Showing posts with label Nursing Homes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nursing Homes. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2026

Nursing Home Arbitration Agreement Found To Be Invalid and Unenforceable as Unconscionable


In the case of Blackshear v. Providence Operator, LLC, No. 250102454 (C.P. Phila. Co. May 28, 2026 Carpenter, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Superior Court to affirm the trial court’s decision overruling a Defendant’s Preliminary Objections in a professional liability action regarding a nursing home negligence case. The Defendants, through Preliminary Objections, sought to transfer this litigation to private litigation pursuant to an ADR agreement signed by the Plaintiff’s decedent when he was admitted to the nursing home.

The trial court ruled that the Arbitration Agreement allegedly signed by the Plaintiff’s decedent was invalid and unenforceable where clear and convincing evidence indicated that the resident lacked the capacity to understand and execute the agreement at the time it was signed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (July 23, 2026).

Source of image:  Photo by Caleb Oquendo on www.pexels.com.


Wednesday, August 19, 2026

Superior Court Ruling Affects Multi-Million Dollar Jury Verdict


In the case of Newlin v. Vita Healthcare Group, No. 259 EDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Aug. 4, 2026 Olson, J., Dubow, J. & McLaughlin, J.) (Op. by Dubow, J.)(Concurring and Dissenting Op. by McLaughlin, J), the Pennsylvania Superior Court found that a new trial on damages was required in a nursing home death case. The Superior Court’s ruling did away with what remained of a nearly $20 million dollar jury verdict in favor of the Plaintiffs.

In part, the Superior Court ruled that the trial court had erred in its handling of both the $4 million dollar compensatory award and the $5 million punitive damages award.

With regards to the compensatory award, the appellate court ruled that the trial court had erred in agreeing to dismiss two Defendants from the case after the jury’s verdict. According to the Opinion, the jury had not apportioned liability to each Defendant in the verdict slip. The Superior Court noted that the trial court had erred in that the trial court had no basis to determine how much of its award that the jury had intended to apportion to the dismissed Defendant.

Relative to the punitive damages award, the Superior Court ruled, based upon its review of the record, that the Plaintiffs had failed to make a case supporting the punitive damages award.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

The Concurring and Dissenting Opinion issued by Judge McLaughlin can be viewed at this LINK.


Source: Article – “Pa. Appeals Court Wipes Out Nearly $10M In Damages In Nursing Home Death Suit, Remands For New Trial,” By Riley Brennan of the Legal Intelligencer (Aug. 5, 2026).

Monday, July 20, 2026

Trial Court Requests Affirmance of its Order Transferring Venue of a Nursing Home Negligence Case Out of Philadelphia and to Delaware County


In the case of Bennett v. Providence Operator, LLC, No. June Term, 2024, No. 240603252 (C.P. Phila. Co. March 4, 2026 Cohen, J.), the trial court judge issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the Superior Court to affirm the trial court’s finding that venue was improper in this nursing home malpractice case filed in Philadelphia County. The trial court had transferred the case to Delaware County after finding that all relevant conduct occurred at the Defendant’s facility that was located in Delaware County. The court noted that the Defendant only had incidental marketing contacts with Philadelphia County.

As such, the trial court had granted the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections as to improper venue.

The court otherwise emphasized that advertising and solicitation do not constitute conducting business. 

The court additionally noted that any revenue generated from Philadelphia residents at the Defendant’s facility was incidental to the care provided in Delaware County.

The trial court additionally rejected the argument that venue was proper in Philadelphia County given that the pre-admission assessment was conducted while the Plaintiff’s decedent was hospitalized in Philadelphia. The court rejected the argument that this constituted a transaction giving rise to the cause of action. 

Rather, the court found that the claims instead of arose from the care provided at the Defendant’s facility and not from the admission decision itself. In this case, the claims of injury were with respect to a fall down event that the Plaintiff decedent allegedly had at the facility in Delaware County.

As such, the trial court found that all relevant transactions and occurrences took place in Delaware County, where the alleged negligence occurred. 

Accordingly, the trial court urged the Superior Court to affirm the trial court’s finding that venue in Philadelphia County was improper and that the Order transferring the case to Delaware County should be affirmed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (July 2, 2026).

Thursday, April 23, 2026

Trial Court Finds That Defendant Waived Arbitration Clause in Nursing Home Case by Litigating Case in Court

 

In the case of the Estate of Smalling v. 2990 Holm Operating, LLC, Jan. Term 2024, No. 240102492 (C.P. Phila. Co. Dec. 9, 2025 Cohen, J.), the trial court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion requesting the appellate court to uphold the trial court’s decision to deny a Defendant’s Motion to Compel an Arbitration in a nursing home case.

In this matter, the Plaintiffs allege that their family member decedent had passed away due to alleged negligence treatment received at the Defendant’s facility.

After the Plaintiffs had filed suit, the case proceeded with pleadings and discovery. Fourteen months after the lawsuit was filed, the Defendants filed a Petition to Compel Arbitration.

The court denied the Petition under the primary rationale that the Defendants had waived its right to compel arbitration by availing itself of the judicial process. The court noted that, here, there was a significant delay of over one year before the Defendant sought to compel arbitration. Given the delay and the active litigation in the lawsuit, including the filing of earlier Preliminary Objections by the Defendant, the trial court found a waiver of the right of the Defendant to request arbitration.

In so ruling, the trial court did not reach the Plaintiffs’ other arguments that the arbitration clause in the nursing home agreement was unenforceable under the doctrines of procedural and substantive unconscionability, and/or the argument that the person who had signed the arbitration agreement did not have the power to bind the decedent to the arbitration agreement.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source of image:  Photo by Matthius Zomer on www.pexels.com.



Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Feb. 12, 2026).

Monday, June 30, 2025

Nursing Home's Effort to Have Lawsuit Dismissed By Virtue of an Arbitration Clause Denied


In the case of Perry v. Saber Healthcare Holdings, LLC, No. 2024-CV6608 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 6, 2025 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed various Preliminary Objections filed in a nursing home malpractice case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff sustained injuries as a result of a fall.  Thereafter, the Plaintiff, through his daughter pursuant to her Power of Attorney, asserted claims of negligence, breach of contract, and other claims against the facility.

Among other issues, the Defendant facility raised Preliminary Objections asserting that the cause of action filed was required to instead be submitted to binding arbitration pursuant to an arbitration agreement executed by the daughter at the time the father was admitted to the facility.

The court ruled that, since the Power of Attorney that the father provided to his daughter expressly stated that the daughter was not authorized to enter into any arbitration agreement on his behalf with any skilled nursing facility or personal care home, the daughter could not bind her father to any arbitration agreement.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County 


Accordingly, Judge Nealon found that there was no enforceable arbitration agreement in place. As such, the Preliminary Objection seeking to have this case transferred to arbitration was overruled.

The court otherwise ruled that certain negligence allegations submitted on behalf of the Plaintiff were not barred by the gist of the action doctrine even though some of the claims presented in this case were based in contract. The court found that the claim for negligent hiring, supervision and retention were collateral to the contract and not contingent on the breach of any terms of the admission agreement.

The court otherwise sustained the demurrer filed against the Plaintiff's claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress given that the Complaint did not allege conduct that was so outrageous in character and extreme in degree as to exceed all possible bounds of decency and be regarded as atrocious and utterly intolerable in a civilized community.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, February 5, 2025

Court Finds Nursing Home Arbitration Agreement to be Unconscionable and, Therefore, Unenforceable


In the case of Harrington v. Kramer, No. 2024-CV-774 (C.P. Luz. Co. Jan. 14, 2025 Gelb, J.), Judge Lesa Gelb of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas found that the terms of a nursing home Arbitration Agreement was unconscionable and, therefore, unenforceable.

The court also denied Preliminary Objections filed by the Defendants against the punitive damages claims. The court noted that these punitive damages issues could be revisited during the Motion for Summary Judgment stage.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff filed claims for vicarious and direct corporate liability against nursing home Defendants in which the Plaintiff’s decedent resided. The Plaintiffs alleged that the decedent sustained injuries while staying at the Defendant’s premises from which the decedent eventually passed away.

A central issue in the case relative to the arguments addressed in this decision were whether the Plaintiff decedent had sufficient cognitive function and understanding to properly agree to the admission paperwork, which included an Arbitration Agreement. 

There was evidence that the decedent was on medications on her arrival to the nursing home and also that she was forgetful and had a short attention span. The court noted that the nursing home’s admission paperwork at that time was over seventy-five (75) pages in length and the Arbitration Agreement was the second to last document in the packet.

It was additionally alleged that the nursing home did not have any written policies about what the Director of Admissions should do in order to prepare for initial meetings with incoming residents, in part, in terms of determining if a person is competent to sign an arbitration agreement.

Judge Lesa Gelb
Luzerne County


Judge Gelb provided a thorough review of Pennsylvania law regarding the validity and enforceability of arbitration agreements in this context. The court noted that, although Pennsylvania and federal law impose a strong public policy in favor of enforcing arbitration agreements, the enforcement of such an agreement to arbitrate can be denied by a court where the party opposing arbitration proves a contract defense that invalidates the agreement to arbitrate. One such defense to an allegation that a valid arbitration agreement has been entered into is the defense of unconscionability.

The court noted that, to invalidate enforcement of a contract based upon unconscionability, the party challenging the contract must show both an absence of a meaningful choice, referred to as procedural unconscionability and contract terms that are unreasonably favorable to the other party, which is known as substantiative unconscionability. The court noted that these tests are assessed under a sliding-scale approach, with a lesser degree of substantiative unconscionability required where the procedural unconscionability is very high.

Applying the law to the facts of this case, the court found that the Arbitration Agreement at issue was unconscionable and, therefore, unenforceable. The court found that the Arbitration Agreement at issue was equally and procedurally substantively unconscionable.

The court noted that it found that the Plaintiff decedent did not have the legal capacity to sign the Arbitration Agreement based upon the medications that she was prescribed, the notes from the nursing staff as to the decedent’s cognition, and the other circumstances surrounding the agreement. The court also found the agreement itself to be substantively unconscionable because it imposed additional costs on the decedent and her representatives that they would not have in a court of law. The court also found that the Arbitration Agreement favored the nursing home in that it permitted the nursing home to pursue the decedent and/or her representatives for non-payment outside of arbitration.

Due to the above issues, the court held that the Arbitration Agreement was not binding.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Thomas F. Foley, III of the Foley Law Firm in Scranton for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, April 2, 2024

Court Upholds Arbitration Agreement in a Nursing Home Malpractice Case



In the case of Dougherty v. Scranton Health Investors, LLC, No. 2014-CV-5245 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Feb. 1, 2024 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed Preliminary Objections filed by the owner and operator of a skilled nursing home facility seeking to compel the Plaintiff to submit this litigation to binding Arbitration pursuant to an Arbitration Agreement.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff commenced this survival action against the facility where her mother allegedly fell and suffered a fractured hip. In the lawsuit, the Plaintiff sought to recover damages for the pain and suffering that the mother endured prior to her death due to unrelated conditions.

According to the Opinion, approximately one year before the mother’s admission to the facility, the mother and her daughter executed a Durable Power of Attorney that granted the daughter the express authority to authorize the mother’s admission to such a facility and to execute agreements related to the mother’s care.

Almost two (2) years after the mother’s admission to the facility and pursuant to the authority granted the Durable Power of Attorney, the daughter executed a “Resident Facility Arbitration Agreement” under which it was agreed that any claims against the facility or its employees for negligence or malpractice to binding arbitration and to specifically waive the right to have such claims decided by a judge or a jury.

After the Plaintiff filed this lawsuit, the facility’s owner filed Preliminary Objections seeking to compel the Plaintiffs to submit the matter to binding arbitration. 

Judge Nealon reviewed the law on the issue and ruled that a litigant’s claims are to be submitted to arbitration if a valid agreement to arbitrate exists between the parties and the claims at issue fall within the scope of that agreement. The court noted that, even if a party has not signed an Arbitration Agreement, the party can be compelled to arbitrate under such an agreement based upon the law of agency and contract. The court noted that a valid Durable Power of Attorney constituted a grant of express authority to act as another’s agent.

Here, the court found that the facility’s owner established by a preponderance of the evidence that the mother had granted her daughter the authority to execute the arbitration agreement at issue, and that the survival claims asserted in this lawsuit were within the scope of that arbitration agreement.

Consequently, the court sustained the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections and directed the parties to instead submit the claims at issue to binding arbitration.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, September 13, 2023

Attempt to Extend Medical Malpractice Liability to a Landlord of a Nursing Home Rejected


In the case of Drake v. Schwartz, No. 2019 - 07345-PL (C.P. Chester Co. Dec. 12, 2022 Binder, J.), an interesting and innovative theory of liability in a medical malpractice case was attempted by a plaintiff but rejected by the court.

In this case, the court granted the Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the Defendant, who was the owner and out-of-possession landlord of a property leased to a nursing home. 

The landowner Defendant had been brought into this nursing home negligence case under a theory that one of the dangerous conditions that caused the patient’s injuries was a condition of severe understaffing at the nursing home that was caused, in part, by financial hardships imposed on the tenant nursing home by its lease agreement with the landlord.

The trial court noted that the issue presented was one of first impression. In its filings, the Plaintiffs acknowledged that they had no authority for extending a landlord’s control over a dangerous condition to a lease that was allegedly unduly economically burdensome to a tenant.

The court declined to create a new avenue for liability against the out-of-possession landlord based solely on a tenant’s invitee alleging that the tenant’s lease was overly costly or burdensome.

As such, the Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment was granted.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 22, 2023).


Source of image:  Photo by RDNE Stock Project on www.pexels.com.

Tuesday, May 16, 2023

Plaintiff Made to File Separate Counts Against Separate Defendants In Med Mal Case


In the case of Boyd v. Shenango Presb. SeniorCare, No. 30007 of 2021, C.A. (C.P. Lawr. Co. March 22, 2023 Motto, J.), the court addressed several Preliminary Objections filed by a Defendant to a Plaintiff’s Complaint which alleged negligence arising out of the Plaintiff’s decedent’s treatment at a senior care facility.

The court sustained the Defendant’s Preliminary Objection asserting that the Complaint lacked specificity due to the fact that the Plaintiff had pled a number of different causes of action in the same Complaint in violation of Pa. R.C.P. 1020(a). The court noted that, under this Rule of Civil Procedure, each cause of action must be stated in a separate count containing a demand for relief.

In this case, the Plaintiffs’ Complaint alleged several causes of action against several Defendants in one (1) count, including alleged claims for negligence, negligence per se, and vicarious liability in a single count.

The court found that such a pleading rendered it impracticable for Defendants to understand which claims were being asserted against which Defendants. Consequently, the Defendants would not be able to properly respond to the Complaint and formulate their defenses.

As such, the Defendants’ Preliminary Objection for lack of specificity were sustained.

Several other Preliminary Objections asserted by the defense were overruled.

The court granted the Plaintiff leave to file an Amended Complaint.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 25, 2023).

Friday, March 10, 2023

ARTICLE: The COVID-19 Pandemic and Its Impact on the Law

 


Here is a LINK to my article published in the Pennsylvania Bar Association's March/April 2023 issue of The Pennsylvania Lawyer entitled "The COVID-19 Pandemic and Its Impact on the Law."

The article outlines the changes in Pennsylvania law and litigation as a result of the pandemic, some of which changes appear to be here to stay.

I send thanks to Patricia Graybill, the Editor of The Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine for selecting this article for publication.

Monday, January 16, 2023

Nursing Home Defendant Found To Have Waived Arbitration By Participating in Lawsuit Proceedings


In the case of Watson v. The Terrace at Chestnut Hill, Sept. Term 2020, No. 00101 (C.P. Phila. Co. Sept. 21, 2022 Shreeves-Johns, J.), the court addressed a Motion to Compel Arbitration in a nursing home case.

The court denied the nursing home’s Motion to Compel Arbitration given that the injured party was found to have waived their right to the arbitration agreement by engaging in the judicial process.

In this regard, the Plaintiffs filed a negligence lawsuit. Approximately nine (9) months after receiving the Complaint, the Defendants filed a Motion to Compel Arbitration, arguing that the arbitration clause in the contract between the parties mandated arbitration.

The court denied the motion on the grounds that the Defendant had waived its right to arbitration by engaging in a judicial process.

In so ruling, the court applied five (5) factors including whether the parties (1) failed to raise the issue of arbitration promptly, (2) engaged in discovery in the litigation, (3) filed pre-trial motions that do not raise the issue of arbitration, (4) waited for adverse rulings on pre-trial motions before asserting arbitration, or (5) waited until the case is ready for trial before a certain arbitration.

In this case, the court faulted the Defendant for not raising the issue of arbitration immediately but waiting until nine (9) months into the litigation, during which time the parties engaged in discovery. The court additionally found that the Defendant’s assertion that the reason for the delay, that is, that the Defendant was simply unaware of the arbitration agreement, was unavailing.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Jan. 3, 2023).

Source of image:  Photo by Eduardo Barrios on www.pexels.com.

Thursday, November 3, 2022

OPEN THE VAULT: Court Allows Discovery of Bank Records of Defendant in Punitive Damages Case


In the case of Williams v. Glenmaura Senior Living at Montage, LLC, No. 21-CV-1494 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Oct. 14, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed discovery motions relative to the scope of permissible discovery of financial assets of a Defendant relative to a punitive damages claim in a personal injury case.

According to the Opinion, this case involved a professional liability action alleging reckless and negligence relative to alleged acts and/or omissions by the Defendants at a senior living facility which allegedly caused the death of the Plaintiff’s decedent.

After the Defendant’s separate Motion for Summary Judgment on the punitive damages claims was denied, the Plaintiff sought additional discovery on the Defendant’s financial assets over and above the tax returns that the Defendant had previously produced. In part, the Plaintiff was seeking to gather bank records in an effort to discover more detailed information on the financial worth of the Defendant.

Judge Nealon overruled the defense objections to the discovery requests and found that the Plaintiff was entitled to discover the most accurate and detailed financial documentation and information that reflects the exact amount by which the Defendant’s assets exceeded its liabilities. 

The court noted that the tax records and balance sheets previously produced by the Defendant may not fully demonstrate the Defendant’s net worth with sufficient precision and completeness.

The court therefore allowed the Plaintiff to gather the relevant bank records since a borrower seeking financing from a bank is likely to portray its financial position in a positive light in an effort to secure the requested funding. The court found that the Defendant’s representations of its assets to the bank would likely assist in this regard.

As such, the court ruled that the Defendant had not satisfied its burden of demonstrating that the requested materials were not discoverable under the liberal discovery allowed in Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 

Accordingly, the court granted the Plaintiff’s Motion to Strike the Defendant’s Objections to the subpoenas that were addressed to the Defendant’s bank. However, the court limited the subpoenas to only require the production of records within the past three (3) years. The court additionally required the execution of a confidentiality agreement between the parties restricting the dissemination of the materials obtained.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source of image:  Photo by Brock Wegner from www.unsplash.com.
 


Thursday, July 28, 2022

Personal Injury Claim Based on COVID-19 Exposure Allowed to Proceed



In the case of Stiver v. Senior Health Care Solutions, LLC, No. 21-CV-842 (C.P. Lacka. Co. July 8, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed various issues arising out of a COVID-19 personal injury claim.

In this matter, a nursing home employee, who claimed to have contracted work-related COVID-19 that allegedly caused permanent pulmonary and cardiac damage and required inpatient hospitalization, filed a corporate liability lawsuit against the owner and operator of the facility which allegedly declined to follow federal agency guidelines for the prevention and mitigation of the COVID-19 virus.

The Defendant owner/operator filed Preliminary Objections. 

In part, the Defendant asserted that it was immune from suit as the Plaintiff’s “statutory employer” under §302(a) of the Worker’s Compensation Act, 77 P.S. §46, or based upon the common law “borrowed employee” doctrine.

The court found that issues of fact prevented it from fully deciding whether the Defendant was entitled to such tort immunity. Accordingly, that argument was overruled without prejudice to the Defendant’s right to raise the issue again at this summary judgment stage of the litigation.

The Defendant owner/operator also filed a demurrer to the Plaintiff’s corporate negligence claim on the basis that the Defendant allegedly did not owe any duty of care to the Plaintiff.

Judge Nealon noted that, since the Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant owner/operator had breached its duty to formulate and implement adequate safety procedures and policies and to provide a safe work environment, this demurrer was denied.

The Defendant requested, pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1006(d)(1), a transfer of venue to the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas based upon forum non conveniens grounds.

The court noted that, given that the Defendant has not submitted any affidavit from any prospective witness, or some other form of evidence, establishing that Lackawanna County is a vexatious or oppressive forum, the Defendant had not satisfied its heavy burden of proof warranting a transfer of venue from the Plaintiff’s chosen forum. As such, this petition seeking a transfer of venue under Rule 1006(d)(1) was denied.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, July 19, 2022

Arbitration Provision In Nursing Home Agreement Found To Be Unconscionable and Unenforceable


In the case of Kohlman v. Grane Health Care Company, No. 103 WDA 2021 (Pa. Super. July 5, 2022 Kunselman, J., King, J., and Collins, J.) (Op. by Collins, J.), the court affirmed a trial court’s overruling Preliminary Objections asserted by various Defendants that sought to compel arbitration of the claims asserted against them by the Plaintiffs.

This case arose out of medical malpractice claims related to treatment secured by the Plaintiff at a skilled nursing home.

The court noted that, in connection with her admission to the nursing home, the Plaintiff's decedent had signed a number of documents including an arbitration agreement.

After the Plaintiffs filed suit in the Court of Common Pleas, the Defendants filed Preliminary Objections seeking to compel arbitration. The trial court overruled the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections and this appeal resulted.

The appellate court agreed with the trial court that the terms of the arbitration agreement were unconscionable.

The court affirmed despite noting that both Pennsylvania and federal law impose a strong public policy in favor of enforcing arbitration agreements. 

The court also acknowledged that the enforcement of an arbitration agreement may be denied only where the party opposing arbitration proves that a contract defense that applies equally to non-arbitration contracts serves to invalidate the agreement to arbitrate.  In this matter, the contract defense of unconscionability of the contract terms was raised.

The Superior Court noted that, to invalidate or bar enforcement of a contract based on unconscionability, the party challenging the contract must show both an absence of meaningful choice, also referred to as procedural unconscionability, and that the contract terms that are unreasonably favorable to the other party, known as substantive unconscionability. 

The Superior Court additionally noted that procedural and substantive unconscionability are assessed under a sliding/scale approach, with a lesser degree of substantive unconscionability required where the procedural unconscionability is very high.

In this Kohlman case, the appellate court agreed with the trial court findings that the arbitration agreement was procedurally unconscionable because the decedent was in pain and was medicated at the time she signed the arbitration agreement, the decedent was alone when she was asked to sign the arbitration agreement, the decedent had no opportunity to read the arbitration agreement and was not given a copy to review prior to her signing the same, and where the provisions of the agreement were not otherwise fully read or explained to the decedent. The court therefore ruled that the process by which the decedent’s signature was obtained on the arbitration agreement denied the decedent a meaningful choice and, therefore, the arbitration agreement was found to be procedurally unconscionable.

The appellate court also agreed with the trial court finding that, on the issue of substantive unconscionability, the provision in the agreement requiring that the decedent pay one half of the cost of any arbitration, including one half of the arbitrator’s fees, was substantively unconscionable because it imposed additional expenses for bringing a claim that the decedent would not have to bear in a court action. The appellate court agreed that this term of the agreement unreasonably favored the nursing home and, therefore, was sufficient to satisfy the requirement of showing substantive unconscionability, particularly where, as here, the record, according to the appellate court, established that the decedent was not given full information regarding her choices or any opportunity to inform herself of what she was signing.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Article “Nursing Home Can’t Enforce ‘Unconscionable’ Arbitration Clause and Wrongful Death Suit, P.A. Appeals Court Rules,” by Aleeza Furman. Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 6, 2022).

Thursday, July 7, 2022

Federal Court Keeps Case in Federal Court After Plaintiff Joins Defendants In Apparent Attempt to Destroy Diversity



In the case of Testa v. Broomall Operating Company, L.P., No. 2:21-CV-05148-KSM (E.D. Pa. May 26, 2022 Marston, J.), the court addressed a Defendant’s Motion to Strike a Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint and a Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand the Case to State Court in a matter arising out of a rehabilitation and nursing home negligence case.

According to the Opinion, it was alleged that the Plaintiff’s decedent passed away after contracting COVID-19 at the facility.

After the suit was filed, the Defendants removed the action to federal court on the grounds of diversity and federal question jurisdiction.

Thereafter, the Plaintiff amended her Complaint as of right and clarified that she was not bringing claims under a Federal act and the Plaintiff additionally added the claims of negligence and wrongful death against individual Defendants. The individual Defendants were residents of Pennsylvania and thereby defeated complete diversity.

In response, the Defendants moved to strike the Amended Complaint. The Plaintiff opposed the motion and moved to remand the case back to state court.

The Defendants argued that the joinder of the individual Defendants was impermissible. 

The court exercised its power to review the joinder under F.R.C.P. 21. The court additionally applied federal law and found that, based upon the timing of the filings and Plaintiff’s counsel’s concessions at oral argument, it appeared to the court that the Plaintiff was aware of the identity of the added individual Defendants at the time the case was initiated. 

The court additionally stated that the lack of any “John Doe” Defendants in the original Complaint made it more likely that the individual Defendants were added for the purpose of destroying diversity. 

It was additionally noted that an email Plaintiff’s counsel sent to defense counsel shortly before amending the Complaint supported that theory.

The court additionally restated that the Plaintiff waited over three (3) months from the time she allegedly learned of the individual Defendants’ identities to name them as parties to the action. It was also noted that the Plaintiff did not offer up any legitimate justification for the delay in the joinder.

The court was also influenced by the fact that the Plaintiff would not be prejudice by the absence of the individual Defendants from the lawsuit.

As such, the court found that the applicable factors to be considered weighed in favor of striking the joinder. Accordingly, the court struck the claims brought against the individual Defendants, which restored the complete diversity in the case.

Given that there was complete diversity in the case, the court denied the Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand the case to state court.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.




Tuesday, April 12, 2022

Section 1983 Claims in Context of Nursing Home Litigation Reviewed


In the case of Tammaro v. County of Chester, No. 21-3811 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 16, 2022 Robreno, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part the Motion to Dismiss filed by the Defendants, which consisted of a health care facility and a county that owned that facility.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff Administratrix filed §1983 Civil Rights and Wrongful Death and Survival claims along with Federal Nursing Home Reform Act claims. 

After reviewing the facts before it and applying the law, the court found that the Plaintiff’s theory that the Defendant deliberately understaffed its facility was not a cognizable theory of liability for her §1983 civil rights claim.

However, the court found that the Plaintiff had sufficiently stated a failure-to-train claim.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (March 10, 2022).


Photo by Matthias Zomer on www.pexels.com.

Monday, July 19, 2021

Certain Nursing Home Care-Related Claims Allowed to be Pursued Under Section 1983


In the case of Alexander v. Fair Acres Geriatric Center, No. 20-2550 (E.D. Pa. May 25, 2021 Pratter, J.), the court denied a nursing home Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss filed against nursing home care-related claims under 42 U.S.C. §1983.

The court found that the Plaintiff’s nursing home care-related claims under 42 U.S.C. §1983 were viable under binding precedent that held that the Federal Nursing Home Reform Amendments conferred individual rights that are enforceable under 42 U.S.C. §1983.

The court additionally found that the Plaintiff’s Complaint sufficiently alleged “deliberate indifference” to support the claims presented by the Plaintiff.

As such, the Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss was granted in part and denied in part.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 22, 2021).

Source of image:  Photo by Markus Spiske from Pexels.com.

Monday, April 26, 2021

Judge Terrence R. Nealon Addresses Claims of Recklessness Under MCARE Act


In the case of Doughitt v. Saber Health Care Group, LLC, No. 20-CV-3136 (C.P. Lacka. Co. April 22, 2021 Nealon, J.), the court addressed issues regarding claims of punitive damages in a medical malpractice action involving Wrongful Death and Survival claims.

This case was brought by an estate and daughter of a former nursing home resident under a medical professional liability claim alleging corporate and individual negligence and recklessness by the Defendants which allegedly resulted in the nursing home resident’s death.

In the Complaint, the Plaintiff confirmed that she was seeking damages under the Wrongful Death Act and the Survival Act, including demands for compensatory and punitive damages.

The Defendants filed Preliminary Objections in the nature of a demurrer seeking to strike the claims for punitive damages on the grounds that those claims were insufficient as a matter of law under §505(a) of the medical care availability and reduction of error (MCARE) Act, 40 P.S. §1303.505(a).

Judge Nealon noted that §505(a) of the MCARE Act is consistent with other Pennsylvania case law governing punitive damages in that the Act provides that punitive damages are recoverable for a healthcare provider’s “willful or wanton conduct or reckless indifference to the rights of others.”

Reiterating his previous rationale as stated in other decisions regarding claims of recklessness, Judge Nealon noted that, although wanton and willful misconduct and recklessness are considered under the law to be conditions of the mind such that they may be averred generally pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1019(b), the court found that the Plaintiff in this matter still alleged sufficient facts in any event that would factually support a finding of wanton or reckless indifference by the Defendant’s in any event.

More specifically, the court noted that the Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant’s intentionally increased a number of infirm residents with complex health conditions in order to increase their governmental reimbursements, knowingly establish staffing levels that were insufficient, repeatedly ignored staff reports regarding alleged alarming increases in infections and illnesses within the facility, and other allegations.

Judge Nealon went on to note that, generally speaking, in a Survival action, the decedent’s estate is permitted to pursue claims that the decedent could have asserted if he or she had lived. In contrast, the Wrongful Death action is brought by specified relatives of the decedent to compensate those surviving family members for the losses that they have sustained as a result of the decedent’s death.

The court noted that, consequently, the decedent’s estate may recover punitive damages in a Survival action if the decedent could have recovered those types of damages had he or she survived. However, under Pennsylvania, punitive damages are not recoverable in a Wrongful Death action.

As such, the court sustained the Defendant’s demurrer to the punitive damages claims only with respect to the Plaintiff’s punitive damages claims asserted in the Wrongful Death action. The Defendant’s demurrer was overruled in all other respects.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Friday, October 23, 2020

Claims Allowed To Proceed Against Personal Care Home


In the case of Rogowski v. Harrison House Personal Care Home, No. 20-CV-2009 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept. 28, 2020 Nealon, J.), the court addressed issues with respect to a duty of care and the application of §323 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts arising out of claims against a personal care home by a resident.
The personal care home resident alleged physical and emotional harm allegedly sustained as a result of assaults by another resident, substandard medical care, and institutional neglect. 

One of the Defendants in this matter filed a demurrer.  That Defendant was the advocacy alliance which was allegedly authorized by the Social Security Administration Act as the resident’s payee for Social Security benefits and manage the same for the resident.  That Defendant asserted that was not liable for any claims of damages on the grounds that the Defendant did not have a duty to protect the resident of the personal care home or any duty to scrutinize the services provided by the personal care home.

The court ruled that, although it was alleged that the personal care home and its owner were aware of serious problems at the home which allegedly increased the risk of harm to the resident, the Plaintiff’s Complaint was found to lack any allegations that the advocacy alliance, as the payee, knew, or should have known, of any issues at the personal care home that could have exposed the resident to possible injury. 

The court also found that the Complaint lacked any factual averments or reasonable inferences that the payee undertook or otherwise assumed any responsibility to monitor or review the quality of care at the home. 

As such, based upon the allegations set forth in the Plaintiff’s Complaint, the court ruled that the representative payee did not owe the resident any common law duty of care upon which to base a negligence claim for physical and emotional harm sustained by the resident at the home. Accordingly, the claims against the payee for non-economic damages was dismissed. 

However, in light of the payee’s fiduciary duties relative to the resident’s Social Security benefits, the demurrer to the “pecuniary loss” claims relating to the advancement of rent and expenditures was overruled.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Tuesday, November 22, 2016

Issues of Corporate Negligence Addressed in Lackawanna County Nursing Home Case

In its recent decision in the case of Breslin v. Geisinger Mountain View Care Center, No. 2015-CV-5015 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Oct. 21, 2016 Braxton, S.J.), Senior Judge John Braxton, sitting for the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas, sustained several Preliminary Objections asserted by a nursing home care facility in a medical malpractice action.  

Of note, the court found that the Plaintiff’s allegations in the Complaint failed to state a corporate negligence claim against the nursing home facility.  

The court additionally found that the Plaintiff failed to plead allegations sufficient to proceed on a claim for vicarious liability.  In part, the defense argued that the Plaintiff failed to identify the nurses, doctors, and other medical, professional staff, who allegedly treated the Plaintiff’s decedent in a negligent manner.  

The court also found that Plaintiff failed to state a claim for punitive damages under facts alleged in the Complaint and, as such, the claim for punitive damages, along with all allegations of recklessness, were stricken.  

Anyone wishing to read this decision, may click this LINK.