Showing posts with label Nonsuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nonsuit. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 12, 2025

Superior Court Affirms Entry of Nonsuit Where Trial Court Precluded Plaintiff's Liability Expert For Giving a 'More Likely Than Not' Expert Opinion


In the case of Peterson v. Stacy’s Pizza, Inc., 315 EDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Jan. 14, 2025 Dubow, J., Sullivan, J., and Olson, J.) (Op. by Dubow, J.; Olson, J, concurring), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the entry of a nonsuit entered by the lower court after finding that the Plaintiffs did not meet their burden of proving the case presented.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was allegedly injured when he was hit by a swinging door while making a delivery.  The Plaintiff retained a liability expert to testify at trial on a opinion on whether the door in question was defective.   

In this decision, the Pennsylvania Superior Court again confirmed that an expert opinion on causation to a reasonable degree of engineering certainty that the condition on the Defendant’s property “more likely than not” caused the Plaintiff’s injury was properly excluded by the trial court as not actually being an expert opinion to a reasonable degree of certainty.

The court noted that the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion only stated that the Defendant’s improper maintenance was more likely than not the cause of the injury.

The Superior Court noted that, because the Plaintiff in this case had rested his case when it became clear that a fatal expert exclusion would cause a nonsuit, and where the Plaintiff did not thereafter present any evidence of damages, any error possibly committed by the trial court in terms of entering a nonsuit would have been harmless in any event.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, March 18, 2024

Superior Court Confirms That, At Times, Plaintiff Can Prove Obvious Injuries Without Medical Expert


In a decision marked as "Non-Precedential" in the case of Kent v. Williams, No. 1855 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Feb. 13, 2024 Murray, J., Lazarus, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Murray, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed the entry of a nonsuit by a trial court in a fall down case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff fell while on a ladder.  The Plaintiff sued the Defendant for not properly securing the ladder and/or providing a defective ladder.    

In this case, the Superior Court noted that a compulsory nonsuit cannot be entered prior to trial but can be treated as an entry of summary judgment by the trial court on appeal.

The appellate court additionally ruled in this case that a medical expert is not necessary to testify as to those types of injuries that may fall within the common experience and understanding of lay people on a jury, such as certain injuries that may result from a fall-down event where, as here, the Plaintiff fell 15 feet down from a ladder and landed on the surface below and allegedly sustained immediate injuries.

The court otherwise ruled that a personal injury Plaintiff is competent to testify as to his or her pain and suffering.

The appellate court additionally found that the trial court had erred in excluding the Plaintiff’s medical records entirely as hearsay. The Superior Court noted that, while some medical records or portions of records may indeed be hearsay, other portions may contain statements made for medical diagnosis which would fall under an exception to the hearsay rule. The trial court was ordered to consider each medical record individually on remand.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by Raphael Brasileiro on www.pexels.com.

Monday, April 8, 2019

Nonsuit in Declaratory Judgment Action on Coverage Affirmed Based On Definition of "Occurrence"


In the case of Kiely v. Phila. Contrib. Ins. Co., 2019 Pa. Super. 90 (Pa. Super. March 26, 2019 Ott, J., Dubow, J. Stevens, P.J.E.)(Op. by Dubow, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s entry of compulsory non-suit in favor of the carrier on a coverage question arising out of a homeowner’s policy and/or an umbrella policy. 

According to the Opinion, an insured who was covered a homeowner’s policy and an umbrella policy issued by the same carrier was sued in an underlying litigation by a former domestic employee, who asserted claims of assault and intentional infliction of emotional distress.   The insured had tendered the lawsuit to the carrier for a defense. The carrier denied coverage, asserting that the intentional torts alleged in the underlying Complaint were not “occurrences.” 

The insured then commenced this coverage litigation against the carrier seeking a declaration that the carrier was obligated to defend and indemnify the insured on the claims presented.  The insured also sought damages for bad faith.  

The coverage litigation proceeded to a trial.  At trial, the trial court permitted the insured to introduce evidence that evidence that he (the insured) lacked the mental capacity sufficient to intentionally assault the Plaintiff in the underlying matter.

The trial court entered a nonsuit in favor of the carrier after finding that the insured failed to introduce evidence of an “accident” which was required in order to trigger coverage under the policy for an “occurrence.”  

On appeal, the Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s entry of a compulsory nonsuit.   The court held that the insured’s alleged assault upon the underlying Plaintiff was not an “accident; rather, it was an intentional tort.”   Accordingly, given that the policy defined an “occurrence” as an “accident,” and given that the no accident or occurrence was alleged in the underlying personal injury Complaint, the Superior Court agreed that the carrier did not owe any duty to defend or indemnify under the policy.  

In addition to upholding the trial court’s entry of a compulsory nonsuit, the Superior Court additionally held that it was improper for the trial court to have permitted the insured to introduce evidence that the insured lacked the mental capacity to commit intentional torts.

The Superior Court noted that in a declaratory judgment action concerning insurance coverage issues, the allegations in the underlying personal injury Complaint control the analysis and that extrinsic evidence could not be admitted while the underlying lawsuit was still pending.  Simply put, in a coverage action, the essential analysis required involved comparing the allegations of the underlying Complaint to the insurance policy to determine if the coverage provisions were triggered.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Benjamin P. Novak, Esquire of the Lancaster, Pennsylvania office of Fowler, Hirtzel, McNulty & Spaulding, LLP, for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, July 5, 2018

Pennsylvania Superior Court Applies Intricacies of Limited Immunity Provision of the Mental Health Procedures Act in a Med Mal Case

In the case of Dean v. Bowling Green-Brandywine, No. 963 MDA 2017 (Pa. Super. July 2, 2018 Gantman, P.J., Panella, J., and Dubow, J.)(Op. by Panella, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the issue of whether a trial court properly entered a nonsuit against the Plaintiff under an application of the limited immunity provision of the Mental Health Procedures Act (MHPA).

Ultimately, the Superior Court affirmed the entry of the nonsuit in favor of some Defendants but not others in the matter.

The court noted that the limited immunity provision of the Act is intended to limit the criminal and civil liability of those charged with treating the mentally ill.  Under the Act, those engaged in treating mentally ill individuals "under the act" cannot be held liable absent "willful misconduct or gross negligence."

The court generally noted that the Act applies to the "voluntary inpatient treatment of mentally ill persons."  Prior to this decision, the term "mentally ill persons" had not been defined by the Act or case law.

According to the Opinion, the case involved a twenty-three year old individual who voluntarily applied to a treatment facility to address his addiction to pain medications he had been taking as prescribed for injuries following an ATV accident.  Less than ten days after his admission, the individual was found unresponsive on the floor of his room in the treatment center.  He subsequently passed away.

Thereafter, a medical malpractice suit was filed against several Defendants, some of whom pled the limited immunity provision of the MHPA as a defense.  During the course of trial, the remaining Defendants requested, and were granted, permission to add that defense to their pleadings.

At the close of the Plaintiff's case, the trial court granted a nonsuit in favor of all of the Defendants, finding that the Plaintiff had failed to show evidence of willful misconduct or gross negligence on the part of the Defendants and that, as such, the Defendants were entitled to the protections of the limited immunity provision.

In its Opinion, the Superior Court affirmed that the limited immunity provision was an affirmative defense ("immunity from suit") that has to be pled as an affirmative defense in a defendant's pleadings.

The appellate court reviewed the entry of the nonsuit with regards to each specific Defendant, finding that some Defendants were indeed entitled to a nonsuit, and others were not.  A critical question in this case was whether the treatment of the decedent's addiction amounted to a treatment of a mental illness with respect to each particular Defendant.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I sent thanks to Attorney Cynthia L. Brennan of the Berwyn, PA law office of Post & Post for bringing this case to my attention.