Showing posts with label Right To Jury Trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Right To Jury Trial. Show all posts

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Court Finds That Arbitration Clause Found on App Inconspicuous and, Therefore, Unenforceable


In the case of Oakley v. FloatMe Corp., No. 1318 WDA 2025 (Pa. Super. Oct. 1, 2026 King, J., Lane, J., and Panella, P.J.E.) (Op. by King, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s rejection of a Defendant’s efforts to compel arbitration of this civil litigation matter.

According to the Opinion, FloatMe is a Texas-based technology company that makes loans or cash advances to Pennsylvania consumers over the internet.

This matter arose out of a Class Action matter. After suit was filed, the Defendant filed Preliminary Objections in the nature of a Motion to Compel Arbitration.

FloatMe asserted that the Plaintiffs were required to sign up via FloatMe’s App before she could obtain a cash advance. FloatMe asserted that the App prompts the user to answer several questions and request certain information. One of the prompts on the App provides that , by continuing with the application process, the applicant agrees to FloatMe’s terms of service and privacy policy.

FloatMe further maintained that the terms of service button is clickable and directs the user to an online format of the terms and condition. The company further asserted that, if a user clicks the phrase terms and conditions, those terms and conditions allegedly clearly indicate that the agreement contains an Arbitration provision and a Class Action waiver.

The Plaintiff asserted that the App’s lengthy sign up process included “at least 16 screens” for a consumer to navigate before they may obtain a case advance. The Plaintiff noted that, at no point in that process did FloatMe mention Arbitration or the waiver of any constitutional rights, such as the right to a jury trial.

The Plaintiffs asserted that this type of a sign up process is not sufficient to bind users to Arbitration or the waiver of any constitutional rights such as the right to a jury trial. 

The Pennsylvania Superior Court agreed and held that the FloatMe App did not conspicuously inform the Plaintiff of her rights.  Rather, the court found that the application process on the App allowed users to complete their registration without being fully informed of the rights that the applicant is waiving.

As such, the Superior Court held that there was no mutual assent and no valid agreement entered into with respect to Arbitration.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Pa. Super. Blog written by Jon Bruno of Bruno Litigation, LLC in Pittsburgh, PA.


Source of image:  Photo by Brett Jordan on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, March 17, 2026

Superior Court Upholds Right to Jury Trial and Rejects Arbitration Clause Relative to Contract Plaintiff Entered Into on Defendant's Website


In the case of Duffy v. Tatum, No. 483 EDA 2025 (Pa. Super. March 3, 2026 Lazarus, P.J., Panella, P.J.E., and Sullivan, J.) (Op. by Panella, P.J.E.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s Order overruling a Defendant’s Preliminary Objections under which the Defendant asserted that a Plaintiff had waived the right to a jury trial by way of an agreement entered into via the Defendant's website.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had proceeded to the Defendant’s website to book services provided by the Defendant moving company.

On that website, the customer was required to check off a box accepting the Defendant’s terms of services. The customer had the ability to click on an underlined phrase that would take the customer to the Defendant’s Terms of Service by way of a hyperlink. 

On that hyperlink, if the customer accessed it, one of the provisions that would be seen in the language on that page would be an ADR clause for the resolution of any disputes that arose between the parties by way of mediation followed by an arbitration, as opposed to by way of an opportunity for a jury trial in a court of law.

In this matter, the trial court found that the Defendant’s website did not provide a reasonably obvious notice of its Terms of Service to the Defendant’s customers prior to the customer’s purchasing the services offered by the company.  As such, the trial court ruled that the customer had never agreed to waive his constitutional right to a jury trial. As noted, on appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s decision in this regard.

The Superior Court framed the central issue before it as involving “an overarching question of whether a person should be deprived of their constitutional right to a jury trial when they ostensibly enter into an arbitration agreement through hyperlinked Terms of Service on a website that the person never clicked on, viewed, or read.” See Op. at p. 6.

In so ruling, the Pennsylvania Superior Court referred to its prior decisions on this issue in which the court had held that the Pennsylvania State Constitution provides its citizens with the greater protections afforded by the right to a jury trial.

The Superior Court otherwise noted that the “copious use of contracts with restrictive arbitration agreements causes concern, particularly in the context of internet contracts like the one at issue here, where the parties are frequently of unequal bargaining power and one party may be unaware of the significant rights they are waiving simply by using a website to make a purchase or retain services.” See Op. at p. 8.

President Judge Emeritus Panella noted in his Opinion that, in recognition of this reality, Pennsylvania courts have taken a small step towards righting the wrongs of arbitration agreements with respect to wrongful death actions involving negligent nursing center facilities. The court otherwise noted that there is still a need for greater scrutiny regarding a person’s waiver of their constitutional right to a jury trial when it comes to these types of arbitration agreements in other scenarios as well. 

Judge Panella stated that “[t]his need is imperative when there is no genuine effort to inform a purchaser of the terms of the contract before they click on a link or box that purports to generate their agreement to a contract, as the case” was in this matter. See Op. at p. 9.

The court went on to note that it found that it is imperative that, in the context of civil litigation matters, that a person be fully informed of their constitutional right to a jury trial and of the effect of waiving that right. Accordingly, the court held that it is essential that any waiver of the right to a jury trial must be clearly described and evidenced such that the person waiving the right fully understands the right that they are giving up by agreeing to enter into the contract.

In light of its holding that the constitutional right to a jury trial in Pennsylvania should be afforded the greatest protection possibly by the courts of Pennsylvania, the court in this Duffy case enunciated a “strict burden of proof [that its] necessary to demonstrate a person’s unambiguous manifestation of assent to arbitration.” See Op. at p. 15.

More specifically, the court noted that this strict burden of proof necessary to demonstrate a person unambiguous assent to arbitration requires (1) an explicit statement on the registration website and application screens that a consumer is waiving their right to a jury trial when then the person agrees to the seller’s Terms of Service and the registration cannot be completed until the person is fully informed of that waiver, and (2) when the agreements are available for viewing after a user has clicked on a hyperlink, the waiver should be not hidden in the middle of the document, but rather, should appear prominently in bold, capitalized text. See Op. at p. 15.

The court additionally noted that the word “arbitration” must also be clearly defined within the arbitration agreement in addition to being prominently displayed in the language of the contract. See Op. at p. 16.

In the end, in this case, where the customer here never clicked on the Terms of Service and, therefore, never saw the Terms of Service, the court ruled the customer did not unambiguously assent or agree to give up his or her rights to a jury trial in favor of arbitration. 

The Superior Court also ruled that, where the website did not provide a reasonably obvious notice of its Terms of Service, there was no meeting of the minds on a contractual basis relative to the issue of arbitration for the resolution of any disputes. 

As such, the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the lower court's decision and found that the trial court did not err in overruling the Defendant company’s Preliminary Objections on the issues presented.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article – “Pa. Superior Court Rules Company’s Terms Didn’t Waive Customer’s Right to Jury Trial” By Tristin Hoffman of The Legal Intelligencer (March 6, 2026).


I also send thanks to Attorney Thomas F. Foley, III of the Foley Law Firm in Scranton, Pennsylvania for making sure that I saw this decision as well.

Source of image:  Photo by Vojtech Okenka on www.pexels.com.

Monday, August 7, 2023

Is Uber's Arbitration Clause Enforceable?


In the case of Chilutti v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 1023 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. July 19, 2023 en banc) (Op. by McCaffery, J.)(Stabile, J., Dissenting), a split Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that the Plaintiffs were not bound by arbitration agreement that was contained within a set of hyper linked “terms and conditions” on a website or a smart phone application that they never clicked upon, viewed, or read.  

Such "terms and conditions" contained an arbitration clause relative to any personal injury claims.

In ruling that a plaintiff is not bound by the arbitration clause under the facts and circumstances at issue in this case, a majority of the Pennsylvania Superior Court en banc panel upheld a Plaintiff’s constitutional right to a jury trial in a personal injury matter. 

This case is the first before a Pennsylvania appellate court to examine the waiver of a right to a jury trial in an online agreement.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Article - “Split Pa. Superior Court Rules Uber’s Arbitration Clause is Unenforceable” by Aleeza Furman Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 21, 2023).

Source of image:  Photo by Austin Distel from www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, October 13, 2022

Arbitration Clause From Uber Not Enforceable Where Plaintiff Did Not Click On It -- Right to Jury Trial Upheld



In the case of Chilutti v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 1023 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Oct. 12, 2022 Stabile, J., Dubow, J., McCaffery, J.)(Maj. Op. by McCaffery, J.(Dissenting Op. by Stabile, J.), the Court held that an arbitration agreement offered by the Defendant via a set of hyperlinked “terms and conditions” on a website or smartphone app that was never clicked on, viewed or read by the Plaintiff was not enforceable against the Plaintiff.

The Plaintiff was wheelchair bound and injured while riding in a car provided by Uber on his way home from a medical appointment.

The Plaintiff filed a negligence claim in the court of common pleas but Uber argued that the case was subject to a mandatory arbitration agreement found in the hyperlinked terms and conditions.

The trial court upheld the arbitration agreement as being applicable and granted Uber’s motion to compel arbitration.

Emphasizing the importance of the constitutional right to a jury trial, the Superior Court reversed and held that the arbitration agreement could not be asserted against the Plaintiff as the Plaintiff had not affirmatively agreed to the arbitration clause. The appellate court instead found that the injured party could invoke his constitutional right to a jury trial.

In so, ruling the Superior Court also issued a new standard of review to be applied to the question of whether or not a party had unambiguously manifested an intent to assent to an arbitration clause. See Op. at p. 30-31.

Anyone wishing to review this interesting decision and the dissent may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.