Showing posts with label Evidence of Governmental Standards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Evidence of Governmental Standards. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 24, 2025

Trial Court Denies Summary Judgment on Products Liability Claims Regarding Motorcycle


In the case of Windhorst v. Colvin, No. 11230 of 2019, C.A. (C.P. Lawr. Co. June 27, 2025 Hodge, J.), the court denied a Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant, Harley Davidson Motor Company, after finding issues of fact in this products liability case arising out of a motorcycle accident.

In this matter, the Plaintiff alleged a designed defect in the lighting system of the motorcycle. 

One defense presented by the Defendants was that the Plaintiff had substantially altered the lighting system on the motorcycle prior to the accident. More specifically, there was evidence in the record that the Plaintiff had installed an after market LED headlamp on the motorcycle in an effort to improve the headlamp’s brightness. 

The record before the court confirmed that the Plaintiff took this step without following the specifications or alignment instructions in the owner’s manual for the motorcycle that was provided by the Defendants. It was also noted that the owner’s manual expressly warned against the use of non-specified parts and also outlined the appropriate wattage for headlamps.

The Defendants additionally contended that the Plaintiff’s claims for a negligent design and for strict product liability were legally insufficient as the subject motorcycle complied with all federal and state conspicuity regulations in terms pf head lamps. 

The Defendant additionally argued that, in any event, the Plaintiff was aware of the alleged design defect and assumed the risk by continuing to operate the motorcycle.

The court denied the Motion after finding genuine issues of material fact existed regarding whether there was an alleged design defect in the motorcycle’s lighting system. The court also found genuine issues of material fact on the issue of whether the Plaintiff had assumed the risk of injury.

The court noted that both parties had produced conflicting evidence on the issue presented through expert reports on the issues of whether or not a design defect existed.

The court additionally noted that, while compliance with government standards is relevant to a claim for negligent design, such evidence is not determinative in cases of strict product liability regarding allegations of defects.

Accordingly, the judge denied the Motion for Summary Judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Sept. 18, 2025).

Tuesday, August 16, 2022

Federal Court Rules That Defendant's Compliance With Industry and Gov't Standards Admissible in Products Cases



In the case of Lehmann v. Louisville Ladder, Inc., No. 21-CV-4626 (E.D. Pa. July 6, 2022 Kearney, J.), the court clarified its Motion In Limine Order. In this decision, the federal court took issue with the Superior Court’s decision in the case of Sullivan v. Werner, which is currently on appeal to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, relative to the law applicable to products liability cases.

The federal court in this case held that evidence of a Defendant’s compliance with industry and government standards should be admissible under the Tincher case in a products liability matter.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  Here is a LINK to the Court's Companion Order of July 6, 2022.

Here is LINK to the Court's July 7, 2022 Clarification Order on the issues presented.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention. I also thank Attorney Kenneth T. Newman of the Pittsburgh office of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer for advising of this decision.