In a recent May 10, 2016 decision out of the Federal Western
District Court of Pennsylvania in the case of
Schutte v. GEICO, 2:16-cv-00374
(W.D. Pa. May 10, 2016 Schwab, J.), Judge
Arthur J. Schwab denied a Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand a post-Koken UIM claim
back to the state court.
According the Opinion, the Plaintiff originally filed a
lawsuit against GEICO alleging breach of contract, bad faith, and loss of consortium
in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.
That case was removed by GEICO to the federal court.
The Plaintiff responded by filing a Motion to
Remand the case back to the state court.
The Plaintiffs argued that the insurance policy at issue
contained a forum selection clause which the Plaintiff asserted was valid and
should be enforced.
That forum
selection clause provided, as follows:
“[T]he dispute shall be resolved in a court of competent jurisdiction in
the county where federal district where the insured resided at the time of the
accident.”
The Plaintiff contended that the language of the forum
selection clause precluded the Defendant’s right to remove the case from state
to federal court.
The Plaintiff further
asserted that, as the filing party, the forum selection clause gave to the
Plaintiff the sole discretion to choose whether to proceed in state or federal
court and that GEICO allegedly contractually agreed to defer to that selection
and waive right to move to federal court.
The Plaintiff alternatively argued that the forum selection clause was
ambiguous and should therefore be construed against the carrier, which drafted
the language.
The court rejected the Plaintiff’s argument and accepted the
carrier’s argument that nothing in the forum selection clause could reasonably
be construed as a waiver of the right to remove the case or as a consent to
submit to the Plaintiff’s chosen forum.
The court further stated that the clear and unequivocal
language of the policy provided that the Plaintiff may file suit in either the
state or federal court in a county in which they reside.
The court found that the Plaintiffs did file
suit in a forum of their choice but that the Defendants were well within their
rights as well to remove the action to federal court.
The court otherwise found that the jurisdictional requirements for
federal court jurisdiction were met in terms of diversity of citizenship and
alleged value of the case.
Accordingly, the Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand was denied.
Anyone desiring a copy of this case may
click this
LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney Joseph Hudock of the Pittsburgh
law firm of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, & Guthrie, P.C.
for bringing this case to my attention.