Showing posts with label Deposition Sanctions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Deposition Sanctions. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 27, 2023

Trial Court Provides Instruction on Scope of Ability of Deponent's Attorney To Properly Interject at a Deposition



In the case of Early Bird Carwash, Inc. v. Piermattei, No.  (C.P. Lyc. Co. Sept. 18, 2023 Linhardt, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part discovery motions filed by both parties in a legal malpractice action.

Of note, the court granted the Plaintiffs’ Motion to Reconvene a Deposition after defense counsel was found to have obdurately and acrimoniously interrupted Plaintiffs’ attorney’s initial attempt at a deposition by way of the defense counsel engaging in continual, repeated objections that were found to be meant to obstruct the course of the deposition.

The court noted that a deposition is meant to be a question-and-answer conversation between the deposing attorney and the witness.

With that in mind, the court noted that the deposing lawyer is entitled to pursue a chosen line of questioning without improper interjections by the witness’s attorney.

Judge Linhardt noted that an attorney for the deposition witness should not act as an intermediary by interpreting questions, deciding which questions the witness should answer, and/or by helping the witness to formulate answers.

In this matter, the court found that the attorney for the Defendants repeatedly and continuously interrupted the deposition testimony by interposing objections, instructing the witness not to answer questions, and otherwise providing commentary on the questions presented and the exhibits being utilized.

The court admonished that the defense attorney’s clear intent was to prevent Plaintiffs’ attorney from pursing his line of inquiry and the deposition from taking its natural course.

The court found that the conduct of defense counsel was obdurate but not necessarily acrimonious, and that defense counsel’s conduct ultimately prejudiced the Plaintiffs by repeatedly and unnecessarily interrupting the deposition.

Accordingly, the court directed that the Defendants submit to a repeat deposition. Defense counsel was ordered to bear the cost of the same. The court also ordered the Defendants should present one or more witnesses properly prepared to answer questions on the designated topics. Additionally, counsel for the Defendant was told to keep interjections to a minimum. The court did decline to issue an award of attorney’s fees as a sanction.

In another Order in this decision, the court ordered the Defendant to provide responses to the Plaintiffs’ requests for discovery of an electronic records, or to explain the unavailability of the associated electronic storage media.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 21, 2023).

Monday, April 4, 2022

Speaking Objections At Depositions Addressed by Judge Terrence R. Nealon of Lackawanna County


In the case of The Fiduciary Trust Co. Int’l of Pa v. Geisinger-Community Medical Center, No. 20-CV-4775 (C.P. Lacka. Co. March 4, 2022 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon tackled the issue of speaking objections during the course of depositions that were conducted in this medical malpractice action.

According to the Opinion, after a nurse who was being deposed had demonstrated an understanding of information on fetal monitoring strips and had defined certain medical terms in that regard during her testimony, a Plaintiff’s attorney displayed the fetal monitoring strips to the nurse and attempted to question her regarding the findings on the same.

The record before the court revealed that, following suggestive interjections by her counsel, the nurse, who had worked as a labor and delivery nurse for almost 40 years until her retirement in 2008, indicated that she did not know if she would be able interpret the fetal monitoring strips satisfactorily.

When the Plaintiff’s attorney then attempted to explore the nurse’s ability to review and comprehend the strips, the nurse’s attorney objected and instructed the nurse not to answer any questions regarding the fetal monitoring strips.

In response, the Plaintiff filed a discovery motion seeking to compel the nurse to answer the questions presented. Plaintiff’s counsel also sought monetary sanctions due for requiring the Plaintiff to file this Motion.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County


After reviewing Pennsylvania law on the issues presented, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas noted that the Plaintiff was entitled to adequately probe the legitimacy and extent of any claimed incompetency by the nurse deponent regarding her ability to read or understand the fetal monitoring strips. The court noted that the issue of whether the nurse’s claim that she had no such abilities should be left to the jury to determine.

In so ruling, the court noted that counsel for a deponent “may direct the witness not to answer a specific question only if that instruction is necessary to (a) protect a recognized privilege, (b) enforce an evidentiary limitation established by an earlier court ruling in the case, or (c) present a motion for a protective order based upon grounds identified in Pa. R.C.P. 4012(a).

The court found that the instruction issued in this case by the attorney to the witness not to answer the Plaintiff’s questions were not based on any of the above noted reasons and, as such, the court granted the Plaintiff counsel fees incurred in preparing and presenting the discovery motion. 

The court also directed the nurse to submit to an additional deposition within the next thirty (30) days to answer the questions regarding her interpretation of the fetal monitoring strips and her ability to do so.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Scott B. Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.

Photo by Andrea Piacquadio from www.pexels.com.

Wednesday, March 27, 2019

Discovery Sanctions Result in Dismissal of Case


In the case of Rivera v. The City of Reading, No. 16-4957 (C.P. Berks Co. Jan. 8, 2019 Rawley, J.), Judge Timothy J. Rawley of the Berks County Court of Common Pleas issued a Rule 1925 Opinion in support of his decision to dismiss the Plaintiff’s case as a discovery sanction given the Plaintiff’s repeated failures to engage in the discovery process.   

Judge Rawley noted that the dismissal of the case followed multiple Motions to Compel and for Sanctions, as well as a prior Order of Court specifically warning the Plaintiff of severe sanctions for continued noncompliance.  

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a fatal motor vehicle accident.   The Plaintiff followed a wrongful death and survival action alleging that the City was responsible for a large pothole on a city street.  

In his Opinion, Judge Rawley outlined the various discovery violations by the Plaintiff particularly relative to the Plaintiff’s failure to appear at depositions and in other respects.  

Judge Rawley noted that, generally speaking, the imposition of sanctions for a party’s failure to comply with discovery is subject to the discretion of the trial court as is the severity of this sanctions imposed.  

After reviewing the several factors to be considered in a sanctions motion, which included (1) the nature and the severity of the discovery violation, (2) the defaulting party’s willfulness or bad faith, (3) the prejudice to the opposing parties, (4) the ability to cure the prejudice, and, (5) the importance of the precluded evidence in light of the failure to comply, the trial court stated that the entry of a dismissal order was appropriate.   Judge Rawley noted that the Plaintiff’s discovery violations were severe, prolonged, and repeated.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Barrie B. Gehrlein of the Wyomissing, PA law office of Johnson Duffie, Stewart & Weidner for bringing this case to my attention.  

Tuesday, October 9, 2018

Judge Nealon Addresses Motion to Preclude Completion of Deposition Due to Deponent's Anxiety


Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas recently addressed a Motion for Protective Order to Preclude the Completion of a Deposition Due to the Deponent's Anxiety in the wrongful death medical malpractice case of Ezrin v. Hospice Preferred Choice, Inc., No. 16-CV-7103 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Oct. 3, 2018 Nealon, J.).

This case arose out of a negligence action pertaining to hospice care provided by a nursing home.

After a charge nurse's deposition was recessed when her anxiety disorder reportedly became exacerbated, and after a dispute arose over the conclusion of the deposition, the nursing home filed the motion for protective order at issue.

After reviewing the record provided to the court on the issue, Judge Nealon ruled that that nursing home had not met its burden of supporting its request that the deposition be adjourned and not recommenced.

In particular, the court noted that a physician's report submitted on behalf of the anxious nurse, the nurse's physician noted that the nurse did not feel at the time of the deposition that she could complete her deposition.  In his report, the doctor also noted his opinion that the deposition should be postponed, as opposed to prohibited, in order to allow the nurse's anxiety to be brought back under control.

The court also noted that the record confirmed that the nurse was employed full-time by the nursing home and was responsible for 30 patients during each shift.

Overall, the court concluded that the nursing home had failed to show "good cause" to permanently prevent the resumption of the deposition on the grounds of unreasonable burden, oppression, or annoyance.  As such, the motion for protective order was denied and the nursing home was directed to produce the nurse to complete her deposition prior to the expiration of the discovery deadline.

In his Opinion, Judge Nealon cautioned the attorneys, including the attorney for the nursing home, against interrupting the deposition process, particularly after a question is asked and before the witness answered.  The court cited to case law confirming that there is no need for an opposing attorney to act as an intermediary, interpreting the meaning of questions for the witness or engaging in other unnecessary interruptions, during the course of a deposition.

The court noted that a less disquieting atmosphere during the recommenced deposition of the nurse may assist in keeping her anxiety at bay.

This Opinion contains a nice recitation of the standard of review for addressing motions for protective orders under Pa.R.C.P. 4012.  The Opinion can be viewed at this LINK

Monday, April 9, 2018

Sanctions Issued in Pike County Case Due to Plaintiffs' Alleged Failure to Comply with Multiple Discovery Orders Compelling Completion of Depositions

Sanctions were granted against a Plaintiff in the Pike County Post-Koken auto accident case of Middaugh v. Horacek and State Farm Ins. Co., No. 691-2011 Civil (C.P. Pike Co. April 2, 2018 Miller, S.J.) due to the Plaintiff's alleged failure to cooperate with the defense efforts to complete the Plaintiff's deposition.  The motion for sanctions at issue was decided by visiting Judge Linda Wallach Miller of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas sitting by assignment in Pike County.

Due to the failure to complete depositions, each of the three named Plaintiffs were ordered to pay $1,000 each as a sanction and, as a further sanction, the Plaintiffs were additionally prohibited from providing any evidence at trial in support of a claim for damages.

According to the opinion, the case had been in litigation for six years over which the Pike County Court had issued two separate Orders compelling that depositions be completed within certain deadlines.  When such depositions were not completed, the defense filed the Motion for Sanctions at issue.

In her Opinion, Judge Miller reviewed the factors to be considered under Pa.R.C.P. 4019 when addressing a discovery motion for sanctions.

The court ultimately ruled that sanctions were warranted where the case had been pending for six years and where the Plaintiff's depositions had not been completed despite the issuance of two separate court orders compelling the same.

As the case makes for an interesting read, I provide this LINK to the Opinion.