Monday, July 31, 2023

Court Finds Issues of Fact Relative to Sudden Emergency Doctrine Preclude Summary Judgment


In the case of Cox v. Cemex, Inc., No. 10132 of 2020, C.A. (C.P. Lawr. Co. March 20, 2023 Motto, P.J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a Plaintiff’s personal injury litigation arising out of a motor vehicle accident.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was a passenger in a vehicle being operated by the Defendant when the vehicle was struck by a tree located on a property next to the road. The Plaintiff sued the Defendant driver, the Defendant’s business, and the owner of the property where the tree was located, among other parties.

There was conflicting evidence about how the accident occurred.

The Defendant driver maintained that the accident happened as he was driving around a curve in the road and oncoming traffic crossed the centerline, forcing the Defendant driver to move his right in his own lane. The Defendant driver denied that his vehicle left the roadway.

However, in his 911 call and alleged statement to ambulance crew members, the Defendant driver allegedly stated that he had run off the road and that a tree had come through the door injuring the Plaintiff. There was also conflicting testimony as to whether there were any tire tracks off the roadway.

The Defendant property owner had testified that the trees on his property had been trimmed to ensure that they did not protrude over the road. Also, a local police officer who routinely patrolled the area confirmed that he did not observe any parts of a tree protruding over the road.

Additionally, the Plaintiff testified that the oncoming vehicle had moved back into its own lane of travel before encountering the Defendant’s vehicle and that the Defendant driver had approximately ten (10) seconds to respond after first seeing the other vehicle.

The court found that issues of fact, including on the issue of sudden emergency doctrine, required the court to deny the Defendant driver’s Motion for Summary Judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 4, 2023).


Source of image:  Photo by David Lin from www.pexels.com.


Thursday, July 27, 2023

Court Finds Jury Issues With Respect to Defense of Open and Obvious Danger


In the case of Irwin v. Neshannock Woods, Inc., No. 10457 of 2022 (C.P. Lawr. Co. May 15, 2023 Motto, P.J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case that occurred at an apartment complex.

In this case, the Plaintiff sued her landlord and the landlord property maintenance company after the Plaintiff allegedly sustained injuries from a slip and fall caused by a snow mound near a dumpster on the property.

In their Motion for Summary Judgment, the Defendants asserted that Plaintiff’s claim of negligence was legally insufficient because the snow mound was an open and obvious condition. 

The Defendants also asserted that the Plaintiff voluntarily assumed a risk by choosing to walk over the mound to dispose of her trash. The landlord additionally asserted that the Plaintiff failed to inform the landlord about an issue with the snow mound before the Plaintiff’s fall.

The court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment after finding that genuine issues of material fact remain to be decided by a jury.

The court otherwise noted that the Defendants had a duty to protect the Plaintiffs from the known and obvious hazard created by the snow mound and that the Defendants could have taken steps to prevent the alleged injuries.

The court additionally considered the fact that the landlord had a policy requiring residents to use the dumpster and the fact that the landlord had made a prior request to have the snow mound removed, which was not accomplished.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 20, 2023).

Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Court Grants Partial Motion For Summary Judgment in UIM Bad Faith Case



In the case of Childs v. Progressive Preferred Ins. Co., No. 2:22-CV-01318 M.J.H. (W. Pa. June 15, 2023 Horan, J.), the court granted a Defendant’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment in a bad faith claim and dismissed the bad faith claim where the court found that the Plaintiff failed to present any evidence indicating that additional investigation would have changed the UIM carrier’s evaluation. The court also found that the Plaintiff failed to present any evidence that the insurance company otherwise failed to conduct a diligent investigation on the case presented.

According to the Opinion, the case arose out of a motor vehicle accident and a UIM claim against Progressive.

According to the Opinion, the tortfeasor Defendant tendered its limits. Progressive granted its consent to settle and, after reviewing the record, offered $1,000.00 to settle the Plaintiff’s UIM claim.

Progressive was later advised that the Plaintiff’s physician had recommended surgery for the Plaintiff’s right shoulder but that the Plaintiff had decided not to move forward with the surgery at that time.

Progressive obtained a medical expert to review the Plaintiff’s MRIs. That expert concluded the Plaintiff’s right shoulder complaints were not related to the accident.

Nevertheless, Progressive then increased the settlement offer to $2,500.00 in a case where Plaintiff’s counsel valued the case at $25,000.00 to $50,000.00. The Plaintiff responded with a bad faith and breach of contract lawsuit.

As noted above, the court found that the record failed to reveal evidence to support the bad faith claim which was dismissed by way of this Partial Motion for Summary Judgment. The court noted that Progressive’s expert’s opinion provided a reasonable basis for the carrier to conclude that the right shoulder complaints were not related to the accident.

The court also noted that the Plaintiff lacked a basis to contest the value of Progressive’s settlement offer given that the Plaintiff had dropped his wage loss claim and given that the Plaintiff was not pursuing recommended shoulder surgery.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 13, 2023).

Tuesday, July 25, 2023

Defendant's Petition To Open Default Judgment Was Too Late


In the case of Locklear v. Pocono Luxury Inc., No. 3142-CV-2020 (C.P. Monroe Co. May 8, 2023 Zulick, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Petition to Open a Default Judgment because the Defendant’s Petition was untimely.

This case arose out of a lawsuit filed by a Plaintiff against a Defendant home improvement company.

The court noted that, in order to open the default judgment, the Defendant was required to show a prompt filing of its Petition, a reasonable explanation for the default, and a meritorious defense.

In this case, the Defendant waited over a year after the default judgment was entered before filing a Petition to Open the Default Judgment. 

The court noted that various court documents and Orders were previously served on the Defendant prior to the filing of the Petition. No explanation was provided to the court why the Defendant did not seek legal representation or otherwise act during the time even before the Complaint was filed.

Judge Zulick noted that the prompt filing of a Petition to Open a Default Judgment typically refers to a period of less than one (1) month. The court noted that delays exceeding that time frame have been deemed to be untimely in other cases.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 20, 2023).

Monday, July 24, 2023

CORRECTED LINK: Trial Court Upholds Right of Plaintiff To Amend Complaint At Trial To Add Claims of Recklessness and Punitive Damages

 

Here is the corrected LINK for the case of Vanston v. Green Ridge Health Care Group, LLC, No. 2019-CV-6227 (C.P. Lacka. Co. July 7, 2023 Munley, Julia, J.), which was highlighted here on Tort Talk yesterday.  The case involved the Court's allowance of an amendment to a Complaint at trial to add claims of recklessness and punitive damages.

Sorry for any confusion that may have been caused.


Trial Court Upholds Right of Plaintiff To Amend Complaint At Trial To Add Claims of Recklessness and Punitive Damages


In the case of Vanston v. Green Ridge Health Care Group, LLC, No. 2019-CV-6227 (C.P. Lacka. Co. July 7, 2023 Munley, Julia, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for an Amendment of an Order for the purpose of seeking an interlocutory appeal.  This request was made relative to the trial court’s underlying Order that had allowed an amendment to the Plaintiff’s Complaint at a trial of a negligence case involving a nursing home to add a claim of recklessness and a claim for punitive damages after the completion of the testimony of certain Defendants and even though the statute of limitations had previously expired.

In this regard, Judge Munley found that there were sufficient facts pled in the original Complaint such that the court rejected the Defendant’s argument that the claims of recklessness and punitive damages were barred by the statute of limitations.

In her decision, Judge Munley cited to previous decisions by her colleague on the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas, Judge Terrence R. Nealon, who had previously ruled that amendments to a Complaint are permitted after the running of the statute of limitations so long as no new causes of action are pled.

Judge Julia Munley
Lackawanna County


In this regard, Judge Munley noted that recklessness is considered an aggravated form of negligence and not a new cause of action. She also noted that, under Pennsylvania law, a request for punitive damages does not constitute a cause of action in and of itself. Rather, a request for punitive damages is merely incidental to an underlying cause of action.

Accordingly, Judge Munley ruled that an amendment to a Complaint to add a claim for punitive damages after the statute of limitations has run is permissible where the main operative facts to support such a claim have been previously alleged in the original Complaint.

Judge Munley noted that a decision was further supported by the fact that the Plaintiffs alleged facts indicative of reckless conduct in the original Complaint.  The Court pointed to those cases in which it has been held that recklessness can be pled in any case whatsoever, regardless of the facts pled.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Jamie Anzalone and Attorney Kelly Ciravolo of Anzalone Law Offices in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania for bringing this case to my attention.