Monday, September 30, 2024
Presenting At This Week's Monroe County Bench Bar Conference
Attorney-Client Privilege Did Not Attach With Ploy Of Routing Documents Through an Attorney
In the case of HU.S. v. CVS ealth Corp., No. 2:16-CV-01582-GAM (E.D. Pa. Aug. 15, 2024 McHugh, J.), the court addressed the applicability of the attorney-client privilege asserted against discovery requests in a civil litigation matter involving an action against the retail pharmacy chain.
After reviewing the documents in question and concluding that a majority of the communications did not relate to any legal advice or questions that required the information to be identified as privileged, the court granted Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel the production of the documents in question.
According to the Opinion, the documents at issue, involve business communications over CVS’ shipping processes.
The court noted that the broad claim of attorney client privilege asserted by the Defendant was not proper in this case given that such protections are not automatically provided simply because documents may be routed through an attorney. The court reiterated that the documents at issue did not contain or reflect legal advice or request for legal advice and did not provide any indication that they were prepared in anticipation of litigation of any kind.
Judge McHugh noted that the “ploy” of using an attorney as an intermediary with another party for what is clearly an exchange of business information should not be endorsed by a court to serve as a means for a party to assert the attorney client privilege.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: “Article – Federal Judge Rejects CVS’ Attorney-Client Privilege Claims, Orders Retailer To Turn Over Communications In Qui Tam Action,” By Riley Brennan The Legal Intelligencer (Aug. 15, 2024).
Jurisdiction Found to Exist in Pennsylvania Due to Multiple Contacts With Pennsylvania
The case involved alleged injuries sustained by the Plaintiff when a lift gate on a Ryder truck collapsed.
The Defendant's moved to dismissed the case principally on the grounds that the accident happened in Maryland.
The court noted that, even though the accident in question happened in another state, specific personal jurisdiction existed. In this regard, the court noted that the Plaintiff’s employer had leased the truck at issue from the Defendant in Pennsylvania.
It was also noted that the record revealed that the alleged negligent maintenance of the truck, which was allegedly a cause of the accident, occurred in Pennsylvania.
The court additionally noted that the Plaintiff was a Pennsylvania resident and received worker’s compensation benefits from a Pennsylvania employer.
Based on these reasons, the Court denied the motion to dismiss.
Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.
Superior Court Rules That Seat Belt Evidence Can't Be Considered Where Plaintiff Took Seat Belt Off Just Before Accident
The court ruled that Pennsylvania’s seat belt law 75 Pa. C.S.A. §4581(e) generally prohibits evidence of seat belt non-use as being used to show contributory negligence on the part of an injured party.
After reviewing the trial court's decision in which summary judgment was granted on the basis, in part, that no negligence on the part of the defendant-driver was shown to be the cause of the Plaintiff's alleged injuries where the Plaintiff had taken their seat belt off before the Defendant driver had stopped short due to a situation on the roadway ahead, the Superior Court noted that the trial court's reliance on the fact that the Plaintiff was not seat belted was an improper consideration. The Court noted that reference to that evidence should have been excluded from the analysis.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Friday, September 27, 2024
Corrected Link For Judge Nealon's Hills and Ridges Decision in White v. Nesbeth Case
Here is the corrected LINK for the case highlighted in the September 27, 2024 Tort Talk post on Judge Terrence R. Nealon's hills and ridges decision in the White v. Nesbeth case.
Apologies for any confusion or consternation caused by the incompleted Link in the original post.
Summary Judgment Granted in Lackawanna County Slip and Fall Case
According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff, who was considered to be an invitee, and who was making a Door Dash delivery to the Defendants’ residence during an ongoing storm of “freezing rain and sleet,” allegedly slipped and fell on the homeowner’s sidewalk.
According to the record before the court, the Plaintiff’s deposition testimony acknowledged the existence of persistent freezing precipitation falling at the time of the incident. The Plaintiff additionally conceded that he did not observe or feel “any kind of an accumulation.” The Plaintiff additionally confirmed that he did not “notice anything” on the sidewalk.
After the completion of discovery, the Defendants filed a Motion for Summary Judgment relying upon the hills and ridges doctrine.
The Plaintiff responded by arguing that, since the landowner applied rock salt to the sidewalk approximately forty-five (45) minutes before the Plaintiff arrived, the hills and ridges doctrine was in applicable due to “human intervention” which allegedly altered the “natural accumulation” that was falling at the time.
In granting summary judgment, Judge Nealon noted that there was no dispute that general slippery conditions prevailed at the time of the incident as a result of a continuous winter event and precipitation.
![]() |
| Judge Terrence R. Nealon Lackawanna County |
Judge Nealon also emphasized that no party or witness had identified or specifically described the condition upon which the Plaintiff allegedly fell.
In his Opinion, Judge Nealon pointed to appellate case law holding that a landowner is not obligated to salt their sidewalk while winter precipitation remains in progress. He also ruled that, in any event, since the record lacked any evidence that the application of rock salt somehow created a dangerous condition or increased the natural hazards of the existing ice, the hills and ridges doctrine still applied and governed the negligence claim presented.
Judge Nealon ultimately held that, even when the record is examined in the light most favorable to the Plaintiff as required by the applicable motion for summary judgment standard of review, the evidence presented was insufficient to establish a prima facie cause of action under the hills and ridges doctrine.
Accordingly, summary judgment was entered in favor of the homeowner.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Judge Nealon Provides Thorough Review of Current Status of Law on Proper and Timely Service of Process
In his recent detailed decision in the case of Potts v. Notariani, No. 2022-CV-1161 (C.P. Lacka. Co., Sept. 19, 2024 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas provided a thorough analysis of the current status of the law applicable to the requests for dismissals of civil litigation matters due to a Plaintiff's failure to complete service in a timely fashion.
In this case involving a pro se prisoner Plaintiff, the record confirmed that the Plaintiff did not follow the Rules of Civil Procedure for the completion of service of original process. Service had not been completed over the 30 months since the lawsuit was filed.
As such, Judge Nealon ruled that the Court had no jurisdiction over the matter and the case was therefore dismissed.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.






