Showing posts with label To A Reasonable Degree of Certainty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label To A Reasonable Degree of Certainty. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 12, 2025

Superior Court Affirms Entry of Nonsuit Where Trial Court Precluded Plaintiff's Liability Expert For Giving a 'More Likely Than Not' Expert Opinion


In the case of Peterson v. Stacy’s Pizza, Inc., 315 EDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Jan. 14, 2025 Dubow, J., Sullivan, J., and Olson, J.) (Op. by Dubow, J.; Olson, J, concurring), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the entry of a nonsuit entered by the lower court after finding that the Plaintiffs did not meet their burden of proving the case presented.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was allegedly injured when he was hit by a swinging door while making a delivery.  The Plaintiff retained a liability expert to testify at trial on a opinion on whether the door in question was defective.   

In this decision, the Pennsylvania Superior Court again confirmed that an expert opinion on causation to a reasonable degree of engineering certainty that the condition on the Defendant’s property “more likely than not” caused the Plaintiff’s injury was properly excluded by the trial court as not actually being an expert opinion to a reasonable degree of certainty.

The court noted that the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion only stated that the Defendant’s improper maintenance was more likely than not the cause of the injury.

The Superior Court noted that, because the Plaintiff in this case had rested his case when it became clear that a fatal expert exclusion would cause a nonsuit, and where the Plaintiff did not thereafter present any evidence of damages, any error possibly committed by the trial court in terms of entering a nonsuit would have been harmless in any event.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, April 19, 2023

Court Precludes Admissibility of Exemplar Pictures of a Surgery That Plaintiff Did Not Even Have



In the case of Crump v. Goldsleger, Aug. Term, No. 01434 (C.P. Phila. Co. Jan. 4, 2023 Powell, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion addressing various issues following a motor vehicle accident trial in which a defense verdict was entered.

Of note was the trial court’s conclusion that it properly denied Plaintiff’s request to admit evidence of photographs that did not pertain to any of the Plaintiff’s injuries. The court found that such evidence was not relevant or probative on the issues presented.

More specifically, in this case, the court noted that the Plaintiff’s credibility had been called into question as the Plaintiff attempted to introduce into evidence pictures of a knee surgery that were not pictures of the Plaintiff’s knee. It was also noted that the pictures did not depicted a type of surgery that was completed on the Plaintiff.

The court noted that, since the photographs of the knee that the Plaintiff sought to introduce were not actually pictures of the Plaintiff’s knee, the court found that the evidence was irrelevant in that any minimal probative value of the picture was severely outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.  The court noted that the only purpose of the photos appeared to be to shock the jury and to attempt to garner sympathy for the Plaintiff.

The court also asserted in its Rule 1925 Opinion that it had properly excluded the expert testimony of the Plaintiff's expert, Dr. Lance Yarus, where the expert had noted a "suspected" knee injury based upon a tele-medicine meeting with the Plaintiff.   The court found that such testimony did not meet the reasonable degree of medical certainty standard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Feb. 28, 2023).

Monday, May 11, 2020

Pennsylvania Superior Court Addresses Admissibility of Expert Testimony At Trial



In the case of Rolon v. Davies, No. 2046 MDA 2018 (Pa. Super. April 28, 2020 Stabile, J., McLaughlin, J., and Musmanno, J.) (Op. by Stabile, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court provided guidance on their required elements for expert testimony to be admissible in a medical malpractice case.

In its decision, the Pennsylvania Superior reserved a trial court’s grant of a nonsuit in favor of a Defendant surgeon in a negligence case filed under allegations that one of his patients had died of a pulmonary embolism following surgery.

At the trial court level, the Defendants moved for a nonsuit under a claim that the Plaintiff’s expert did not offer his opinion to as reasonable degree of medical certain consistent with Pennsylvania law regarding the Defendant’s alleged negligence. The trial court judge granted that particular Defendant’s motion for a nonsuit and the jury eventually returned a defense verdict in favor of the other Defendants. The Plaintiff appealed asserting, in part, that the trial court judge erred in granting the nonsuit regarding the expert at issue.

The Superior Court reversed the trial court’s entry of a nonsuit after finding that the record confirmed that the Plaintiff’s medical expert stated he was certain of his opinion.  The Superior Court also noted that the Plaintiff’s medical expert also provided a thorough explanation as to how he arrived at his opinion given the evidence before him.

In its Opinion, the Superior Court provided a nice review of the requirements to allow expert testimony into evidence. The court reiterated the rule that an expert need not use the 'magic words' "to a reasonable degree of medical certainty” for her or his testimony to be admissible.   Rather, the Superior Court panel noted that, if the remainder of the expert’s opinion confirms that the expert expressed his opinion with reasonable certainty, then the opinion should be allowed into evidence as supportive of the case presented by that party offering the expert.

The court noted that an “expert fails this standard of certainty if [he] or [she] testifies that the alleged cause ‘possibly,’ or ‘could have’ led to the result, that it ‘could very properly account’ for the result, or even that it was ‘very highly probable’ that it caused the result.” See Op. at 5 [citation omitted] [bracket inserted here].

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Article – “Court Calls for New Med Mal Trial, Reversing Ruling That Expert Testimony Was Insufficient.” By P.J. D’Annunzio Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 30, 2020).