Showing posts with label Hills and Ridges Doctrine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hills and Ridges Doctrine. Show all posts

Monday, February 2, 2026

Summary Judgment Denied in Federal Court Snow and Ice Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Spa Resort, L.P., No. 3:24-CV-0796 (M.D. Pa. Jan. 9, 2026 Saporito, J.), the court denied the Defendant resort’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case.

The Defendant landowner argued that the hills and ridges doctrine applied because the Plaintiff allegedly slipped and fell due to icy conditions that resulted from snowfall on the day of the incident.

In opposition, the Plaintiffs argued that the Plaintiff did not slip and fall due to icy conditions caused by the snowstorm, but rather, because the Defendants’ driveway was improperly maintained and repaired such that the hills and ridges doctrine did not apply.

The court ultimately concluded that questions of fact remained as to whether the hills and ridges doctrine applied to shield the property owner from liability regarding the allegedly slippery conditions on the premises.
Judge Joseph F. Saporito, Jr.
M.D. Pa.


In his decision, Judge Saporito provided a detailed review of the current status of the law in Pennsylvania regarding the hills and ridges doctrine.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article – “Jury To Decide If Spa Resort Can Be Liable Under ‘Hills and Ridges’ Doctrine In Slip-And-Fall Case,” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (Jan. 12, 2026).

Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Superior Court Rules That 3 Hour Delay Between End of Snowstorm and Beginning of Cleanup Was Not Unreasonable (Non-Precedential)


It appears that it is reasonable in Pennsylvania to have a cup of coffee or tea and enjoy the sight of a freshly fallen snow before having to go out and shovel.

In its non-precedential decision in the case of Melvin v. Sellani, No. 1234 MDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Dec. 31, 2025 Bowes, J., Stabile, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Mem. Op. by Stabile, J.), the court affirmed the entry of summary judgment in favor of the Defendant landowners and property manager in a slip and fall matter involving ice and/or snow.

The trial court decision entering summary judgment in favor of the Defendants had been entered by Judge Richard M. Hughes, III of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas.

Relative to the hills and ridges argument, the court noted that the Plaintiff failed to present evidence to establish when photographs of the scene of the incident were taken. There were conflicting statements as to whether the photos were taken the day of the incident or shortly thereafter. As such, the court noted that the photographs relied upon by the Plaintiff were not sufficient to create any material issues of fact as to whether the Defendants were under a duty to remedy any alleged hills and/or ridges of snow at the time of the incident.

The Superior Court otherwise observed that the Plaintiff failed to establish that an unreasonable of time had passed between the snowstorm and the alleged dangerous accumulation of snow or ice.

By the Plaintiff’s own testimony, it was snowing when she arrived at work at 6:30 in the morning on the day of the fall. The Plaintiff also confirmed that the snow had stopped by 3:00 p.m. when she left work. Three (3) to five (5) inches of snow had accumulated.

It was additionally indicated that the Defendant property manager indicated that he had begun to remove snow at 9:30 a.m. at the Plaintiff’s residence. The Plaintiff confirmed that the property manager was still working at snow removal when the Plaintiff arrived at home.

The court noted that, even if the snow had stopped immediately when the Plaintiff arrived at work earlier that morning, the Plaintiff provided no case law to support an argument “that a 3-hour delay between the cessation of the snow and the beginning of the clean up effort constitute[d] an unreasonable delay.” See Op. at 7.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source of image:  Photo by Jill Wellington on www.pexels.com.

Friday, June 6, 2025

Summary Judgment Denied in Parking Lot Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Coolbaugh v. Sonesta Select Allentown Bethlehem Airport, No. 2023-C-1548 (C.P. Leh. Co. Nov. 13, 2024 Reichley, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a case involving an alleged slip and fall in the Defendants’ parking lot.

In denying the motion, the court held that there were genuine issues of material fact regarding the application of the hills and ridges doctrine where a de-icing of the parking lot had occurred approximately twenty-four (24) hours before the Plaintiff’s accident.

According to the record before the court, there was evidence that the Plaintiff fell when temperatures were around freezing and where it had snowed three or four days earlier. The court noted that, where the evidence also indicated that the parking lot had been de-iced approximately twenty-four (24) hours before the Plaintiff’s accident, there was an issue of fact on whether the alleged accumulation of the ice upon which the Plaintiff had slipped was a natural accumulation or not.

Given these issues of fact, the court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment.

The court also denied the Motion for Summary Judgment on the basis of rejecting the Defendants’ argument that they had delegated the snow and ice removal duties to a third party under a contract. The court stated that the record was silent as to whether the moving Defendants had relinquished possession and control of the parking lot during or after the third party had performed snow removal services.

The court additionally noted that there were factual questions regarding the Defendants’ notice of the parking lot’s condition where snowy and ice conditions had been observed in the lot for days or weeks leading up to the Plaintiff’s accident.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (April 30, 2025).

Source of image:  Photo by Wolfgang Lutzgendorf on www.pexels.com.

Friday, February 21, 2025

Summary Judgment Granted Relative To Slip and Fall That Occurred During an Active Snowstorm


In the case of King v. Hermitage Plaza, No. 2023-CV-1055 (C.P. Mercer Co. Jan. 14, 2025 Amrhein, Jr., J.), the court entered summary judgment in a slip and fall case where the Plaintiff slipped and fell in a parking lot owned by the Defendant during an ongoing snowstorm.

According to the Opinion, on the day of the incident, the Plaintiff exited her place of employment during an ongoing snowstorm, walked across the parking lot owned by the Defendant and went to her vehicle. The Plaintiff then moved her vehicle closer to her place of business by parking at the curb. When the Plaintiff then exited her vehicle again at that point, she slipped and fell on the snow and/or ice that had accumulated near the curb.

The Plaintiff alleged injuries as a result and attributed the incident to the Defendant’s failure to fully remove snow and ice from the premises. The Plaintiff sued both the landowner and a snow removal contractor.

In its decision, the court reviewed the current status of the hills and ridges doctrine in Pennsylvania. The court also cited to the case of Collins v. Phila. Suburban Dev. Corp., 179 A.3d 69, 75 (Pa. Super. 2018), for the proposition that a landowner has no obligation to address any snow and ice on the premises “until a reasonable time after the winter storm has ended.”

The court in this case, again relying on the Collins decision, ruled that a period of approximately six (6) hours (or overnight) does not constitute an unreasonable passage of time concerning a landowner’s failure to remove ice and snow, particularly when a winter storm is ongoing during that period.

The court emphasized that the record in this case demonstrated that the site of the incident experienced severe winter weather conditions before, during, and after the subject slip and fall incident. The Plaintiff noted that she had observed the Defendant snow removal contractor plowing the lot approximately one hour before her fall. The court stated that this plowing activity fell within the six hour to overnight window established in the Collins case.

The court also noted that photographs of the parking lot which were taken by the Plaintiff immediately after the fall demonstrated that the lot was actively being cleared throughout the day. There was also a continued snow fall thereafter.

The court also found here that the Plaintiff did not present evidence to show that snow and ice has unreasonably accumulated to such a degree as to unreasonably obstruct travel so as to satisfy the elements of the Hills and Ridges Doctrine, or that an unreasonable time has passed after the end of a storm. 

Consequently, the Plaintiff was unable to prove the breach of duty element essential to this negligent claim. Accordingly, the Plaintiff was not able to sustain a negligence claim and the court therefore entered summary judgment in favor of the Defendants.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Joseph Hudock of the Pittsburgh office of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Rauch, P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Annie Niemaszyk on www.unsplash.com.


Monday, December 30, 2024

THE 2024 TORT TALK TOP TEN


THE 2024 TORT TALK TOP TEN


10.  Waiting On Supreme Court Decision Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens


Civil litigators are awaiting a decision from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court relative to the application of the doctrine of forum non conveniens in the case of Tranter v. Z & D Tour, Inc., 303 A.3d 1070 (Pa. Super. 2023) appeal granted 367 EAL 2023 (Pa. 2024). 


At the Superior Court level, that Court had ruled Defendant did not demonstrate sufficient grounds to support the request for a transfer of venue under doctrine of forum non conveniens in an effort to move the case out of Philadelphia County.  The Court ruled, in part, that the affidavits provided by the defense from witnesses regarding whether or not Philadelphia County was an oppressive or vexatious venue from the perspective of those witnesses were not specific enough.


The primary issue for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to decide is whether the Superior Court misapplied Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens.


The Tort Talk post on the Superior Court’s decision in this case can be reviewed at this LINK.



9.  Supreme Court Addresses Business Interruption Coverage in Context of Covid-19 Shutdown


In the case of Ungarean v. CNA, No. 12 WAP 2023 (Pa. Sept. 26, 2024) (Op. by Brobson, J.), the court addressed issues regarding business interruption coverage in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.


This case involved a class action that was led by a dental practice which had purchased a commercial property insurance policy from an insurance company, which policy was intended to cover business-related losses.


After the court mandated closures as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the insured filed a claim under the policy, which was denied by the insurance company on the grounds that there was no physical damage to the property.


The trial court had granted summary judgment in favor of the insureds. The trial court had interpreted the policy language to include loss of use of the property as a form of “direct physical loss.”


That trial court decision was affirmed by the Superior Court who also found the policy language at issue was ambiguous and should be construed in favor of the insured.


However, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed the Superior Court’s decision.


The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that the policy language was unambiguous and required a physical alteration to the insured’s property for the coverage to apply.


The court ruled that the economic losses sustained by the insured due to the government shutdown did not meet this requirement.


As such, the Supreme Court ruled that the insured was not entitled to coverage under the policy. The case was remanded to the Superior Court with instructions for summary judgment to be entered in favor of the insurance company.


The Tort Talk post on this case can be viewed at this LINK.



8. Plaintiff Can Secure Both Punitive Damages and Treble Damages in the Same Case Punitive and Treble Damages


In the case of Dwyer v. Ameriprise Financial, No. 2 WAP 2023 (Pa. April 25, 2024), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a trial court may, under the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL), award both punitive damages and treble damages.


This case involved Plaintiffs who sued Ameriprise Financial for negligent and fraudulent misrepresentation relative to a life insurance policy. The Plaintiffs alleged that the carrier misrepresented to them that their quarterly premium payments would remain the same for the life of the policy. In reality, if the Plaintiff’s premium payment had remained the same, the policy would have allegedly lapsed for insufficient funds in 2020.


The Supreme Court held that treble damages under the UTPCPL are a separate remedy available to the Plaintiffs and must be considered by the trial court without regard to a separate punitive damages award that may be issued on related common law claims.  The Pennsylvania Supreme Court noted that nullifying the availability of a statutory award because of a common law award was not a permissible exercise of discretion by the trial court.


The Tort Talk Blog post on this case, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed at this LINK.



7. Plaintiff Must Answer Questions at IME or DME


In the Monroe County case of Nelson v. Wilkins, No. 1381-CV-2022 (C.P. Monroe Co. Jan. 26, 2024 C. Daniel Higgins, Jr., J.) from earlier this year, the court granted a defendant’s Motion to Compel a plaintiff to provide information to the IME doctor during an independent medical examination of a plaintiff in a case arising out of a motor vehicle accident.


According to the decision, the plaintiff had appeared for an examination but refused to answer the IME doctor’s questions, asserting that the questions were allegedly outside the scope of Pa. R.C.P. 4010 about the occurrence of the accident that led to the plaintiff’s alleged injuries.


Judge C. Daniel Higgins, Jr. of Monroe County noted that Rule 4010 provides that the examiner is limited to inquiring into matters regarding the facts of liability that were germane to the issue of damages.  Rule 4010 itself provides that “[t]he examiner's oral interrogation of the person to be examined shall be limited to matters specifically relevant to the scope of the examination.”  See Pa.R.C.P. 4010(a)(4)(i).


The court found that the plaintiff’s attorney’s position that the IME doctor should not ask questions regarding the history of the accident that could relate to liability and the plaintiff’s argument that the doctor could avoid the problem by reviewing depositions, police reports, Interrogatories, and other discovery materials “was untenable” because it placed too high of a burden on the examining doctor.


In granting the defendant’s Motion to Compel in this regard, the Court ordered that the plaintiff was required to cooperate and answer the questions of the examining doctor.  The court noted that, as set forth under Rule 4010, the plaintiff could have her counsel or other representative present during the examination.


The Tort Talk Blog post, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed HERE.



6. Hills and Ridges Doctrine


Over the past year, one court addressed the issue of whether the Hills and Ridges Doctrine should be applied where a Plaintiff fell in an area that was covered by an awning or a canopy.


In the case of Johnson v. Harris-Dent, No. 23-00,097 (C.P. Lyc. Co. July 8, 2024 Linhardt, J.), Judge Eric R. Linhardt denied a Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case that occurred when the plaintiff allegedly slipped on alleged black ice that was allegedly located on the top step of a homeowner's porch that was covered by an awning.


In this case, the Plaintiff had cited to the case of Heasley v. Carter Lumber, 843 A.2d 1274 (Pa. Super. 2004) for the proposition that the Hills and Ridges Doctrine is not applicable where the incident occurred in an area that was covered by a roof or awning.  In the Heasley case, the plaintiff’s slip and fall occurred while the Plaintiff was walking in a shed that had three walls, with the fourth side open.  The shed had an overhead roof with an awning extending from it. In that case, the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that the Hills and Ridges Doctrine did not apply to a fall occurring inside an outdoor storage shed. 


The Court in Heasley reasoned that the Hills and Ridges Doctrine was intended to protect property owners from an undue burden of ensuring that open spaces such as sidewalks and parking lots are constantly kept clear of snow and ice.  The court found that the defendant did not present anything that demonstrated that keeping a structure, which is only partially open to the elements, free of snow and ice presented any burden at all, let alone an undue burden on its owners. The Heasley court also indicated that the extension of the Hills and Ridges doctrine to structures and/or other partially opened areas would raise many difficult questions. As such, the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the Heasley case declined to extend the application of the Hills and Ridges Doctrine to an incident that occurred in a structure covered by a roof and/or an awning.


Judge Linhardt applied the rationale of the Heasley case to this Johnson case in which the plaintiff alleged that he fell on black ice on the top step of the Defendant’s covered porch which step was allegedly covered by an awning. Judge Linhardt noted that, under the current status of Pennsylvania law, if that allegation was proven, then it appeared that the Hills and Ridges Doctrine would not be applicable to this litigation. The court therefore found that genuine issues of material fact must be resolved by the jury in this regard and, as such, the Defendant’sMotion for Summary Judgment was denied.


The Tort Talk Blog post on this case, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed at this LINK.



5. Notable Decisions on Certificates of Merit in Med Mal Cases


There were a couple of decisions of note that came down over the past year regarding Certificates of Merit that are required in medical malpractice cases in Pennsylvania.


In the case of Rightmyer v. Philly Pregnancy Center, P.C., No. 23-1925 (E.D. Pa. March 1, 2024 Quinones Alejandro, J.), the court granted a defendant’s motion to dismiss after confirming that the Certificate of Merit requirements for medical malpractice claims under Pennsylvania state law also apply in federal court.  In this case, the court also ruled that a nurse is not qualified to execute a required Pennsylvania Certificate of Merit in a medical malpractice action against a medical doctor.


The Tort Talk Blog post, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed HERE.



In the separate case of Berk v. Rothman Institute Orthopedic Foundation, No. 23-1437 (E.D. Pa. March 28, 2024 Murphy, J.), the court addressed the extent to which a plaintiff could attempt to compel one of the plaintiff’s own doctors to write a Certificate of Merit to enable the plaintiff to pursue a claim against another medical provider.


The court in Berk granted the doctors' Motion to Dismiss after finding that treating physicians do not owe their patients any fiduciary duty to provide them with a Certificate of Merit that would allow the patient to sue other doctors for medical malpractice.  The rationale for this decision was, in part, the general rule that potential experts may not be compelled to issue expert opinions against their will.


The court otherwise found that there is no valid cause of action for an alleged intentional deprivation of legal recourse for an alleged injury.


The Tort Talk Blog post, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed at this LINK.



4. Use of Exhibits in Opening Statements


A common dispute at civil litigation trials is the extent to which one party or the other may utilize demonstrative exhibits during the course of Opening Statements.  Typically, trial court judges have punted on the issues and have stated that such exhibits would only be permitted during Opening Statements if the attorneys have agreed on the same.


In what appears to be the first Opinion of its kind, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed the issue of whether a party may utilize demonstrative exhibits during an Opening Statement in the case of Webb v. Scranton Quincy Hospital Company, LLC, No. 2021-CV-4073 (Lacka. Co. March 8, 2024 Nealon, J.).  In this decision, Judge Nealon provided a thorough analysis of the law applicable to the reference to admissible evidence during the course of an Opening Statement at a civil litigation trial.


In this medical malpractice case, the Plaintiff filed a Motion In Limine seeking leave of court to utilize admissible excerpts of videotaped depositions of unidentified defense witnesses during the course of the Opening Statement to be presented by Plaintiff’s counsel.


After reviewing the sparse law on the issue, Judge Nealon noted that the reference and showing of admissible evidence during the course of an Opening Statement can be permitted by a trial court judge under the broad discretionary powers of judges to run trials that occur before them.  


The court otherwise ordered the Plaintiff to identify which portions of what video deposition they intend to utilize during the course of the Opening Statement so that the opposing party could assert any reserved evidentiary objections to those excerpts so that any required rulings may be made prior to the Opening Statement.


The Tort Talk Blog post, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed LINK.



3. Service of Process


Over the past year, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court provided its latest guidance on the issue of proper and timely service of process in civil litigation matters.  In the case of Ferraro v. Patterson-Erie, No. 1 WAP 2023 (Pa. April 25, 2024), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed a statute of limitations argument related to service of process issues in a slip and fall case.


According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a slip and fall event.  The Plaintiff filed her Complaint within the two (2) year statute of limitations. However, the Plaintiff encountered difficulties with serving the Complaint on the Defendants due to issues with the Sheriff’s service and the COVID-19 pandemic.


The Plaintiff thereafter served the Complaint on the Defendant through a private process server. She later reinstated the Complaint and then served it through the Sheriff.  However, this service by the Sheriff occurred after the statute of limitations had elapsed.


The Defendants argued that the action was barred by the statute of limitations because the Plaintiff did not make a good faith effort to serve them in a timely manner.


On appeal to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the Court held that the Plaintiff had failed to meet her burden of demonstrating that she made a good faith effort in diligently and timely serving process on the Defendants.  Accordingly, the Supreme Court found that the Defendants’ informal receipt of actual notice was irrelevant.  In the end, the case was dismissed.


Check out Justice Wecht’s Dissenting Opinion in this case for an excellent overview on the current status of the law in Pennsylvania on the issue of proper service of process.


The Tort Talk Blog post on this case, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed at this LINK.



2. Regular Use Exclusion Upheld as Valid and Enforceable

At the start of the year, on January 29, 2024, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued its long-awaited, much anticipated decision in the Regular Use Exclusion case of Rush v. Erie Insurance Exchange, No. 77 MAP 2022 (Pa. Jan. 29, 2024)(Maj. Op. by Donohue, J.)(Concurring Op. by Wecht, J.).

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that, as presented in this case, the Regular Use Exclusion contained in motor vehicle insurance policies did not violate the express language of Pennsylvania's Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law [MVFRL].

The Plaintiff in Rush was a police officer who was injured in a motor vehicle accident while driving his police vehicle. The Plaintiff recovered the liability limits from the tortfeasor's policy and the UIM limits on the police vehicle.  The Plaintiff then sought to obtain additional recoveries from the Erie Insurance policies that covered his personal vehicles at home.  Erie Insurance relied upon a Regular Use Exclusion contained in the policy to deny coverage on the UIM claim.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed the lower courts' decisions and upheld the validity and enforceability of the Regular Use Exclusion.

In this Rush v. Erie Insurance Exchange case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court once again confirmed that it had previously clarified and narrowly limited its Gallagher decision in its decision in the case of Erie Insurance Exchange v. Mione.  In Mione, the Supreme Court had confirmed that the Household Exclusion remained valid and applicable except possibly in cases where the insured was attempting to stack coverage under 75 Pa.C.S.A. Section 1738.

The Supreme Court in Rush also specifically held that the Regular Use Exclusion remained a permissible limitation of UIM coverage within the language of the MVFRL and that, "[w]ith decades of reliance by insureds and insurers, and no justification to allow this Court to depart from decades of established law," the Court would maintain its continued course on this issue "unless and until the General Assembly or the Insurance Department acts in a way that would suggest we do otherwise." Ultimately, the Supreme Court overruled the lower court decisions and held that the Regular Use Exclusion remained valid and enforceable.

The Tort Talk Blog post on this case, which contains a link to this decision, can be viewed at this LINK.



1. The Use of AI to Draft Court Filings


Over the past year, the trending use of AI has apparently hit the legal field with attorneys utilizing AI to draft motions and briefs to be filed with the courts.  This has led to bar associations and courts in Pennsylvania taking steps to provide guidance on the proper and responsible use of AI in this regard. 

In May of this year, the Pennsylvania Bar Association and the Philadelphia Bar Association issued a Joint Formal Opinion providing advice on the use of Artificial Intelligence in the legal profession.  That Joint Formal Opinion can be viewed at this LINK.

The Opinion itself notes that it is an "advisory only" Opinion.  Generally speaking, the Opinion recommends that attorneys be aware of, and competent with, the use of AI in the legal profession.  The Opinion recommends that those in the legal profession check and confirm the veracity of all information generated through the use of AI, including citations to legal authority.  The Opinion also cautions that client confidentiality should be protected at all times.

In terms of steps being taken by the courts of Pennsylvania to monitor the use of AI with court filings, in the federal courts of Pennsylvania, Middle District Court Judge Karoline Mehalchick crafted and issued what appears to be the first Civil Practice Order on Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence to be issued in the Commonwealth. 


Under this Order, which can be viewed at this LINK, Judge Mehalchick ordered that if a party to any litigation pending before her has utilized AI in preparation of any filing, that filing must be accompanied with a Certificate of Use of Generative AI.

In that Certificate of Use of Generative AI, the party is required to disclose and certify the following information:

(1) The specific AI tool utilized

(2) Identification of the portions of the filing prepared by the AI program; and

(3) Certification that a person filing the document has checked the accuracy of any portion of the document generated by AI, including all citations and legal authority

In the Order, Judge Mehalchick cautioned that failure to comply with this Civil Practice Order could result in sanctions.

At the state court level, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has created an Advisory Committee on Artificial Intelligence.  That Committee was created to propose appropriate statewide rules to provide guidance to counsel on the use of AI with filings in the state court systems.



Source of above image: Photo by Sergei Starostin on www.pexels.com.


Friday, September 27, 2024

Corrected Link For Judge Nealon's Hills and Ridges Decision in White v. Nesbeth Case


Here is the corrected LINK for the case highlighted in the September 27, 2024 Tort Talk post on Judge Terrence R. Nealon's hills and ridges decision in the White v. Nesbeth case.

Apologies for any confusion or consternation caused by the incompleted Link in the original post.

Summary Judgment Granted in Lackawanna County Slip and Fall Case


In the case of White v. Nesbeth, No. 2022-CV-2147 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept. 17, 2024 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas granted summary judgment in favor of a Defendant homeowner under the hills and ridges doctrine in a slip and fall case.  The Opinion provides an excellent, thoroughly researched overview of the current status of the hills and ridges doctrine in Pennsylvania.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff, who was considered to be an invitee, and who was making a Door Dash delivery to the Defendants’ residence during an ongoing storm of “freezing rain and sleet,” allegedly slipped and fell on the homeowner’s sidewalk.

According to the record before the court, the Plaintiff’s deposition testimony acknowledged the existence of persistent freezing precipitation falling at the time of the incident. The Plaintiff additionally conceded that he did not observe or feel “any kind of an accumulation.” The Plaintiff additionally confirmed that he did not “notice anything” on the sidewalk.

After the completion of discovery, the Defendants filed a Motion for Summary Judgment relying upon the hills and ridges doctrine.

The Plaintiff responded by arguing that, since the landowner applied rock salt to the sidewalk approximately forty-five (45) minutes before the Plaintiff arrived, the hills and ridges doctrine was in applicable due to “human intervention” which allegedly altered the “natural accumulation” that was falling at the time.

In granting summary judgment, Judge Nealon noted that there was no dispute that general slippery conditions prevailed at the time of the incident as a result of a continuous winter event and precipitation.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County



Judge Nealon also emphasized that no party or witness had identified or specifically described the condition upon which the Plaintiff allegedly fell.

In his Opinion, Judge Nealon pointed to appellate case law holding that a landowner is not obligated to salt their sidewalk while winter precipitation remains in progress.  He also ruled that, in any event, since the record lacked any evidence that the application of rock salt somehow created a dangerous condition or increased the natural hazards of the existing ice, the hills and ridges doctrine still applied and governed the negligence claim presented.

Judge Nealon ultimately held that, even when the record is examined in the light most favorable to the Plaintiff as required by the applicable motion for summary judgment standard of review, the evidence presented was insufficient to establish a prima facie cause of action under the hills and ridges doctrine.

Accordingly, summary judgment was entered in favor of the homeowner.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.