Showing posts with label Declaratory Judgment Actions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Declaratory Judgment Actions. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 22, 2026

Carrier Prevails on Declaratory Judgment Action Regarding Validity of Rejection of UIM Coverage By Insured


In the case of Huggins v. Progressive Adv. Ins. Co., No. 965 MDA 2025 (Pa. Super. June 18, 2026 Bowes, J., Dubow, J., and Neuman, J.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s dismissal of a Plaintiff’s declaratory judgment action against Progressive in which the Plaintiff had sought UIM benefits.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had a single policy with Progressive Insurance which was a motorcycle insurance policy. The Plaintiff had electronically executed the policy and signed a letter rejecting UIM protection.

After the Plaintiff was involved in a motor vehicle accident while operating his motorcycle, he settled the third party claim against the tortfeasor. He then pursued a UIM claim under his motorcycle policy with Progressive. That claim was denied by Progressive based upon the fact that the Plaintiff had previously signed a letter rejecting UIM coverage.

The Plaintiff filed a declaratory judgment action, asserting an entitlement to UIM coverage. According to the Plaintiff, the rejection was invalid because the form he executed did not include the associated policy number.  The Plaintiff made this argument even though he only had one policy with Progressive.

As noted above, the trial court had ruled in favor of the insurance company. The trial court determined that there was no question that the UIM rejection form pertained to the only policy that the Plaintiff had with Progressive. The trial court found that the Plaintiff had declined UIM coverage in accordance with the provisions set forth in 75 Pa. C.S.A. §1731 of the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law. The trial court therefore granted summary judgment in favor of Progressive and dismissed the Plaintiff’s Complaint with prejudice.

As noted, on appeal, the Superior Court affirmed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney David Friedman of the King of Prussia office of Forry Ullman for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Valentin Sarte on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, July 2, 2026

Superior Court Finds That Having Lunch At Mom's House Doesn't Make You a Resident of that House When You Have Your Own Apartment


In the case of Lanunziata v. Penn. Nat’l Mut. Cas. Ins., No. 2026 Pa. Super. 97 (Pa. Super. May 13, 2026 Bowes, J., Dubow, J., and Neuman, J.) (Op. by Dubow, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the entry of summary judgment in favor of an insurance company in a declaratory judgment action in which the child of the insured was seeking UIM benefits under his parent’s automobile policy following an accident.

According to the Opinion, under the policy in question, an insured included the named insured and any family member.  A family member was defined, in part, as a resident of the insured's household. 

Here, the record before the court confirmed that the child had moved out of his parents’ home several years before the incident and spent a majority of his time in his own apartment.

After reviewing the case law on the issue of "residency" in this context, the Superior Court rejected the claim that the Plaintiff was a resident of his parents’ home.  The Plaintiff asserted that he ate lunch at his parents' house on a regular basis, had his mail delivered there, and had left a few personal items at his parents’ home.

The Court noted that the Plaintiff had graduated from college in 2016 and had leased an apartment in 2019 and had no intention of returning to his parents' home to live. 

The Court found that the evidence confirmed that the quantity of contacts and time that the Plaintiff spent in his own apartment greatly outweighed his contacts with his parents home.

As such, the Superior Court affirmed the entry of summary judgment in favor of the carrier on the coverage question presented.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Court Summaries” by Timothy L. Clawges of The Pennsylvania Bar News (June 15, 2026).

Thursday, June 26, 2025

Appellate Court Addresses Applicability if an Absolute Auto Exclusion in a Business General Liability Policy


In the case of Chris Eldredge Containers v. Crumb & Foster Specialty Ins., 2025 Pa. Super. 92 (Pa. Super. April 24, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., King, J., Lane, J.) (Op by. Lazarus, P.J.), the court addressed a coverage issue in this declaratory judgment action involving various coverage issues, including the applicability of an automobile exclusion in a business policy in a case involving an accident that involved a service truck driven by an employee of the carriers' insured.

The appellate court noted that it was proceeding under a de novo standard of appeal, meaning that it was not limited by the trial court's rationale and could affirm or reverse the trial court decision on any basis.   
The Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that the absolute auto exclusion, which excluded coverage for bodily injury under the policy for any incident arising out of the use of an auto, was found to be ambiguous in the context of this policy and was, therefore, found to be not enforceable.

The Superior Court additionally ruled that the ownership clause in the absolute auto exclusion was found to be ambiguous when it failed to specify whose ownership, maintenance, use, or entrustment served to trigger that exclusion.

In the end, the appellate court reversed the trial court decisions and found that the carriers did owe a duty to defend and indemnify its insured under the facts presented.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Court Summaries” in the Pennsylvania Bar News By Timothy L. Clawges (June 9, 2025).


Source of image:  Photo by Vlad Deep from www.unsplash.com.

Friday, May 23, 2025

Court Upholds Assault and Battery Exclusion in Liability Policy Related To Shooting Incident


In the case of The Farmers Fire Ins. Co. v. S.W. Krauss, LLC, No. 2023-CV-5087 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 12, 2025 Gibbons, J.), the court granted a liability carrier’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings based upon an assault battery exclusion contained in the subject policy relative to a shooting incident that occurred on the insured’s premises.

According to the Opinion, this matter involved an injured party who suffered a gunshot wound after gunfire was exchanged between unidentified individuals who were engaged in an dispute.

President Judge James A. Gibbons
Lackawanna County



The carrier for the landowner filed a declaratory judgment action and asserted that coverage was barred under the assault and battery exclusion contained in the policy. After reviewing the policy as compared to the facts alleged in the underlying civil litigation Complaint, the trial court here agreed and granted the carrier’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.

The trial court also rejected the injured party’s efforts to create issues of fact based upon affirmative defenses raised in the injured party’s New Matter responses to the declaratory judgment Complaint. In this regard, the trial court noted that there were boilerplate allegations in the New Matter pleadings and no factual allegations in support of the same.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, September 4, 2024

Federal Court Remands Coverage Action to State Court


In the case of Turner v. Progressive Specialty Ins. Co., No. 2:24-CV-00939-JFM (E.D. Pa. Aug. 14, 2024 Murphy, J.), the court granted a motion to remand a class action regarding UM/UIM coverage issues after finding that grounds for federal court jurisdiction were not met by the carrier.

The court noted that this case was removed by Progressive from the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County to the federal district court. The court noted that the purported basis for jurisdiction in this case was the Class Action Fairness Act which requires, among other things, that the aggregate amount in controversy be at least $5 million dollars.

In an Amended Complaint, the Plaintiff dropped any claim for punitive damages and and confirmed that all that was sought was a judicial declaration of uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage for him and other proposed class members.

The court found that Progressive had not met its burden to establish the amount in controversy for federal court jurisdiction. As such, the case was remanded to the state court.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Scott B. Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, December 13, 2023

Federal Court Applies Abstention Doctrine To Declaratory Judgment Action



In the case of Assoc. Ind. Ins. Co., Inc. v. 101 West Lehigh, LLC, No. 2:23-CV-03736-CFK (E.D. Pa. Oct. 31, 2023 Kenney, J.), the Motion of a necessary party/Defendant to dismiss a declaratory judgment action was denied.

The underlying matter involved a fatal shooting incident at a gas station. The Plaintiff insurance company filed a declaratory judgment action on the issue of the duty to defend or indemnify certain Defendants involved in the underlying case.

The Plaintiff insurance company included the estate of the deceased individual as a necessary party Defendant.

That necessary party Defendant filed a Motion to Dismiss pursuant to the abstention doctrine. The necessary party Defendant argued that the coverage action should be dismissed in light of the federal court’s limited discretionary authority to review insurance coverage issues where there was a pending state court proceeding that did not implicate federal interest.

This motion was denied. The federal court initially noted that it had subject matter jurisdiction based upon the diversity and the amount in controversy.

Because the federal action involve a request for declaratory relief only and involved a question of insurance coverage, the court addressed the issue of its abstention authority under the analysis set forth in Reifer v. Westport Ins. Corp., 751 F.3d 129 (3d. Cir. 2014) and State Auto Ins. Co. v. Summy, 234 F.3d 131 (3d. Cir. 2000).

Applying the factors required by those decisions, the federal court in this case initially confirmed that there was no parallel state proceeding because the state court action as focused on the issue of liability while this federal court action involved coverage questions. The federal court noted that the absence of a parallel state court proceeding favored the federal court’s exercise of its jurisdiction.

The court in this case additionally found that the application of the remaining factors weighed in favor of the federal court retaining jurisdiction over the declaratory judgment action. As such, the Motion to Dismiss was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be found at this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 24, 2023).

Thursday, October 26, 2023

Federal Court Punts On Declaratory Judgment Action Involving Insurance Coverage Questions

Ray Guy
Legendary Raiders Punter

In the case of Mesa Underwriters Spec. Ins. Co. v. Alisha Real Estate, LLC, No. 2:23-CV-01281-GJP (E.D. Pa. Sept. 7, 2023 Pappert, J.), the court granted a Defendant commercial property owner’s Motion to Dismiss or Stay the Carrier’s Federal Declaratory Judgment Action.

In this declaratory judgment action, the carrier was asserting that it had no duty to defend or indemnify a Defendant in the underlying state court personal injury action.

This federal court exercised its discretion under the Declaratory Judgment Act to decline jurisdiction where the relevant parties were all parties to the state court action and to litigate the coverage issues in the state Court of Common Pleas.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Oct. 6, 2023).

Wednesday, May 10, 2023

Does The Issuance of a New Policy Number on an Automobile Insurance Policy Constitute the Creation of a New Policy?


In the case of Shea v. Nationwide Ins. Co. and Davis, No. 3:22-CV0-00494-MEM (M.D. Pa. April 6, 2023 Mannion, J.), Judge Malachy E. Mannion of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania adopted the Report and Recommendation of Chief Federal Magistrate Judge Karoline Mehalchick and ordered that this declaratory judgment action be remanded to state court for review by the state court.

The legal issue presented in this matter addressed “the novel question or whether or not the issuance of a new policy number constitutes the establishment of a new policy requiring new sign down forms.”

The court determined that this issue presented a novel and unsettled issue of state law. As such, under the factors set forth in the case of Reifer v. Westport Ins. Corp., 751 F.3d 129 (3d. Cir. 2014), the court decided to remand the case to the state court for a decision.  The case was remanded to the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Report and Recommendation of Judge Mehalchick and well as the decision of Judgment Mannion approving the Report and Recommendation may click this LINK.

Plaintiff's counsel in this case was Attorney Neil T. O’Donnell and Attorney Gerard Gaughan of the Kingston, PA law firm of O’Donnell Law Offices.

 

Source of image: Photo by Priscilla Piacquadio on www.pexels.com.


Friday, April 22, 2022

No Duty to Defend or Indemnify Found Relative to Alleged Faulty Workmanship in a Home Construction Case


In the case of Main St. Am. Assurance Co. v. Conolly Contractors, Inc., No. 2:19-CV-04241-JHS (E.D. Pa. Feb. 28, 2022 Slomsky, J.), the court granted the carrier’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings in its declaratory judgment action.

The issue in this case is whether the carrier had a duty to defend and indemnify a contractor or builder who was sued by homeowners for alleged home construction defects.

The court found that the carrier had no duty to defend and indemnify because the homeowners’ claims of faulty workmanship did not allege that the property damage was caused by an “occurrence” as required by the contractor’s policy of insurance.

The court additionally found that the builder was not listed as an additional insured under the contractor’s policies.

As such, the carrier’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings in this declaratory judgment was granted.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's Order can be viewed LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 24, 2022).

Monday, April 18, 2022

Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens Reviewed In Dispute Between Two Plaintiff's Law Firms Over a Substantial Fee


In the case of Fellerman & Ciarimboli Law, PC v. Joseph L. Messa, Jr., & Associates, No. 21-CV-4654 (C.P. Lacka. Co. April 14, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed issues under the doctrine of forum non conveniens.

According to the Opinion, the personal injury law firm Plaintiff in this matter, which maintains offices in Delaware County, Lackawanna County, Luzerne County, Philadelphia County, and New Jersey, commenced a declaratory judgment action against a Philadelphia personal injury law firm seeking a determination regarding the proper method for calculating the Philadelphia firm’s share of attorney’s fees of a little over $2 million dollars that relative to a civil litigation matter.

The counsel fees in dispute were generated from a wrongful death lawsuit that was filed and litigated in Philadelphia County and defended by Philadelphia area attorneys. The underlying case arose from the death of a Philadelphia resident in a Philadelphia accident. The court also noted that the counsel fees were approved by a Philadelphia County judge.

It was also noted that, with regards to the attorney’s fees at issue, the Philadelphia law firm had instituted a separate action against the Plaintiff law firm in Philadelphia County asserting breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, unjust enrichment, and other claims.

In this Lackawanna County declaratory judgment case filed by the Plaintiff law firm, the Defendant Philadelphia law firm filed a Petition pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1006(d)(1) seeking to transfer venue in this declaratory judgment action to the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County on forum non conveniens grounds.

After reviewing the record before him, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas determined that the records contained sufficient proof that the continued litigation of this declaratory judgment action in Lackawanna County would be unduly burdensome for the Philadelphia law firm and the anticipated witnesses. The court noted that no material witness or any relevant evidence was located in Lackawanna County and that Philadelphia County would provide easier access to the witnesses and other sources of proof.

Based upon the totality of the circumstances, the court found that Lackawanna County is an oppressive forum for the adjudication of this case. As such, the court granted the Petition to Transfer Venue and transferred the case to Philadelphia County.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source of image:  Photo by gratisography on www.pexels.com.

Monday, December 20, 2021

Request For Attorney Fees Rejected Relative to Declaratory Judgment Action


In the case of Atain v. Ins. Co. v. Kaz Tire, Inc., No. CV-21-3651 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 16, 2021 Kearney, J.), the court denied an insured’s request for attorney’s fees under the Declaratory Judgment Act in federal court after the insured obtained summary judgment in its favor in a declaratory judgment action regarding coverage under a policy.

The court noted that, under the Declaratory Judgment Act, an insured was compelled to bring a declaratory judgment action to establish the carrier’s duty to defend an action brought by a third party may recover attorney’s fees incurred in the declaratory judgment action if the carrier has refused to defend the action in bad faith.

The court, based upon the record before it, did not find that the carrier’s initial denial of coverage was in bad faith or was otherwise frivolous. As such, the request for the payment of fees and costs in this action in which it appeared to the court that the carrier had properly sought declaratory relief, was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Lee Applebaum of the Philadelphia office of Fineman, Krekstein & Harris for bringing this case to my attention. Attorney Applebaum is the writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law blog which can viewed HERE.



Source of image:  photo by Karolina Grabowska from www.pexels.com.

Thursday, September 9, 2021

Federal Judge Denies Motion For Summary Judgment Filed by Carrier on Coverage Issues Related to Alleged Fraternity Hazing Death

In the case of Nationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v. Dibileo, No. 3:19-CV-01003 (M.D. Pa. July 20, 2021 Brann, J.), the court denied a carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment in its Declaratory Judgment Action regarding issues of coverage under a homeowner’s insurance policy arising out of alleged actions by fraternity students in an alleged hazing death.   

The court found that the action filed by the decedent’s parents stated a claim for negligence.  The court found that policy provisions in the homeowner’s policy excluding coverage for criminal and intentional acts did not serve to insulate the carrier from the negligent claims asserted by the plaintiff in the underlying personal injury action. 


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source:  “Digest of Recent Opinions.”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 17, 2021). 


Tuesday, March 16, 2021

Insured Loses Fight for Coverage for a Fight


In the case of State Farm Fire and Cas. Co. v. Simone, No. 2:20-CV-00908-RJC (W.D.P. Jan. 28,2021 Colville, J.) County Court addressed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings filed by the liability insurance company seeking a declaratory judgment that the carrier did not have a duty to defend or indemnify the defendant with respect to allegations set forth in an underlying complaint arising out of an altercation during which the insured punched the injured party after they bumped into one another on a walkway at a crowded concert. 

After comparing the allegations in the Plaintiff’s complaint against the terms of the policy in question, the court ruled that the allegations in the complaint described a willful physical assault and an intentional tort for which there was no coverage under the policy. 


As such, the carrier’s motion for judgment on the pleadings was granted.


Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.


Monday, October 26, 2020

Eastern District Court Remands Motor Vehicle Accident Insurance Coverage Question Back to State Court


In the case of Gibbons v. Mid-Century Insurance Company, No. 20-3381 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 24, 2020 Kenney, J.), the Court granted a Motion to Remand a motor vehicle accident insurance coverage Declaratory Judgment action that was removed to federal court. 

The case arose out of a car accident where the minor children witnessed their father’s death as the family crossed a street as pedestrians. The insurance dispute focused on the ability of the children to receive coverage for claims of emotional distress. 

After the case was removed to federal court by the carrier, the Plaintiff filed a Motion to Remand and argued that the case should be remanded because the issue involved in the case has not been decided by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and was based exclusively upon state law. 

The carrier argued that the District Court should exercise jurisdiction because there was no other parallel state court case pending.

The District Court noted that, if it retained jurisdiction, it would need to determine “whether Pennsylvania law or public policy precludes an insurance policy from defining emotional distress injuries suffered by a bystander witnessing the death of a close relation as derivative of the injury sustained by the relation.” 

The District Court noted that the Pennsylvania courts have not reached a well-settled conclusion on the issue. As such, the Court exercised its discretion under the Federal Declaratory Judgment Act and chose to abstain from jurisdiction. Accordingly, the insured’s Motion to Remand was granted.

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harriburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, October 2, 2020

Injured Plaintiff's Desire To Recover on Defendant's Liability Coverage Not Sufficient to Support Intervention in a Coverage Action


In the case of Crum & Forster Specialty Ins. Co. v. American Diamond Builders, Inc., No. 20-1608 (E.D. Pa. July 31, 2020 Joyner, J.), the court denied a personal injury Plaintiff’s Motion to Intervene in a declaratory judgment action on coverage.

The court ruled that a personal injury Plaintiff with a potentially large claim against an insured Defendant does not have a cognizable legal interest in the insured Defendant’s insurance coverage that can support the Plaintiff’s effort to intervene in a coverage dispute between the liability carrier and its insured Defendant.

The court otherwise noted that the fact that a lawsuit may impede a Plaintiff’s ability to recover in a separate litigation is not a sufficient basis to support an intervention in the coverage action.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  Here is a LINK to the companion Order.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, October 1, 2020

Federal Western District Court of Pennsylvania Declines Jurisdiction Over Business Interruption Coverage Question


In the case of Venezie Sporting Goods, LLC v. Allied Ins. Co. of America, 2:20-CV-1066 (W.D. Pa. Sept. 23, 2020 Hornak, C.J.), the Western Federal District Court of Pennsylvania exercised its discretion to decline jurisdiction over a declaratory judgment action involving a business interruption coverage claim relative to the Covid-19 pandemic.

After review of the factors set out by the Third Circuit in the case of Reifer v. Westport Ins. Co., 751 F.3d 129 (3d Cir. 2014),to consider relative to the question of whether a federal district court should accept jurisdiction over a declaratory judgment action, the court in this matter granted the insured's motion to remand the matter to state court.

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA office of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this decision to my attention.

Monday, September 28, 2020

Home Hopping Daughter Found To Be Resident of Her Father's House For Car Insurance Coverage Purposes



In the case of apparent first impression, a Montgomery County judge ruled in the case of Erie Insurance Exchange v. Montesano, No. 2016-13318 (C.P. Montg. Co. Sept. 1, 2020 Rogers, J.), that a daughter who lived periodically in different relatives’ homes was considered to be a resident of her father's house and therefore covered under her father’s car insurance policy. As such, the court held that Erie Insurance could be held liable for $200,000.00 in coverage for injuries allegedly sustained by the daughter during a motor vehicle accident that occurred while she was traveling from her mother’s home in Florida to her grandparents’ home in Alabama. 
The Erie Insurance policy at issue belonged to the injured party’s father and stepmother. 

According to the Opinion, the injured party daughter lived with her father and stepmother for about 19 years before moving in with her mother in Florida. She then decided to move in with her grandparents in Alabama. 

The injured party’s movements among the residences apparently ended when the family members decided that she should move back to the home of her father and stepmother. Prior to her return, the subject accident occurred in which the daughter was injured and her mother was fatally injured. The injured party’s sister was driving the vehicle at the time, which vehicle belonged to the injured party’s mother. 

The family filed a claim with Erie on behalf of the injured daughter demanding the payment of the $200,000.00 policy limits. The carrier denied coverage because the injured party was not a “resident” of the father and stepmother’s home at the time of the accident. 

The court found that the central issue of the case was what constituted “physically living” with another “on a regular basis” under the terms of the policy. 

The court found that the injured party daughter had physically lived in her father and stepmother’s home for nineteen (19) years before departing with a carry-on bag and a few clothes, shoes, and toiletries, but leaving behind all of her other worldly possessions. 

The court ruled that the injured party daughter only lived as a house guest at both her mother’s trailer house in Florida and her grandmother’s house in Alabama. The court noted that the injured party’s previous visit to her mother and grandmother had been temporary and sporadic. The court found that the trip at issue was no different. 

The court otherwise noted that, although as a question of physical fact, the injured party was making her way from her grandmother’s home to her father’s home at the time of the accident, for all intents and purposes, the injured party’s true and permanent residence was her father’s home. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer P.C., for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, July 31, 2020

Issues of Fact Preclude Summary Judgment on Excess Coverage Issue



In the case of Farber v. Erie Insurance Exchange, No. 19-CV-2302 (C.P. Lacka. Co. July 8, 2020 Nealon, J.), the court addressed coverage issues pertaining to whether an excess/umbrella policy was precluded by an exclusion. In the end, after finding that the insurance company had not established its position in a fashion that was free and clear from any doubt, the carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment on the issues presented was denied. 

By way of background, a boat owner, who had been sued in a wrongful death lawsuit involving the use of his motorboat, instituted a coverage action against his excess/umbrella carrier asserting claim for breach of contract, declaratory judgment, bad faith, and violations of the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection law. 

According to the Opinion, the excess/umbrella policy contained a watercraft exclusion that provided temporary insurance coverage for watercraft “acquired during the policy period,” but that liability coverage “ceases” to exist, if notice is not given [by the insured] within thirty (30) days” of “the date of acquisition” of the watercraft.

According to the record before the court, the insured gained possession of the motorboat on August 5, 2017 and paid the seller for its purchase on August 18, 2017. 

The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania issued title to the boat in the insured’s name on September 6, 2017. 

The fatal motorboat accident occurred on September 26, 2017. 

The carrier filed a Motion for Summary Judgment arguing that the insured has “acquired” the motorboat when he took custody of it on August 5, 2017 and asserted that, as such, the excess/umbrella coverage was allegedly precluded by the watercraft exclusion since the thirty (30) day temporary coverage purportedly lapsed on September 4, 2017, which would have been several weeks before the subject incident. 

Judge Nealon noted that the carrier had drafted the policy in utilized words such as “acquired” and “acquisition,” rather than words like “possessed” or even “purchased,” in establishing the dates for commencement and cessation of temporary liability coverage for watercrafts. 

The court also noted that the terms utilized by the carrier in the policy were not defined within the policy. 

Turning to ordinary dictionary definitions of the undefined words led the court to conclude that the words used by the carrier mean gaining “ownership” or the “power of disposal” of the watercraft. 

The court also noted that the state regulations indicate that a purchaser of a boat becomes the lawful owner upon obtaining title to the boat. 

Since the court found that different interpretations of the terms at issue gave rise to an ambiguity, and since Pennsylvania law requires that all ambiguities be construed in favor of the insured, Judge Nealon found that the carrier had not established, in a fashion that was free and clear from doubt, that the carrier was entitled to judgement on the question of coverage. As such, the Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the carrier was denied. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Thursday, June 11, 2020

Court Finds No Duty to Defend Owed by Liability Carrier Where Daughter Did Not Reside with Insured Mother




In the case of Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. v. Hansen, No. 2019-0968-Civil (C.P. Lawr. Co. April 14, 2020 Cox, J.), the court granted summary judgment in favor of an auto insurance carrier arising out of a Declaratory Judgment Action regarding a coverage dispute for liability coverage given residency issues with respect to the daughter of the insured policyholder.

In this case, the insured’s daughter was involved in an accident while driving her uncle’s vehicle. The injured parties filed suit and pursued liability insurance proceeds from the uncle’s policy, as well as the policy purchased by the insured daughter’s mother. The theory against the mother’s carrier was that the daughter should have been deemed a “resident relative” of her mother's residence, thus entitling the daughter to coverage.

The carrier argued that (1) the daughter/driver denied that she resided with her mother in written discovery responses, (2) both the daughter and mother both testified at their respective depositions that they did not reside together, and (3) the record showed that the mother had removed her daughter from her policy three weeks before the accident.

In its Opinion, the Court found the terms of the applicable insurance policy to be clear and unambiguous. 

The Court went on to note the distinction between domicile and residence, and found that there was no dispute that the insured’s daughter had moved to Florida to live with her brother prior to the accident. Although she returned to Pennsylvania numerous times, the record confirmed that it was never with the intent to change her residence.

As such, summary judgment was granted in favor of the carrier, and it was held as a matter of law that the mother’s insurer did not owe defense or indemnification to the daughter arising out of the accident.

Anyone wishing to review the Court’s decision in this matter may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Aaron H.Weiss of the Pittsburgh law firm of Zimmer Kunz, P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, December 23, 2019

Court Rules That Artful Pleading Cannot Defeat Exclusions Applicable Under Homeowner's Policy



In the case of Carrasquillo v. Kelly and Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co., No. 2720 EDA 2018 (Pa. Super. Nov. 12, 2019 Panella, P.J., Kunselman, J., and Stevens, J.E.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.)(Non-precedential decision), the court addressed issues pertaining to a declaratory judgment action under a homeowner’s policy.

According to the Opinion, the Nationwide insured fatally shot and killed the Plaintiff’s decedent in the insured’s home. The insured later pled guilty to a charge of murder in the third degree. Thereafter, the decedent’s family pursued a wrongful death and survival action.

In response, Nationwide, the carrier who provided homeowner’s coverage on the home where the incident occurred, denied coverage under the intentional acts exclusion and the criminal acts exclusion. A declaratory judgment action was filed to address these issues.

In this declaratory judgment action, the Plaintiff attempted to argue that it had pled negligence allegations in the underlying Complaint such that the exclusions were not applicable. The court disagreed and noted that artful pleading did not serve to avoid the exclusions in this matter.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Benjamin P. Novak of the Lancaster, PA law firm of Fowler, Hirtzel, McNulty & Spaulding for bringing this case to my attention.