Showing posts with label Zero Verdict. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Zero Verdict. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 16, 2025

Zero Verdict For Pain and Suffering Sent Back Down For a New Trial


In its non-precedential decision in the case of Banasiak v. Robinson, No. 2041 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Feb. 24, 2025 Olson, J., Dubow, J., and Lane, J.) (Op. by Olson, J.), the Superior Court sent a zero verdict case back down the appellate ladder for a new trial.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was run over by the Defendant’s truck and eventually had to have a leg amputated.

At trial, a jury awarded the Plaintiff his medical expenses but award zero for pain and suffering.

The appellate court ruled that the zero award for pain and suffering was against the weight of the evidence. The court also found that the zero award to the Plaintiff’s wife for loss of consortium was likewise against the weight of the evidence.

Here, the court confirmed that the Defendant did not offer any expert evidence contesting the causation of the Plaintiff’s injury. The Superior Court also reiterated the rule of law that a jury cannot disregard an obvious injury.

The court found that there was no reasonable basis for the jury to believe either that the Plaintiff did not suffer pain or that the Plaintiff's pain was not caused by the Defendant’s negligence.

As such, the case was remanded to the trial court for a new trial.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith office in Philadelphia for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, January 27, 2025

Superior Court Affirms Entry of Defense Verdict Even Though Defendant's Answer to Complaint Was Stricken Prior to Trial


In the case of Derbyshire v. Jefferson Frankford Hospital, No. 1409 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Dec. 20, 2024 Olson, J., Stabile, J. and Colins, J.) (Op. by Stabile, J.), the Superior Court found that a trial court judge did not commit any error in post-trial proceedings by denying a Plaintiff’s Motion for a New Trial limited to the issue of damages.

This matter arose out of a slip and fall event.

According to the Opinion, prior to the trial in the underlying matter, a motions court judge had stricken the Defendant’s Answer to the Complaint with prejudice due to untimeliness under Pa. R.C.P. 1029(b).

Later, another judge who presided over the trial, refused the Plaintiff’s request to direct the jury to find in the Plaintiff’s favor on the issues of negligence and causation and, instead, allowed these issues to go to the jury.

The jury then returned a verdict in favor of the Defendant on the issue of causation and awarded zero damages.

The Superior Court held that, while the Defendant’s failure to answer the Complaint resulted in a deemed admission of the facts alleged in the Plaintiff’s Complaint, at trial, the Plaintiff still had a burden to prove a legal causal connection between the Defendant’s alleged negligent conduct and the Plaintiff’s alleged damages. In its ruling, the Superior Court noted that, since the jury found the Defendant negligent, the Plaintiff suffered no prejudice from the trial court’s refusal to deem that issue admitted. The Superior Court therefore focused its attention on the issue of causation.

In ruling in the manner it did, the Superior Court found a 1984 decision from the Supreme Court of Texas to be persuasive. That court in Texas had concluded that a plaintiff who obtains a default judgment in a personal injury matter must still prove damages apart from the deemed admission of liability. 

Here, in this Derbyshire case, the court found that the striking of the Defendant’s Answer and New Matter resulted in a deemed admission of all facts but only an admission of “liability” by the Defendant. 

The Superior Court ruled that the Plaintiff still had to proceed to trial on the issue of damages and, in this regard, the Plaintiff had a burden to establish that the Defendant’s conduct caused the Plaintiff’s damages. 

As noted, in this case, the jury was not convinced that the Plaintiff’s alleged damages were related to the Defendant’s negligent conduct.

The Superior Court ruled that, based upon a review of the evidence in the record, it was within the jury’s prerogative to award zero damages.

Accordingly, the Superior Court ultimately ruled that the trial court did not err in denying the Plaintiff’s Post-Trial Motions seeking a new trial on damages.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 14, 2025).

Thursday, May 16, 2024

Issues Surrounding a Zero Verdict That Was Never Read Out Loud in Open Court


In the case of Shook v. Lehigh Valley Restaurant Group, Inc., No. 1861 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. April 4, 2024 Dubow, J., King, J., and Lane, J.) (Op. by Dubow, J.), the court reversed a trial court Order ordering a new trial on damages.

In this case, the Superior Court noted that the jury verdict in the trial below was never actually read out loud in open court before the trial court rejected the zero verdict returned by the jury.  According to the record from the trial court proceedings, the original zero verdict was never announced in court, the jury was not polled and the verdict was not properly recorded. 

As such, the Superior Court found that there was nothing for the trial court to reinstate. Accordingly, the Superior Court noted that a jury verdict that was never read out in open court is not a verdict that could be reinstated by the court.

In the end, the trial court’s ordering of a new trial was reversed and the trial court was instructed to review the issues presented on remand only if the Plaintiff actually preserved the same.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I thank Attorney James MBeck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, November 29, 2023

Defense Verdict Upheld Where Evidence Was Disputed On Whether Plaintiff Was Injured At All

In the non-precedential decision by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the case of Smith v. Nguyen, No. 1312 EDA 2022 (Pa. Super. March 28, 2023 Panella, J., Bender, P.J.E., and Sullivan, J.) (Op. by Sullivan, J.), the court affirmed a trial court’s denial of a Plaintiff’s post-trial motions seeking a new trial after a jury found that a Defendant driver did not cause injury to a Plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident case.

After reviewing the record before it, the appellate court found that the trial court did not err by failing to grant a new trial under an argument that the jury’s finding of no causation of any harm was against the weight of the evidence.

In so ruling, the Superior Cour noted that the jury’s finding of no liability on causation for the Plaintiff’s injuries confirmed that the jury had rejected the Plaintiff’s expert witness’ testimony.

The court noted that the Plaintiff’s experts and the Defendant’s experts disputed one another on the issue of causation.  

The court also noted that the fact that the defense radiologist expert did not dispute the Plaintiff’s “subjective” reports of pain resulting from the collision did not constitute an agreement by the defense expert that the collision caused injury.

The court otherwise found that the jury’s decision that the Defendant’s negligence did not cause harm to the Plaintiff could properly have been based upon the evidence that the collision occurred at a relatively low speed, that the Plaintiff had pre-existing similar problems and degenerative conditions and/or that the Plaintiff did not complain of neck pain until four (4) years after the collision.

Overall, the court found that the Plaintiff did not show that the trial court abused its discretion in finding that the jury’s verdict did not shock the judicial conscience given that the post-trial claim was found to lack merit, the trial court’s denial of the same was affirmed on appeal.

This decision is also notable for the court’s ruling that a party is not entitled to adverse inference related to the failure of an opposing party to call a witness at trial where that witness was equally available to each party to be called as a witness.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Paul Gambone of the King of Prussia office of the Forry Ullman law firm for bringing this decision to my attention.

Friday, September 29, 2023

Jury's Zero Verdict Upheld



In the case of Derry v. Blackman, No. 3:21-CV-01744 (M.D. Pa. June 30, 2023 Mehalchick, J.), the court ruled that a jury’s zero verdict in a conceded liability case was not against the weight of the evidence.

The court emphasized that the record in the case confirm that the existence, severity and alleged cause of the Plaintiff’s alleged injuries were all disputed.

Judge Mehalchick reiterated the rule of law that a jury is free to decide which side’s witnesses are credible.

The court also noted the general rule of law that, even if a jury found that a Plaintiff did actually suffer some pain or discomfort as a result of an accident, the jury could conclude that the injuries were not significant enough to warrant compensation.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Jury's Zero Verdict Upheld Even Though Defense Medical Expert Conceded Evidence of Alleged Injury


In the case of Derry v. Blackman, No. 3:21-CV-01744 (M.D. Pa. June 30, 2023 Mehalchick, Mag. J.), the court ruled that a jury’s zero verdict in a conceded liability case was not against the weight of the evidence.

In this matter, the Plaintiff filed a motion for a new trial.  The Federal Court addressed the motion under the standards set forth in F.R.C.P. 59.  Federal Magistrate Judge Karoline Mehalchick, who has been nominated to assume a position as a Federal Judge in the Middle District of Pennsylvania, wrote a thoroughly researched Opinion on the current status of Pennsylvania law regarding the validity of zero verdicts handed down by juries in Pennsylvania.

The court emphasized that the record in the case confirm that the existence, severity and alleged cause of the Plaintiff’s alleged injuries were all disputed.

Federal Magistrate Judge Mehalchick reiterated the rule of law that a jury is free to decide which side’s witnesses are credible.

The court also noted the general rule of law that, even if a jury found that a Plaintiff did actually suffer some pain or discomfort as a result of an accident, the jury could conclude that the injuries were not significant enough to warrant compensation.

In the end, the court found that the jury's verdict did not result in a miscarriage of justice and that the verdict did not cry out to be overturned as shocking the judicial conscience.   

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, May 25, 2023

New Trial Granted After Jury Awarded Zero Damages


In the case of Giko v. Calgiano, No. 1262 EDA 2022 (Pa. Super. March 29, 2023 Lazarus, J., Nichols, J., and McCaffery, J.) (Op. by Lazarus, J.) [non-precedential], the Pennsylvania Superior Court concluded that a jury’s award of $0 damages was against the weight of the evidence and, as such, the appellate court remanded the case for a new trial limited to damages.

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a rear-end motor vehicle accident.

At trial, the jury found that the Plaintiff had sustained injuries in the accident and that the Defendant was 75% liable. However, the jury awarded $0 in damages.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff declined treatment at the scene and proceeded to work. Later that day, however, the Plaintiff’s supervisor suggested that the Plaintiff leave work early and get treatment for complaints of neck and back pain.

The Plaintiff reported to an Urgent Care Center and was prescribed medication and advised to use ice and heat. Shortly thereafter, the Plaintiff began a course of physical therapy.

The Plaintiff also eventually underwent bilateral sacroiliac joint injections. She additionally had EMG and MRI testing for complaints of neck and back pain. The Plaintiff’s overall medical bills were noted to be in excess of $26,000.00.

Based upon the evidence in the record, the Superior Courtfound that the jury’s finding that the Plaintiff’s harm was not compensable was against the weight of the evidence. The court held that the award of $0 damages bore no reasonable relationship to the alleged losses suffered.

While the court recognized that not every injury results in compensable pain and that a jury may decline an award of compensation for pain and suffering if the jury determines that the discomfort suffered by the Plaintiff was the sort of “transient rub of life” for which compensation is not warranted, here, the court found that the record confirmed that the Plaintiff had indeed sustained pain and suffering and that the general proposition that victims of accidents must be compensated for all that they suffer from the tort of another warranted the granting of a new trial.

Accordingly, the Superior Court found that the jury’s award of $0 damages was against the weight of the evidence. As such, the court reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded the case for a new trial limited to damages only.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Dale G. Larrimore of the Philadelphia law firm of Larrimore & Farnish, LLP, for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, April 27, 2023

Zero Verdict For Pain and Suffering Damages Upheld


In the case of Wilson v. Hannigan, Aug. Term, 2022, No. 00196 (C.P. Phila. Co. Nov. 22, 2022 Alan, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion following a slip and fall case in which a jury found the parties to be equally liable and in which the jury granted the Plaintiff an economic damages award but no pain and suffering award.

The Court noted that, the Plaintiff was not able to advise the jury was to what caused her to fall on a sidewalk.  

Also, the medical evidence appeared to confirm that the Plaintiff may have sustained an ankle sprain for which she had minimal and conservative treatment.  The trial court judge also noted in his Opinion that, although the Plaintiff testified to the jury that she had walked with a limp at times, the jury was able to watch the Plaintiff walk to and from the witness stand.    

In requesting the Pennsylvania Superior Court to affirm its decision denying the Plaintiff’s Motion for a New Trial, the trial court found that the evidence was sufficient for the jury to decline to award the Plaintiff non-economic damages where the Plaintiff’s subjective complaints were inconsistent with the objective medical evidence presented.

The court also found that the Plaintiff’s treatment was excessive in relationship to the alleged severity of the injury.  The Plaintiff was also noted to have been non-compliant with her doctor's treatment recommendations.

The trial court also faulted the Plaintiff with respect to the number of issues raised on appeal in the Plaintiff’s Concise Statement of Matters Complained of on Appeal.  Given that the Plaintiff's Concise Statement was not concise, the trial court requested that the Superior Court find that the Plaintiff's alleged errors be deemed waived under Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b)(4)(vii).

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 14, 2023).


For review Tort Talk posts on Zero Verdict cases, as well as an article entitled "Litigating the Zero Verdict" by Daniel E. Cummins and Stephen T. Kopko, please click this LINK.

Thursday, February 10, 2022

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Issues With Zero Verdict For Pain and Suffering Claim


In the case of Fertig v. Horace Mann Ins. Co., No. 16-CV-4801 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 18, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part a Plaintiff’s Motion for Post-Trial Relief in a case involving an uninsured motorist claim against a carrier.

According to the Opinion, the jury in this UIM benefits trial rendered a verdict awarding the Plaintiff $75,000.00 for future medical expenses but $0 for past and future non-economic damages.

The jury entered this verdict even though the defense medical expert testified that the Plaintiff had unresolved injuries to her head, neck, and knee that were casually related to the accident. The court noted that the jury had been instructed, without objection, that it must award at least some damages for those uncontested injuries in this admitted liability case.  Nevertheless, the jury awarded $0 for pain and suffering.

After the verdict was molded to $0 to reflect the stipulated credit for the tortfeasor’s liability insurance coverage of $100,000.00, the Plaintiff filed a post-trial motion seeking a new trial on the issue of non-economic damages on the grounds that the verdict was against the weight of the uncontroverted medical evidence. The Plaintiff additionally requested an award of delay damages based upon the verdict of $75,000.00, that is, on the amount before the verdict was molded to zero.

The Defendant contended that the Plaintiff waived her right to secure a new trial by failing to object at the time the verdict was announced and by failing to request that the jury be sent back to resume its deliberations to correct a $0 verdict. The Defendant also asserted that the Plaintiff was not entitled to a new trial even if she did preserve her weight of the evidence challenge.

The defense additionally asserted that the Plaintiff cannot recover delay damages on a verdict that was molded to $0.

In addressing whether or not the Plaintiff had waived any arguments against the $0 verdict, the court cited, in part, to the article entitled “Litigating the Zero Verdict,” written by Daniel E. Cummins and Stephen T. Kopko which appeared in the Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine for the proposition that one option a party has in a case involving a $0 verdict is to request the court to send the jury back out to deliberate further in an effort to avoid any post-trial issues that may be created by the entry of that $0 verdict.  However, as noted below, where a claim is made that a verdict was against the weight of the evidence, it is not required that such a request be made for the issue to be preserved.

The court in this case emphasized that the Plaintiff was asserting that the jury’s award was contrary to the weight of the evidence and shocked one’s sense of justice. The court noted that, where a party has asserted a weight of the evidence challenge, an objection filed of record before the jury is discharged is not required in order to preserve the issue for review during post-trial motions.

The court found that, since a verdict must bear some reasonable relation to the harm suffered as demonstrated by the uncontroverted medical evidence, and given that an award of $0 for past and future non-economic damages was found to be so disproportionate to the uncontested medical evidence so as to the defy common sense and logic, the court granted the Plaintiff’s request for a new trial non-economic damages.

On the issue of delay damages, Judge Nealon ruled that, given that delay damages under Rule 238 are to be calculated based upon a molded verdict, and given that the verdict in this case was molded to $0 following the stipulated offset for the liability insurance coverage limit, the Plaintiff was not entitled to any delay damages under Rule 238 and that, as such, this request was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


If you wish to read the article entitled “Litigating the Zero Verdict,” written by Daniel E. Cummins and Stephen T. Kopko which appeared in the Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine please click HERE.

Source of image: Photo by TBS 44 on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, September 21, 2021

Post-Trial Motions Denied in Zero Verdict Personal Injury Case


In the case of Kim v. Weishaupt, No. 2018-C-1698 (C.P. Lehigh Co. Jan. 11, 2021 Johnston, J.), the court denied a Plaintiff’s post-trial motions after a defense verdict in a rear-end motor vehicle accident litigation.

According to the Opinion, at trial, the Defendant stipulated to negligence but denied causing the injuries and damages alleged by the Plaintiff. The jury returned a verdict in favor of the Defendant.

The Plaintiff filed post-trial motions asserting that he was entitled to either a new trial or judgment notwithstanding the verdict. The Plaintiff claimed that the weight of the evidence overwhelmingly established that the Defendant’s negligence caused the Plaintiff’s injuries.

After reviewing the applicable standard of review, the court noted that, a jury was entitled to believe some, all, or none of the evidence presented. The court additionally noted that, if the jury did not believe the expert testimony presented at trial, it was free to disregard such testimony. The court noted that “[f]or example, the experts base their opinions, in part, on subjective information provided by Plaintiff and, if the jury does not find Plaintiff credible, the jury is free to disregard the expert testimony.” See Op. at p. 3.

The court also noted that a jury was not obligated to resolve the question of causation in the Plaintiff’s favor simply because a Defendant had stipulated to liability. 

The court reviewed the evidence presented and stated that the jury’s decision had a reasonable relationship to the evidence presented and did not shock the judicial conscience. 

 The court otherwise noted that there was contradictory evidence regarding the existence and the cause of the Plaintiff’s injuries, which also served to support the jury's verdict.

As noted, the Plaintiff’s post-trial motions were denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 24, 2021).


Source of image:  Photo by Bernard Hermant on Unsplash.com.

Friday, June 4, 2021

Pennsylvania Superior Court Affirms Granting of New Trial in Zero Award for Pain and Suffering Where Medical Expenses Awarded




In the case of Mazzie v. Lehigh Valley Hospital-Muhlenberg, No. 473 EDA 2020 (Pa. Super. April 16, 2021 Kunselman, J., Nichols, J., and Pellegrini, J.) (Op. by Nichols, J.), the court ruled that a trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting a Plaintiff a new trial limited to damages in her medical malpractice action after finding that the liability issues were fairly determined and were not intertwined with the damages issues.

The case arose out of a medical malpractice action following a laparoscopic surgery to repair multiple hernias. After the surgery, the Plaintiff allegedly suffered septic shock and required additional surgeries and treatment to safe her life.

The appellate court also found that the trial court had correctly granted the Plaintiff a new trial on damages for pain and suffering even though the jury entered a verdict for $0 on the Plaintiff’s non-economic damages claims. The court found that there was significant testimony and evidence to confirm the Plaintiff’s alleged pain and suffering to the point that the Plaintiff almost died following the treatment.

In another notable part of this opinion, the Court reviewed the validity of an expert's opinion where the expert did not use the words "to a reasonable degree of medical certainty" during his or her testimony.  The Court found that, viewing the expert's testimony as a whole, the testimony was sufficiently certain even though the magic words were not used.    

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 4, 2021).


Thursday, December 3, 2020

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Addresses Standards for Survival and Wrongful Death Claims



In the case of McMichael v. McMichael, No. 50 and 51 WAP 2019 (Pa. Nov. 18, 2020 Todd. J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether a trial court abused its discretion in denying a Motion for a New Trial following a jury award of $0 in damages on one of the elements of damages in a wrongful death action. 

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs entered in a lease with a Defendant under which the Defendant was to install a natural gas pipeline on the Plaintiff’s property. The lease required that Defendant to hire a company owned by the Plaintiff to perform tree clearing on the property in preparation for the installation of the pipeline.

That landscaping company hired the Plaintiff’s nephew and others to perform the work. While the nephew/decedent was supervising the tree clearing process, he was struck by a tree and fatally injured.

A lawsuit was filed and the case proceeded to trial. The jury ultimately awarded the decedent’s estate $225,000.00 in survival damages, which was reduced to $135,000.00 to reflect the jury’s finding that the decedent was 40% negligent. The court awarded $0 on the wrongful death claim.

Upon review, the Pennsylvania Superior Court concluded that the trial court had erred in denying a new trial with respect to the non-economic damages award. The case was remanded for a new trial limited to the issue of non-economic damages to be potentially awarded to the Plaintiff.

In its decision, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court provides a nice distinction between survival damages and wrongful death damages.

With regards to the jury’s verdict of $0 in damages for the wrongful death claim, the court noted that it was undisputed that the Plaintiff did not present any evidence of medical, funeral, or estate administrative expenses. The court noted that the Plaintiff’s potential recovery in this regard was therefore limited to the loss of the decedent’s services. The court noted that the Plaintiff had produced evidence in this regard in terms of how the decedent performed home repairs, mowed the lawn, did most of the cooking, and drove his wife to work when the weather was bad. 

It was noted, however, that neither the wife nor any economic expert retained, testified as to an estimate as to the value of these contributions or services, or the cost of hiring somebody else to perform these tasks. 

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court noted that, in the absence of any evidence as to the economic value of these contributions, the jury would have been forced to engage in speculation regarding the value of these services. 

As such, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed with the trial court’s denial of any new trial for any economic damages. 

However, as noted, the request for a new trial with respect to the non-economic damages relative to the wife’s loss of her husband of thirty (30) years was granted.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority decision may click this LINK.


Justice Mundy's Concurring and Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.

Justice Dougherty's Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE

Wednesday, October 21, 2020

Verdict For Past Medical Expenses But Not For Pain and Suffering Overturned By Trial Court



In the decision of Mazzie v. Lehigh Valley Hospital-Muhlenberg, No. 2016-C-2523 (C.P. Lehigh Co. Dec. 31, 2019 Varricchio, J.), handed down at the end of last year, the court ruled that the Plaintiffs were entitled to a new trial limited to damages in this medical malpractice case where the jury awarded the Plaintiffs $39,000.00 for past medical expenses but $0 damages for pain and suffering, future medical expenses, and loss of consortium. 

The court ruled that this verdict shocked the court’s conscience such that the court granted the Plaintiffs’ Motion for a New Trial.

According to the Opinion, the case arose out of an alleged medical malpractice related to a surgical procedure. 

The court in this matter cited to the case of Davis v. Mullen, in which that court ruled that a jury’s award of medical expenses without compensation for pain and suffering should not be disturbed where the trial court had a reasonable basis to believe that the jury did not believe that the Plaintiff suffered any pain and suffering or that a pre-existing condition or injury was the sole cause of the alleged pain and suffering. 

In contrast, the court in the Mazzie found that there was no reasonable basis to believe that the Plaintiff did not suffer any pain as a result of the alleged malpractice. The court also found that there was no reasonable basis to believe that a pre-existing condition or injury was the sole cause of the Plaintiff’s alleged pain and suffering. 

As such, the trial court granted a new trial limited to the issue of damages. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 25, 2020).



Tuesday, January 28, 2020

Pennsylvania Superior Court Provides Guidance to Trial Courts on What To Do (And What Not To Do) if Jury Returns a Zero Verdict



In the case of Avery v. Cercone, 2019 Pa. Super. 366 (Pa. Super. Dec. 23, 2019 Kunselman, J., Bender, J., and Musmanno, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the court reversed in part and vacated in part the lower court’s decision on the Plaintiff’s post-trial motions in a case in which the jury awarded damages for economic damages but zero dollars for the Plaintiff’s pain and suffering claim. 

The court reaffirmed the rule of law that a jury is always free to award zero dollars on a pain and suffering claim. However the court noted that, in some instances, such a verdict can be against the weight of the evidence, particular where the injury is not contested by the defense. 

The appellate court noted that the trial court erred by providing an additional jury instruction suggesting that the weight of the evidence did not support the jury’s initial verdict. Providing the jury with such an instruction invades the province of the jury. 

The Superior Court held that the trial court should have let the verdict stand and left it to the Plaintiff to file post-trial motions to challenge the verdict as being against the weight of the evidence. 

 As such, the revised verdict was found to be in error and was vacated. The case was remanded back to the trial court to determine whether the verdict was indeed against the weight of the evidence under the “shocks the judicial conscience” standard. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Jury Comes Back with $20,000 Verdict After First Handing Down Zero Verdict




Here is a case that highlights the uncertainty associated with sending a jury back out to deliberate further after they have entered a zero ($0) in an admitted liability case.

In the case of Vella v. Hopkins, No. 16-S-1314 (C.P. Adams Co. Aug. 12, 2019 Campbell, J.), the court denied a Plaintiff’s Motion for a New Trial after finding that the jury did not ignore the court’s jury instructions and that the verdict was not against the weight of the evidence.

This matter arose out of a motor vehicle accident. At trial, the Defendant admitted liability such that the only issue at trial was on damages. The court also noted that, although medical experts for both the Plaintiff and the Defendant agreed that the Plaintiff had sustained some level of injury, the experts disagreed on the extent of injury.

The jury initially returned a verdict of zero ($0) for all damages alleged.

The court ordered the jury to return to its deliberations because the parties had stipulated that the Defendant was at fault for causing the accident and, in the eyes of the court, the jury had to award at least some damages.

After a further short deliberation, the jury returned with a verdict in favor of the Plaintiff for Twenty Thousand Dollars ($20,000.00). The verdict included damages for past, present, and future pain and suffering but did not provide any award for loss of earning capacity or disfigurement.

In a post-trial motion, the Plaintiff sought a new trial on damages under an argument that the jury had ignored the court’s instructions and that the final verdict was so low that it was against the weight of the evidence. The Plaintiff argued, in part, that the jury did not carefully consider damages the second time around during deliberations because it spent no more than fifteen (15) minutes before returning with its $20,000.00 verdict.

The court held that the length of time that the jury spent deliberating did not serve to nullify the award. The trial court also noted that it had polled the jurors after they returned from their final deliberations and that the required number of jurors were in agreement regarding the amount of damages.

The court otherwise found that the verdict did not shock one’s sense of justice and, therefore, the Plaintiffs claim that it was entitled to a new trial based upon the weight of the evidence was rejected. The court found that the verdict had a reasonable relationship to the evidence presented, particularly where the experts differed on the extent of injury.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


To review an article on the law of litigating a zero verdict, please click HERE.




Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Zero Verdict for Pain and Suffering Upheld Even Though Medical Expenses Awarded



In the case of Rabuh v. Hoobrajh, No. 3:17-CV-15 (W.D. Pa. Sept. 19, 2019 Gibson, J.), the court affirmed a verdict in favor of the Plaintiff in which a jury did not enter an award to the Plaintiff for pain and suffering damages even though it awarded medical expenses.

The court in Rabuh confirmed that a jury need not award pain and suffering damages every time it awards medical expenses. Rather, a jury, under Pennsylvania law, is free to reject the Plaintiff’s testimony on pain and suffering as a credibility determination.

The record before the court confirms that there were both credibility problems for the Plaintiff and also that the Plaintiff had a pre-existing condition that was put into evidence.

This decision is also notable in that the court denied an untimely Motion for Delay Damages after applying the ten (10) day deadline for such motions under Pa. R.C.P. 238.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, September 6, 2019

ARTICLE: "Litigating the Zero Verdict" by Daniel E. Cummins and Stephen T. Kopko


Here is a LINK to the Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine article written by Daniel E. Cummins and Stephen T. Kopko both of the Scranton insurance defense firm of Foley, Comerford & Cummins entitled "Litigating the Zero Verdict."

The article provides an overview of the propriety or impropriety of zero verdicts by juries under different circumstances in personal injury matters.  The article also reviews the variety of arguments that can be raised by both sides in support of either affirming or overturning such a verdict based upon the facts of the case.

We thank Patricia Graybill, the editor of the Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine for selecting this article for publication.

To review additional zero verdict cases here on Tort Talk, please click HERE.

Wednesday, February 13, 2019

New Trial Granted in Post-Koken UIM Zero Verdict Case


In the Post-Koken case of Singer v. State Farm Mut. Ins. Co., No. 2015-CV-2859 (C.P.  Lacka. Co. Jan. 24, 2019 Gibbons, J.), the court addressed a Plaintiff's post-trial motion for a new trial after the entry of a zero verdict by the jury.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had previously settled with the third party tortfeasor and this matter involved a jury trial on the Plaintiff's claims against the UIM carrier.  The Plaintiff asserted that the jury's verdict of $0 bore no rational relationship to the evidence produced at trial, and defied common sense and was shocking.

The court noted that liability was admitted in this rear end accident matter.  The court also noted that it was uncontested by both the Plaintiff's experts and the Defendant's experts that the Plaintiff had sustained a cervical sprain strain as a result of the accident.  The Plaintiff's experts additionally testified that this type of injury resulted in pain for the Plaintiff.  The Defense expert also agreed that this type of injury ordinarily takes six to twelve months to resolve.

The court reviewed other zero verdict cases and noted that under the law, a cervical sprain/strain injury is a type of objective injury that normally involves pain and suffering.  Without noting any of the other evidence that was presented at trial, the court in Singer concluded that, based on the experts' testimony, the jury had no reason to believe that [the Plaintiff] did not suffer pain.  The court also noted that there was no evidence that the Plaintiff had a pre-existing condition or injury prior to the accident which could have been a cause of his alleged pain.

As such, the court ruled that the jury's decision to disregard what the trial court judge viewed as the uncontested evidence of the Plaintiff's injury and to award zero damages for pain and suffering constituted, in the court's eyes a decision that bore no rational relationship to the evidence produced at trial.  Accordingly, the trial court judge found that the jury's verdict was contrary to the weight of the evidence.

The court therefore set aside the jury's verdict and awarded the Plaintiff a new trial.

Anyone wishing to review this Opinion may click this LINK.

Friday, January 25, 2019

Zero Verdict in Dog Bite Case Upheld on Appeal (Non-Precedential)


In a non-precedential decision issued by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the case of Anthony v. Rizzo, No. 1067 M.D.A. 2017 (Pa. Super. April 3, 2018 Bowes, J., Murray, J., and Blatt, J.) (Non-precedential Op. by Murray, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the trial court decision by the Honorable Lesa S. Gelb following an appeal from the judgement entered in favor of the Defendants after a jury awarded the Plaintiff $0 damages in this negligence cause of action arising out of an alleged dog bite by a poodle.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was employed as a house cleaner for the Defendants.   The Plaintiff had walked up to the Defendant’s car in which a poodle was located, unrestrained and in the rear seat with the windows opened.  As the Plaintiff approached the car, the dog “came into contact” with the Plaintiff’s right forearm. 

 The Opinion indicates that the Plaintiff was treated for what was described as a dog bite which involve an avulsion, or tearing of the skin, on the Plaintiff’s right forearm. The Plaintiff treated with her family doctor who cleaned the area, applied steri-strips, prescribed antibiotics, and administered a tetanus shot.    The Plaintiff had a follow-up visit with the family doctor one (1) month later at which point the Plaintiff's injury was noted to appear to be healing. The Plaintiff was not referred to any plastic surgeon to discuss any scarring-related issues.

As reflected on the verdict slip, the jury found that the Defendants were negligent and that the negligence of the Defendant was a factual cause of the Plaintiff’s harm.   However, the jury also attributed 50% of the causal negligence to the Plaintiff.  As for damages, the jury wrote down $0 on the verdict slip.  

The Plaintiff raised two (2) issues on appeal, first the Plaintiff asserted that the trial court committed an error in denying the Plaintiff’s Motion to Preclude a Verdict Slip Question and Jury Instruction on factual cause when it was not disputed that the Plaintiff had suffered some injury as a result of the accident.

The Plaintiff’s second issue was whether the trial court committed an error of law in denying the Plaintiff’s Motion for a new trial on damages since the jury’s verdict was so contrary to the evidence that it shocked one’s sense of justice.  

As to the first issue, the Superior Court stated that its review of the trial court’s jury instruction on factual cause revealed that that instruction was nearly identical to the Pennsylvania Standard Jury Instruction.   As such, the Superior Court found that the trial court provided an adequate instruction for factual cause to sufficiently guide the jury in its deliberation.   The Superior Court also noted that, even if an error had occurred in this regard, such error would be harmless because the jury found that the Defendant’s negligence was indeed a factual cause of the Plaintiff's harm in any event.  

 The appellate court also rejected the Plaintiff’s contention that the jury’s verdict was against the weight of the evidence.   Given that the appellate court agreed that the Plaintiff did not offer sufficient evidence in support of a claim for “compensable” pain, there was no need to overturn the decision below.   This was particularly so in this case where the Plaintiff had not presented any expert medical testimony about her alleged pain and suffering and where the Defendants asserted that the Plaintiff had suffered a mere scratch that represented a minor injury.  

As such, the Plaintiff’s appeal was denied and Judge Gelb’s decision below was affirmed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court. 

Anyone wishing to review this non-precedential decision by the Pennsylvania Superior Court, may click this LINK.

The trial court decision in this matter by Judge Lesa Gelb of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas may be viewed at this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Stephen T. Kopko of my office for bringing this decision to my attention. 

Wednesday, June 29, 2016

Zero Verdict Overturned by Superior Court (Non-Precedential)

In the non-precedential Memorandum decision in the case of Hernandez-Lerch v. Gray, No. 842 MDA 2015 (Pa. Super. May 17, 2016 Panella, Lazarus, Platt, J.J.)(Op. by Lazarus, J.), by Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that a trial court erred in denying the Plaintiff’s Motion for a New Trial on the issue on damages after the jury awarded an automobile accident Plaintiff damages for medical bills and wage loss but nothing for pain and suffering.  The court found that uncontested evidence of the Plaintiff’s injuries showed that she had suffered compensable pain that amounted to more than a mere transient rub of life.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged soft issue injuries along with wage losses and medical expenses.   The Superior Court noted that uncontested evidence revealed that the Plaintiff’s injuries were treated with an epidural steroid injection, physical therapy, along with the use of a TENS unit and a home traction unit.   The court reiterated that the evidence of the injury was uncontested and that the Plaintiff’s treating doctor and physician’s assistant offered testimony in records to substantiate the Plaintiff’s alleged injuries.  

More specifically, the court noted that the evidence showed that the Plaintiff suffered cervical and lumbar sprain and strain injuries with resultant pain, along with an aggravation of a pre-existing back injury.  The court also noted that the injuries took at least four (4) months to heal.  

Anyone wishing to read a copy of this decision online may click this LINK.

Source:  “Digest of Recent Opinions.”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 31, 2016).