Tuesday, January 20, 2026
Superior Court Addresses Crashworthiness Doctrine
In its non-precedential decision in the case of Amagasu v. Fred Beans Family of Dealerships, No. 1594 EDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Dec. 22, 2025 Olson, J., Dubow, J., and Beck, J.) (Op. by Olson, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court vacated a one billion dollar jury verdict in favor of the Plaintiffs in a products liability case.
According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a motor vehicle accident. In this product liability case against Mitsubishi, the Plaintiffs allege, in part, that the seat belt system and the low roof configuration of the vehicle, and other related structures were defective.
In its Opinion, the Pennsylvania Superior Court held, in part, that the trial court had erroneously instructed the jurors to apply a wrong legal standard, resulting in a verdict that was reached by the jury under an improperly reduced burden of proof.
The Superior Court noted that the jurors at the trial should have been instructed to apply the “crashworthiness” doctrine. This standard holds a vehicle manufacturer liable for injuries caused by design defects in their vehicles during accidents.
In this matter, the jurors were instead instructed to apply a general strict liability standard which had a lower burden of proof.
Accordingly, the Superior Court agreed with the defense argument that the trial court abused its discretion in electing to given only a traditional Section 402A strict products liability instruction.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney Kenneth T. Newman of the Pittsburgh office of the Thomas Thomas & & Hafer, LLP law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Thursday, January 30, 2025
Western District Federal Court of Pennsylvania Addresses Products Liability Claims In a Prescription Medical Device Litigation
In the case of Blair v. Abbvie, Inc., No. 2:23-CV-1871 (W.D. Pa. Jan. 9, 2025 Ranjan, J.), the court granted a Motion to Dismiss in a prescription medical device litigation.
In this decision, the Western Federal District Court confirmed that Pennsylvania’s across-the-board application of the Restatement §402A, comment k, as precluding strict liability design defect claims, but not strict liability manufacturing defect claims.
The court also ruled that, similarly, given that the elements of implied warranty claims are identical to strict liability claims, the Plaintiff’s implied warranty claims were dismissed.
The court also ruled in this case that the manufacturing defect claims asseted by the Plaintiff were inadequately pled because the claims did not reveal either any specific problem with the device or how the device allegedly failed. The court noted that the availability of a malfunction theory manufacturing defect claim does not exclude excuse failure to plead the circumstances of the alleged malfunction.
The court also ruled that the negligent design and warning claims were inadequately pled because the Plaintiff did not identify the design defect, anything about the manufacturing process, or what information should have been given to his medical providers.
Based on these issues, the trial court granted the Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Thursday, June 27, 2024
Crashworthiness Test Applied to Golf Cart in Accident Case
According to the Opinion, the golf cart was designed by Defendant, JH Global, and sold to a licensed dealer. Prior to its sale, the golf cart was modified by the dealer with a lift kit designed and sold by another Defendant.
In this matter, the court addressed a Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the manufacturer of the golf cart.
The Defendant filed a Motion for Summary Judgment on the grounds that there was allegedly no support for a claim against JH Global as the designer of product that was impermissibly altered by a dealer and where the designer’s original parts were not the parts that failed during the course of the accident.
The Plaintiffs also subsequently filed a Motion for Summary Judgment asserting that the record should demonstrate that the Defendants should have had knowledge that their carts were being modified and sold by their dealers that the Defendant designer did not adequately monitor and reprimand those actions, and that there was no sufficient warning within the warranty itself to convey the dangerous potential results of those modifications. The Plaintiff additionally asserted that the design of the cart invited modifications without appropriate safety mechanisms.
The court applied a 3-factor test for a defective design claim: whether a product could be designed to be safer, whether a design failed to perform as safely as an ordinary consumer would expect when used as intended or in a reasonably foreseeable manner, and if the designed caused the injury, whether the Plaintiff could demonstrate that a challenged feature outweighs the risk inherent in the design.
The court also applied the crash worthiness of a motor vehicle test to the golf cart as a matter of first impression.
Here, the court found that the Plaintiff could not identify or offer an available alternative cart design that would have prevented the Plaintiff’s injuries. The alleged defect was that the cart enabled modifications that it was constructed to handle. The court noted that he Defendant’s warranty instructions said that the cart should not be modified.
The court found that a design that permitted modification of a catastrophically flawed lift kit was unintended and unforeseeable. As such, the court found that the Defendant was not responsible for manfuracturing each golf cart to withstand modifications and noted that the Defendant made a golf cart with additional safety measures when it is lifted, but the original purchaser did not buy that model.
As such, the court found that the design defects alleged by the Plaintiff were without merit.
On the claim of an inadequate warning of the possible consequences of modifying the golf cart, the court stated that the Plaintiff was required to provide proof that the lack of warning rendered the cart unreasonably dangerous and that it was approximate cause of the injury. The court denied summary judgment on the failure to warn claim, finding that this claim presented issues to be resolved by the jury.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: Law.com: “The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert” (May 8, 2024).\
Wednesday, January 3, 2024
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules that Evidence of a Product's Compliance With Industry Safety Standards Is Not Admissible in a Strict Liability Design Defect Case
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that such compliance evidence is inadmissible in this context.
In the case below, the trial court granted a Plaintiff’s Motion to Preclude the Defendants from adding into evidence any industry or governmental standards with regards to the scaffolding. After a verdict was entered in favor of the Plaintiff, this appeal followed and went up the appellate ladder.
In the Sullivan case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court concluded that evidence of a product’s compliance with governmental regulations or industry standards is inadmissible in a strict liability design defect case to show that a product is not defective under the risk-utility theory because such evidence goes to the reasonableness of the manufacturer's conduct in making its design choice, not to the issue of whether the product was defectively designed.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority Opinion in this decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney Kenneth T. Newman of the Pittsburgh office of Thomas Thomas & Hafer for bringing this case to my attention.
Tuesday, December 13, 2022
Strict Liability Failure to Warn Claims Fail Where Plaintiffs Did Not Read Warnings
The court ruled that the Plaintiff’s warning defect theory failed as a matter of law because the Plaintiff admitted in this case that they never even read the warning label on the Defendant’s product.
The court therefore found that an unread warning could not be a cause of an injury in a products liability claim.
In this particular matter, the court also found that the Plaintiff’s failure to warn claim was also preempted by the Hazardous Substances Act because that Act did not require the Defendant to include a spontaneous combusting warning on the label as a principal hazard.
The court additionally noted that the Plaintiff was unable to establish any design or manufacturing defect because the Plaintiff’s lacked any expert evidence that the product, whether it was defective or not, actually caused the fire that injured them.
The court confirmed that the Plaintiff did not identify a cause and origin expert with regards to the fire in question. It was additionally held that lay opinion testimony is speculative and no substitute for expert fire causation testimony, particularly where there were possible alternative origins for the fire in this case. The court also noted that scientific knowledge about the chemical components of the product and their corresponding combustibility was beyond the understanding of a layperson and, therefore, required the testimony of an expert.
The court also found that the Plaintiff could not rely upon a malfunction theory of liability to establish an alleged manufacturing defect because the Plaintiffs did not have the expert testimony necessary to eliminate other possible causes.
The court also found that the Plaintiff’s implied warranty of merchantability claim was similar to a strict liability claim and that this implied warranty of merchantability claim failed because the Plaintiffs were not able to establish a product defect.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.
I thank Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Thursday, September 8, 2022
Federal Court Addresses Potiential Liability of Drug Manufacturer in Products Liability Case
According to the Opinion, the Defendant designed and manufactured a prescription medication sold under the trade name of Harvoni which was used to treat Hepatitis C.
The Plaintiff filed this lawsuit alleging a failure to warn and design and manufacturing defect claims under both negligence and strict liability. The Plaintiffs claimed that the decedent’s development of cancer was caused by his use of the medication.
The court dismissed the negligent failure-to-warn claim, noting that it was well-settled Pennsylvania law that pharmaceutical companies do not owe a duty to warn the public. Rather, manufacturers of medications are only required to warn prescribing doctors of the risk of the medications. The court cited to the learned intermediary doctrine which holds that drug manufacturers are only required to direct required drug safety warnings to physicians who, in turn, are required to relay the same to patients.
However, the court declined to dismiss the Plaintiff’s negligent design and manufacturing defect theories, finding that the Plaintiff had asserted a valid cause of action that the Defendants had allegedly negligently designed and manufactured the medication.
Lastly, the court did dismiss the Plaintiff’s strict liability claims after holding that strict liability claims against prescription drug manufacturers were barred by Pennsylvania products liability law.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.
Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 12, 2022).
Friday, March 18, 2022
Federal Court Addresses Daubert Motion Relative to Expert Testimony and Motion for Summary Judgment in Products Case
According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was allegedly injured while cleaning a vehicle and using a power buffer/polisher manufactured by the Defendant.
Relative to the issues raised by the defense with respect to the Plaintiff’s expert testimony, the court found that the Plaintiff’s expert’s testimony about an alternative design was admissible under Rule 702. The court noted that the reliability analysis with respect to an expert testimony looks at the reliability of the methodology as opposed to the conclusions of the expert. To be admissible, the expert’s testimony must also assist the trier of fact in resolving a factual dispute.
The court noted that it is not essential that an expert be able to recreate the facts of the accident. The court reasoned in this case that, while the accident in this case happened quickly while the Plaintiff was allegedly distracted while using the Defendant’s power tool, those facts did not preclude the Plaintiff’s expert from opining on the issue of causation.
In another important ruling, the court noted that experts are allowed to rely upon the testimony of witnesses, even where that testimony is disputed.
The court ultimately found that, since the Plaintiff’s expert’s testimony was admissible, the Plaintiff’s risk/utility theory of a designed defect survived the Motion for Summary Judgment. However, summary judgment was granted with respect to the Plaintiff's claims of a manufacturing defect, and with regards to the breach of express warranties and failure to warn claims.
The court additionally noted that the extent to which the Plaintiff’s alleged carelessness and alleged failure to follow instructions caused the accident was an issue for the jury to decide.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck from the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Tuesday, March 1, 2022
Chief Judge Brann of Federal Middle District Court Addresses Variety of Products Liability Issues
In the case of Goodling v. Johnson & Johnson, No. 4:21-CV-00082 (M.D. Pa. Feb. 10, 2022 Brann, C.J.), the court granted in part and denied in part a Motion to Dismiss in a medical device strict liability and negligence claim reagarding pelvic mesh product.
The court found that, although the Plaintiffs’ Complaint provided comparatively little information about the medical procedure and the injuries at issue, the allegations were found to provide adequate notice of the claims and supporting facts and could not be dismissed as an alleged shotgun pleading.
Notably, Judge Brann also ruled that Pennsylvania law did not require an application of the Restatement of Torts (Second) §402A, comment k, across the board to bar strict liability claims against medical devices.
| Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann M.D. Pa. |
Judge Brann noted that Pennsylvania Superior court precedent barring such claims has been undermined by other decisions. Judge Brann felt that comment k applied to medical devices only on a case-by-case basis.
While the court found that the Plaintiff’s strict liability allegations involving a design defects and with respect to warnings were adequately pled, the court dismissed the strict liability manufacturing defect claim because there was no allegation made that the device deviated in some unique way from its intended design.
Judge Brann additionally dismissed the Plaintiff’s negligent misrepresentation and fraud claims as duplicative of the Plaintiffs’ warning claims.
The court also noted that the claim of unjust enrichment did not apply in products liability claims where the Plaintiff actually received and used the product.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this notable decision by Chief Judge Brann of the Federal Middle District Court of Pennsylvania may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck from the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Thursday, July 2, 2020
Plaintiff Required to Prove Design Defect in Design Defect Case
In the case of Pennsylvania Nat’l Mut. Ins. Co. v. Sam’s East, Inc., PICS No. 20-0472 (C.P. Dauphin Co. April 13, 2020 Cherry, J.), the court granted a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a products liability suit based upon an alleged design defect with a space heater.
This matter arose out of a residential fire. The insurance company Plaintiff filed a subrogation action against Sam’s East, Inc. and related parties based upon an allegation that the fire was allegedly caused by a space heater purchased at the Sam’s East, Inc. store.
The court noted that, under Pennsylvania law, to recover in a design defect case, Plaintiff must prove that the product was defective, that the defect was the cause of the Plaintiff’s injuries, and that the defect existed at the time it left the manufacturer’s control.
The court noted that, based upon burn patterns and physical evidence observed at the scene, it was the opinion of the Plaintiff's investigator that the fire was accidental in nature and that the fire originated within the electric space heater that was located in the basement.
The court noted, however, that the investigator’s report did not identify any design defect, state how any alleged defect caused the heater to catch fire, or identify what type of safety design should have existed instead.
As such matters were beyond ordinary knowledge of the average juror and, therefore, required expert opinion, the court found that the investigator’s simple conclusion that the “fire originated within the electric space heater” was insufficient to enable the Plaintiff to proceed to the jury. The court noted that, to allow this case to proceed to the jury would have invited speculation on the part of the jury as to the cause of the fire and whether any defect was the source of the same.
As such, the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment was granted.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 9, 2020).
Tuesday, September 11, 2018
Expert Testimony Needed on Alternative Design Theories in Products Cases
More specifically, the Superior Court agreed with the trial court’s finding that the Plaintiffs required expert testimony to establish that an alternative design of the siren just as an effective warning device for all persons, such as pedestrians, as the Plaintiff’s reference to the industry standard was not an acceptable substitute for such required expert testimony.
Ultimately, the Superior Court affirmed the finding that the Plaintiffs’ expert’s failure to opine on the alternative design of the siren for the safety for pedestrians and motorists was fatal to the Plaintiff’s claim that the alternative design was an acceptable alternative design that would render the Defendant’s currently designed siren unreasonably dangerous.
Tuesday, July 24, 2018
Summary Judgment Granted in Part and Denied in Part Under Tincher Analysis
![]() |
| Judge Robert D. Mariani M.D. Pa. |
Wednesday, March 23, 2016
Recent Post-Tincher Decision of Note Out of the Western District
This matter arose out of a fatal incident involving a Plaintiff who was performing maintenance under his motorhome when the vehicle descended upon him.
The court concluded that the central question of whether adding a filter to an air flow system would have made the product harder to use because the filter would have to be changed too often was a question for the jury to determine.
The court in Rapchak referred to the Wade factors for risk/utility and an “ordinary consumer” test for consumer expectation.
Also, in a footnote, the court in Rapchack described one of Tincher’s “principal impacts” as being the elimination of the Azzarello negligence/strict liability dichotomy and the other being that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to adopt the Restatement (Third) of Torts relative to Pennsylvania Products Liability claims. See n. 15.
Anyone wishing to review this case may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith, and the main blogger for the Drug and Device Law Blog for bringing this case to my attention.






