Friday, September 29, 2023
Jury's Zero Verdict Upheld
In the case of Derry v. Blackman, No. 3:21-CV-01744 (M.D. Pa. June 30, 2023 Mehalchick, J.), the court ruled that a jury’s zero verdict in a conceded liability case was not against the weight of the evidence.
The court emphasized that the record in the case confirm that the existence, severity and alleged cause of the Plaintiff’s alleged injuries were all disputed.
Judge Mehalchick reiterated the rule of law that a jury is free to decide which side’s witnesses are credible.
The court also noted the general rule of law that, even if a jury found that a Plaintiff did actually suffer some pain or discomfort as a result of an accident, the jury could conclude that the injuries were not significant enough to warrant compensation.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Thursday, September 28, 2023
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Addresses Issues of Indemnification and Contribution in Context of Medical Malpractice Claim
However, the Court was evenly divided on the question as to whether the hospital could also seek indemnification from the dialysis clinic.
Given the decision on contribution and the inability to reach a decision on the indemnity issue, the Superior Court decision was affirmed.
In this case, the issue presented to the court was whether, as a matter of law, the hospital could seek contribution and/or indemnity from a dialysis clinic for negligence allegedly committed by the doctor employees of the dialysis clinic.
The trial court and the Superior Court had both previously concluded that, although the judicial principles for contribution and indemnity did not apply cleanly to these particular circumstances, equitable principles of law permitted the hospitals to seek both contribution and indemnity from the dialysis clinic. As noted above, the Supreme Court agreed on the issue of indemnification but split on the issue of contribution.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority decision may click this LINK.
Justice Wecht's Concurring Opinion can be viewed HERE.
The Supreme Court's Per Curiam Order can be viewed HERE.
Source: “Justia Daily Opinion Summaries” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 29, 2023).
Source of image: Photo by Camilo Jiminez on www.unsplash.com.
Court Finds Medical Malpractice Claim To Be Barred By Statute of Limitations
According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged medical negligence relative to hip replacement surgeries. The Plaintiff asserted that the doctor utilized prosthetics that were too short during each of the Plaintiff’s surgeries, causing a painful limp. The Plaintiff also alleged that she consulted a different doctor, who performed a third surgery, and concluded that the prosthetics that the Defendant had implanted were too short and made the Plaintiff’s legs uneven.
In this matter, there was a dispute between the parties as to when the Plaintiff’s cause of action arose.
The Defendants asserted that the latest date that the Plaintiff’s cause of action could have accrued was around July of 2018 when the Plaintiff obtained a third opinion confirming that her hip replacement surgery caused her to have a shorter right leg and corresponding pain.
The Plaintiffs asserted that the discovery rule should be applied such that the accrual of the cause of action would not be until after the third surgery was completed in October of 2018 when the first doctor’s alleged negligence was allegedly confirmed.
The trial court considered the discovery rule and concluded that the Plaintiff’s cause of action accrued no later than July of 2018 as evidenced by the record and the Plaintiff’s own deposition testimony.
More specifically, the record indicated that the Plaintiff was, at that point, aware of significant harm and a causal connection between the harm and the doctor’s actions, even though the Plaintiff did not have complete knowledge of the injury’s full extent or precise cause of the same.
The court confirmed that the Plaintiff testified at her deposition with admissions that she knew by July of 2018 that she was suffering pain, leg length discrepancy, and physical limitations after the second surgery and that she believed that the doctor’s surgeries were responsible.
Accordingly, since the Plaintiff filed suit beyond the two (2) year statute of limitations, the court ruled in favor of the Defendants and dismissed the Complaint.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 22, 2023).
Accordingly, since the Plaintiff filed suit beyond the two (2) year statute of limitations, the court ruled in favor of the Defendants and dismissed the Complaint.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 22, 2023).
Source of image: Photo by Anna Shvets on www.pexels.com.
Wednesday, September 27, 2023
Claims of Recklessness And Punitive Damages Allowed To Proceed in Trucking Accident Case Where Outrageous Facts Pled
In the case of Guy v. Eliwa, No. 4:23-CV-00472 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 11, 2023 Brann, C.J.), Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann of the Federal Middle District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania reviewed the propriety of claims of recklessness in civil litigation matters in the context of a federal court personal injury suit.
According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a three (3) vehicle accident on Interstate 80 that involved three (3) tractor trailers. Two (2) tractor trailers were involved in an accident on the highway and then struck the Plaintiff’s parked tractor trailer.
One of the Defendant tractor trailer drivers fled the scene of the accident without attempting to stop or render aid. That driver was subsequently charged with accidents involving death or personal injury, disregarding the traffic lane, accident involving property damage, failure to stop and give information and render aid, careless driving, and recklessly endangering another person.
The Plaintiff sued the tractor trailer drivers and their employers. In the Complaint, the Plaintiff asserted various allegations of recklessness.
The Defendants filed various motions against the Complaint.
In contrast to the more stringent state court Rules of Civil Procedure requiring fact-pleading in Pennsylvania, under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, notice pleading is all that is required.
Relative to the Plaintiff’s claims for punitive damages, the court in this case noted that the Plaintiff cited to Pennsylvania case law explaining that the procedural rules allow a Plaintiff to pled gross negligence and recklessness generally.
Judge Brann noted that this would mean that a Plaintiff need only allege that a Defendant was “reckless” for punitive damages claims to survive a Motion to Dismiss, so long as the underlying negligence claim also survives.
In reviewing this area of the law, Judge Brann noted that there is a split of authority amongst the Pennsylvania state courts on this point. In noting the split of authority, Judge Brann cited to “Pleading For Clarity: Appellate Guidance Needed to Settle the Issue of the Proper Pleading of Recklessness in Personal Injury Matters” by Daniel E. Cummins, 93 PA Bar Ass’n Q.32 (2022).
Judge Brann noted that “even in Pennsylvania courts which permit recklessness to be averred generally at the Motion to Dismiss stage, the record must ultimately support a finding of recklessness beyond merely claiming recklessness generally. See Op. at 12 citing Monroe v. CBH20, LP, 286 A.3d 785, 780 (Pa. Super. 2022).
In this case, Judge Brann applied Federal Rule of Procedure 9(b). The court noted that Rule 9(b) mirrors Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 1019(b) by stating that “[m]alice, intent, knowledge, and other conditions of a person’s mind may be alleged generally.”
With respect to the separate issue of allegations in support of a claim for punitive damages, the court noted that a Plaintiff is required to show that the Defendant had a state of mind such that the Defendant had to be an outrageous manner due to other an evil motive or a reckless indifference to the rights of others.
The court stated that, in order to show reckless indifference sufficient to support a claim for punitive damages, the Plaintiff must present evidence to establish that a Defendant had a subjective appreciation of the risk of harm to which the Plaintiff was exposed and that the Defendant acted, or failed to act, in conscious disregard of that risk.
Judge Brann stated that this means that recklessness - - like negligence - - is a legal standard, with components relating to a Defendant’s conduct and a Defendant’s state of mind. The court noted that Rule 9(b) only pertains to the Defendant’s state of mind.
Accordingly, Judge Brann held that a federal court may dismiss a completely bald allegation of “recklessness” as conclusory when a Plaintiff is requesting punitive damages. However, he emphasized that a federal court is not compelled to dismiss such a claim.
Relative to the Plaintiff’s claims for punitive damages, the court in this case noted that the Plaintiff cited to Pennsylvania case law explaining that the procedural rules allow a Plaintiff to pled gross negligence and recklessness generally.
![]() |
| Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann M.D. Pa. |
Judge Brann noted that this would mean that a Plaintiff need only allege that a Defendant was “reckless” for punitive damages claims to survive a Motion to Dismiss, so long as the underlying negligence claim also survives.
In reviewing this area of the law, Judge Brann noted that there is a split of authority amongst the Pennsylvania state courts on this point. In noting the split of authority, Judge Brann cited to “Pleading For Clarity: Appellate Guidance Needed to Settle the Issue of the Proper Pleading of Recklessness in Personal Injury Matters” by Daniel E. Cummins, 93 PA Bar Ass’n Q.32 (2022).
Judge Brann noted that “even in Pennsylvania courts which permit recklessness to be averred generally at the Motion to Dismiss stage, the record must ultimately support a finding of recklessness beyond merely claiming recklessness generally. See Op. at 12 citing Monroe v. CBH20, LP, 286 A.3d 785, 780 (Pa. Super. 2022).
In this case, Judge Brann applied Federal Rule of Procedure 9(b). The court noted that Rule 9(b) mirrors Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 1019(b) by stating that “[m]alice, intent, knowledge, and other conditions of a person’s mind may be alleged generally.”
With respect to the separate issue of allegations in support of a claim for punitive damages, the court noted that a Plaintiff is required to show that the Defendant had a state of mind such that the Defendant had to be an outrageous manner due to other an evil motive or a reckless indifference to the rights of others.
The court stated that, in order to show reckless indifference sufficient to support a claim for punitive damages, the Plaintiff must present evidence to establish that a Defendant had a subjective appreciation of the risk of harm to which the Plaintiff was exposed and that the Defendant acted, or failed to act, in conscious disregard of that risk.
Judge Brann stated that this means that recklessness - - like negligence - - is a legal standard, with components relating to a Defendant’s conduct and a Defendant’s state of mind. The court noted that Rule 9(b) only pertains to the Defendant’s state of mind.
Accordingly, Judge Brann held that a federal court may dismiss a completely bald allegation of “recklessness” as conclusory when a Plaintiff is requesting punitive damages. However, he emphasized that a federal court is not compelled to dismiss such a claim.
Reviewing the law of the Third Circuit, Judge Brann found that the weight of authority in the Third Circuit has prompted most courts in the District, including the federal courts of the Middle District, to employ the trial court’s wide discretion in preserving recklessness claims at the Motion to Dismiss stage and allowing such claims to proceed into discovery.
Judge Brann continued by stating that the courts in the Middle District have more specifically stated that, because the question of whether punitive damages are proper often turns on the Defendants’ state of mind, this question frequently cannot be resolved on the pleadings alone but must await the development of the full factual record at trial. As such, such claims are generally allowed to proceed beyond the pleadings stage.
Turning to the allegations asserted by the Plaintiff in this case, Judge Brann found that the Plaintiff had actually alleged outrageous facts to show evidence of reckless indifference on the part of the Defendant in any event so as to allow the claim to proceed into discovery. More specifically, the court noted that flight from the scene of an automobile accident, without attempting to stop or render aid, certainly demonstrates a degree of reckless indifference possibly justifying the application of punitive damages.
Judge Brann’s decision in this case is otherwise notable for his addressing various issues with regards to trucking accident cases, including the requirement of the Plaintiff to cite to specific statutes and laws and regulations in the Complaint when making claims of violations of the same.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE
I send thanks to Attorney Hannah Molitoris of the Philadelphia office of the Morgan & Morgan law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Judge Brann continued by stating that the courts in the Middle District have more specifically stated that, because the question of whether punitive damages are proper often turns on the Defendants’ state of mind, this question frequently cannot be resolved on the pleadings alone but must await the development of the full factual record at trial. As such, such claims are generally allowed to proceed beyond the pleadings stage.
Turning to the allegations asserted by the Plaintiff in this case, Judge Brann found that the Plaintiff had actually alleged outrageous facts to show evidence of reckless indifference on the part of the Defendant in any event so as to allow the claim to proceed into discovery. More specifically, the court noted that flight from the scene of an automobile accident, without attempting to stop or render aid, certainly demonstrates a degree of reckless indifference possibly justifying the application of punitive damages.
Judge Brann’s decision in this case is otherwise notable for his addressing various issues with regards to trucking accident cases, including the requirement of the Plaintiff to cite to specific statutes and laws and regulations in the Complaint when making claims of violations of the same.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE
I send thanks to Attorney Hannah Molitoris of the Philadelphia office of the Morgan & Morgan law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Allegations of Recklessness and Implicit Punitive Damages Claim Allowed to Proceed In Federal Trucking Accident Case
The court found that the Plaintiff’s allegations plausibly supported a punitive damages remedy at this early stage of the litigation.
According to Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged that he slowed down for a truck that was turning into a driveway in front of him at which point another truck driver rear-ended the Plaintiff’s vehicle.
The Plaintiff asserted negligence claims against the truck driver and the truck company and alleged outrageous conduct in terms of the Defendants’ allegedly willfully and recklessly ignoring the safety hazards of driving a commercial vehicle in an unsafe manner and driving a vehicle in a substandard condition for interstate travel.
The Plaintiff additionality alleged that the truck company failed to properly trail its driver, failed to properly equip or maintain trucks, failed to monitor its driver performance, and was negligent in terms of hiring and retaining drivers, and/or in otherwise allegedly violating commercial motor vehicle regulations.
The Plaintiff additionally averred that the Defendant driver “consciously” drove the truck at a high rate of speed under the circumstances and also violated Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations.
The court denied the Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss the Plaintiff’s implicit demand for punitive damages and the allegations of recklessness, gross negligence, and/or willful misconduct as be a premature request at this pleading stage of the litigation.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Sept. 21, 2023).
Source of image: Photo by Esteban Zapata on www.unsplash.com.
Tuesday, September 26, 2023
Superior Court Upholds Admission of Evidence of Plaintiff's Consumption of Alcohol in Pedestrian Accident Case
In the case of Moffitt v. Miller, No. 8 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Sept. 18, 2023, Pelligrini, J., Bowes, J., and Stabile, J.) (Op. by Pelligrini, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a lower court’s denial of Plaintiff’s post-trial motions in a case involving a pedestrian Plaintiff who was struck by a motor vehicle.
The court found that the low verdict and the 50/50 negligence apportionment by the jury were not against the weight of the evidence.
One of the issues that the Plaintiff challenged was the admission of testimony regarding the Plaintiff's consumption of alcohol before the accident. The appellate court found that evidence of the Plaintiff pedestrian’s high blood alcohol level at the time of the accident was properly admitted by the court below.
The Superior Court noted that the evidence was supported by competent expert testimony that the Plaintiff’s judgement would be impaired. Additionally, there was witness testimony that the Plaintiff smelled of alcohol at or around the time of the incident. The court noted that the exclusion of this evidence would have deprived the jury of relevant evidence to consider in its decision.
The court also found that the Defendant’s alcohol expert was competent to testify based upon the expert’s several decades of experience of treating alcoholics.
In another notable ruling, the Superior court ruled that evidence established that the Plaintiff had attempted to cross the street in a mid-block area and outside of any crosswalk. As such, the court found that the Plaintiff's requested “unmarked crosswalk” instruction was properly denied.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
The court also found that the Defendant’s alcohol expert was competent to testify based upon the expert’s several decades of experience of treating alcoholics.
In another notable ruling, the Superior court ruled that evidence established that the Plaintiff had attempted to cross the street in a mid-block area and outside of any crosswalk. As such, the court found that the Plaintiff's requested “unmarked crosswalk” instruction was properly denied.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







