Showing posts with label Judge Carlucci. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Judge Carlucci. Show all posts

Friday, June 26, 2026

Court Finds That Determination of Whether Plaintiff Was an Invitee, Licensee, or Trespasser is for the Jury


In the case Martin v. Cable Services Co., Inc., No. CV-2025-00988 (C.P. Lyc. Co. April 23, 2026 Carlucci, J.), the court denied Preliminary Objections filed by various Defendants in a premises liability case involving the death of the Plaintiff. One of the Defendants involved was charged with criminal homicide.

According to the Opinion, an incident took place at the business premises of Cable Services Co., Inc. which resulted in the death of the Plaintiff’s decedent. As a result of that incident and death, one of the Defendants was charged with criminal homicide. No more details regarding the facts of the incident were provided in the Opinion.

This Opinion addressed various Preliminary Objections filed by certain Defendants against the Complaint. The Defendants essentially asserted that the Plaintiff’s reference to a corporate safety manual in the Complaint was insufficient to establish any duty owed to the decedent because the decedent was not an employee of Cable Services on the date of the incident.

The Defendants additionally asserted that the allegations in the Plaintiff’s Complaint failed to establish that the decedent was a public invitee to whom the Defendants owed a duty of care.

Judge William P. Carlucci
Lycoming County


Judge William P. Carlucci noted that he was declining to determine whether or not the Defendants owed a duty of care to the decedent at this Preliminary Objections stage. The court noted that, generally speaking, in premises liability cases, the determination of whether an individual is an invitee, licensee, or trespasser is a question of fact for the jury.

The court also noted that the issues of foreseeability with respect to the harm suffered by the decedent is also ordinarily a question of fact for the jury.

As such, the various Preliminary Objections filed by the Defendant were overruled.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (May 28, 2026).

Tuesday, June 23, 2026

Judge Allows Trip And Fall Case To Proceed Beyond Summary Judgment


In the case of Bonnell v. Knight-Confer Funeral Home, Inc., No. CV0-2023-01345 (C.P. Lyc. Co. March 23, 2026 Carlucci, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a trip and fall case based upon the expert opinion of the Plaintiff’s expert engineer creating questions of fact to be decided decision by the jury.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff allegedly tripped and fell on a step on the Defendant’s premises. During her deposition, the Plaintiff did not assert that there was any debris on the step where she fell,  Nor did the Plaintiff point to any defect in the step itself.

Rather, the Plaintiff testified that she opened the door and thought she was stepping onto the sidewalk and, as a result, missed the step and fell.

The Defendant filed a Motion for Summary Judgment arguing that the complete absence of any debris or any defects with regards to the step confirm that there was no material evidence upon which a jury could base any finding of negligence. The Defendant additionally pointed out that the Plaintiff had traveled over the same step on her way into the building without incident.

The Plaintiff’s opposition to the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment was based, in part, on the fact that the Plaintiff produced an expert engineering report. That expert offered an opinion that the single step condition at the threshold of the doorway created a hazardous condition which endangered the public. The expert further concluded that the actions and/or inactions of the Plaintiff did not cause the incident to occur. The expert otherwise noted that the step was below the normal line of sight and the Plaintiff was therefore unable to perceive it as she exited the doorway.

After reviewing the record before him as applied to Pennsylvania law, the judge noted that, if the jury believed the testimony of the Plaintiff’s engineering expert, a jury could reasonably find that the condition at the threshold of the doorway was a hazardous condition which endangered the Plaintiff and that the Plaintiff’s own conduct was not a legal cause of her injuries. 

Accordingly, the court denied the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment and allowed the case to proceed forward.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (May 28, 2026).


Source of image:  Photo by Becca Lavin on www.unsplash.com.

Wednesday, June 17, 2026

Court Allows Plaintiff's Expert To Testify in Medical Malpractice Case


In the case of Pratt v. Shahid, No. CV-23-00720 (C.P. Lyc. Co. April 14, 2026 Carlucci, J.), the court denied the Defendants’ Motion In Limine seeking to preclude the Plaintiff from introducing the testimony of a doctor in a medical malpractice case.

In this case, the court denied the Defendants’ request for an exclusion of the Plaintiff’s medical expert’s testimony given that the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion was found to be supported by medical literature.

The court also noted that the Defendants’ challenge went to the Plaintiff’s expert’s conclusions rather than the methodology utilized by the expert. 

The court found that the Plaintiff’s expert’s methodology was not novel, as it was similar to the methodology used by the Defendants’ expert. The court further noted that, even if the Plaintiff’s methodology was considered to be novel, it was still generally accepted in the scientific community as supported by articles from scientific journals submitted by the Plaintiff.

In the end, the court ruled that, while the Plaintiff’s expert’s conclusions differed from those advanced by the Defendants’ expert, that difference is not a proper basis for excluding the testimony of the Plaintiff’s expert.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (May 28, 2026). 


Thursday, December 11, 2025

Trial Court Judge Orders Opening of a Snap Default Judgment


In the case of Susquehanna Legal Aid For Adults & Youth v. Winkleman, No. CV-2024-01041 (C.P. Lyc. Co. Sept. 23, 2025 Carlucci, J.), Judge William P. Carlucci of the Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas granted a Plaintiff’s Petition to Open a Defendant’s default judgment filed relative to the Defendant’s counterclaim where the court found that the Defendants had entered a “snap” default judgment.

In ruling upon the Plaintiff’s Petition to Open and/or Strike the default judgment, the court reviewed the standard of review which required the court to determine (1) whether the default was excusable; (2) whether the parties seeking to open the judgment has shown a meritorious defense or claim, and (3) whether the Petition to Open has been promptly filed.

The court also noted that it “sincerely believe[d]” that the Rules of Civil Procedure are not intended to become a “bag of tricks.” See Op. at 5. 

In so noting, the court also referred to Pa. R.C.P. 126 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure that requires the rules to be liberally applied to secure the just, speedy and inexpensive determination of every action. Judge Carlucci noted that, under that rule, a court is, at every stage of the action, permitted to disregard any error or defect of procedure that does not affect the substantive rights of the parties.

Judge William P. Carlucci
Lycoming County 


Judge Carlucci additionally noted that it is the well-settled law of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania that “snap judgments” are heavily disfavored.

According to the record before the court in this case, forty-one (41) minutes after the Defendants electronically filed their default judgment on their counterclaim against the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff had electronically filed their Preliminary Objections to the Defendants’ counterclaim.

Judge Carlucci noted that, had counsel for the Defendants made any effort to contact counsel for the Plaintiff before taking the default judgment, counsel for the Defendant would have learned that a responsive pleading was only minutes away from being filed.

Based upon the record before the court, the court found that the Petition to Open or Strike was promptly filed and was worthy of being granted. As such, the court opened the default judgment and directed the Plaintiff to file its responsive pleading.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Nov. 6, 2025).

Monday, October 6, 2025

Issues of Fact Preclude Summary Judgment Against Landlord-Out-Of Possession In Parking Lot Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Alexander v. ECM Realty Management, Inc., No. CV 24-00061 (C.P. Lyc. Co. 2025 Carlucci, J.), the court denied a Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case involving ice and/or snow in a parking lot area.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff slipped and fell at the rear of a property that her husband rented from the Defendants. The Plaintiff had previously been a tenant of the same premises.

The court noted that, while it was apparently undisputed that the Defendants were landlords out-of-possession of the apartment, the Plaintiff was maintaining that the Defendants retained control over the parking lot area.

In this matter, the court agreed that, where a landlord leases out some areas of a property, but retains control over others, a landlord may be found negligent in the maintenance of the areas over which the landlord retained control. 

Here, however, the court noted the record was clear that the Defendants were landlords out-of-possession relative to the apartment.

The dispute in this matter was whether the parking space where the Plaintiff slipped and fell should be considered a portion of the leased apartment under the control of the tenant, or a “common area” over which the landlord Defendant had retained control.

The court found that the issues of fact in this regard prevented the entry of summary judgment. As such, the Defendant's Motion was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Aug. 14, 2025).


Source of image:  Photo by Erik McLean on www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, September 4, 2025

Trial Court Gives Lessons on Medical Malpractice Complaint Drafting


In the case of Dawes v. The Williamsport Home, No. 2025-CV-00381 (C.P. Lyc. Co. June 6, 2025 Carlucci, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part Preliminary Objections filed against a Plaintiff’s claim in a medical malpractice case arising out of alleged negligent care regarding the Plaintiff’s thoracic surgical wound.

According to the Opinion, the court denied the Defendant’s demurrer to the Plaintiffs’ claim for punitive damages but still directed the Plaintiff to file an Amended Complaint which either deletes any claim for punitive damages or sets forth sufficient material allegations in support of the same.

Relative to any claims against any agents or employees of the medical Defendants the court directed that the Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint should limit allegations regarding the acts or omissions by a Defendant or its agent or employees to that conduct that the Plaintiff contends was a substantial factor in causing the Plaintiff’s injuries. In this regard, the court directed the Plaintiff to not include any extraneous allegations not pertinent to the causation issues. 

The court also required the Plaintiff to provide additional factual support and allegations on the claims for corporate liability.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert,” www.Law.com (Aug. 7, 2025).

Friday, September 6, 2024

No Duty of Care Created by Simply Giving a Thumbs Up To Proceed With Cutting Down a Tree


In the case of Miller v. Kinley, No. 22-00349 (C.P. Lyc. Co. June 18, 2024 Carlucci, J.), the court granted a Defendant summary judgment based on a finding that simply given a Plaintiff a “thumbs up” signal during the course of cutting down a tree did not create a duty of care by that Defendant when the tree that the Plaintiff was cutting fell on the Plaintiff.

In this case, the Plaintiff alleged that the Defendants had granted him permission to cut down trees on their property. The Plaintiff alleged that one Defendant, who had transported the Plaintiff to the property, agreed to assist in the removal of the trees by acting as a spotter and a safety coordinator.

The court noted that the Plaintiff failed to support this allegation with his deposition testimony.

The Defendant at issue filed a Motion for Summary Judgment. The court found that the Defendant was entitled to summary judgment because there was no genuine issue of material fact as to any duty owed by that Defendant to the Plaintiff. The court found that no reasonable jury could find that, by giving the Plaintiff a “thumbs up” signal, that Defendant assumed as duty of care to ensure that the Plaintiff safely cut down the tree and stay out of its way as it fell.

Judge Carlucci noted that, under the common law of Pennsylvania, absent a special relationship between the parties, there is no duty to control the conduct of a third party to protect another from harm.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert” Law.com (Aug. 22, 2024).

Thursday, July 11, 2024

Issues of Fact Preclude Summary Judgment in Case of Fall Through Porch Railing


In the case of Rockey v. Stearns, No. CV-2022-00791 (C.P. Lyc. Co. Feb. 29, 2024 Carlucci, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a case where a Plaintiff allegedly fell off of a porch when the railing broke loose from a structural post and collapsed.

The court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment after finding that there were genuine issues of material fact to be considered by a jury.

More specifically, the court noted that the fact that the railing collaposed allegedly under only a light load, and given the condition of the railing as described by the Plaintiffs, there was support in the records that a jury could find that the railing was in a defective condition.

The court also noted that, the fact that the railing had been repaired earlier, and that the homeowner had owned the home for forty (40) years, supported a possible conclusion by a jury that the homeowner had either actual or constructive notice of the allegedly defective condition of the railing.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: Law.com, “The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert” (June 5, 2024).




Monday, July 1, 2024

Court Addresses Proper Method of Serving Out-of-State Defendants


In the case of Morgan v. Compton, No. CV-22-01100 (C.P. Lyc. Co. Carlucci, J.), the court found that a pro se Defendant satisfied the three prongs required to open a default judgment entered against him on a Plaintiff’s Complaint for personal injuries.

According to the Complaint, the parties were formerly in a romantic relationship. With regards to that relationship, the Plaintiff filed a three (3) Count Complaint alleging various personal injury allegations against the Defendant, who resided in California.

The court confirmed that the Plaintiff mailed the Complaint to the Defendant by certified mail but the certified mail was returned marked “unclaimed.”

The Plaintiff then mailed the Complaint to the Defendant by regular mail, which was not returned.

Thereafter, the Plaintiff mailed the Defendant a Notice of Intention to take a Default Judgment by first class mail and certified mail. The certified mail envelope was returned as unclaimed.

No responsive pleading was filed by the Defendant thereafter. A default judgment was then entered.

When the Plaintiff requested a trial on damages, the Defendant attended a conference by telephone and advised the court that he intended to defend the case.

Thereafter, the Defendant filed a Petition to Open the Default Judgment and the court held a hearing by Zoom. The Defendant claimed that he mailed a written response to the Complaint but that filing did not appear in the court file.

Judge Carlucci ruled that Pa. R.C.P. 4003 and 4004 governed service by mail on out-of-state parties. Under those Rules, if service by mail is returned as unclaimed, then the Plaintiff must make service by another means that does not include ordinary mail.

The court found that, at the time the default judgment was entered, the court lacked jurisdiction over the Defendant due to a lack of any completion of service of process.

The court also found that the Defendant had promptly filed a Petition to Open a Default Judgment, had explained the reasons for the delay due to the improper service, and had alleged not only a defense of improper service under Rule 403 but had also denied the allegations in the Complaint.

As such, the court granted the Defendant’s Petition to Open the Default Judgment and the ordered the Defendant to file an Answer within twenty (20) days.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: Law.com, “The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert” (May 22, 2024).

Source of image:  Photo by Abstrakt XXcelence studios on www.pexels.com.

Tuesday, September 12, 2023

Leash That Puppy: Violation of Dog Law Amounts To Negligence Per Se, But Plaintiff Must Still Prove Causation


In the case of Goodell v. Stroble, No. 22-00906 (C.P. Lyc. Co. July 26, 2023 Carlucci, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part a Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a dog bite case.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant dog owner attended an estate sale. The subject incident occurred when the Defendant was putting her purchases in her vehicle and her dog jumped out of the vehicle and allegedly attacked the nearby Plaintiff.

The Plaintiff filed a Motion for Summary Judgment arguing that the Defendant’s failure to restrain her dog on a leash or within the vehicle violated the Dog Law, making the Defendant negligent as a matter of law on a negligence per se basis.

While the court agreed that Pennsylvania law requires owners to control their dogs and that a deliberate violation of the Dog Law does constitute negligence per se, claims of absolute liability as a result can still be defended if a Defendant provides an appropriate defense.

In this regard, the court noted that there still remained the crucial question as to whether or not the dog owner’s negligence was the proximate cause of the Plaintiff’s injuries. The court explained that proximate cause refers to a direct link between a Defendant’s actions and a Plaintiff’s harm.

The court emphasized that the question of proximate cause generally remains a question to be decided by a jury.

As such, the court granted the Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment in part and denied it in part. More specifically, the court ruled that the Defendant’s conduct in this case was negligent per se under the Dog Law violation. However, the motion was denied in part on the question of proximate causation.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 15, 2023).


Source of image:  Photo by Blue Bird on www.pexels.com.

Monday, August 28, 2023

Plaintiff Granted Leave to Amend To Try To Plead Punitive Damages in a Dog Bite Case


In the case of Jennings v. Lycoming County SPCA, No. CV23-00512 (C.P. Lyc. Co. July 20, 2023 Carlucci, J.), the court struck a Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages in a dog bite but allowed the Plaintiff the right to amend.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was in the lobby of a local SPCA when she was allegedly attacked by a Terrier named “Peanut.” 

The Plaintiff alleged that the dog had been previously adopted by a family, but returned to the SPCA, after biting a child in that family. The Plaintiff also alleged that the dog previously bit a SPCA employee and that, therefore, the SPCA had actual knowledge that the dog was dangerous.

In his Opinion, Judge Carlucci noted that he was not satisfied that the facts alleged in the Plaintiff's Amended Complaint were sufficient to show that the Defendant's conduct demonstrated a reckless indifference to the interests of others.  However, as noted, the Court granted the Plaintiff leave to try again in another Amended Complaint.    

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 15, 2023).

Photo by Victor Grabarczyk on www.unsplash.com.