Showing posts with label Invasion of Privacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Invasion of Privacy. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

Court Addresses Permissible Claims Where Employees Private Medical Information is Improperly Accessed or Disclosed


In the case of S.S. v. Thomas Jefferson Univ., No. 2024-CV-5812 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept. 29, 2026 Nealon, J.), the court addressed various Preliminary Objections filed in an employee medical-privacy suit filed against a hospital system.

According to the Opinion, this lawsuit the Plaintiff alleged that a Pennsylvania healthcare system allowed employees’ sensitive medical information to be improperly accessed and disclosed.

In addressing the Preliminary Objections by way of a detailed Order many pages in length, Judge Terrence R. Nealon overruled many of the Preliminary Objections, including those seeking the dismissal of the lawsuit.

The trial court ruled, in part, that the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act’s (HIPAA) lack of a private right of action does not necessarily foreclose state law negligence in privacy claims.

In the end, the court allowed several of the Plaintiff’s claims to move forward, including claims for invasion of privacy, civil conspiracy, and vicarious liability. The court found that the Complaint plausibly alleged that co-workers of the Plaintiff had improperly accessed and disseminated sensitive medical information through the health system’s computer networks.

In so ruling, it appeared that the trial court was attempting to follow a 2018 State Supreme Court ruling in the case of Dittman v. UPMC finding that employers have a duty to protect the private information of its employees.

The trial court otherwise rejected the defense argument that federal statute and state regulations preempted the field and provided no right of a private cause of action for an employer’s disclosure of an employee’s private health information. 

Rather, the court found that Pennsylvania law recognizes that an employer has a legal duty to exercise reasonable care to safe guard its employees’ sensitive personal information stored by the employer on an internet accessible computer system.

The court otherwise noted that the Plaintiff’s Complaint contained allegations suggesting that the employees may have been acting both inside and outside the scope of their employment, making it to early to determine whether the Defendants could be held vicariously liable.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


On November 5, 2026, the same trial Court issued an Order denying the Defendant's Motion For Reconsideration on the same issues.  That Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: Article – “Employee Medical – Privacy Suit Against Pa. Hospital System Moves Forward, Judge Rules,” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (Oct. 21, 2026).

Tuesday, October 28, 2025

Trial Court Dismisses Claim of Non-Trepassory Invasion Asserted Against a Defendant in a Fire Loss Case


In the case of Pursell v. DTB Services, LLC, No. 691-CV-2025 (C.P. Monroe Co. Sept. 22, 2025 C. Daniel Higgins, J.), the court sustained certain Preliminary Objections filed by a Defendant in a fire loss case.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant is a company that engages in the business of installing, servicing, and repairing gas fireplaces. The Plaintiffs are homeowners who utilized the Defendant’s services.

The Plaintiffs allege that the Defendants were negligent in providing inspection and repair work on the Plaintiff’s gas fireplace.

More specifically, the Plaintiffs alleged that the Defendant failed to inform the Plaintiffs that the outside vent to the fireplace was low-grade and dangerously close to combustibles. The Plaintiffs also allege that the Defendants did not recommend any urgent corrective action or that the fireplace should not be used.

Thereafter, a fire occurred. The Plaintiffs contended that the fire was the result of combustibles located near the venting system igniting.

In one of the Counts of their Complaint, the Plaintiffs alleged that the Defendants’ acts and/or omissions interfered with the Plaintiffs’ right of peaceful enjoyment of their real property. The Plaintiffs otherwise alleged in that Count that the Defendant committed a non-trespassory invasion of the Plaintiffs’ property by way of the Defendants’ negligent conduct and that the invasion caused the fire. The Defendants filed a Preliminary Objection to this Count asserting that the Plaintiffs failed to plead any facts that could be considered to be an invasion of their privacy.

The court noted that a claim for interference with the right of peaceful enjoyment of one’s real property is based on the private nuisance doctrine. The court noted that this doctrine is governed under Pennsylvania law by §822 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts.

The court noted that, under §822l, liability exists in this regard only if the contested “conduct is the legal cause of an invasion of another’s interests in the private use and enjoyment of any land.” Under the law, such an invasion must be either intentional and unreasonable, or unintentional and otherwise actionable under the rules controlling liability for negligent or reckless conduct, or for abnormally dangerous conditions and activities.

The court noted that an “invasion” in this context has been identified under the law as occurring when a Plaintiff’s property interests have been encroached by something that has come onto the property against the Plaintiff’s will.

Here, the court found that the Plaintiff did not assert any facts that would allow for a jury to presume that the Plaintiff did not voluntarily use Defendant’s services and invite them onto to their property for the inspection and/or maintenance of their fireplace.

Accordingly, the court found that, regardless of whether or not the Defendant’s actions at the Plaintiffs’ home were the cause of the fire, such actions did not constitute an invasion as that term is identified by the law. Accordingly, the court sustained the Defendant’s demurrer to this Count of the Plaintiffs’ Complaint.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Richard (Ricky) E. Santee, Esquire of the Bethlehem, PA law firm of Shay, Santee, Kelhart & Deschler, LLC for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, December 2, 2019

Case of First Impression Decided by Judge Nealon on Medical Marijuana Issue in Civil Litigation Context



Addressing a case of first impression in the case of Palmiter v. Commonwealth Health Systems, Inc., No. 19-CV-1315 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 22, 2019 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon reviewed Preliminary Objections filed by employers in this employment litigation raising a novel issue that has not yet been addressed by any state or federal court in Pennsylvania, that being the question of whether §2103(b)(1) of the Medical Marijuana Act (“MMA”), 35 Pa. S. §10231.2103(b)(1), which states that “[n]o employer may discharge… or otherwise discriminate or retaliate against an employee…solely on the basis of such employee’s status of an individual who is certified to use medical marijuana” creates a private cause of action for a medical assistant who was terminated by her health care employers for prescribed use of medical marijuana while not working in her place of employment.

The Defendants noted that the Department of Health has the exclusive authority to enforce the MMA’s provisions such that the employee’s sole remedy for her termination should be to seek the assessment of a civil penalty by the Department of Health.

After his review of the law, Judge Nealon held that there was nothing the MMA or any related regulations that vests the Department of Health, or any other state agency, with the authority to enforce the Act against private employers that have not chosen to voluntarily take part in the program.

The court also noted that the anti-discrimination provisions in the act would be rendered meaningless if an aggrieved employee could not pursue a private cause of action and seek to recover compensatory damages from an employer that violates the MMA.

As such, the court recognized an implied right of action under the act and, therefore, denied the employers’ demurrer to the employee’s private cause of action based upon §2103(b)(1).

In other decisions of note in this case, Judge Nealon did sustain demurrers to claims for invasion of privacy/intrusion on seclusion based upon the employee’s contention that her employers discovered the identity of her treating physician from their review of her medical records.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.