Showing posts with label FELA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FELA. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Court Addresses Statute of Limitations Under Federal Employers' Liability Act


In the case of Loomis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Co., Inc., No. 17-CV-5421 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 12, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment based, in part, on the three (3) year statute of limitations under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (“FELA”).

In this matter, the Plaintiff filed suit under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act alleging that her husband contracted cancer and later died from continuous exposure to toxic substances during his railroad employment and due to the railroad employer’s failure to provide a reasonably safe work environment.

According to the record before the court, the decedent was first diagnosed with cancer in 2007 and later died in 2014.

In response to the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment on the statute of limitations issues, the court found that neither the decedent nor his widow was ever advised by any healthcare professional, railroad representative, or any other person that the cancer was possibly related to the decedent’s railroad work or his exposure to toxic substances. Rather, the evidence indicated that a potential causal connection between the decedent’s cancer and his job was first mentioned to the widow by a co-worker of the decedent in the same year that she commenced a lawsuit.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source of image:  Photo by Tom Barrett on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Judge Nealon Reviews Frye Expert Standard in FELA Case

In another FELA decision in the case of Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Co. Inc., No. 2005-CV-1826 (C.P. Feb. 12, 2013 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed a Frye motion filed by the railroad Defendants to bar the opinion of the Plaintiff’s expert.  

As you may recall from prior posts, these consolidated cases involve former railroad workers seeking to recover damages under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C. §51-60, for black lung disease allegedly caused by occupational exposure to coal dust.  

In this particular matter, the Defendants filed a Frye motion asserting that the Plaintiffs’ pulmonary expert admitted under oath during his trial deposition that he did not observe the generally accepted methodology for diagnosing pneumoconiosis (black lung disease), such that the expert’s opinion should be deemed to be inadmissible under the standard set forth in the Frye decision.  

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County
Judge Nealon granted the Defendant’s Motion after noting that, during his trial testimony, the Plaintiffs’ expert identified the generally accepted methodology for diagnosing black lung disease but acknowledged that he did not follow that methodology in formulating his opinions.  

The Court also noted that the expert’s opinions were not supported by any generally accepted diagnostic criteria. Accordingly, the testimony was ruled inadmissible under Frye and Pa. R.C.P.  207.1.   The Court therefore granted the Defendant’s Frye motion and ruled that the expert’s testimony was inadmissible.  

Judge Nealon’s opinion provides a thorough review of the standard set forth under Frye v. United States, 293 F. 1013 (D.C. Cir. 1923) for the evaluation of novel scientific evidence being offered by an expert.  

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.  Given the number of decisions issued in this matter, please reference Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway (Frye standard) when requesting this Opinion.

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Several Issues Under Federal Employers' Liability Act (FELA)

Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas recently addressed a number of different issues in several opinions in the context of consolidated actions brought under the Federal Employers' Liability Act (FELA).  Below are summaries of the recent decisions:


Enforceability of Releases

In his recent January 25, 2013 decision in the case of Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc., No. 2005-CV-1826 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 25, 2013 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed a railroad Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment seeking to dismiss four lawsuits by its former employees under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (“FELA”).   The railroad Defendants asserted that release agreements that were excluded by the employees at issue barred their actions seeking to recover damages for black lung disease allegedly caused by coal dust exposure.
 
In his decision, Judge Nealon noted that, under the more stringent more federal standard governing the enforceability of releases under the FELA, the language of the settlement  release is strong, but not conclusive, evidence of the parties’ intent and the critical inquiry is what employment-related risks were known to the railroad employees at the time they signed their earlier releases.  
 
Ultimately, the court in this matter held that, in light of the more demanding standard applicable to FELA releases, it was a jury question as to whether the Claimants were aware of their black lung disease and its relation to occupational coal dust exposure at the time they executed their releases.   As such, the railroad Defendant’s Motions for Summary Judgment were denied.  
 
In his Opinion, Judge Nealon provides a thorough overview of the validity of FELA releases making this Opinion one to have if you are faced with such issues.  
 
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.  Please reference this case as Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway (Enforceability of Releases).  



FELA's Statute of Limitations

In yet another decision issued by Judge Terrence R. Nealon in the case of Fraynert v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc., No. 2005-Civil-2822 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 31, 2013 Nealon, J)(consolidated with Dennis case), Judge Terrence R. Nealon addressed another issue arising under six (6) consolidated claims brought pursuant to the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C. §51-60.   In this particular Opinion, the court addressed FELA’s three year statute of limitations. 

The cases all involve alleged pulmonary injuries that were allegedly negligently caused by occupational exposure to coal dust.  

This particular issue came before the Court by way of Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the Railroad Defendants in all six (6) cases.  In their Motion, the Defendants asserted that the occupational exposure claims were barred by FELA’s three year statute of limitations. 

Ultimately, Judge Nealon granted the Railroad’s Motion for Summary Judgment as to one Plaintiff based upon the federal version of the “discovery rule.”  The court found that jury questions on the issues presented remained in the other five (5) cases and the Motions for Summary Judgment were denied in those cases.

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may shoot me an email at dancummins@comcast.net.   Given the number of Opinions I have in this case, to assist me in locating and send to you this particular decision, please reference Fraynert v. Delaware and Hudson Railway (statute of limitations under discovery rule). 



New Matter//Affirmative Defenses
 
In yet another Opinion arising out of the railroad/FELA cases pending before the court, Judge Terrence R. Nealon addressed the need to assert affirmative defenses in order that such defenses may not be waived in the case of Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc., No. 2005-Civil-1826 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Feb. 8, 2013 Nealon, J.).  

In this particular opinion, Judge Nealon addressed another Motion for Summary Judgment by the railroad Defendant in this action under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C. §51-60.

In this case, the Defendant argued that an Asset Purchase Agreement (APA) under which it acquired substantially all of the assets of the former Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, barred the Plaintiff’s suits seeking to recover non-economic damages for alleged pulmonary injuries negligently caused by occupational exposure to dust.   The railroad Defendants contended that, under the terms of the APA, it did not assume liability for the FELA claims at issue involving occupational exposures during the periods of the Plaintiffs’ employment with the former Delaware and Hudson Railway Company.  

However, Judge Nealon ruled that the Defendant’s summary judgment argument based upon the Asset Purchase Agreement raised extrinsic facts which, if true, would defeat Plaintiffs’ FELA claims even if the allegations contained in their Complaints were accepted as true.   Accordingly, this argument was found to constitute affirmative defense that was waived unless timely raised in a new matter pursuant to Pa. R.C.P.  1030(a).   Since the pleadings filed by the Defendants in these cases never asserted the affirmative defense based upon the Asset Purchase Agreement, the Defendant waived that defense and was, therefore, not entitled to summary judgment based upon the Asset Purchase Agreement.

Judge Nealon’s Opinion provides a thorough overview of the law pertaining to affirmative defenses and the waiver of those defenses that are required to be pled under Pa. R.C.P.  1030.   The Opinion also cautions that Rule 1030(a) list but does not limit what may be pled as a New Matter and, as such, there are other affirmative defenses not listed as Rule 1030 that could be deemed to be a waivable defense.  
 
For example, the Court cites cases noting that the following affirmative defenses can be deemed to be waivable in particular cases:  Abandonment, Rescission, and a defense which is premised upon a contractual limitation or provision.  

As such, this Opinion emphasizes the importance of raising all possible defenses in the New Matter even if they are not listed as affirmative defenses in Pa. R.C.P.  1030(a).   The import of this rule is not limited to FELA cases.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.   Given the number of Opinions issued by the Court in this particular case, when requesting a copy of this case, please reference Dennis v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc. (affirmative defenses).

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Judge Nealon Addresses Lack of Expert in FELA Claim

In the case of Mullin v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc., No. 2005-Civil-3088 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 15, 2012 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas dismissed a Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA) claim alleging occupational exposure pulmonary damage on the grounds that the proof of medical causation was insufficient as a matter of law.

In this matter, the Plaintiff filed suit against his former employer, Defendant, Delaware and Hudson Railway Company, Inc., d/b/a Canadian Pacific Railway a/k/a CP Rail System alleging permanent pulmonary damage as a result of prolonged exposure to dust during the course of his employment as a conductor. 

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County
 This case came before the Court by way of a Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the Defendant in which the Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff had not produced an expert report from a medical witness opining that the Plaintiff had developed any pulmonary condition due to heavy dust exposure, and, as such, the Plaintiff was unable to satisfy his burden of proof under the FELA.

Judge Nealon noted that, in order to prevail on a claim under the FELA, Plaintiff must prove: (1) that the Defendant was a common carrier by railroad engaged in interstate commerce; (2) that the Plaintiff was employed by Defendant and assigned to perform duties that further such commerce; (3) that Plaintiff’s injuries were sustained while the Plaintiff was employed by the common carrier; and (4) that the Plaintiff’s injuries resulted from the Defendant’s negligence. [citations omitted].

The Court also noted that FELA claims are subject to a relaxed standard of causation which standard provides for a recovery if the employee’s negligence played any part, no matter how small, in bringing about the employee’s injury. [citations omitted]. Judge Nealon noted that, in light of this liberal burden of proof, a Court was justified in granting summary judgment “only in those extremely rare instances where there is 0 probability either of employer negligence or that any such negligence contributed to the injury of the employee.” [citation omitted].

After applying the record before him to the applicable law, Judge Nealon ruled that, where the Plaintiff neglected to produce an expert medical report substantiating, or even addressing, his occupational exposure claim, the Motion for Summary Judgment should be granted. The Court also noted that this particular Plaintiff had never been deposed in this matter which was consolidated with a number of other matters, and there was no record indicating that this particular Plaintiff had ever been diagnosed with a pulmonary alignment or that any such alleged condition was in any way attributable to his occupation.

Judge Nealon further noted this particular Plaintiff had “not identified a scintilla of medical proof” or “an iota of medical evidence” in support of the causation element and, as such, based upon the record before the Court there was indeed a “zero probability” that any negligence by the Defendant employer contributed to any alleged pulmonary injury allegedly suffered by the Plaintiff.

Accordingly, summary judgment was granted.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion by Judge Nealon in the case of Mullin may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.