there was a total absence of any federal legal question presented.  The Third Circuit clarified the factors to be considered in determining whether or not to exercise jurisdiction.  As such, an upward trend of federal court declaratory judgment actions on the issue of insurance coverage is anticipated. 

Anyone wishing to review the Reifer Opinion by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals may click this LINK.


6.  Discovery of Attorney-Expert Opinions is Barred

In 2014, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's much-anticipated, but short-handed, decision on the issue of whether an attorney's communications with an expert are discoverable was handed down in the form of a 3-3 decision in the case of Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital, 91 A.3d 680 (Pa. April 29, 2014).  This split decision allowed the previous en banc Superior Court decision (8-1), found at 32 A.2d 600 (Pa. Super. 2011), to stand which held that communications between a lawyer and an expert witness are not discoverable.

On a related note, in August of this year, the amendments to Pa.R.C.P. 4003.5(a)(4) became effective.  These amendments to this expert discovery Rule incorporated the law of Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital by providing that such communications, as well as draft reports by experts,  need not be disclosed "except in circumstances that would warrant the disclosure of privileged communications under Pennsylvania law."


5.   A Short-handed Pennsylvania Supreme Court – Again.

Another year ends with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court at less than a full complement of Justices again.  Time to consider a switch to merit selection process where the nominees are fully vetted in the same rigorous manner as Federal Court Judicial nominees are subjected to?



 
4.  Much Needed (Not Appellate) Guidance on Proper Jury Instructions for Post-Koken Cases  

In Moritz v. Horace Mann Ins. Co.,  No. 2013-CV-544 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 10, 2014), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas reviewed cases from within and without Pennsylvania in an effort to formulate even-handed jury instructions designed to inform the jury as to the involvement of the insurance company in the matter, explaining the absence of the tortfeasor driver in the context of this particular matter, and emphasizing that the jury’s focus should be upon an evaluation of the claims and defenses presented as opposed to the type of parties involved.  

Anyone wishing to review this decision of first impression in Pennsylvania by Judge Terrence R. Nealon in Moritz may click this LINK.


3.  Statutory Caps in Cases Against Governmental Agencies Upheld

 In Zauflik v. Pennsbury School District, 1 MAP 2014 (Pa. Nov. 19, 2014 ),  the Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the statutory cap of $500,000 protecting local governmental agencies in personal injury tort claims.

The Court's Opinion in Zauflik can be viewed HERE. 

Justice Baer's Concurring Opinion can be viewed HERE.


2.  Right to a Fair and Impartial Jury Upheld 

In Cordes v. Associates of Internal Medicine, 87 A.3d 829 (Pa. Super. March 12, 2014) (en banc) appeal denied, 192 WAL 2014 (Pa. 2014), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the issue of the trial court's denial of the plaintiff’s strikes for cause during jury selection after the exhaustion of that party’s peremptory challenges.  According to the Opinion, the jury that resulted in the Cordes case included a husband of a patient of the defendant doctor, the daughter of a patient of the defendant doctor, and an employee of the parent medical corporation whose subsidiary employed the defendant doctor.   The Opinions issued by the Cordes court all essentially agree with the notion that an important goal of jury selection is ensure not only a jury that is impartial in fact, but one that also appears to be free from the taint of partiality to a disinterested observer.   In the end, it was held that the trial court erred in refusing, after the exhaustion of a party’s peremptory challenges, to strike for cause those jurors who had a close relationship to a Defendant doctor and/or were employed by the same company as that doctor despite those jurors’ assurances of impartiality.   As such, the defense verdict in this medical malpractice case was vacated and the case was remanded for a new trial.  As noted above, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court curiously denied allocatur.


1.  A New Analysis for Pennsylvania Products Liability Cases Adopted

In Tincher v. Omega Flex, Inc.,  the Pennsylvania Supreme Court did not adopt the Restatement (Third) of Torts analysis for products liability cases but did alter the required analysis.  The import of the Court’s lengthy Opinion is still being debated and is likely to lead to ongoing litigation on the proper analysis to be utilized in products cases in the years to come.

Concisely, the new strict products liability analysis adopted by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was enunciated, as follows:

"...we conclude that a plaintiff pursuing a cause upon a theory of strict liability in tort must prove that the product is in a “defective condition.” The plaintiff may prove defective condition by showing either that (1) the danger is unknowable and unacceptable to the average or ordinary consumer, or that (2) a reasonable person would conclude that the probability and seriousness of harm caused by the product outweigh the burden or costs of taking precautions. The burden of production and persuasion is by a  preponderance of the evidence."

The Court went on to emphasize that the issue of whether or not a product is in a defective condition was a question of fact to be considered by a jury and could only be decided by a court on a motion for summary judgment if the court found that no reasonable minds on a jury could differ on a conclusion that a product was not defective.

To review a copy of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's lengthy decision in Tincher v. Omega Flex, click HERE.

In his Dissenting and Concurring Opinion, which can be viewed HERE, Justice Saylor noted, in part, that he favored the adoption of the Restatement (Third) of Torts analysis for products cases.

HONORABLE MENTIONS:
-Still awaiting appellate guidance on wide variety of Post-Koken issues
-Still awaiting appellate guidance on Facebook discovery issues
-Still awaiting appellate guidance on Cellphone Use in auto accident cases (punitive damages)
-Hudak-Bisset v. County of Lackawanna et al., No. 2007-CV-2401 (C.P. Lacka. Co. March 19, 2014 Minora, J.): recognizes cause of action for recovery of damages for a suicide allegedly secondary to accident related injuries and chronic pain caused by the negligence of a tortfeasor defendant in a car accident case.
-Commonwealth v. Parker,  2014 Pa. Super. 253, No. 918 EDA 2011 (Pa. Super. Nov. 6, 2014 Olson, Ott, Stabile, J.J.)(Opinion by Olson, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior court ruled that an out-of-court in the form of a question can be deemed to be a hearsay statement if it includes an assertion, or an implied assertion, within the question.





 
NOTE:  Portions of this blog post are copied from other previous Tort Talk blog post as well as my November 25, 2014 Pennsylvania Law Weekly Article entitled "THE MORE THINGS CHANGE, THE MORE THEY REMAIN THE SAME: A Review of Important Civil Litigation Cases and Trends in 2014"

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

DING DONG THE WITCH IS DEAD!


According to a press release from The American Association for Justice, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has withdrawn its proposed rule in tort actions on future medicals called “Medicare Secondary Payer and Future Medicals.” 

According to the AAJ, this means that, currently, there is no future medicals rule pending from Medicare and the prospect of having to do Medicare Set-Asides in third party liability matters is now dead.

I send thanks to Attorney Bruce Zero of the Scranton, PA -based Powell Law for bringing this news to my attention.

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Two More Decisions Addressing Whether Medicare Lien Issues Can Hold Up a Settlement

I recently came across additional decisions in which a trial court addressed the issue of Medicare lien payments possibly holding up the resolution of a civil litigation settlement:

In his 2011 decision in the case of Mackrides v. Marshalls, Marmaxx Operating Corp., No. 11-Civil-6540 (E.D. Pa. April 23, 2013, Joyner, J.), Judge J. Curtis Joyner addressed Medicare issues with regards to a settlement of a slip and fall personal injury suit.  

In this decision, the Court addressed a Plaintiff’s Motion to Enforce a Settlement.   The Court ruled that the motion would be denied.  

In the Opinion, the Court noted that, although the Defendant’s failure to tender a proposed Release or settlement, was dilatory, unreasonable, and bordering on being deemed worthy of sanctions, the motion to enforce the settlement was denied where questions about the settlement terms remained unresolved, including questions pertaining to whether the settlement figure included funds to reimburse Medicare, whether Medicare made payments subject to reimbursement, and whether Medicare had waived any right to reimbursement.  

Anyone wishing to review this Mackrides Opinion may click this LINK. 


 
The older Northampton County Court of Common Pleas decision from back in 2011 in the case of Furman v. Wildermuth, No. C-0048-CV-2008-3556 (C.P. Northampton Co. July 12, 2011 Dally, J.), is another example of a trial court decision holding that a settlement of a personal injury may not be conditioned upon receipt of a final conditional payment letter from Medicare.   That Court relied upon the Pennsylvania Superior Court decision in Zaleppa v. Siewel, 9 A.3d 632 (Pa. 2010).  
 
The Furman decision can be viewed HERE.
 
Source:   “Court Summaries,” Pennsylvania Bar News (May, 2013) by Timothy L. Clawges.    
 


Click HERE to view other Tort Talk posts on Medicare issues, including with respect to settlements of personal injury matters.

Sunday, August 5, 2012

More Decisions Regarding Impact of Medicare Liens on Finalization of Settlements

Below are summaries of two recent federal court decisions regarding the impact of potential Medicare liens on the finalization of a settlement of a third party action:

Carty v. Clark, Civil Action No. 11-6083 (E.D.Pa. June 14, 2012 Rueter, Mag. Judge)(Order by Robreno, J.)

In Carty, the Plaintiff agreed in a Release that defense counsel could hold settlement amount in escrow until Plaintiff produced Final Demand Letter from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

The Plaintiff thereafter produced a Final Demand Letter and the defense counsel refused to release settlement amount citing fears that an unpaid medical bill might be paid by Medicare in the future and would have to be added to the lien.

The Court granted Plaintiff's Motion to Enforce settlement citing the clear terms of the Release which stated that, once the Final Demand Letter was produced by the Plaintiff from Medicare, the settlement proceeds were to be released to the Plaintiff. 

The Plaintiff's request for sanctions were denied as it did not appear to the court that the defense had acted in bad faith.

To view Federal Magistrate Rueter's Report and Recommendation, click HERE.

To view the Eastern District Court Order issued by Judge Eduardo C. Robreno adopting Judge Rueter's Report and Recommendation, click HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney Bill Mabius of the Pennsylvania Association of Justice for bringing this case to my attention.



Sipler v. Trans AM Trucking, Inc., et al, No. 10-3550(DRD)(D.N.J. July 24, 2012 DeBevoise, S.J.)

Although the Sipler case is a Federal District Court of New Jersey decision that was marked by that court as "NOT FOR PUBLICATION," a number of Pennsylvania litigators are pointing to the case for its persuasive authority on the issue of the impact (or more appropriately, the non-impact) of Medicare issues on personal injury settlements.

In the District of New Jersey case of Sipler, the parties settled a personal injury action arising out of a motor vehicle accident.  The parties were unable to finalize the settlement due to disagreements over the terms of the Release, which dispute included issues over release terms pertaining to Medicare matters.  The Plaintiff brought the matter before the court by way of a Motion to Enforce Settlement.

After thoroughly reviewing the applicable law pertaining to Medicare and the potential for Medicare liens, the court in Sipler noted that, while the Plaintiff was Medicare eligible, there was no evidence that Medicare had paid for any of the Plaintiff's accident-related treatment.

Based on the demands of the defense in this matter in terms of the requested provisions of the release, one of the issues in this case became whether the Medicare Secondary Payer statute required language in the release provisions of the plaintiff's settlement agreement specifying (1) the plaintiff's obligation not to seek such payments from Medicare, and (2) that a portion of the settlement amount would be set aside for future medical expenses arising out of the accident.

The court in Sipler noted that, while set-aside agreements were common in workers' compensation matters, "no federal law requires set-aside arrangements in personal injury settlements for future medical expenses."  Op. at p. 6.

The court went on to note that personal injury settlements should not be required to have such set-aside agreements because "to require personal injury settlements to specifically apportion future medical expenses would prove burdensone to the settlement process and, in turn, discourage personal injury settlements."  Id. at p. 7.

In a footnote, Judge DeBevoise also stated "Indeed, it would be particularly discouraging if litigants were required to obtain Medicare's approval of a settlement."  Id. at p. 7, n. 1.

Accordingly, the court held that "the parties in this case need not include language in the settlement documents noting [the Plaintiff's] obligations to Medicare or fashion a Medicare set-aside for future medical expenses."  Id. at p. 7.

To view the Sipler decision online, click this LINK.

I thank several attorneys for pointing this decision out to me including, but not limited to, Attorney Andrew Bigda of the Wilkes-Barre, PA law firm of Rosenn, Jenkins & Greenwald, and Attorney Thomas Foley, Jr. of the Scranton, PA Foley Law Firm.


To review, other Tort Talk posts (as well as my July of 2012 Pennsylvania Law Weekly article) on this issue of the interaction of Medicare lien issues and personal injury settlements,
click this LINK.

Friday, November 19, 2010

New Superior Court Case Regarding Naming Medicare on Settlement Drafts

In its recent November 17, 2010 decision on an appeal from a Luzerne County case, the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the issue of naming Medicare on settlement checks in the case of Zaleppa v. Seiwell, 2010 Pa.Super. 208 (Pa.Super. Nov. 17, 2010, Allen, Mundy, and Colville, JJ.).

At trial, the Plaintiff had obtained a $15,000.00 jury verdict against the Defendants, $5,000 of which was for future medical expenses and the remainder of which was for pain and suffering.

On post-trial motions, the Defendants argued that the trial court erred in denying the Defendants' request that the court enter an Order directing the Defendants to pay the verdict either (1) by naming Medicare, along with the Plaintiff and her attorneys, as payees on the check satisfying the verdict, or (2) by paying the verdict into court pending notification from Medicare that all outstanding Medicare liens had been satisfied.

In its Opinion, the Superior Court noted that the Plaintiff was 69 years of age at the time of the car accident that was the subject of this litigation. However, there was no evidence presented at the trial court level that any of the Plaintiffs' past medical treatment had been paid by Medicare to date. The Superior Court additionally noted that there was no claim presented for any past medical expenses by the Plaintiff because she was precluded from doing so by 75 Pa.C.S.A. 1722 in that the first party medical benefits under her own automobile insurance policy had not been exhausted. The Zaleppa Court further emphasized that the jury did not enter any award for past medical expenses.

The Superior Court held that there was no legal basis under either federal or Pennsylvania law to assert the interests of the United States government as to the reimbursement of Medicare liens. As such, the Superior Court held that the trial court properly denied the Defendants' request in this regard.

It is noted that the Superior Court does a nice analysis of a defendant's (and arguably a plaintiff's) obligations under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act (MSPA). To review this Opinion, click on this link:

http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Superior/out/A30027_10.pdf


I was made aware of this recent, important decision by Attorney Ron Marrero, of Robert J. Casey & Associates (State Farm house counsel, Philadelphia) and I send a "thanks" his way..

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Medicare Reporting Deadline Postponed - Again

I have obtained permission to re-publish this November 16, 2010 blog post on the Medicare reporting requirements by Dave Walk, Esquire from the Drug and Device Law Blog as a guest post here. Attorney Walk provided this update:

We have reported to you occasionally, but not consistently or reliably or intelligibly, about the new obligation of product liability defendants and others to report settlements and other payments on personal injury claims to Medicare authorities. See, for example, our posts titled Boring Stuff We Need to Know and More Boring Stuff We Need to Know. The reporting obligation has been extended several times and was scheduled to kick in starting on January 1, 2011 – an extension we did not tell you about. We told you we are not reliable chroniclers of boring stuff. What can we say? We'd rather write about preemption or Daubert or TwIqbal.

Last week, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which goes by the confusing acronym CMS instead of the more logical CMMS, announced that the reporting deadline for some but not all entities and some but not all settlements has been postponed for one full year. The CMS alert states: “The required submission of liability insurance (including self-insurance) initial claim reports has been changed from the first calendar quarter of 2011 to the first calendar quarter of 2012 for all liability insurance (including self-insurance) TPOC amounts with no ORM involvement. Liability insurance (including self-insurance) ORM reporting is not subject to this delay.”

We speak bureaucratese about as well as we speak jive (R.I.P., Barbara Billingsley). Here is a rough translation: The deadline for reporting personal injury settlements and other payment obligations (that’s TPOC) has been extended for one year, until the quarter starting January 1, 2012, but only for settlements or other payments paid by liability insurance or the defendant itself (that’s self-insurance) and not for no-fault insurance and workers’ compensation. The extension does not apply to settlements or other payment obligations that include an ongoing responsibility for paying the injured party’s medical bills (that’s ORM).

This is complicated stuff that is very important to our clients, so if you have an issue in this area, please read the CMS alert and consult with professional translators of CMS bureaucratese.

--
Posted By David Walk to Drug and Device Law at 11/16/2010 01:23:00 PM

The Drug and Device Law blog can be accessed by clicking on this link:

http://druganddevicelaw.blogspot.com/

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Pennsylvania Association For Justice Puts On Excellent Seminar at the 27th Annual Pennsylvania Automobile Law Program in Philadelphia

Yesterday (May 27, 2009), I attended excellent presentations on the current status of Pennsylvania automobile law at the 27th Annual Pennsylvania Automobile Law Seminar put on by the Pennsylvania Association of Justice.

Attorney Leonard Sloane did a great job as the moderator, keeping the program moving and providing his own insight on the many topics covered.

The following is a recap of some of the highlights of the seminar.


Update of First Party, Third Party Liability, Limited Tort, and Coverage Issues

Attorney David Lutz's thorough recap of the case updates confirmed that there were not too many earth-shattering opinions handed down recently. Many of the cases reviewed were the ones that have been summarized in previous posts to this blog, such as the excess insurance case of Kropa v. Gateway Ford case and others.

Attorney Lisa Woodburn provided some nice tips on the inter-play between workers comp law and the auto law arena. Also, Frank J. Wesner, Jr. Esquire took part in discussion of the updates in bad faith law.

Later in the seminar, Attorney Lutz also provided tips or reminders to improve one's trial performance and results, which are always good to hear. Here are the ten tips covered and suggested to keep in mind:

1. Failure to clearly develop a powerful theme.

2. Failure to file appropriate motions in limine.

3. Failure to use a legal assistant during voir dire (to assist you in writing down juror's answers and info).

4. Failure to ask open-ended questions and follow-up questions during voir dire.

5. Failure to use demonstrative exhibits during opening statement.

6. Failure to properly prepare Plaintiff for cross-examination.

7. Failure to properly prepare treating doctor's testimony concerning causation and prognosis opinions.

8. Failure to use the internet for cross-examination of the Defendant witnesses, especially the defense expert witnesses.

9. Failure during closing argument to clearly convey that "the goal is money."

10. Failure to have a legal assistant properly conduct a jury debriefing after a verdict.


Update on Subrogation

Jason E. Matzus, Esquire from Pittsburgh presented his update on subrogation issues. If a passion is needed to become and expert on this topic and bring it to life during a seminar, this guy has it.

Of particular note, were his written materials and presentation on the impending Medicare Set-Aside issue. Attorney Lutz reviewed the Medicare, Medicaid and SCHIP Extension Act of 2007 which is to become effective on July 1, 2009. This Act, which is apparently directed at the liability industry and not plaintiff's attorneys, has the bar up in a tizzy about whether or not Medicare Set-Asides, common in worker's compensation cases, will be required in third party liability cases.

The purpose of the Medicare Set-Aside provision is to ensure that the primary payers (liability carriers) bear the cost of future medical expenses so that Medicare does not have to pay them down the road. The provision works by requiring that money be set aside from a settlement and be kept at the ready for the payment of future medical expenses. The Act also provides for hefty penalties if the provisions are not followed.

In his presentation and materials, Attorney Lutz explains while there is a growing movement to expand this program of Set-Asides from the worker's comp arena to the litigation arena, it is currently only a rare occurence in Pennsylvania that the issue is raised in the litigation context. However, if Medicare's budgetary problems continue, it is anticipated that the Set-Asides may become a mandatory requirement in third party matters.

Currently, it does not appear to Attorney Lutz that there are any express requirements that Plaintiff's attorneys create any Medicare Set-Aside plans (MSAs) to date. As long as a liability settlement does not specifically delineate some of the monies to future medical care, then no amount of the settlement would appear to be covered by Medicare's efforts to recover for future medical expenses.

Attorney Lutz cautiously concludes, however, that since we are proceeding in "unchartered waters" in the absence of any specific guidance from the applicable law, there is no "safe harbor" course of conduct currently established for litigants to avoid Medicare's reach on this issue.


Update on Bad Faith Law

The hot topic in the bad faith arena is the settlement of a class action lawsuit out of the Miller County trial court in Arkansas involving UM/UIM policies under Allstate and CNA auto policies. The case involved allegations that, between January 1, 1994 and February 19,2009, those companies underpaid claimants by using computer programs such as Colossus, Claims Outcome Advisor, and/or Injury IQ to evaluate cases. Despite settling the suit, the carriers denied that they underpaid claims and asserted that their use of these computer programs was proper.

More detailed information on this settlement, and whether a claim you previously concluded may be covered by it, can be found at http://www.cazaressettlement.com/.


James Ronca, Esquire on 18 Wheels and 2 Wheels--Some insights into non-automobile vehicle cases

The always energetic and entertaining Attorney James Ronca provided some nice, informative samples on conducting depositions in trucking accident cases. He also provided primers on how to handle and approach bicycle accident cases and motorcycle accident cases. Many great tips were gathered from his presentation.


Koken Update, UM/UIM Update

The case updates in the Koken area confirmed that there have not been any more recent significant cases handed down recently other than those cases reviewed in the blogs noted below, particularly with respect to the trial courts allowing UIM and third party cases to proceed in a consolidated fashion under one caption under the rationale of judicial economy.

During this portion of the program, noted Plaintiff's attorney Scott Cooper and noted defense attorney James Haggerty faced off with varying points on the important UM/UIM cases over the past year or two, such as the Sackett cases, the Generette case, and others. As these two attorneys were personally involved in the cases discussed, they were able to to an excellent job explaining the ins and outs of how these cases came to be as well as the implications of those decisions on future UM/UIM cases in a readily understandable way.

A highlight of the Koken portion of the program was a presentation by Judge Robert Colville of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas and Plaintiff's attorney Sean Carmody who worked one of state's first post-Koken-like cases. The defense counsel was unable to make it to the discussion.

The UM claim that they tried before a jury involved an out-of-state State Farm policy that did not have an arbitration clause.

The judge noted that he viewed the case as a contract dispute between a carrier and its insured, with the case having many tort concepts to consider. With the agreement of counsel, the court openly and honestly explained to the jury the nature of the contract dispute between the claimant and State Farm Insurance Company as a defendant. The court advised the jury that the carrier had a duty to provide the coverage or benefits available under the insurance policy where warranted.

During voir dire, defense counsel was permitted to ask basis questions such as whether the jurors had ever had a claim against a carrier and whether their experience was good or bad.

Plaintiff's attorney was allowed to present a theory of the case during the opening statement of corporate vs. the little guy, insurance company vs. the little insured, etc., as well as argue the claimant's position that he had paid an premium for these UM benefits and that the claimant felt that he was entitled to an award under the circumstances presented in this case involving a DUI tortfeasor. Plaintiff's counsel noted that the defense counsel took pains to separate State Farm from the DUI tortfeasor (who was not present at the trial).

Plaintiff's counsel noted that the defense went through the trial with an empty chair and the claims rep in the back of the courtroom. Plaintiff's counsel only called the claims rep as a witness for a brief and limited purpose during trial.

The issue of the declarations page, or other information on the available limits, did not come into play given the plaintiff's counsel's strategy of not offering that info to the jury in order to avoid any potential preconceived notions as to the value based upon the coverage.

I believe it was indicated that the verdict came back in the high six figures range, but that would have to be confirmed.


All in all, it was a very informative day with six CLE credits in the bank, followed by a few innings of the Phillies at the Citizen's Bank Stadium under a perfect night for baseball.