Showing posts with label Causal Connection to Maintenance or Use of a Motor Vehicle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Causal Connection to Maintenance or Use of a Motor Vehicle. Show all posts
Wednesday, February 4, 2026
Accidental Shooting From One Vehicle To Another Found To Involve "Use" of a Motor Vehicle
In the case of Allmerica Financial Benefit Ins. Co. v. Hunt, No. 2:24-CV-02767 (E.D. Pa. Dec. 15, 2025 Weilheimer, J.), the court denied Motions for Judgment on the Pleadings filed by two (2) UIM carriers in a case in which the two (2) automobile insurance companies were attempting to avoid having to pay underinsured motorists (UIM) coverage after an accidental shooting while the vehicle was at a red light.
This matter arose out of an accidental shooting that occurred between two drivers at a red light. One driver was attempting to unload a gun he had taken out of his glove compartment. The gun accidentally went off and struck an individual in the adjacent car, resulting in fatal injuries to that person.
The family of the decedent recovered the liability limits from the tortfeasor’s coverage and then turned to seek UIM coverage.
The UIM carrier filed suit, arguing that the shooting did not result from the “use” of a vehicle as required under the terms of that policy.
The court held that the policy language contained in the UIM policies conflicted with Pennsylvania’s Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (MVFRL) because it attempted to impose a stricter, proximate cause standard for UIM coverage instead of Pennsylvania’s broader standard of review.
The court wrote that, in close or doubtful insurance coverage cases, the law requires judges to err on the side of the insured.
The court additionally noted that, while insurers should not be considered to always be on the hook in terms of coverage because of their perceived ability to bear the cost of paying on the policy, public policy dictates that when there is a “tie” on the positions put forth by the UIM carrier and the insured on a coverage dispute, the court should err in favor of finding coverage.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.
Source: Article – “Pa Federal Judge Rules Auto Insurers Can’t Dodge UIM Coverage In Fatal Stoplight Shooting Case,” By Tristin Hoffman of the Legal Intelligencer (Jan. 2,2 026).
Monday, November 12, 2018
No UIM Coverage for Gunshot Wounds From High Speed Police Chase
In the case of Eberhardinger
v. City of York and State Farm, No. 1:16-cv-2481 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 18, 2018 Connor, C.J.),
the court addressed the elements of a UIM claim. More specifically, the court
reaffirmed the rule that a Plaintiff’s alleged injuries in a UIM claim must
have a causal connection to the use of a motor vehicle.
In this matter, the passenger Plaintiff was struck by bullets fired by the police during a high speed vehicle chase. The Plaintiff passenger, who was the owner of the vehicle involved in the high speed chase, sought PIP and UIM benefits from her policy.
The court held that the injuries to the Plaintiff passenger from being shot did not arise out of the “maintenance or use of a motor vehicle” for purposes of recovering UIM benefits under the policy. These injuries were found to be not vehicle-caused injuries, but rather, were the direct consequence of an intentional intervening act of a third party, with only incidental involvement of the motor vehicle.
The court additionally noted that, in any event, even if causation could be shown, the UIM coverage under the policy excluded injuries caused by a firearm.
The court in this decision went on to grant summary judgment on the Plaintiff's companion bad faith claim on the rationale that there could be no bad faith where there was no coverage under the policy.
In case you are interested, the court in this decision also addressed claims of Section 1983 civil rights liability against the municipal defendants.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's Order can be viewed HERE.
In this matter, the passenger Plaintiff was struck by bullets fired by the police during a high speed vehicle chase. The Plaintiff passenger, who was the owner of the vehicle involved in the high speed chase, sought PIP and UIM benefits from her policy.
The court held that the injuries to the Plaintiff passenger from being shot did not arise out of the “maintenance or use of a motor vehicle” for purposes of recovering UIM benefits under the policy. These injuries were found to be not vehicle-caused injuries, but rather, were the direct consequence of an intentional intervening act of a third party, with only incidental involvement of the motor vehicle.
The court additionally noted that, in any event, even if causation could be shown, the UIM coverage under the policy excluded injuries caused by a firearm.
The court in this decision went on to grant summary judgment on the Plaintiff's companion bad faith claim on the rationale that there could be no bad faith where there was no coverage under the policy.
In case you are interested, the court in this decision also addressed claims of Section 1983 civil rights liability against the municipal defendants.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's Order can be viewed HERE.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

