Showing posts with label Jurisdiction By Registration in PA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jurisdiction By Registration in PA. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 25, 2026

Pennsylvania District Court Finds Jurisdiction Over Out-of-State Manufacturer Under Consent-by-Registration Statute

 In the case of Blade v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 2:25-CV-06645-MAK (E.D. Pa. March 5, 2026 Kearney, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court ruled that a lawsuit against Sig Sauer, a gun manufacturer, would remain in Pennsylvania in light of the U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 decision in the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway which provided the court with jurisdiction over this out-of-state company.

According to the Opinion, the gun manufacturer had moved to dismiss the case based on an argument that the court lacked personal jurisdiction because Pennsylvania’s “consent-by-registration” statute allegedly violated the dormant commerce clause and was unconstitutional under the due process clause.

The Eastern District federal court rejected these arguments and ruled that, in light of the Mallory decision, the court had general personal jurisdiction over the lawsuit because the gun manufacturer had consented to such jurisdiction by registering to do business in Pennsylvania.

The court additionally ruled that Pennsylvania’s registration clause did not violate the due process or the dormant commerce clauses as applied to the Defendant.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article – “Gun Malfunction Litigation Will Remain in Pa., Thanks to Controversial US Supreme Court Jurisdiction Decision” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (March 11, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by Addy Mae on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, February 20, 2025

Federal Court Finds No Jurisdiction Over Insurance Company Existed Under Claims Asserted


In the case of Abira Medical Laboratories, LLC v. Freedom Life Insurance Co., No. 2:24-CV-02110-JHS (E.D. Pa. Jan. 10, 2025 Slomsky, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court of Pennsylvania, addressing a question of first impression, held that a Defendant foreign insurance company did not consent to general personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania to be sued by a private party on its own behalf for any cause of action simply based on the fact that the carrier obtained a Certificate of Authority issued pursuant to 40 Pa. C.S.A. § 46 in order to conduct business in Pennsylvania.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was a medical testing laboratory that provided testing services to the Defendant insurance company’s insured members as an out-of-network provider.

When the Plaintiff had a billing dispute with the insurance company regarding services performed, the Plaintiff sued the Defendant in a Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas.

The Defendant carrier removed the action to federal court on the basis of diversity and then filed this Motion to Dismiss. The Defendant carrier asserted, in part, that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the insurance company.

The Plaintiff argued that the Defendant carrier had consented to general personal jurisdiction on any claim because the Defendant had applied for and received a Certificate of Authority to do insurance business in Pennsylvania pursuant to 40 Pa. C.S.A. § 46.

The court noted that the referenced statute did not provide for general jurisdiction over foreign insurance companies conducting business in Pennsylvania.

Rather, the court noted that, under the plain language of § 46 foreign insurance companies wishing to conduct business in Pennsylvania must obtain a Certificate of Authority from Pennsylvania’s Department of Insurance. The statute further provides that, upon obtaining a Certificate of Authority, § 46 allows for any action arising out of a violation of § 46 that is instituted by or on behalf of the insurance commissioner to be brought against the foreign insurance company in Pennsylvania.

Here, given that the current action was not commenced by the insurance commissioner arising out of a violation of § 46, but rather was an action brought by a private party, the grant of jurisdiction provided under § 46 over a foreign insurance company was not found not to be implicated.

The court also held that the Defendant insurance company had no otherwise consented to personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania.

Given that the court found that it lacked general personal jurisdiction, as well as specific personal jurisdiction over the Defendant insurance company, the court granted the carrier’s Motion to Dismiss.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Federal Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 30, 2025).
 



Tuesday, December 12, 2023

ARTICLE: A Mixed Bag: Plaintiffs and Defendants Score Victories in Law Changes in 2023

The below article of mine providing a year-end review of the notable cases and trends in Pennsylvania civil litigation law appeared in the December 7, 2023 edition of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly:


A Mixed Bag: Plaintiffs and Defendants Score Victories in Law Changes in 2023

Pennsylvania Law Weekly
December 07, 2023

By Daniel E. Cummins

Daniel E. Cummins
Cummins Law
www.TortTalk.com


















Here’s a look at the notable trends and decisions in Pennsylvania civil litigation law over the past year along with a review of anticipated decisions to keep an eye out for in the year ahead.

Consent to Jurisdiction by Registration to Do Business

Over the past year, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court in the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway, ___ U.S.___ (June 27, 2023) in a 4-1-4 plurality decision involving the validity of Pennsylvania’s “consent by registration” statute.

In Mallory, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the Pennsylvania law requiring out-of-state companies that register to do business in Pennsylvania to agree to submit to jurisdiction in Pennsylvania courts on any cause of action filed against the company, even when the alleged injury occurred outside of Pennsylvania. The lower decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was vacated and remanded.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court thereafter punted on the issue under an order issued on Aug. 29, 2023, and remanded the question presented all the way back down to the trial court for consideration. Presently, the statute providing that a corporation’s registration to do business in Pennsylvania thereby subjects that corporation to Pennsylvania state court jurisdiction over personal injury lawsuits remains valid but subject to continuing attacks.

Test for Proper Venue Revised

Just last month the Pennsylvania Supreme Court continued its penchant for changing the law in a plaintiff-friendly way by revising the test for determining proper venue by rejecting the “percentage of revenue” venue defense.

In the case of Hangey v. Husqvarna, No. 14 EAP 2022 (Pa. Nov. 22, 2023), the court determined that venue was proper in Philadelphia County even though the only 0.005% of the defendant company’s national revenue was derived from that county. As such, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a defendant company’s percentage of sales is no longer sufficient, in and of itself, to determine whether or not a company has sufficient business in a particular jurisdiction for purposes of proper venue.

Accordingly, under yet another plaintiff-friendly decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, a business that only derives a small portion of its revenue from a particular county in Pennsylvania may still be sued in that county. This decision is expected to keep many more civil litigation matters in Philadelphia County.

The Dying Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens

Over the past year a number of decisions have been handed down by the trial and appellate courts of Pennsylvania that call into question the continuing vitality of the doctrine of forum non conveniens. These numerous decisions are thoroughly researched and reviewed by Judge Terrence R. Nealon in his recent opinion in the case of Brooks v. Griffy, No. 22-CV-3250 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Oct. 18, 2023 Nealon, J.).

While a plaintiff’s choice of forum for a particular lawsuit is given great weight under Pennsylvania law, a defendant does have avenues to challenge the same. One such way is by the filing of a motion to transfer venue under the doctrine of forum non conveniens under Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1).

Although the term forum non conveniens is Latin for “an inconvenient forum,” in order to prevail under such a motion to transfer, a defendant cannot simply show that the venue selected by the plaintiff is inconvenient, but rather must show that the forum vexatious and oppressive from the vantage point of the defendant and the involved witnesses.

In the case of Brooks v. Griffey, a plaintiff from Chester County, Pennsylvania, who was involved in an accident with a Lancaster County tractor-trailer driver in a Montgomery County accident, filed a lawsuit against the driver and his employer, which maintained its principal place of business in Idaho and had a single facility in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, in the Lackawanna County Common Pleas Court.

The defendant driver and his employer filed a forum non conveniens motion seeking to transfer the case to Montgomery County pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1006(d)(1).

In his opinion, Nealon addressed the current status of the law regarding this doctrine and noted that the law had been chipped away at by recent decisions calling into question the continued validity of the arguments made under this doctrine, especially in light of the need to show that the jurisdiction chosen by the plaintiff was oppressive and vexatious.

Notably, Nealon, who presides in what is still apparently the only county Court of Common Pleas in Pennsylvania with an innovative local rule on the use of advanced communications technology (ACT) in court proceedings, pointed to the continued use of ACT in litigation matters as lessening the burdens of the participants. The court noted that the use of ACT, such as Zoom for depositions and minor court conferences, has served to substantially lessen any hardships that may be associated with participating in any given litigation at any location.

Nealon noted that the affidavits in support of the petition filed by the defendant did not support the granting of the motion. The court found that the defendants had not established that the defendants chosen forum was oppressive or vexatious. As such, the defendant’s motion to transfer the case to Montgomery County based upon the doctrine of forum non conveniens was denied.

Social Host Liability

Over the past year, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court considered the extent to which a host of an event at which alcohol is served may be held liable for the actions of an intoxicated guest, particularly when that intoxicated guest is an employee of the host.

In the case of Klar v. Dairy Farmers of America, No. 29 WAP 2022 (Pa. Aug. 22, 2023 Wecht, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court revisited precedents from over a half of a century that have imposed civil liability arising from the provision of alcohol to visibly intoxicated persons with respect to persons and taverns licensed to engage in the commercial sale of alcohol, as compared against those same precedents that have limited the liability of social hosts.

In this Klar case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in a defense-friendly decision, affirmed the decisions of the lower courts that held that an organization hosting an event at which alcohol was provided, but which organization was not a liquor licensee, could not be held liable for injuries caused by a guest who had become intoxicated at the event and was later involved in a motor vehicle accident.

COVID Issues Persists

In 2023, the COVID-19 pandemic fallout continued in the form of ongoing insurance coverage litigation involving business interruption coverage policies, virus exclusions and related issues.

Over the summer, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued an order granting allocator to hear arguments in the case of MacMiles v. Erie Insurance Exchange, and the case of Ungarean v. CNA and Valley Forge Insurance. In these two cases, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reached opposite conclusions regarding whether insureds should be allowed business interruption insurance coverage for losses stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic.

For those handling COVID-19 business interruption coverage issues, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decisions in these matters is highly anticipated and will determine whether such claims for coverage are valid, thereby possibly ending the epidemic of these types of coverage cases.

Punitive Damages

In a pro-plaintiff decision in the case of Bert Co. v. Turk, No. 13 WAP 2022 (Pa. July 19, 2023), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court considered U.S. Supreme Court precedent in addressing the constitutionality of an award of punitive damages by a civil jury in Pennsylvania.

In the Bert case, the court reviewed the appropriate ratio calculation to be used by the courts to measure the relationship between the amount of punitive damages awarded against multiple defendants. The court declined to create a bright-line rule to determine when punitive damages are to be considered to be unconstitutionally excessive.

In this case, the jury had awarded $250,000 in compensatory damages as well as a total of $2.8 million dollars in punitive damages. The defendants asserted that this award went against U.S. Supreme Court precedent holding that punitive damages generally should not exceed 10 times the amount of a compensatory damages award.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court determined that the defendants’ approach was an incorrect calculation. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court generally endorsed the per-defendant analysis of the ratio, instead of a per-judgment analysis, as being consistent with federal constitutional principles that require consideration of each defendant’s due process rights relative to the entry of punitive damages. According to a July 24 article by Pennsylvania Law Weekly litigation reporter, Aleeza Furman, titled “‘Sky’s the Limit’: Pa. Justices’ Punitive Damages Rulings Creates Uncertainty for Defendants,” commentators on the plaintiffs side of the bar view this decision as upholding the goals of punitive damages. In contrast, members of the defense bar noted that this decision opened a new door for unrestrained punitive damages awards while, at the same time, limiting the types of challenges a defendant can assert against such an award.

Stacking Waiver Forms

In what was considered to be a case of first impression, in Franks v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance, No. 42 MAP 2022 (Pa. April 19, 2023) (Op. by Mundy, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a defense-favorable decision in holding that that the removal of a vehicle from a multiple motor vehicle insurance policy, in which stacked coverage had been previously waived through a waiver form executed by the insured, did not require the insurance carrier to secure a renewed expressed waiver of stacked coverage under Section 1738(c).

The basic rationale of the court was that Section 1738 requires insurance companies to secure a new written waiver of UIM coverage whenever an insurance policy is purchased. Here, there was a change made to an existing policy. No new policy was purchased. As such, according to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, there was no requirement under the law for the carrier to secure a new waiver form.
 
Household Exclusions

In the case of Erie Insurance Exchange v. Mione, No. 89 MAP 2021 (Pa. Feb. 15, 2023) (Op. by Wecht, J.), without admitting to the same, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court did an about face on the issue of the enforceability of household vehicle exclusions in automobile insurance policies. Whereas the Pennsylvania Supreme Court previously ruled in its decision of Gallagher v. GEICO that household exclusions are unenforceable across the board, in this more recent Mione decision from earlier this year, the court has now held that household exclusions do remain enforceable under Pennsylvania law in certain circumstances.

In its previous 2019 decision in the case of Gallagher, which was repeatedly described in the Law Weekly as resulting in a ‘seismic” change in the law, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court wrote “we hold that the household vehicle exclusion violates the MVFRL; therefore, these exclusions are unenforceable as a matter of law.” See Gallagher v. GEICO, 201 A.3d 131, 138 (2019). That unfortunate and flawed decision led to an unnecessary four years of upheaval and expensive litigation in this area of the law.

Although the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the previous case of Gallagher v. Geico, and again in the case of Donovan v. State Farm, attempted to eradicate the household exclusion across the board, in this decision of Erie Insurance Exchange v. Mione, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court did an about face and distinguished and limited its previous decision in Gallagher v. GEICO and instead affirmed the lower court decision that the household exclusion was valid and enforceable.

In this Mione decision, Justice David Wecht noted that the court “reiterates today that the holding in Gallagher was based upon the unique facts before the court in that case, and that the decision there should be construed narrowly.”
 
Service of Process

There were many decisions handed down over the past year by trial and appellate court judges confirming that a case will be dismissed if a plaintiff does not make good faith efforts to complete service of original process on the actual defendant in the matter in accordance with the case of Lamp v. Heyman and its progeny. To access a number of these decisions as summarized on the Tort Talk Blog (www.TortTalk.com), use this link: https://rb.gy/4t5nrk.

Statutory Caps

In the case of Freilich v. SEPTA, No. 327 C.D. 2022 (Pa. Cmwlth. July 6, 2023) [opinion not reported], the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court rejected a plaintiff’s challenge to Pennsylvania’s liability caps for state agencies, such as SEPTA and PennDOT. In so ruling, the appellate court upheld a trial court order reducing a $7 million stipulated jury verdict entered by a jury against SEPTA to the $250,000.00 statutory liability cap required by Pennsylvania law under 42 Pa.C.S.A. Section 8528(b).

Indications are that plaintiffs’ attorney plans to appeal the case up to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. It remains to be seen whether the Plaintiff-oriented Pennsylvania Supreme Court will continue its judicial activism in favor of plaintiff’s causes by changing the established law or will instead make a rare showing of judicial restraint and hold that any changes to this law should come from the legislative branch of the Pennsylvania government.

Fair Share Act

Trial courts continue to split on the validity and enforceability of the dicta in the decision of Spencer v. Johnson, 249 A.3d 529 (Pa.Super. 2021), which decision contains superfluous commentary indicating that the Fair Share Act may not apply in cases where the plaintiff is an innocent victim of an accident and not contributorily negligent. This issue can routinely come into play, for example, in medical malpractice cases where a plaintiff is under anesthesia or where a plaintiff is a guest passenger in a motor vehicle that is in an accident.

This past year, in the case of Ace v. Ace, No. 6242-CIVIL-2020 (C.P. Monroe Co. Jan. 12, 2023), Judge David J. Williamson issued an opinion in a nonjury trial arising out of a shooting incident. The court addressed the import of the dicta in the Spencer v. Johnson decision relative to the applicability of the Fair Share Act in a case in which no liability is assessed to a plaintiff.

Williamson then noted that “there has been a lot of confusion recently as to whether or not defendants are subject to joint and several liability for a judgment, regardless of their proportionate share of liability.” After reviewing the history of the Comparative Negligence Act and the Fair Share Act, Williamson asserted that “It makes more sense that the legislature would have enacted this measure in all cases of multiple defendants, even where the plaintiff has no contributory negligence.”

That being said, Williamson went on to review the contrary result noted in the dicta put forth by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in its Spencer v. Johnson, 249 A.3d 529 (Pa. Super. 2021) decision. Williamson noted that the rationale of the Spencer court regarding Fair Share Act “appears as dicta in the Superior Court’s decision, as it was not the direct holding” of the Superior Court.

Despite noting earlier in his decision that the reasoning as contained in the Spencer decision was “absurd,” Williamson, apparently feeling compelled to do so, stated that he would “adhere to the dicta stated in Spencer in this particular case, and find joint and several liability without the application of the Fair Share Act as between both defendants” given that there was no finding of contributory negligence against the plaintiff in this case.

In contrast, another trial court judge found no fault with the validity of the Spencer v. Johnson decision. In the case of Tucchi v. Carroll, No. CV-2018-1794 (C.P. Northumb. Co. Jan. 24, 2023), a trial court judge ruled that, pursuant to Spencer v. Johnson, 249 A.3d 529, 559 (Pa. Super. 2021), that the Fair Share Act was inapplicable given that the minor plaintiff in this matter was not found to be contributorily negligent by the jury or, in other words, was an innocent plaintiff. In a footnote in his order, the judge noted that the Spencer decision “was a precedential holding of the Superior Court after an analysis of the Fair Share Act, and not “dicta” as contended by” the defendant.”

What to Watch for in 2024

As noted above, looking ahead to 2024, litigators are anticipating how the Pennsylvania Supreme Court will rule on the issue of coverage under business interruption policies as applied to the government ordered closures of businesses during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Auto accident litigators are anticipating a decision from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on the validity of the regular use exclusion found in automobile insurance policies. Keep an eye out for a decision in the high court in the case of Rush v. Erie Insurance Exchange.

In terms of any other anticipated events in 2024, it is noted that on May 4, 2024, the Tort Talk blog, found at www.TortTalk.com and which is utilized by civil litigators as a resource for streamlined legal research on a wide variety of civil litigation topics, will celebrate 15 years of providing free updates on the law to both the bar and the bench.


Daniel E. Cummins is the managing partner of the Clarks Summit law firm of Cummins Law, a civil litigation practice. He also conducts mediations of civil litigation matters through Cummins Mediation Services. Cummins is also the sole creator and writer of the Tort Talk Blog (www.TortTalk.com), which is designed to provide continuing updates on important cases and trends in Pennsylvania civil litigation law. He can be reached at dancummins@CumminsLaw.net.

Monday, September 25, 2023

Pennsylvania's Consent to Jurisdiction By Registering To Do Business In Pennsylvania Valid, But Subject To Continuing Attacks

Tort Talkers may recall the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway in which the United States Supreme Court addressed the validity of Pennsylvania's consent by registration statute.  Under that statute, corporations and companies that register to do business in Pennsylvania thereby consent to subject themselves to jurisdiction in Pennsylvania state courts for lawsuits, even if the underlying accident occurred elsewhere.

A majority of U.S. justices upheld the validity of the statute, determining that it does not violate due process violations, and remanded the case back to Pennsylvania.  Yet, commentators note that the language of a Concurring Opinion by Justice Alito may spur Defendants to continue to attack the statute.

Under a recent Order, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court punted and remanded the issue all the way back down to the trial court for consideration, thereby rejecting the Defendants' attempt at a fast-tracked review by the Commonwealth's highest Court on continuing challenges to the question of whether or not Pennsylvania's consent by registration statute violates the U.S. Constitution.

Anyone wishing to review the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Order in this regard may click this LINK.

Presently, the statute providing that a corporation's registration to do business in Pennsylvania thereby subjects that corporation to Pennsylvania state court jurisdiction over personal injury lawsuits remains valid but subject to continuing attacks.


Source of image:  Photo by Jackie Hope on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Jurisdiction Challenge Rejected Given that Defendant Company Was Registered in Pennsylvania as of the Date the Claim Was Filed



In the exposure to asbestos case of Data v. AO Smith Corp., No. 2:19-CV-00879-CRE (W.D. Pa. Feb. 11, 2021 Eddy, Mag. J.), a federal magistrate judge issued a Report and Recommendation it which it was recommended that the District Court deny a Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss the case based upon jurisdictional arguments.

The court ruled that Pennsylvania’s statute imposes general jurisdiction on all companies registering to do business in Pennsylvania is constitutional.

Notably, the court ruled that jurisdiction exists over a Defendant even for causes of action that arose prior to Defendant's registration in Pennsylvania as a foreign company so long as the corporation is so registered as of the time the lawsuit is filed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, December 15, 2020

ARTICLE: Shutdown Makes for a Quiet year in Civil Litigation

Here is a copy of my December 10, 2020 Year-End review article published in The Pennsylvania Law Weekly on civil litigation developments in Pennsylvania over the past year.  It is republished here with permission.

My Year-End article on developments in Motor Vehicle Accident Law is forthcoming.


Shutdown Makes for a Quiet Year in Civil Litigation


By Daniel E. Cummins | December 10, 2020

  Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law.


While 2020 was a year in a pandemic and political upheaval, things were relatively calm in terms of any notable civil litigation decisions. The biggest news of the year was that courts were not conducting trials which gave judges more time to issue notable decisions, some of which are outlined below.
COVID-19 Stops Civil Litigation Trials

In 2020, the rise of COVID-19 pandemic shut down the court system in March. Generally speaking, the courts were almost entirely shut down for two months before gradually opening over the summer with virtual online proceedings. Then by September, the courts began to hold trials again in courtrooms outfitted with plexiglass and jurors spread out between the jury box and the gallery in an effort to maintain social distancing. It remains to be seen how the COVID-19 pandemic will influence jury awards.

Stay of Civil Litigation Matters Pending Result of Criminal Case

In a case of first impression handed down in March in the matter of Keesee v. Dougherty, 230 A.3d 1128 (Pa. Super. March 16, 2020), the Pennsylvania Superior Court confirmed the standards that a trial court judge must consider with respect to a request by a defendant to stay a civil lawsuit while a companion criminal case is pending.

The lawsuit in this matter was brought by a nonunion electrical contractor against an indicted union boss and other defendants.

With its ruling the Pennsylvania Superior Court adopted the six-factor test previously established by the federal courts in the case of In re Adelphia Communications, No. 02-1781, (E.D. Pa. 2003), for determining whether to stay a civil case pending resolution of a related criminal matter.

Going forward, under Keesee, the six factors to be addressed by a trial court in determining whether to stay a civil case pending the resolution of a companion criminal case included the extent to which the issues in the civil and criminal cases overlap, the status of the criminal proceedings and whether any defendants have been indicted, the plaintiff’s interests in an expeditious civil proceeding weighed against the prejudice to the plaintiff caused by the delay, the burden on the defendants, the interests of the court, and the public interests.

What Happens in Pennsylvania, Stays in Pennsylvania

One of the most active areas of Pennsylvania law over the past year was on the issue of personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania over foreign defendants.

Just recently, the judicially activist Pennsylvania Supreme Court advanced its agenda of helping plaintiff’s causes by expanding the ambit of jurisdiction over foreign defendants and opening the door even wider to hauling more potentially liable parties into Pennsylvania personal injury matters. In the case of Hammons v. Ethicon, 7 EAP 2019 (Pa. Oct. 21, 2020) (Op. by Baer, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reviewed jurisdictional issues in a pelvic mesh products liability case. In the end, the court affirmed the entry of a judgment in favor of the plaintiffs over foreign defendants who had raised issues of jurisdictional.

The Hammons case presented a law school essay type of jurisdictional challenge in a matter involving a lawsuit filed in Pennsylvania by an Indiana resident who had a surgical procedure performed in Indiana and who alleged injuries from an implanted pelvic mesh that was manufactured by New Jersey corporate defendants.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court provided a detailed summary of the current status of the law pertaining to personal jurisdiction that was noted to be in a state of flux. The court reviewed several notable U.S. Supreme Court opinions, the most recent of which was in the case of Bristol-Myers Squibb v. Superior Court of California, San Francisco County, 137 S. Ct. 1773 (2107). According to legal commentators, the Bristol-Myers decision by the Supreme Court was deemed to be a defense-friendly decision.

Concisely, after the Bristol-Myers case, the following three elements must be met in order for specific personal jurisdiction to lie over a defendant. First, a defendant must have purposefully conducted activities within the forum state, or must have purposefully directed its conduct towards the forum state. Second, the plaintiff’s claim must have arisen out of or relate to the defendant’s activities in the forum state or directed toward the forum state. Third, a finding of jurisdiction over the defendant must be found by the court to be fair and reasonable.

In Hammons, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court diverged from the law set down by the U.S. Supreme Court in Bristol-Meyers by rejecting the defense’s arguments that, under Bristol-Myers, the jurisdictional analysis should focus on the jurisdiction’s connection to each of the plaintiff’s individual claims. Instead, the 6-1 Majority in Hammons, with Chief Justice Thomas G. Saylor dissenting, ruled that the focus should remain on the defendant’s conduct.

In the end, the court found that the defendant’s suit-related contacts justified jurisdiction in that the particular defendant supervised the design and manufacturing process of its product in Pennsylvania in collaboration with a Pennsylvania company. The court additionally noted that this particular defendant also worked with a Pennsylvania physician in developing and marketing the product. In favoring the plaintiffs’ position, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected a more narrow jurisdiction analysis set down by none other than the U.S. Supreme Court as such a contrary view “could unnecessarily restrict access to justice for plaintiffs.”

Split of Authority on Another Jurisdiction Issue

In terms of jurisdictional issues in the federal courts of Pennsylvania, it appears that a split of authority has arisen between the federal district courts of Pennsylvania as to whether or not Pennsylvania’s long arm statute imposing general jurisdiction upon any foreign corporation registering to do business in Pennsylvania is constitutional.

On the one side, we have the case of Kraus v. Alcatel-Lucent, 441 F.Supp.3d 68 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 27, 2020 Savage, J.), in which the court ruled that Pennsylvania’s long-arm statute, which allows for general jurisdiction on any foreign corporation registering to do business in Pennsylvania, is constitutional.

The case of Weigold v. Ford Motor, No. 20-2141 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 9, 2020 Savage, J.) represents another decision in which a court held that a foreign company’s registration to do business in Pennsylvania also represents a valid consent to general personal jurisdiction over that company in lawsuits filed in Pennsylvania.

In contrast, in the case of Reynolds v. Turning Point Holding, No. 2:19-CV-01935-JDW (E.D. Pa. Feb. 26, 2020 Wolson, J.), the court granted a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction after finding, in part, that Pennsylvania’s statutory scheme requiring foreign corporations to consent to general personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania by virtue of registering to do business in Pennsylvania violates the due process clause of the U.S, Constitution.

According to this opinion, the defendant franchiser involved in this matter did not have any significant contacts with Pennsylvania and the store where the plaintiff was alleged injured was a separately maintained corporation. The court in Reynolds specifically ruled that the defendant’s registration as a foreign corporation to do business in Pennsylvania was insufficient to subject it to general personal jurisdiction.

Over the past year, this important issue was also watched the state court arena. The case of Murray v. American LaFrance, 2020 Pa. Super. 149 (Pa. Super. June 25, 2020) (en banc) (Op. by Bowes, J.), was viewed as the case in which would determine the validity of the argument that Pennsylvania’s business registration law was, in and of itself, sufficient to establish jurisdiction over an out-of-state company where that company has registered with the state to do business in Pennsylvania.

However, the en banc panel of the Superior Court ruled that the plaintiff had failed to properly preserve this issue of jurisdiction before the trial court and, as such, the court found that the issue was not preserved. As a result, litigants will have to await another day for this important and unsettled issue to be decided in Pennsylvania.

Products Liability

In 2020, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was poised to decide whether Amazon.com could be sued in a products liability action in Pennsylvania as a “seller” of a defective product.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed to accept that issue for review as certified to its attention by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in the case of Oberdorf v. Amazon.com, No. 41 EM 2020 (Pa. 2020).

In the case of Oberdorf v. Amazon.com, No. 18-1041 (3d Cir. July 3, 2019), the Third Circuit had reversed the lower court and held that Amazon.com may be sued as a “seller” in products liability cases.

The case arose out of an incident during which the plaintiff was injured when a retractable leash she was using while walking her dog allegedly malfunctioned, snapped back, and caused permanent injury to the plaintiff’s eye.

It was more recently reported that this case was settled before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court could issue a decision on the question. As such, practitioners will have to wait for another day to hear from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on whether Amazon can be sued in products liability claims here in Pennsylvania.

Medical Malpractice

The validity of the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur in medical malpractice matters was reaffirmed in a couple of cases over the past year. In the case Lageman v. Zepp, 237 A.3d 1098 (Pa. Super. 2020), the Pennsylvania Superior Court found that a trial court had erred in failing to charge the jury on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur. The court found that, with the help of expert opinion, plaintiff had established all three elements of the res ipsa loquitur doctrine in connection with the defendant’s performance of the medical procedure at issue.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court emphasized that, while the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur is usually associated with events that are within the common knowledge of laypersons and not requiring any expert testimony, the application of the doctrine is not foreclosed where the plaintiff also presents a medical expert offering evidence of other specific negligent conduct.

In another res ipsa loquitur case, Snyder v. Scranton Hospital, No. 19-CV-83 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Aug. 28, 2020 Nealon, J.), the court denied the defendants’ motions for partial summary judgment in which it was asserted that the plaintiff should not be permitted to rely upon the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur in support of the claims presented.

According to the opinion, the plaintiff underwent ear surgery but allegedly awoke with a severe left ulnar nerve neuropathy injury as a result of a compression injury allegedly due to the medical providers’ failure to properly position, protect and assess the plaintiff’s left arm while he was unconscious during the surgery.

The plaintiff produced expert opinion evidence that such an injury does not happen during an ear surgery in the absence of negligence on the part of the medical providers. The plaintiff asserted that that expert evidence also served to eliminate other potential causes of the injury. The defense produced its own expert testimony in support of claims that the plaintiff ‘s injury was indeed the result of other unrelated causes.

The court denied the motion given that there was a dispute between the experts as to whether the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur should be applied. In the end, that issue was left for the jury to decide.

Looking Ahead

In the year ahead, the courts will continue to navigate the coronavirus pandemic in terms of holding trials. However, it is expected that the trial courts and the appellate courts will continue to churn out notable decisions on a wide variety of civil litigation issues, including with respect to jurisdiction, proper venue, and in a wide variety of premises liability, products liability and medical malpractice matters.

Daniel E. Cummins is the managing partner of the Clarks Summit law firm of Cummins Law, a civil litigation practice. He also conducts mediations of civil litigation matters through Cummins Mediation Services. Cummins is also the sole creator and writer of the Tort Talk Blog (www.TortTalk.com), which is designed to provide continuing updates on important cases and trends in Pennsylvania civil litigation law. He can be reached at dancummins@CumminsLaw.net.







Tuesday, July 28, 2020

Jurisdictional Issue Found To Have Been Waived



In the case of Murray v. Am. LaFrance, LLC., No. 2020 Pa. Super. 149 (Pa. Super. June 25, 2020) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court that the Plaintiffs had waived the effort to establish general personal jurisdiction over a Defendant based upon the Defendant’s registration as a foreign corporation in Pennsylvania.  

The appellate Court found that the Plaintiff failed to raise the issue in response to the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections on the issues presented. 

This matter arose out of claims by the Plaintiff against a foreign corporation for negligence and strict products liability under claims that the Plaintiff suffered injuries due to excessive sound exposure from fire engine sirens that the Defendant company, which was a Delaware company, had manufactured in Illinois, which was where its principal place of business was located. 

The Defendant filed Preliminary Objections to personal jurisdiction and submitted documents to show that only four (4) of its employees resided in Pennsylvania and that only 3.5% of its total sales in 2015 were made to Pennsylvania buyers. 

The trial court had sustained the Preliminary Objections and dismissed the claim after finding that the foreign corporation’s alleged contacts with Pennsylvania were not so continuous and symptomatic to support the exercise of general personal jurisdiction. 

On appeal, the Plaintiffs argued that general personal jurisdiction over the Defendant was proper given the Defendant’s registration as a foreign corporation in Pennsylvania. However, given that the Plaintiff had failed to raise this issue at the trial court level, the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s ruling on the separate basis that the issues presented had not been preserved for appeal. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Cases.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 6, 2020).

Friday, May 22, 2020

Jurisdiction by Consent Concept Upheld in Two Recent Federal Court Cases


In two (2) recent Federal Pennsylvania District Court Decisions, separate courts held that the Third Circuit’s decision in the Bane case, recognizing general jurisdiction by consent, conferred by virtue of a foreign corporation’s securing a registration to do business in Pennsylvania, remains binding. 

This rule of law was relied upon in the case of Smith v. NMC Wollard, Inc., No. 19-5101 (E.D. Pa. April 24, 2020) as well as in the case of Replica Auto Body Panels & Auto Sales, Inc. v. InTech Trailers, Inc., No. 4:19-CV-02018 (M.D. Pa. April 16, 2020 Brann, J.). 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Smith decision may click this LINK  and this LINK for the companion Order.  

The Replica Auto decision can be read at this LINK and the companion Order at this LINK

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.