Showing posts with label Personal Jurisdiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Personal Jurisdiction. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 25, 2026

Pennsylvania District Court Finds Jurisdiction Over Out-of-State Manufacturer Under Consent-by-Registration Statute

 In the case of Blade v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 2:25-CV-06645-MAK (E.D. Pa. March 5, 2026 Kearney, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court ruled that a lawsuit against Sig Sauer, a gun manufacturer, would remain in Pennsylvania in light of the U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 decision in the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway which provided the court with jurisdiction over this out-of-state company.

According to the Opinion, the gun manufacturer had moved to dismiss the case based on an argument that the court lacked personal jurisdiction because Pennsylvania’s “consent-by-registration” statute allegedly violated the dormant commerce clause and was unconstitutional under the due process clause.

The Eastern District federal court rejected these arguments and ruled that, in light of the Mallory decision, the court had general personal jurisdiction over the lawsuit because the gun manufacturer had consented to such jurisdiction by registering to do business in Pennsylvania.

The court additionally ruled that Pennsylvania’s registration clause did not violate the due process or the dormant commerce clauses as applied to the Defendant.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article – “Gun Malfunction Litigation Will Remain in Pa., Thanks to Controversial US Supreme Court Jurisdiction Decision” By Riley Brennan of The Legal Intelligencer (March 11, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by Addy Mae on www.pexels.com.

Wednesday, March 26, 2025

Federal Court Addresses Jurisdiction Over Claims of Defamation Over the Internet


In the case of Rhodes v. Azeff, No. 2:22-CV-00101-WSH (W.D. Pa. Jan. 29, 2025 Hardy, J.), the court addressed issues of personal jurisdiction that were based upon alleged defamatory statements that were published online.

In this case, the court granted a Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss this case for lack of personal jurisdiction and also granted the Motion to Dismiss the counterclaims.

In this decision, the court provided an excellent overview as to the standard of review relative to the issue of personal jurisdiction over a Defendant.

The court reiterated Third Circuit law that publishing statements on the internet does not subject the author to personal jurisdiction anywhere in the world from which a user could access the internet.

The court noted that an out-of-state person does not expressly target Pennsylvania nearly by publishing statements on the internet that are accessible from Pennsylvania.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Thomas McDonnell of the Pittsburgh office of the Summers, McDonnell, Hudak, Guthrie & Rauch, P.C. law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, February 20, 2025

Federal Court Finds No Jurisdiction Over Insurance Company Existed Under Claims Asserted


In the case of Abira Medical Laboratories, LLC v. Freedom Life Insurance Co., No. 2:24-CV-02110-JHS (E.D. Pa. Jan. 10, 2025 Slomsky, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court of Pennsylvania, addressing a question of first impression, held that a Defendant foreign insurance company did not consent to general personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania to be sued by a private party on its own behalf for any cause of action simply based on the fact that the carrier obtained a Certificate of Authority issued pursuant to 40 Pa. C.S.A. § 46 in order to conduct business in Pennsylvania.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was a medical testing laboratory that provided testing services to the Defendant insurance company’s insured members as an out-of-network provider.

When the Plaintiff had a billing dispute with the insurance company regarding services performed, the Plaintiff sued the Defendant in a Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas.

The Defendant carrier removed the action to federal court on the basis of diversity and then filed this Motion to Dismiss. The Defendant carrier asserted, in part, that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the insurance company.

The Plaintiff argued that the Defendant carrier had consented to general personal jurisdiction on any claim because the Defendant had applied for and received a Certificate of Authority to do insurance business in Pennsylvania pursuant to 40 Pa. C.S.A. § 46.

The court noted that the referenced statute did not provide for general jurisdiction over foreign insurance companies conducting business in Pennsylvania.

Rather, the court noted that, under the plain language of § 46 foreign insurance companies wishing to conduct business in Pennsylvania must obtain a Certificate of Authority from Pennsylvania’s Department of Insurance. The statute further provides that, upon obtaining a Certificate of Authority, § 46 allows for any action arising out of a violation of § 46 that is instituted by or on behalf of the insurance commissioner to be brought against the foreign insurance company in Pennsylvania.

Here, given that the current action was not commenced by the insurance commissioner arising out of a violation of § 46, but rather was an action brought by a private party, the grant of jurisdiction provided under § 46 over a foreign insurance company was not found not to be implicated.

The court also held that the Defendant insurance company had no otherwise consented to personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania.

Given that the court found that it lacked general personal jurisdiction, as well as specific personal jurisdiction over the Defendant insurance company, the court granted the carrier’s Motion to Dismiss.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Federal Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 30, 2025).
 



Wednesday, January 8, 2025

No Jurisdiction Where Foreign Corporation Had No Direct Contacts With Pennsylvania


In the case of Montgomery v. Bobst Mex SA, No. 24-367 (E.D. Pa. Dec. 13, 2024 Arteaga, Mag. J.), the court granted a Motion to Dismiss based upon jurisdictional issues. More specifically, the court found that the Defendant, which was a Swiss corporation, was not subject to personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant sold all of its products, including the one that allegedly injured the Plaintiff, to a New York sole distributor. There was no evidence that the Defendant directed any of its activities at or in Pennsylvania.

The court noted that the record otherwise confirmed that there was no direct contacts by the Defendant in Pennsylvania.

Moreover, the court noted that any subsequent sales in the United States was at the discretion of the sole distributor in New York, with no direction being provided to that distributor by the Swiss corporation Defendant.

Although the Swiss Defendant allegedly had knowledge of Pennsylvania end-users of the product, the court found that evidence in this regard, without more, was insufficient to establish specific jurisdiction.

In the end, the federal court found that, without evidence of a strong relationship between the Defendant, the forum, and the litigation, the court could not exercise specific jurisdiction over that Swiss corporation as a Defendant. Accordingly, the Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss was granted.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Pavel Danilyuk on www.pexels.com.

Monday, September 30, 2024

Jurisdiction Found to Exist in Pennsylvania Due to Multiple Contacts With Pennsylvania

In the case of Duvall v. Ryder Truck Rental, Inc., No. 24-1920 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 9, 2024 McHugh, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss on jurisdictional issues.  

The case involved alleged injuries sustained by the Plaintiff when a lift gate on a Ryder truck collapsed.

The Defendant's moved to dismissed the case principally on the grounds that the accident happened in Maryland.

The court noted that, even though the accident in question happened in another state, specific personal jurisdiction existed.   In this regard, the court noted that the Plaintiff’s employer had leased the truck at issue from the Defendant in Pennsylvania. 


It was also noted that the record revealed that the alleged negligent maintenance of the truck, which was allegedly a cause of the accident, occurred in Pennsylvania.   


The court additionally noted that the Plaintiff was a Pennsylvania resident and received worker’s compensation benefits from a Pennsylvania employer.


Based on these reasons, the Court denied the motion to dismiss.


Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Preliminary Objections Regarding Venue and Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens Addressed by Superior Court


In the case of Kennedy v. Crothall Healthcare, Inc., No. 383 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Aug. 9, 2024 Collins, J., Stabile, J., and McLaughlin, J.) (Op. by Collins, J.) (McLaughlin, J. dissenting), the Superior Court affirmed a trial court's granting of a defendant's Preliminary Objections based upon a lack of jurisdiction and also affirmed the dismissal of remaining claims under the doctrine forum non conveniens.

Relative to the issue of jurisdiction, the court found that the Plaintiff asserted no valid basis for jurisdiction over a manufacturer for injuries sustained in a surgery that was completed in a state other than Pennsylvania. 

The court also emphasized that the Defendant was not located in Pennsylvania and the product at issue was never manufactured in the state of Pennsylvania.

The court additionally noted that the Plaintiff did not assert general jurisdiction and, as such, any arguments based upon the Pennsylvania registration of the corporation to do business were considered to be waived.  The Plaintiff attempted to request a retroactive application of a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co. regarding jurisdiction over corporations that register to do business in Pennsylvania.  However, the Court found that the Plaintiff had waived this issue of general jurisdiction.

In terms of the Plaintiff's efforts to establish specific jurisdiction over the defendant, the court additionally noted that the fact that the payment for the product at issue was sent to a Pennsylvania lock box was insufficient to support a claim of specific personal jurisdiction against the Defendant. The court emphasized that the lock box had nothing to do with the product liability issue.

The court agreed that the Defendants did not otherwise purposefully direct their activities towards Pennsylvania. Also, the Plaintiff’s claims did not, in any meaningful way, arise out of the use of the lock box. Moreover, the court noted that the lock box belonged to the manufacturer’s bank and not toe the Defendant manufacturer. The court reasoned that if the presence of an independent product distributor is insufficient to support jurisdiction, then the presence of an independent lock box also cannot be sufficient.

Relative to the issues raised under the doctrine of forum non conveniens, the court found it was also proper for the trial court to have dismissed the case on these grounds as well. In this matter, it was established that every witness was located out of state as were all of the Defendant’s alleged activities related to the lawsuit. The Superior Court agreed that the Defendant had demonstrated the hardship that justified disturbing the Plaintiff’s choice of forum.

The court in Kennedy additionally ruled that the fact that a corporate Defendant had headquarters in Pennsylvania, in and of itself, was not enough to defeat a motion filed under the doctrine of forum non conveniens seeking a transfer of venue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith law firm in Philadelphia for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, August 12, 2024

Entry of Judgment Would Be Void In Light of Lack of Proper Service


In the case of Bradford Crossing Homeowners Assoc., Inc. v. DeSimone, No. 2023-05885-IR (C.P. Chest. Co. Nov. 22, 2023 Binder, J.), the court denied a Plaintiff’s homeowner’s association’s request for the entry of judgment against a Defendant after finding that service of process was not properly completed on that Defendant.

The court noted that any judgment is void when it is entered by a court lacking personal jurisdiction due to the failure of a plaintiff to obtain proper service of original process, or a waiver of original process, or consent by a defendant to the jurisdiction of the court. 

Here, the court noted that the record included a Sheriff’s return that indicated that the Complaint and the Petition at issue were served on a third party at the property in dispute. However, nothing in the record indicated that the Defendant at issue resided at that property.  Accordingly, the court found that the attempted service was outside the scope of the general rules governing original service of process.

The court additionally noted that there was no indication in the record that the Defendant had waived his right to proper service or had otherwise consented to the court’s jurisdiction.

As such, the court stated that it could not grant the Plaintiff’s motion against the Defendant because the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the Defendant and any judgment that would be entered in the Plaintiff’s favor would be void as a matter of law in any event.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Court of Common Pleas Case Alert at www.law.com (July 10, 2024).

Thursday, July 6, 2023

U.S. Supreme Court Reverses Pennsylvania Supreme Court and Upholds Pennsylvania Law Conferring Jurisdiction on Corporations Who Register To Do Business in PA

In the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co, ___ U.S.___ (June 27, 2023) in a 4-1-4 plurality decision, the United States Supreme Court upheld the Pennsylvania law allowing state courts to hear lawsuits against out-of-state companies who had registered to conduct business in Pennsylvania, even when the alleged injury occurred outside of the Pennsylvania.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, April 4, 2023

Eastern District Court Dismisses German Office of Porsche From Products Liability Claim Due to Lack of Jurisdiction


In the case of Riad v. Porsche Cars N. Am., Inc., No. 18-5175 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 24, 2023 Pratter, J.), the court granted a Defendant’s F.R.C.P. 12(b)(2) Motion to Dismiss based upon lack of jurisdiction.

In this matter, the Plaintiff had purchased a used Porsche from a non-Porsche-brand dealer. Years later, after noting problems with the vehicle’s engine and, the Plaintiff was instructed by Porsche to bring it to the nearest dealership for inspection and repair.

On the way to the dealership, smoke allegedly began coming through the AC vents into the passenger area allegedly causing the Plaintiff to suffer permanent lung damage and asthma.

The Plaintiff filed a products liability claim against or Porsche Cars North America, Inc. and Porsche AG.

Both Defendants moved to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction.

The court had previously ruled that it could exercise general personal jurisdiction over Porsche Cars North America.

The court granted Porsche AG’s Motion to Dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.

The court first ruled that it did not have general personal jurisdiction over Porsche AG as that entity was not “at home” in Pennsylvania.  Rather, that company was incorporated in, and had its headquarters in, Germany.

The court denied to find that Porsche North America was a mere alter ego of Porsche, AG, which would have permitted the court to impute general personal jurisdiction.

Rather, the court found that there was sufficient evidence that the two entities were separate legal entities that interacted with each other pursuant to arm’s length agreement and that neither party exercised dominion or control over the other. 

The court additionally stated that there was an agreement between the parties that expressly disclaimed any authority for Porsche North America to act as an agent or legal representative of Porsche AG.

The court also found that it lacked specific jurisdiction over Porsche AG in that there was no evidence that that entity had purposefully directed its business activities in Pennsylvania.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 16, 2023).

Source of image:  Photo by Clement Roy on www.unsplash.com.   

Wednesday, January 11, 2023

Personal Jurisdiction Over Foreign Corporation Found to Exist Based on Actions of the Distributor for the Corporation


In the products liability case of Merino v. Repak, B.V., No. 135 MDA 2022 (Pa. Super. Dec. 6, 2022 Bowes, J., McCaffery, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by McCaffery, J.), a Defendant company operating out of the Netherlands filed an appeal from a trial court Order overruling its Preliminary Objection to personal jurisdiction. The Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s Order.

In so ruling, the Superior Court rejected the Defendant’s arguments that the trial court had erred and abused its discretion when the trial court exercised personal jurisdiction over the foreign company based upon either the Defendant’s independent contacts with the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania or its relationship with a Co-Defendant company.

The Superior Court noted that the trial court properly exercised specific personal jurisdiction over the foreign manufacturer with no minimum contacts of its own within the forum. The court found that, based upon the actions and contacts of the foreign manufacturer’s exclusive distributor, with whom the manufacturer had a close agency relationship, jurisdiction over the foreign manufacturer was warranted.

The Superior Court found that the Co-Defendant distributor had acted as an agent for the foreign manufacturer by selling the manufacturers products to customers in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec. 27, 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Elena Mozhvilo at www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, January 3, 2023

Federal Middle District Court Addresses Jurisdiction Over Accident That Occurred in Virginia


In the case of Grady v. Rothwell, No. 4:22-CV0-00428 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 8, 2022 Brann, J.), the court addressed issues of personal jurisdiction in a trucking accident case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff’s decedent was killed in a motor vehicle accident that occurred in Virginia.

The Defendant tractor trailer driver was not a resident of Pennsylvania, nor was La-Z-Boy Logistics, which was the company for which the driver was driving.

Judge Brann found that the court lacked personal jurisdiction as there was no evidence or allegation that the corporate Defendant was “at home” in Pennsylvania. Personal jurisdiction was also not found due to the fact that the subject motor vehicle accident occurred outside of Pennsylvania.

Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann 
M.D. Pa.


Judge Brann ruled that the fact that La-Z-Boy did business nationwide, including Pennsylvania, was insufficient, in and of itself, to confer general personal jurisdiction over that party, as there was no allegation that the company had any locations or employees in Pennsylvania.

The court additionally found that there was no basis to assert specific personal jurisdiction as the underlying motor vehicle accident occurred in the State of Virginia.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order may be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec. 1, 2022).


Source of top image:  photo by Josiah Farrow from www.pexels.com.


Thursday, June 30, 2022

Trial Court Opines That Defendant's Appeal From Order Dismissing Defendant's Objections to Jurisdiction Should Be Quashed


In the case Galette v. New Jersey Transit, No. 200800610 (C.P. Phila. Co. May 31, 2022 Crumlish, J.), the trial court filed a Rule 1925 Opinion to the appellate court recommending the dismissal of the Defendant’s appeal from the trial court’s Order dismissing the Defendant’s objections to jurisdiction.

It was the position of the trial court that the Order dismissing the Defendant’s objection to jurisdiction was appealable only under Pa.R.A.P. 311(b) and that the requirements of that Rule had not been met. 

According to the Opinion, this matter arose out of a personal injury action filed by the Plaintiff against the Defendant New Jersey Transit, and another Defendant. According to the lawsuit, the Plaintiff was injured while sitting in a parked vehicle in the City of Philadelphia when that vehicle was allegedly struck by a bus operated by one of NJ Transit’s employees.

The Defendant, NJ Transit, objected to the court’s jurisdiction over it through a Motion to Dismiss. That Motion was denied and NJ Transit filed an appeal, which prompted this Opinion by the court.

The trial court noted that an Order denying a Motion to Dismiss is ordinarily interlocutory and, therefore, not appealable unless expressly made so by statute.

In its Opinion, the court cited to Pa.R.A.P. 311, which lists the interlocutory appeals that may be taken as a right, and Pa.R.A.P. 312, which allows for interlocutory appeals by permission.

Under Pa. R.A.P. 311(b), an appeal is allowed as a right when a trial court’s Order overruled Preliminary Objections to the trial court’s in personam or in rem jurisdiction and either the Plaintiff elected to treat the Order as final or the trial court stated in the Order that a substantial issue of jurisdiction existed.

Given that these requirements were not met, and given that the Defendant, NJ Transit, did not otherwise seek leave of court to file an interlocutory appeal, or request an Order stating that a substantial issue of jurisdiction was presented, the trial court noted that the appeal should be quashed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 7, 2022).




Tuesday, April 26, 2022

Validity of Part of Pennsylvania's Long-Arm Statute Going Up to the U.S. Supreme Court for Consideration


The United States Supreme Court has agreed to consider arguments in the Pennsylvania case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway about the constitutionality of Pennsylvania’s law requiring out-of-state companies and corporations to submit to jurisdiction in Pennsylvania as a requirement when registering to do business in the Commonwealth.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that this law was unconstitutional late last year, finding that it violated due process principles.

The Tort Talk post on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's decision in the Mallory case, along with a Link to that decision, can be viewed HERE.

Source:  Article - "SCOTUS Takes Up Appeal Over Pa.'s Jurisdiction By Business Registration Law" by Max Mitchell of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 25, 2022).

Source of image:  Photo by Brad Weaver on www.unsplash.com.

Friday, April 22, 2022

No Jurisdiction Found Over Out-of-State Contractor in Construction Litigation Case


In the case of Bean Sprouts LLC v. Life Cycle Const. Serv., LLC, No. 1467 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Feb. 17, 2022 Panella, P.J., Dubow, J., McCaffery, J.) (Op. by Panella, P.J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that the trial court did not err when it found that the Defendant did not have the requisite minimum contacts with Pennsylvania for the trial court to exercise jurisdiction.

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a construction contract dispute.

The Plaintiff was a construction and excavating company and the Defendant was a contractor engaged in construction projects throughout the country.

The Plaintiff filed a breach of contract action in Pennsylvania. The Defendant contractor filed Preliminary Objections asserting that it did not have the requisite minimum contacts with Pennsylvania such that a Pennsylvania court could not exercise personal jurisdiction over the Defendant.

The trial court sustained the Preliminary Objections and the appellate court affirmed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 8, 2022).

Photo by skitterphoto on www.pexels.com.

Wednesday, January 19, 2022

Court Finds No Personal Jurisidiction Over Cruise Line Where Plaintiff's Injury Did Not Occur In Pennsylvania


In the case Knox v. Seven Seas Cruises, No. 525, August Term 2020 (C.P. Phila. Co. Aug. 21, 2021 New, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Superior Court to confirm the trial court’s decision to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction.

According to the Opinion, the lawsuit between the Plaintiff and the cruise line grew out of a dispute over the Plaintiff’s request for a cash refund. 

The Plaintiffs filed suit in Philadelphia County on the claims presented and asserted that the Pennsylvania trial court had specific jurisdiction because the financial harm that the Plaintiff allegedly suffered related to the cruise line’s contacts in Pennsylvania, specifically, the company’s solicitation of the Plaintiffs’ business.

The cruise line filed Preliminary Objections raising the issue of personal jurisdiction.

The court ruled that, while the Defendant solicited business from Pennsylvania, including the Plaintiffs’ business, the court lacked specific personal jurisdiction over this foreign corporation because the allegedly injury-causing incident involving the Defendant did not occur in this State of Pennsylvania. The court otherwise found that the combination of the Plaintiffs’ Pennsylvania residency and the Defendant’s solicitation of business in Pennsylvania was not sufficient to confer personal jurisdiction over the Defendant.

As such, the trial court requested that the Superior Court affirm its decision on appeal.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec. 21, 2021).

Wednesday, December 29, 2021

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Limits the Reach of the Jurisdictional Long-Arm Statute Over Foreign Corporations

Pennsylvania State Capitol Building
Home of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court

In the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co., No. 3 EAP 2021 (Pa. Dec. 22, 2021) (Maj. Op. by Baer, C.J.)(Concurring Op. by Mundy, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recognized that a recent decision by the United States Supreme Court precluded the exercise of general personal jurisdiction by a Pennsylvania court over a party solely on the basis of the fact that a foreign corporation had registered to do business in Pennsylvania. As such, that aspect of the Pennsylvania long-arm statute has been declared unconstitutional in this Mallory decision.

In this matter, a Virginia resident filed an action in Pennsylvania against a Virginia corporation, under an allegation of injuries sustained in Virginia and Ohio.

The Plaintiff asserted that the Pennsylvania courts have general personal jurisdiction over the case based exclusively upon the fact that the foreign corporation registered to do business in Pennsylvania. 

In this regard, the Plaintiff had relied upon 42 Pa. C.S.A. §5301(a)(2)(i). The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed with the trial court decision that the Pennsylvania statute, affording Pennsylvania court general personal jurisdiction over a foreign corporation that registers to do business in Pennsylvania regardless for the lack of continuous and symptomatic contacts within the state by that corporation, fails to comport with the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution.

In other words, the Court held that Pennsylvania's "statutory scheme is unconstitutional to the extent that it affords Pennsylvania courts general jurisdiction over foreign corporations that are not at home in the Commonwealth."  See Op. at p. 44.    

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority Opinion of this decision may click this LINK.  The Concurring Opinion by Justice Mundy can be viewed HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith law firm in Philadelphia for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by Andre Frueh on www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, April 22, 2021

Court Allows for Jurisdiction in Pennsylvania Over Connecticut-Based Company Based, in part, On Website Activity



In the case of D&S Auto Sales v. Commercial Sales & Marketing, No. 19-CV-7494 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Feb. 19, 2021 Nealon, J.), the court ruled that a Connecticut-based auto dealership can be sued in Pennsylvania because its website specifically targeted consumers from Pennsylvania and actively pursued their business.

After reviewing the record before him, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas found that enough buyer-seller activity occurred on the Defendant’s interactive website to establish general jurisdiction to allow the case to move forward in Pennsylvania.

In his decision, Judge Nealon noted that a number of activities occurred over the interactive website as opposed to visitors to the site just gathering information, including customers scheduling vehicle maintenance, requesting parts to be ordered, checking availability of vehicles, and inquiring about pricing.

The Court found that this level of interaction activity sufficient to form a basis for general jurisdiction over the Defendant.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, April 19, 2021

Court Excuses Delays Related to COVID-19 Pandemic With Respect to Completion of Service of Process




In the case of Pasquariello v. Manwiller, No. C-48-CV-2020-00607 (C.P. North. Co. Jan. 11, 2021 Murray, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Preliminary Objections against the Plaintiff’s Complaint in which the Defendants asserted a lack of personal jurisdiction based upon untimely service.

The court rejected the Defendant’s contention that the Plaintiffs had stalled the legal machinery that they had set in motion by way of the filing of the lawsuit. Rather, the court found that the Plaintiffs had made a good faith effort to complete service.

The court emphasized that, when the Plaintiff filed a Writ of Summons, the Plaintiffs sent a copy of the Writ to the claims adjuster for the Defendant’s carrier and inquired whether the carrier would accept service in order to avoid expenses to the Defendants (and the Plaintiffs). This request was rejected by the carrier.

The court also noted that, around the time of this request, the COVID-19 pandemic shut down the normal operations of the Sheriff’s Departments throughout the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

The record confirmed that the Plaintiff had reissued the Writ of Summons as soon as the local Sheriff’s Office reopened.

The court found that the delay in service was due to the pandemic and not because the Plaintiff had stalled the legal machinery that had been set in motion.

It was noted, however, that the Plaintiff had failed to complete service within the time allowed. As such, in its decision, the court required the Plaintiff to file a Praecipe to Reinstate the Writ and to serve the Defendants within thirty (30) days from the date of the reinstatement.

The court also addressed other Preliminary Objections in this case.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Feb. 23, 2021).

Friday, April 16, 2021

U.S. Supreme Court Latest Pronouncement on Personal Jurisdiction Over Out-of-State Defendants In a Products Liability Case



The United States Supreme Court recently issued a notable decision in the case of Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, No. 19-368 (U.S. March 25, 2021), in which the Court affirmed a decision finding the existence of personal jurisdiction over products liability claims by an in-state plaintiff for in-state injuries against an out-of-state defendant.

Defendant Ford had sought to extend the Supreme Court’s decision in Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court, 137 S. Ct. 1773 (2017), which rejected personal jurisdiction over claims by out-of-state plaintiffs against out-of-state defendants for out-of-state injuries.

Ford asserted that, under the Bristol-Myers analysis, specific jurisdiction requiresd a “causal link” between the defendant’s forum contacts and the plaintiff’s claims, which was not present in this Ford case because the cars involved in the accidents were not designed, manufactured, or first sold in-state.

The five-justice majority disagreed.  The majority rejected a strict causal link standard and distinguishing the forum-shopping circumstances of Bristol-Myers from the claims in Ford by in-state plaintiffs for in-state injuries. The majority held that the Court’s specific jurisdiction standard includes suits that sufficiently “relate to” a defendant’s forum contacts, even in the absence of a causal link.

Applying this standard to the two cases before it, the majority held that Ford’s activities in Montana and Minnesota, including marketing, selling, and servicing the same models of cars at issue in the cases, enticed residents to purchase Ford cars and, as such, were sufficiently related to the plaintiffs’ claims to create specific jurisdiction over their suits. The Court held: “Ford had systematically served a market in Montana and Minnesota for the very vehicles that the plaintiffs allege malfunctioned and injured them in those States. So there is a strong ‘relationship among the defendant, the forum, and the litigation,’—the ‘essential foundation’ of specific jurisdiction.”

Commentators have noted that now, following the Ford decision, it appears that a defendant’s showing that a plaintiff’s claim does not arise out of or is not causally linked to the defendant’s conduct in the forum state may not be enough to prevail on a defense argument that a court lacks personal jurisdiction if a plaintiff can show that the claim sufficiently “relates to” the defendant’s conduct in the state.

Commentators have also noted that the Bristol-Myers analysis still also stands.  Those commentators have asserted that the Ford decision does not disturb the U.S. Supreme Court’s previous rejection in Bristol-Myers of specific jurisdiction over claims by non-resident plaintiffs against a non-resident company whose product allegedly injured the plaintiffs. 

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Dale Larrimore of the Philadelphia law firm of Larrimore & Farnish, LLP for bringing this decision to my attention.

Thursday, October 22, 2020

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Hands Down Decision on Personal Jurisdiction Issues


In the case of Hammons v. Ethicon, Inc., 7 EAP 2019 (Pa. Oct. 21, 2019) (Op. by Baer, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reviewed jurisdictional issues in a pelvic mesh products liability case.   In the end, the court affirmed a judgment in favor of the Plaintiffs on appeal.  

The case presented a jurisdictional challenge in a matter involving a lawsuit filed in Pennsylvania by an Indiana resident who had a surgical procedure performed in Indiana and who alleged injuries from an implanted pelvic mesh that was manufactured by New Jersey corporate defendants.

With regards to issues pertaining to personal jurisdiction over Defendants, the court reaffirmed the rule that a Defendant challenging personal jurisdiction has the burden of supporting that objection.   

The Court provided a detailed summary of the current status of the law pertaining to personal jurisdiction which was noted to be in a state of flux.  The Court reviewed several notable United States Supreme Court Opinions, the most recent of which was in the case of Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court of California, San Francisco County, 137 S. Ct. 1773 (2107).   Concisely, after the Bristol-Myers case, the following three (3) elements must be met in order for specific personal jurisdiction to lie over a defendant:  

First, a defendant must have purposefully conducted activities within the forum state, or must have purposefully directed its conduct towards the forum state.  

Second, the plaintiff’s claim must arise out of or relate to the defendant’s activities in the forum state or directed towards the forum state.  

Third, overall, a finding of jurisdiction over the defendant must be fair and reasonable.  

Here, the court found that the Defendant’s suit-related contacts justified jurisdiction in that the particular Defendant supervised the design and manufacturing process of its product in Pennsylvania in collaboration with a Pennsylvania company.  The court additionally noted that this particular Defendant also worked with a Pennsylvania physician in developing and marketing the product which, in this case, was a medical product used to treat prolapsed pelvic organs.  

In other words, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court took a wider, big picture view in its analysis and determined that the case as a whole established ties between the defendant's actions in the forum state and the litigation.  See Op. at p. 36-37.

In favoring the Plaintiffs' position, as it has been wont to do, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected a more narrow analysis of the jurisidictional issue as such a contrary view "could unnecessarily restrict access to justice for plaintiffs."  See Op. at p. 36.

The Majority Opinion of this 6-1 decision can be viewed HERE.

The Concurring Opinion can be viewed HERE.

The Dissenting Opinion can be viewed HERE.