Showing posts with label Forum Selection Clause. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Forum Selection Clause. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2026

Nursing Home Arbitration Agreement Found To Be Invalid and Unenforceable as Unconscionable


In the case of Blackshear v. Providence Operator, LLC, No. 250102454 (C.P. Phila. Co. May 28, 2026 Carpenter, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Superior Court to affirm the trial court’s decision overruling a Defendant’s Preliminary Objections in a professional liability action regarding a nursing home negligence case. The Defendants, through Preliminary Objections, sought to transfer this litigation to private litigation pursuant to an ADR agreement signed by the Plaintiff’s decedent when he was admitted to the nursing home.

The trial court ruled that the Arbitration Agreement allegedly signed by the Plaintiff’s decedent was invalid and unenforceable where clear and convincing evidence indicated that the resident lacked the capacity to understand and execute the agreement at the time it was signed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (July 23, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by Caleb Oquendo on www.pexels.com.


Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Court Allows Claim To Proceed Against UIM Carrier Where UIM Claims Rep Allegedly Interfered With Settlement Negotiations In Third Party Case


In the case of Winner v. Progressive Advanced Ins., No. 2230 EDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Sept. 24, 2025 Panella, P.J.E., Nichols, J., and Ford Elliott, P.J.E.) (Op. by Panella, P.J.E.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court overruled the dismissal of an Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL) claims that was based on alleged actions of an insurance adjuster who allegedly intentionally interfered with the policyholder’s settlement negotiations in a lawsuit with a third party Defendant.

According to the Opinion, this matter arose out of a car accident.  During the course of the matter, after completing productive settlement negotiations in the third party matter, Plaintiff's counsel contacted the UIM carrier to request that a UIM claim be opened.

Thereafter, the UIM claims representative, without the consent of the carrier's insured or the insured's attorney, contacted the third party defense attorney and informed that defense attorney of a subsequent accident that the Plaintiff had been involved in.  As is turned out, the subsequent accident only involved property damages and no injuries to the insured.

Plaintiff's counsel in this matter alleged that the UIM carrier had allegedly contacted the third party defense attorney in order to persuade that attorney to reduce his settlement offer in the third party case in an attempt to shield the UIM carrier from the UIM claim.  In other words, the Plaintiff asserted that the UIM carrier purposely interfered in the third party matter in an effort to prevent the Plaintiff from recieving UIM benefits.

Based on these facts, the Superior Court overruled the trial court's dismissal of the Plaintiff's UTPCPL claims.

The Superior Court additionally held that the forum selection clause in the policy that applies to any action brought against the insurance company requiring that such action must be brought in a county in which a person seeking benefits resides also applies to bad faith and unfair trade practices claims based on the conduct alleged in this matter.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Court Summaries” By Timothy L. Clawges, Pennsylvania Bar News (Oct. 20, 2025).

Source of image:  Photo by Sean Musil on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, August 12, 2025

Superior Court Rules that Forum Selection Clause in Informed Consent Form is Enforceable in Medical Malpractice Cases


In the medical malpractice case of Somerlot v. Jung, No. 2578-EDA-2024 (Pa. Super. July 30, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., Kunselman, J., and King, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the validity of forum selection clauses in informed consent forms.

According to the Opinion, in this personal injury action, the Plaintiff had undergone treatment with certain medical providers and, under the contract entered into with those medical providers, the Plaintiff agreed that any litigation would be pursued solely in Bucks County.

Yet, the Plaintiff brought this personal injury lawsuit in Philadelphia County.  The medical Defendant filed Preliminary Objections asserting improper venue.

The Superior Court affirmed the decision of the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas transferring the case to Bucks County based upon the forum selection clause.

The Superior Court upheld the general principle of contract law that the parties are free to pre-select among all possible proper venues as to which venue would be utilized to decide any legal disputes that might arise between them. Accordingly, the Superior Court affirmed the lower court’s decision.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source of image:  Photo by Etactics Inc. on www.unsplash.com.

Thursday, August 7, 2025

Superior Court Upholds a Forum Selection Clause Found in Consent To Treatment Form in Medical Malpractice Case


In the medical malpractice case of Somerlot v. Jung, No. 2578-EDA-2024 (Pa. Super. July 30, 2025 Lazarus, P.J., Kunselman, J., and King, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the validity of forum selection clauses in a medical consent form.

According to the Opinion, in this personal injury action, the Plaintiff had undergone treatment with certain medical providers and, under the contract entered into with those medical providers, the Plaintiff agreed that any litigation would be pursued solely in Bucks County.

The Plaintiff brought this personal injury lawsuit in Philadelphia County.

The Superior Court affirmed the decision of the Philadelphia County Court transferring the case to Bucks County based upon the forum selection clause.

The Superior Court upheld the general principle of contract law that the parties are free to pre-select among all possible proper venues as to which venue would be utilized to decide any legal disputes that might arise between them. Accordingly, the Superior Court affirmed the lower court’s decision.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, June 24, 2025

Court Applies Forum Selection Clause Contained in Pre-Surgery Consent Form To Transfer Medical Malpractice Case Out of Philadelphia Venue to Bucks County


In the case of Somerlot v. Jung, Sept. Term 2023, No. 3138 (C.P. Phila. Co. Nov. 25, 2024 Bright, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Pennsylvania Superior Court to uphold the Philadelphia County trial court’s decision to transfer a medical malpractice case from Philadelphia County to Bucks County.

According to the Opinion, this matter arose out of an alleged medical malpractice claim related to a surgery that was rendered in Bucks County to a Bucks County resident Plaintiff by a Bucks County physician/medical practice.

The court based its decision on transferring the case from Philadelphia County to Bucks County on a valid forum selection clause that was contained in a pre-surgery consent form executed by the Plaintiff.

The Plaintiff pointed to the fact that one of the Defendants, a medical device manufacturer, had previously stipulated with the Plaintiffs that venue was proper in Philadelphia as to that Defendant. However, the trial court noted that the propriety of venue in Philadelphia was not dispositive based on the fact that a Defendant had previously stipulated to venue in Philadelphia. 

Here, the court noted that the injured Plaintiff had contracted to litigate in a different, but also proper venue when the Plaintiff executed the consent form. The trial court held that it was giving preference to the Plaintiffs’ original choice of forum, as reflected in the executed consent form. 

The court additionally noted that litigating the entire case in Bucks County would void splitting the case just as effectively as reversing the transfer of moving the matter back to Philadelphia as was requested by the Plaintiffs. 

The trial court additionally stated that there were no exceptional circumstances present in this case that would warrant straying from the general principle that a valid forum selection clause is to be honored by the courts.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (March 27, 2025).

Thursday, February 20, 2025

Venue of UIM Case Transferred Due To Terms of Forum Selection Clause in Policy


In the case of Winner v. Progressive Adv. Ins. Co., March Term, 2023, No. 1654 (C.P. Phila. Co. Nov. 15, 2024 Bright, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion addressed to the Pennsylvania Superior Court relative to an appeal when trial court decisions in response to a Motion to Transfer UIM and Bad Faith Claims from Philadelphia County to Chester County.

In its Opinion, the trial court asserted that it did not commit error in transferring the UIM and bad faith claims from the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas to the Chester County Court of Common Pleas based upon an unambiguous forum selection clause contained in the automobile insurance policy at issue.

The trial court also asserted that it did not err in deciding the Preliminary Objections at issue without ruling on discovery motions which, according to the trial court, had become moot.

The trial court also requested that the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law Claim be remanded to the trial court for further consideration.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 23, 2025).

Tuesday, June 18, 2024

Jurisdiction and Venue Issues Addressed in Insurance Coverage Action


In the case of Franko v. USAA, No. 2023-CV-1996 (C.P. Lacka. Co. May 31, 2024 Nealon, J.), the court addressed a coverage action relative to the theft of an allegedly covered vehicle. After the carrier denied coverage, the insured filed a lawsuit for breach of contract and bad faith liability.

The carrier filed Preliminary Objections asserting a lack of subject matter jurisdiction due to the policy’s form selection clause that limited legal actions to a court and county and state where the covered person resided at the time of the of the accident. The carrier also filed a Preliminary Objection asserting lack of personal jurisdiction based upon the allegations of the Complaint. Also asserted were improper venue objections along with a legal insufficiency of the bad faith claim.

Judge Nealon ruled that the policy’s form selection clause was inapplicable under the language of the policy given that the Plaintiff’s “comprehensive loss” claim arose from the deliberate “theft” of his vehicle, rather than an unintentional “accident.”

The court additionally ruled that, by obtaining a certificate of authority to conduct insurance business in Pennsylvania, the carrier had voluntarily consented to general personal jurisdiction in Pennsylvania.

The court additionally found that the allegations of the Complaint, and the exhibits attached thereto, stated a cognizable bad faith claim against the carrier.

With regards to the venue issue, the court directed the parties to conduct venue discovery and to resubmit the challenge to the court for a decision thereafter.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, May 31, 2023

Court Rules That Forum Selection Clause in UIM Policy Allowed Plaintiff to File in Federal Court That Covered Area Where Plaintiff Resided


In the case of Warren v. Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., No. 1:22-CV-01309 (M.D. Pa. May 4, 2023 Wilson, J.), the court denied the UIM carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a UIM claim and granted the Plaintiff leave to effectuate proper service.

In this UIM matter, the Defendants asserted that the Complaint should be dismissed for insufficient service of process, improper venue, and failure to state a claim.

As noted, the court granted the Plaintiff leave to effectuate proper service.

In part, the UIM carrier asserted that the insurance contract’s forum selection clause rendered the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania an improper venue.

In addressing this motion, the court applied the venue rules found under F.R.C.P. 12.

In reviewing this Motion to Dismiss, the court noted that the forum selection clause in the policies at issue required that the Plaintiff to file the action in a “court of competent jurisdiction in the county and state” where the Plaintiff resided at the time of the accident.

The carriers asserted that, because the Plaintiffs resided in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania at the time of the accident, the forum selection clause only allowed the Plaintiff to bring his claim into Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas.

The court disagreed and accepted the Plaintiff’s claim that the forum selection clause should be interpreted broadly to also cover the Federal Middle District Court as a court of competent jurisdiction that covered the area of Cumberland County.

The court found that the plain language of the forum selection clause allowed the Plaintiff to file the action in the Federal District Court if so desired.   As such, the Motion to Dismiss was denied in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA office of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Friday, May 20, 2022

Court Addresses Forum Selection Clause in a Post-Koken UIM Case As Well As the Validity of Allegations of Recklessness



In the case of Coello v. Fitzgerald and Erie Insurance Exchange, No. 7019-CV-2021 (C.P. Monroe Co. Feb. 11, 2022 Zulick, J.), the court addressed issued of proper venue in a post-Koken motor vehicle accident litigation. 

Relative to the Preliminary Objections filed by the UIM carrier Defendant asserting improper venue, the court noted that, although venue is proper in Monroe County under Pa. R.C.P. 2179, which allows for an injured party to bring a civil action against an insurance company/ corporation in a county where that company or corporation regularly conducts business, in this matter, Erie Insurance was relying upon a forum selection clause in the parties’ insurance contract.

Under that forum selection clause, the parties agreed that any suit to enforce the terms of the policy would be filed in the county of the Plaintiff’s legal domicile at the time the suit was filed. The record in this case confirmed that the Plaintiff alleged in his Complaint that he resided in Scranton, Lackawanna County.

The court upheld the forum selection clause and carved out the UIM case and transferred that portion of the case to Lackawanna County but kept the Plaintiff's case against the tortfeasor in Monroe County.

As such, the UIM carrier Defendant’s Preliminary Objections with regards to venue was sustained.

In so ruling, the court found that the Plaintiff’s argument that it would be unreasonable to put him to the expense of securing a medical expert for two (2) separate trials did not outweigh the contract provision on venue.

Judge Arthur L. Zulick
Monroe County



In his Opinion, Judge Arthur L. Zulick of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas also addressed the tortfeasor Defendant’s demurrer against the Plaintiff’s claims against punitive damages. The tortfeasor Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff failed to allege sufficient facts to support such a claim and that the Plaintiff had only merely alleged that a motor vehicle collision had occurred.

Relative to the allegations of recklessness, Judge Zulick referred to Rule of Civil Procedure 1019(b), which provides that conditions of the mind may be averred generally. The court noted that, under the case of Archbald v. Kemble, 971 A.2d 513, 519 (Pa. Super. 2009), an allegation of recklessness is an allegation as to a condition of the mind which could be averred generally.

As such, the court denied the Defendant’s demurrer to the Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages and noted that such a decision should be left to the jury in terms of whether the Plaintiff’s case met the burden of proof in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 12, 2022).


Monday, August 9, 2021

Forum Selection Clause in UIM Policy Upheld as Unambiguous


In the case of Van Divner v. Sweger, No. 1129 MDA 2020 (Pa. Super. June 24, 2021 Bowes, J., Dubow, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Stevens, P.J.E.), the court addressed an appeal from a trial court Order granting Preliminary Objections filed by the UIM carrier in this motor vehicle accident case on the issues of the application of the forum selection clause in the policy.

The injured party Plaintiffs asserted that the trial court erred in granting the Defendant's Petition to Transfer the Case to another County on the basis of a forum selection clause.   The Plaintiff argued that the forum selection clause was allegedly ambiguous in terms of at what point the residency of the insured should be determined to apply under the forum selection clause, i.e., either at the time the policy was purchased or at the time of the accident.

The Superior Court found that the trial court had erred in transferring the UIM claim under the forum selection clause to another county. The court found that the forum selection clause was not ambiguous and clearly tied the relevant time of residency to the time that the action was brought. As such, the trial court’s Order was vacated and remanded for further action.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 13, 2021).


Source of image:  Photo by Clement Nivesse from Pexels.

Friday, February 19, 2021

Reformation of a UIM Policy Found to Also Include the Addition of a Forum Selection Clause


In the case of Matthews v. Erie Insurance Group, 2021 Pa. Super. 6 (Pa. Super. Jan. 12, 2021 Bender, P.J.E., Lazarus, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Bender, P.J.E.), the court addressed issues of venue in a UIM case.   

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle accident while operating a vehicle insured by the carrier under a policy issued to a construction company.   


The injured party filed suit for UIM coverage under the Erie policy under an argument that the construction company had never validly rejected UIM coverage.  


The carrier filed Preliminary Objections to venue seeking to transfer the case from Philadelphia County to Bucks County.  Those Preliminary Objections were sustained in the trial court and the case was transferred. 


The trial court had ruled that the reformation of the insurance policy to provide UIM coverage must also include the forum selection clause that would have accompanied the policy if it had been properly issued.  


On appeal, the injured party argued that Erie should not be entitled to a forum selection clause that was not included in the original policy and which had been reformed by the court.   The injured party attempted to argue that the reformation should only be with respect to a provision of UIM benefits and should not be expanded to include additional contract provisions such as a forum selection clause.   


The Pennsylvania Superior Court rejected the injured party’s argument and affirmed the trial court’s Order.   The appellate court agreed with the carrier’s position that the injured party’s position would afford greater rights to those insureds that did not select UIM coverage as compared to those customers who did select UIM coverage and, therefore, would be subject to the forum selection clause in the carrier’s UIM coverage provisions.  


The court further found that, if the injured party argues that he is entitled to UIM coverage, it would be just and fair that he should also be subject to the forum selection clause asserted with that coverage. 


Accordingly, the court affirmed the trial court and found that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in applying the terms of a forum selection clause in transferring the case to Bucks County.  


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 26, 2021).  


Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Western District Federal Court Denies Plaintiff's Motion to Remand Post-Koken Case to State Court

In a recent May 10, 2016 decision out of the Federal Western District Court of Pennsylvania in the case of Schutte v. GEICO, 2:16-cv-00374  (W.D. Pa. May 10, 2016 Schwab, J.), Judge Arthur J. Schwab denied a Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand a post-Koken UIM claim back to the state court. 

According the Opinion, the Plaintiff originally filed a lawsuit against GEICO alleging breach of contract, bad faith, and loss of consortium in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.  That case was removed by GEICO to the federal court.  The Plaintiff responded by filing a Motion to Remand the case back to the state court.  

The Plaintiffs argued that the insurance policy at issue contained a forum selection clause which the Plaintiff asserted was valid and should be enforced.   That forum selection clause provided, as follows:  “[T]he dispute shall be resolved in a court of competent jurisdiction in the county where federal district where the insured resided at the time of the accident.”  

The Plaintiff contended that the language of the forum selection clause precluded the Defendant’s right to remove the case from state to federal court.   The Plaintiff further asserted that, as the filing party, the forum selection clause gave to the Plaintiff the sole discretion to choose whether to proceed in state or federal court and that GEICO allegedly contractually agreed to defer to that selection and waive right to move to federal court.   The Plaintiff alternatively argued that the forum selection clause was ambiguous and should therefore be construed against the carrier, which drafted the language.  

The court rejected the Plaintiff’s argument and accepted the carrier’s argument that nothing in the forum selection clause could reasonably be construed as a waiver of the right to remove the case or as a consent to submit to the Plaintiff’s chosen forum.  

The court further stated that the clear and unequivocal language of the policy provided that the Plaintiff may file suit in either the state or federal court in a county in which they reside.   The court found that the Plaintiffs did file suit in a forum of their choice but that the Defendants were well within their rights as well to remove the action to federal court.  

The court otherwise found that the jurisdictional requirements for federal court jurisdiction were met in terms of diversity of citizenship and alleged value of the case.  

Accordingly, the Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand was denied.

 
Anyone desiring a copy of this case may click this LINK.

 
I send thanks to Attorney Joseph Hudock of the Pittsburgh law firm of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, & Guthrie, P.C.  for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Erie Forum Selection Clause Allows for Federal Court Venue Too

In its recent decision in the case of Otto v. Erie Insurance Exchange, NO. 13-6722 (E.D. Pa. March 31, 2014 Brody, J.), Judge Anita B. Brody of the U.S. Federal Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania addressed the application of Erie Insurance's forum selection clause in a Post-Koken matter.

Based upon diversity that existed at the time of filing the suit, the Plaintiff filed suit in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.  

The Erie policy mandated that a suit "must be filed in a court of competent jurisdiction in the county and state of [the Ottos’] legal domicile at the time of the accident." 

Erie asserted that this language required the case be filed in state court only. The Plaintiff countered with the argument that the forum selection clause should be broadly construed to possibly include both the federal and state courts.

Applying the Third Circuit case of Jumara v. State Farm Insurance Company, 55 F.3d 873 (3d. Cir. 1995), the court in Otto ruled that that the language in the Erie Insurance forum selection clause would be construed to include the federal court located in the county the insured resides at the time of the accident. 

Since the Eastern District federal court included Montgomery County where the Ottos’ resided at the time of the accident, then the Eastern District federal court was found to be a proper venue under the clause.

Accordingly, the court denied Erie Insurance’s motion to dismiss based upon forum non conveniens because the Plaintiff's decision to file suit in federal court complied with the terms of the forum selection clause.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Anyone wishing to review this case may click this LINK.
 
Source of Image: www.arup.com
 

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Dauphin County Trial Court Refuses to Transfer Venue of Post-Koken Case Based On Forum Selection Clause

In the Dauphin County post-Koken case of Werner v. Jamison and Erie Ins.,  2011 CV-3221 (March 7, 2012 Evans, J.), Judge Scott Arthur Evans denied preliminary objections filed by Erie Insurance asserting improper venue.

It was reported that, in this matter, the plaintiffs resided in Elk County and were injured in an accident that occurred in Dauphin County. The tortfeasor defendant resided in Dauphin County.

Erie filed a Motion to Sever and transfer the UIM case to Elk County based on the Forum Selection provision in the Erie Insurance policy. Judge Evan’s one line Order denied Erie’s preliminary objection alleging improper venue.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer and Attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic, PA law office of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for advising me of this new decision.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Pennsylvania Superior Court Upholds Carrier's Forum Selection Clause in a Post-Koken Case

On November 9, 2009, the Pennsylvania Superior Court issued an opinion upholding Liberty Mutual Insurance Group's forum selection clause in the post-Koken underinsured (UIM) case of O'Hara v. The First Liberty Ins. Corp. d/b/a Liberty Mut. Ins. Group, 2009 Pa.Super. 214 (November 9, 2009, Judges Freedberg, Cleland and Kelly).

According to the opinion written by Judge Kelly, this case involved plaintiffs who lived in Delaware County, Pennsylvania and a motor vehicle accident that occurred in Delaware County. After receiving the tortfeasor's limits, the plaintiff submitted a UIM claim to Liberty Mutual, who denied the claim. The plaintiffs filed suit in Philadelphia County alleging a breach of contract and loss of consortium claims.

Liberty Mutual's policy had a forum selection clause that provided that if suit was filed by the insured, the suit "must be brought in a court of competent jurisdiction in the county and state of your legal domicile at the time of the accident."

After suit was filed in Philadelphia County, Liberty Mutual filed preliminary objections on the basis of improper venue. The trial court granted the preliminary objections and transferred the case to Delaware County. The plaintiff appealed.

On appeal, the Superior Court rejected the plaintiff's claims that the forum selection clause should be deemed void and unenforceable as it conflicts with Pennsylvania law and because it was against public policy.

Finding the clause to be clear and unambiguous, the Superior Court found the clause not to be in violation of Pennsylvania law. In terms of the plaintiff's public policy argument, the Court stated that a clause requiring the plaintiffs to litigate in the county in which they lived and in which the accident happened could hardly be said to be an insurance policy clause that would injure the public or be against the public good.

As such, the Superior Court affirmed the trial court's Order granting the carrier's preliminary objections on improper venue.

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


I thank Attorney Bruce Zero of the Scranton, PA law firm of Powell Law for bringing this case to my attention.