In its recent decision in the case of
Hunter-McLeod v. Dollar General, No.
13-3113 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 16, 2014 DuBois, J.) (Memorandum and Opinion), the
Eastern District Federal Court addressed the issues of subsequent remedial
measures in a slip and fall case as well as the admissibility of an expert
medical opinion.
This matter arose out of a slip and fall accident that
occurred at a Dollar General Store in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Surveillance cameras captured the
Plaintiff’s entrance into the store and her accident.
The surveillance video also captured the
four (4) employees placing a piece of cardboard over the area of the fall
following the incident.
Prior to trial, the Defendant filed a Motion In Limine to
exclude all evidence of subsequent remedial measures contained in the
surveillance video as well a Motion to Preclude the Plaintiff’s medical expert
from offering certain evidence at trial.
Applying F. R.E. 407, pertaining to the admissibility of
subsequent remedial measures, the court granted the Defendant’s Motion and
excluded the evidence of the store’s post-accident actions as
inadmissible.
In so ruling, the court
found that there was no evidence that the subsequent remedial measures
contradicted any witnesses’ testimony directly in order to be admissible for
impeachment purposes.
With respect to admissibility of the Plaintiff’s expert
medical opinion that the subject accident “may have” aggravated Plaintiff’s
degenerative arthritis of the left hip, the court found that this testimony was
not admissible even though the witness stated that the opinion was offered to a
reasonable degree of medical certainty.
Applying Pennsylvania law, the federal court noted that the
Pennsylvania Superior Court has stated that “[e]xpert testimony is admissible
when, taken in its entirety, it expresses reasonable certainty that the accident
was a substantial factor in bringing out the injury.”
Citing Kravinsky
v. Glover, 396 A.2d 1349, 1356 (Pa. Super. 1979).
The federal court noted that the
Kravinsky Superior Court also explained
that “an expert fails this standard of certainty if he testifies that the
alleged cause possibly, or could have[,] led to the result, that it could have
very properly accounted for the result, or even that it was very highly probable
that it caused the result.”
396 A.2d at
1356 [other citations omitted].
In this case, the Plaintiff’s medical expert report provided
as follows:
“I believe her slip and fall
caused an aggravation of pre-existing degenerative disc [sic] made of x-ray
findings which revealed degenerative arthritis of the left hip.
This was not caused by the fall, but may
have been aggravated.”
The defense took issue with the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion
that the accident “may have” caused an aggravation of the Plaintiff’s
arthritis.
The federal court concluded
that the Plaintiff’s expert medical opinion was insufficient and therefore
inadmissible even though the doctor concluded his report with a statement that
his opinion “have been rendered with a reasonable degree of medical certainty.”
Anyone wishing to review this Eastern Pennsylvania Federal Court memorandum decision may click this
LINK