Showing posts with label Surveillance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Surveillance. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 18, 2025

Court Denies Motion For Summary Judgment in Store Trip and Fall Case

In the case of Vargas v. Wal-Mart Supercenter, No. 3:22-CV-01642 (M.D. Pa. Oct. 7, 2025 Latella, Mag. J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a premises liability case. 

The Defendant was attempting to rely upon surveillance videotape evidence that showed the Plaintiff's actions at the time of the incident.  The Defendant also asserted that the video confirmed that the condition that the Plaintiff encountered was open and obvious.

Federal Mag. Judge Leo Latella



Federal Middle District Court Magistrate Judge Leo Latella ruled that the Defendant’s surveillance videotape evidence did not reach the level of an irrefutable physical fact that could support summary judgment in this slip and fall matter.  

With regards to the Defendant’s argument that the interpretation of the video established the assumption of the risk defense as a matter of law, the court noted that it was for the jury to decide whether the Plaintiff’s account of the events leading to the fall down event was believable.  


The court additionally noted that the Defendant should have taken customer distraction into account in maintaining safety on the premises. 


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.  


Thursday, September 25, 2025

Summary Judgment Granted in Store Bathroom Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Staley v. Price Chopper, No. 3908-CIVIL-2024 (C.P. Monroe Co. Aug. 11, 2025 Williamson, J.), the court granted summary judgment in a slip and fall matter that occurred at a grocery store.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff visited a grocery store and went to use the lady’s restroom. While in the restroom, the Plaintiff allegedly slipped on some unknown substance and fell.

After the completion of discovery, the defense filed a Motion for Summary Judgment asserting that the Plaintiff had failed to offer any evidence to show how or when the alleged substance came to be on the floor and/or that the store employees had any actual or constructive notice of the condition.

The court agreed with the defense position. The court noted that the Plaintiff failed to offer any evidence as to what substance allegedly caused her to fall. The Plaintiff admitted that she did not notice any wet spots on the floor before she fell. 

All the Plaintiff could state at her deposition was that she knew there was a liquid on the floot because her clothes were wet after the incident.  However, the record revealed not only that it may have been raining on the day of the accident but also that, when the Plaintiff fell in the bathroom stall area, her arm and hand had gone into the toilet.

The court also noted that, even considering the evidence in the light most favorable to the Plaintiff, the only conclusion is that the Plaintiff allegedly may have slipped on something wet. The court noted that it is not unusual for wet spots to be found in public restrooms, particularly around the toilet area. The court held that, without some indication of what the substance actually was, for example, from a leaking toilet or a spilled hand soap, it was difficult to determine from the record whether the condition that caused the Plaintiff was a long-standing condition as opposed to a transitory one.

In this regard, the court also noted that the Plaintiff failed to provide any evidence as to the length of time that the condition existed or if the Defendant store employees knew or should have known of the alleged condition.

The court also rejected the Plaintiff’s contention that the Defendant should have regularly checked the bathroom during the course of the day. The court noted that the Plaintiff did not produce any evidence in this regarding, including any chart under which employees would check off whether or not they had inspected the bathroom at certain times during day.

The Plaintiff also pointed to surveillance video of the store that shows that no employee entered the restroom for thirty (30) minutes prior to the Plaintiff’s fall. 

The court noted that while the video may show that no one attended to the restroom for thirty (30) minutes before the Plaintiff’s fall, that evidence does not translate to a finding that the Defendant was negligent in not cleaning the restroom that entire day. 

Rather, the court noted that the surveillance video simply showed that the restroom was not checked for thirty (30) minutes before the Plaintiff’s fall. The court held that this did not mean that the Defendant was aware of, or should have been aware of, an alleged dangerous condition that went unattended.

For these reasons, and others noted in the Opinion, the court granted summary judgment to the Defendant store.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

It is noted that Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law was defense counsel in this matter.



Source of image: Photo by Juno Jo on www.unsplash.com.

Monday, August 29, 2022

Federal Court Addresses Discovery of Store Surveillance Videos in Premises Liability Case

In the premises liability case of Dietzel v. Costco Wholesale, No. 22-CV-0035 (E.D. Pa. July 12, 2022 Sitarski, J.), the court ruled that an incident report in a slip and fall matter was not privileged where it was a standard incident form prepared in the ordinary course of business and where there was no evidence that legal counsel ordered the preparation of the report or was involved in its preparation. As such, the Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Discovery was granted in this regard.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff allegedly tripped and fell on a sidewalk as he entered the Defendants’ store.

In this matter, the Plaintiff also moved to compel the Defendant to produce surveillance footage.

The Defendants asserted that the fall was not captured on video because there were no nearby cameras. However, claim notes produced during discovery confirmed instructions to the Defendant to preserve footage from the nearest camera.

During the course of discovery, the Plaintiff requested the surveillance and, when it was refused, filed a Motion to Compel the Defendants to produce any footage from the property or to confirm that they failed to preserve footage as directed.

The court found that the Plaintiff’s request for all security footage from the store to be an overbroad request. Instead, the court ruled that a more reasonable scope would be to allow for footage from thirty (30) minutes before and after the subject incident and/or to require the Defendant to certify that they had no such footage.

In its Opinion, the court also ordered the Defendant to provide more specific Responses to the Plaintiff’s Interrogatories. However, the court denied the Plaintiff’s request for the identity of all employees working anywhere on the property on the date of the incident. The court found no basis for the Plaintiff to need to know the identity of the more than 100 workers who were working at the store on the date of the incident.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 12, 2022). 


Monday, January 10, 2022

Corrected Link to Capenos v. Greentree Hardware Case

 

Here is the corrected LINK for the case of Capenos v. Greentree Hardware & Electric, Inc., No. GD-20-010087 (Dec. 17, 2021 Ignelzi, J.), highlighted on Tort Talk yesterday, in which the court issued an Order ruling that surveillance footage of an automobile accident was required to be produced to Plaintiff’s counsel prior to the completion of the Plaintiff’s deposition.


Sorry for the faulty Link yesterday and thank you for reading Tort Talk.

Trial Court Judge Rules That Defense Must Produce Video of Accident Before Plaintiff's Deposition


In the case of Capenos v. Greentree Hardware & Electric, Inc., No. GD-20-010087 (C.P. Alleg. Co. Dec. 17, 2021 Ignelzi, J.), the court issued an Order ruling that surveillance footage of an automobile accident was required to be produced to Plaintiff’s counsel prior to the completion of the Plaintiff’s deposition.

According to one of the litigating attorneys, it does not appear that there is any Pennsylvania state appellate court decision on this particular issue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK


I send thanks to Attorney Brad D. Trust, Esquire of the Pittsburgh law office of Edgar Snyder & Associates, LLC for bringing this Order to my attention.

Source of image: Photo by Pawel Czerwinski of Unsplash.





Thursday, July 8, 2021

No Summary Judgment Allowed Based on Lack of Notice in Slip and Fall Case Where Surveillance Tape Spoliated




In the case of Nixon v. Family Dollar Stores, No. 4:20-CV-00404 (M.D. Pa. May 20, 2021 Brann, J.), the court found that a claim of spoliation precluded the entry of summary judgment in a slip and fall case.

According to the Opinion, the court found that the Defendant spoliated surveillance camera tapes. The court found that this allowed for a permissive adverse inference jury instruction.

Based on the possibility of a permissive adverse inference, the court found that summary judgment was precluded with respect to any argument regarding notice of the alleged dangerous condition.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The companion Order by Judge Brann can be viewed HERE,

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by Justin Buisson on Unsplash.com.





   

Tuesday, March 31, 2020

Claim of Spoliation of Video in Slip and Fall Case Rejected



In the case of Pace v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LP, No. 18-3313(3d Cir. Jan. 28, 2020 Chagares, J., Greenaway, J., Greenberg, J.) (Op. by Chagares, J.)[Non-Precedential], the court affirmed the entry of summary judgment in favor of the defense in a slip and fall case.

Notably, the court affirmed the lower court’s ruling that the Plaintiff had failed to establish that the Defendant store had spoliated any surveillance video of the Plaintiff where the Plaintiff fell.

In this regard, the court noted that the Plaintiff did not have any evidence that any such video existed in the first place, let alone that it was destroyed.

The court also noted that the record confirmed that the alleged fall took place in a blind spot in the Defendant’s store in terms of any video surveillance.

On the liability issue, the court noted that there was no evidence in the record to establish that the Defendant either created the hazard or had any constructive notice of an allegedly defected condition. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Thursday, September 19, 2019

ARTICLE: "Trial Court Erred in Refusing to Give Adverse Inference Instruction After Videotape Lost"



Here is a LINK to an article of mine entitled "Trial Court Erred in Refusing to Give Adverse Inference Instruction After Videotape Lost" which was recently published in the Civil Litigation Update Vol. 22, No. 3 (Summer 2019) issued by the Civil Litigation Section of the Pennsylvania Bar Association.

The article analyzes the Pennsylvania Superior Court's latest analysis of the law surrounding spoliation of evidence as set forth in the Court's recent decision in the case of Marshall v. Brown's IA, LLC (June 19, 2019). 

The Brown case involved a slip and fall case in which the Defendant Supermarket failed to produce the entirety of a surveillance tape that depicted the Plaintiff's incident.


Thursday, May 2, 2019

Superior Court Addresses Adverse Inference Penalty for Spoliation of Video in a Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Marshall v. Brown’s IA, LLC, No. 2588 EDA 2017 (Pa. Super. March 27, 2019 Bowes, J., Stabile, J., and McLaughlin, J.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed a trial court ruling after finding that the trial court erred in refusing to give an adverse inference instruction based upon the Defendant’s alleged spoliation of videotape evidence in a grocery store slip and fall case.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff allegedly slipped and fell on water in the produce aisle of a ShopRite located in Philadelphia.   The ShopRite employees came to the Plaintiff’s aid immediately after the incident and summoned medical assistance.   The manager also completed an incident report at that time. 

Approximately two (2) weeks after the incident, the store received a letter of representation from the Plaintiff’s attorney requesting that the store retain any surveillance video of the accident and/or the area in question for six (6) hours prior to the incident and three (3) hours after the incident.   The court noted that the letter from the Plaintiff’s attorney also cautioned that any failure by the store to maintain that video surveillance evidence until the disposition of the claim, it would be assumed by Plaintiff that the store intentionally destroyed and/or disposed of the evidence. The attorney also advised the store that it (the store) was not permitted to decide what evidence the Plaintiff would like to review for the case.  As such, the attorney specifically indicated in the letter to the store that “discarding any of the above evidence will lead to an adverse inference against you in this matter.”  

The court confirmed in its Opinion that the Plaintiff’s slip and fall was indeed captured on the store’s video surveillance system. 

However, according to the record before the court, the store decided to preserve only 37 minutes of the video prior to the Plaintiff’s fall and approximately 20 minutes after.   The store otherwise permitted the remainder of the film to be automatically overwritten after thirty (30) days. 

The court additionally noted that, during the course of the trial, defense counsel for the store told the jury in an opening statement that, “it is impossible to tell from the video if there was water on the floor, how it got there or when it got there.”  

At trial, the store’s manager testified that it was the store’s “rule of thumb” to preserve video surveillance from twenty (20) minutes before and twenty (20) minutes after a fall.   The store’s Risk Manager also testified that, in his opinion, the video produced was sufficient to see the defective condition, if it could be seen at all.   He additionally asserted that, since the substance on the floor could not be seen on the retained portion of the video, it “would be a fool’s errand” to go back several hours as requested.  He also asserted that it was impractical and costly to retain the requested six (6) hours of pre-incident video tape.  

At trial, the Plaintiff asserted that the store’s conscious decision not to retain the video evidence constituted spoliation for which the Plaintiff should be given an adverse inference charge to the jury.   

In opposition, the store argued that there was no relevant evidence as the video did not show drops of water on the floor.   The store also asserted that it did not act in bad faith in deleting the additional video requested.  

The trial court initially found that the fact that the video was requested did not, in and of itself, make the video relevant. The trial court also concluded that there was no bad faith on the part of the store. As such, the trial court refused to give the requested adverse inference charge.   However, the trial court did allow the Plaintiff’s counsel to argue to the jury that it should infer from the store’s decision not to retain more of the video prior to the fall supported a conclusion that the video was damaging to the store.   At trial, Plaintiff’s attorney made such an argument to the jury. 

The Superior Court noted that the defense counsel countered by asserting that, under the quality of the video, there was a question as to whether there was any expectation that, if more video had been saved, something else would have been seen particularly when the video showed an obviously small spot of water that could not be readily seen and given that one could not know when it came to be on the floor.  

The jury entered a defense verdict in favor of the store, finding no negligence.

On appeal, one (1) issue was raised for the Superior Court’s review, that being whether the trial court abused its discretion by failing to give a spoliation evidence instruction to the jury at trial.  

After reviewing the current status of Pennsylvania spoliation law and the penalty of an adverse inference, the Superior Court ruled that the trial court should have given such an instruction as the store’s conduct constituted spoliation.   

The court noted that other evidence confirmed that another fifty (50) minutes of time had passed between the last time that a store employee had inspected the area and the time noted on the video.   The court also noted that there was no testimony from anyone at the store that anyone had watched the video for the six (6) hour period prior to the fall to determine that it did not contain any relevant evidence.  Rather, the Superior Court noted that the record confirmed that the store unilaterally determined that there was no relevant evidence on the deleted tape.  

The Superior Court also noted that the trial court’s finding that there was no spoliation because the store did not act in bad faith was based upon an incorrect application of the doctrine of spoliation.   The appellate court noted that spoliation may be negligent, reckless, or intentional.   

The Superior Court additionally emphasized that the party’s good faith or bad faith in the destruction of potentially relevant evidence instead goes to the type of sanction that should be imposed, not whether a sanction is warranted in the first place.  

As such, the court vacated the judgment entered below in favor of the defense and remanded the case for a new trial.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Cheryl Wolf of the Feasterville, PA law firm of Rovner, Allen, Robner, Zimmerman, Sigman & Schmidt, as well as Attorney James Hockenberry of the office of Leon Aussprung, M.D., LLC, for bringing this case to my attention. 

Monday, February 8, 2016

Federal Middle District Magistrate Mehalchick Addresses Spoliation of Evidence Issues in Slip and Fall Case

In her recent decision in the case of Mack v. Pilot Travel Centers, LLC, 1:14-CV-00090 (MD Pa. Dec. 22, 2015 Mehalchick, M.J.), Magistrate Judge Karoline Mehalchick denied a Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment under a rationale, in part, that the Plaintiff was not entitled to a spoliation inference from a Defendant’s failure to preserve store surveillance video tapes.  

The Plaintiff in this matter initially attempted to overcome the Defendant's motion for summary judgment by arguing that the Plaintiff was entitled to the assessment of a spoliation sanction against the defense relative to the surveillance video of the subject incident.

The Plaintiff asserted that, despite an informal policy of the defendant to save twenty minutes of footage when an incident occurred, in this matter, the Defendant only saved a fragmented, less than twenty minute portion of footage.

The court noted that the record before the court confirmed that the video of the incident itself was preserved and saved.   There was no evidence of any actual withholding of suppression of any other evidence.   Judge Mehalchick stated that a spoliation inference requires that there have been an intentional destruction of evidence, which was not found to be present in this matter.  

Nevertheless, the court went on to deny the motion for summary judgment after finding that, even in the absence of a spoliation inference, the Plaintiff had adduced sufficient evidence on the causation issue to allow the Plaintiff's case to proceed to a jury.

Summary judgment on the liability issues was denied where, under the record before the court, the Plaintiff offered evidence that the Plaintiff testified that he saw the water upon which he fell and given that one interpretation of the surveillance video supported the Plaintiff’s version of the incident.   The Plaintiff also presented a liability expert in support of his claims of negligence.  As such, the court found that a jury question was presented.  

Judge Karoline Mehalchick
M.D.Pa.
Judge Mehalchick otherwise indicated that an alleged "pervasive or obvious" recurrent problems on the premises can suffice as evidence of notice on the part of a defendant of an allegedly dangerous condition, particularly where the recurrent conditions allege were present at the time of the incident.  Here, there was evidence that the area of the Plaintiff's fall was a high traffic area and that employees of the landowner were trained to watch for patrons tracking in snow or rain water into the premises in the area in question.  For this additional reason, the defendant's motion for summary judgment was denied.

Anyone wishing to review this decision by Judge Mehalchick may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Two Recent Slip and Fall Decisions Addressing Constructive Notice/Spoliation Issues


In Rodriguez v. Kravco Simon Co., 2015 Pa. Super. 41, 2291 EDA 2014 (Feb. 20, 2015 Strassburger, Allen, Olson, J.J.)(Op. by Strassburger, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed the entry of summary judgment in a slip and fall case as issues of fact existed on whether or not the Plaintiff met the burden of proving notice on the part of the Defendant of the allegedly dangerous condition.

The court ruled in this fashion even though there was no evidence of how long the spill had been present before the Plaintiff came along and fell.  The court noted that issues of fact were raised by the fact that the defendant’s maintenance records for the date in question were missing. 
Moreover, as there was therefore an open question in the matter about spoliation relative to the missing maintenance records, and whether an adverse inference in favor of the Plaintiff's case might be proper, summary judgment was found to be precluded on the issue of constructive knowledge.  The court additionally noted that there was no requirement that spoliation be resolved before summary judgment to be applicable.

Anyone wishing to review this Rodriguez decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith for bringing this case to my attention.  I highly recommend that you check out Attorney Beck's award-winning and nationally recognized blog, the Drug and Device Law Blog, which can be accessed at this LINK.

 
_____________________________
 
In its recent decision in the case of Harrell v. Pathmark, 2015 U.S. Dist. Lexis 23154 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 26, 2015 Pratter, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court of Pennsylvania granted  summary judgment in a slip and fall case due to a Plaintiff's inability to prove actual or constructive notice of the Defendant of an allegedly dangerous condition. 
In so ruling, the court rejected the Plaintiff's spoliation claim in a case where the store routinely saved over its surveillance tapes.
The court noted that, in this matter, evidence was presented that the store's surveillance camera tapes of the area were routinely reused.  Moreover, there was no evidence that the surveillance camera(s) at issue captured the Plaintiff’s fall.  The record also established that the cameras may not even have been pointed in the necessary direction.
As such, the court ruled that, under circumstances presented in this case no adverse inference in favor of the Plaintiff from an alleged spoliation of evidence arises if the evidence was lost, accidentally destroyed, or where the failure to produce it is otherwise properly accounted for -- in this case, the court noted that re-recording of videotapes in the usual course of business is not bad faith.  In this regard, the court also pointed out that a spoliation sanction requires more than proof of mere negligence.
The court also notably ruled that the mere fact that a  fall in a store does not mean that litigation is imminent or otherwise serve to put the store on notice to save the video tapes.  In this case, the Plaintiff did not put defendant on notice of suit at or around the time of her fall.

Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith for bringing this case to my attention.  I highly recommend that you check out Attorney Beck's award-winning and nationally recognized blog, the Drug and Device Law Blog, which can be accessed at this LINK.



Friday, October 24, 2014

Subsequent Remedial Measures And Medical Expert's Opinion Precluded in Slip and Fall Case

In its recent decision in the case of Hunter-McLeod v. Dollar General, No. 13-3113 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 16, 2014 DuBois, J.) (Memorandum and Opinion), the Eastern District Federal Court addressed the issues of subsequent remedial measures in a slip and fall case as well as the admissibility of an expert medical opinion.  

This matter arose out of a slip and fall accident that occurred at a Dollar General Store in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.   Surveillance cameras captured the Plaintiff’s entrance into the store and her accident.   The surveillance video also captured the four (4) employees placing a piece of cardboard over the area of the fall following the incident.  

Prior to trial, the Defendant filed a Motion In Limine to exclude all evidence of subsequent remedial measures contained in the surveillance video as well a Motion to Preclude the Plaintiff’s medical expert from offering certain evidence at trial. 

Applying F. R.E. 407, pertaining to the admissibility of subsequent remedial measures, the court granted the Defendant’s Motion and excluded the evidence of the store’s post-accident actions as inadmissible.   In so ruling, the court found that there was no evidence that the subsequent remedial measures contradicted any witnesses’ testimony directly in order to be admissible for impeachment purposes.  

With respect to admissibility of the Plaintiff’s expert medical opinion that the subject accident “may have” aggravated Plaintiff’s degenerative arthritis of the left hip, the court found that this testimony was not admissible even though the witness stated that the opinion was offered to a reasonable degree of medical certainty. 

Applying Pennsylvania law, the federal court noted that the Pennsylvania Superior Court has stated that “[e]xpert testimony is admissible when, taken in its entirety, it expresses reasonable certainty that the accident was a substantial factor in bringing out the injury.”   Citing Kravinsky v. Glover, 396 A.2d 1349, 1356 (Pa. Super. 1979).   The federal court noted that the Kravinsky Superior Court also explained that “an expert fails this standard of certainty if he testifies that the alleged cause possibly, or could have[,] led to the result, that it could have very properly accounted for the result, or even that it was very highly probable that it caused the result.”   396 A.2d at 1356 [other citations omitted]. 

In this case, the Plaintiff’s medical expert report provided as follows:  “I believe her slip and fall caused an aggravation of pre-existing degenerative disc [sic] made of x-ray findings which revealed degenerative arthritis of the left hip.   This was not caused by the fall, but may have been aggravated.”  

The defense took issue with the Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion that the accident “may have” caused an aggravation of the Plaintiff’s arthritis.   The federal court concluded that the Plaintiff’s expert medical opinion was insufficient and therefore inadmissible even though the doctor concluded his report with a statement that his opinion “have been rendered with a reasonable degree of medical certainty.”  

 
Anyone wishing to review this Eastern Pennsylvania Federal Court memorandum decision may click this LINK

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Senior Judge Thomson Addresses Spoliation Issue in Lackawanna County Slip and Fall Case


In his July 6, 2011 Opinion and Order in the Lackawanna County slip and fall case of Trently v. Giant Food Stores, LLC, No. 2008-CIV-3961 (Lacka. Co. July 6, 2011 Thomson, S.J.), Senior Judge Harold A. Thomson, Jr. denied the Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment after finding genuine issues of material fact on the actual or constructive notice issue existed. 

The court also appeared to be influenced in its decision to deny the Defendant's motion given the Plaintiff's assertion of spoliation of evidence on the part of the Defendant given the possible failure of the defense to produce a surveillance videotape of the Plaintiff's incident.

Judge Thomson's Opinion gives a nice recitation of the current status of the law on the duties of store owners to its business invitees along with the standards applicable to actual or constructive notice evidence.

In this case, the Court noted that the Plaintiff allegedly slipped on a puddle of a brown substance that was located on the store's white floor in close proximity to the checkout counters where the store's cashiers were working.  Judge Thomson accepted the Plaintiff's argument that the motion for summary judgment was untimely in that there were still depositions of relevant witnesses to be completed, including the cashiers.  The Plaintiff also asserted that factual issues existed on the notice issue given the number of store employees that were in the vicinity of the fall at the time of the incident.

Judge Thomson also touched upon the law of spoliation and found that additional material factual issues existed in this regard in that there was evidence that the Defendant's store manager first indicated his belief that there was a videotape of the incident that was reviewed, yet later, it was learned that there was no tape in existence.

Based upon all of these issues, the court denied the Defendant store's motion for summary judgment and allowed the case to proceed.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion by Judge Thomson in the case of Trently v. Giant Food Stores, LLC may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

I thank the prevailing Plaintiff's attorney, Thomas Holmes, Esquire of Scranton, Pennsylvania for bringing this decision to my attention.


Image from http://www.posigrip.blogspot.com/

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Adverse Inference Allowed as Spoliation Sanction in Pennsylvania Eastern Federal District Slip and Fall Case

In the United States Eastern District Federal Court Decision of Baynes v. Home Depot, U.S.A., Inc., PICS Case No. 11-1158 (E.D. Pa. June 9, 2011, Shiller, J.), the Court granted a Plaintiff’s motion for spoliation sanctions in a case where the Defendant store failed to preserve certain video surveillance footage in a slip and fall case. The Court allowed the Plaintiff the sanction of an adverse inference against the Defendant.

In this case, the Plaintiff allegedly slipped and fell at a Home Depot store as a result of a puddle of liquid on the floor.

The Defendant store admitted that there was a standard procedure for identifying and retaining video regarding slip and fall events that occurred in the store. According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff’s counsel also sent a letter to the store requesting that the video surveillance footage be preserved from four (4) hours before the incident to one (1) hour after the incident.

However, the store preserved and produced only about 20 minutes of footage, beginning less than a minute before the Plaintiff’s accident and continuing through her removal from the store by paramedics.

After reviewing the case presented, and applying Pennsylvania law regarding spoliation sanctions, the Court concluded that the Plaintiff had demonstrated that a spoliation sanction was proper.

The Court noted that there was no dispute that the store’s surveillance system was within the store’s control and that footage of the area of the Plaintiff’s fall was clearly relevant. The Court also noted that it was foreseeable to the Defendant that the video footage would be discoverable if the case proceeded to suit.

According to the court, the store’s conduct in securing employee statements and conducting an internal investigation into the Plaintiff’s fall, including the decision to save a selected portion of the video, indicated that the store was aware that litigation could be imminent.

Although the store retained footage of the Plaintiff’s fall, it apparently disposed of video footage that may have shown how long the substance was present on the floor prior to the Plaintiff’s fall. The Court felt that the store’s failure to retain all but 20 minutes of video from the date of the accident prejudiced the Plaintiff’s case thereby warranting a spoliation inference with respect to the missing portions of the video.

According to the opinion, the Court also went on to find in favor of the Plaintiff on the merits of the case presented and entered an award in the Plaintiff’s favor in the amount of $44,384.00 in damages.


Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.