Wednesday, May 31, 2023

Court Rules That Forum Selection Clause in UIM Policy Allowed Plaintiff to File in Federal Court That Covered Area Where Plaintiff Resided


In the case of Warren v. Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., No. 1:22-CV-01309 (M.D. Pa. May 4, 2023 Wilson, J.), the court denied the UIM carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a UIM claim and granted the Plaintiff leave to effectuate proper service.

In this UIM matter, the Defendants asserted that the Complaint should be dismissed for insufficient service of process, improper venue, and failure to state a claim.

As noted, the court granted the Plaintiff leave to effectuate proper service.

In part, the UIM carrier asserted that the insurance contract’s forum selection clause rendered the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania an improper venue.

In addressing this motion, the court applied the venue rules found under F.R.C.P. 12.

In reviewing this Motion to Dismiss, the court noted that the forum selection clause in the policies at issue required that the Plaintiff to file the action in a “court of competent jurisdiction in the county and state” where the Plaintiff resided at the time of the accident.

The carriers asserted that, because the Plaintiffs resided in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania at the time of the accident, the forum selection clause only allowed the Plaintiff to bring his claim into Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas.

The court disagreed and accepted the Plaintiff’s claim that the forum selection clause should be interpreted broadly to also cover the Federal Middle District Court as a court of competent jurisdiction that covered the area of Cumberland County.

The court found that the plain language of the forum selection clause allowed the Plaintiff to file the action in the Federal District Court if so desired.   As such, the Motion to Dismiss was denied in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA office of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, May 29, 2023

Trial Court Denies Motion to Stay Underlying Proceedings Related to Companion Coverage Case



In the case of Pettinato Realty Co., Inc. v. Travelers Prop. Cas. Co. of Am., No. 22-CV-932 (C.P. Lacka. Co. March 16, 2023 Nealon, J.), the court denied a carrier’s Motion to Stay the civil proceedings in an underlying breach of contract and negligence claim arising out of an insurance coverage dispute.

While the Defendant carrier argued that the underlying matter was not yet “ripe” for litigation given that no coverage determination had been made to date, the trial court determined that it was in the court’s best interests to allow the litigants to proceed with discovery and pre-trial proceedings so that the case would not later be delayed once coverage determination was completed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (April 11, 2023).

Friday, May 26, 2023

LACKAWANNA PRO BONO GOLF TOURNAMENT NEEDS YOU

 


Plaintiff Allowed to Proceed With Claims in Premises Liability Case That Decedent Passed Away From Exposure to Covid-19 Virus During Post-Accident Treatment


In the case of Corter v. Wal-Mart, No. CV-22-00100 (C.P. Lyc. Co. April 11, 2023 Linhardt, J.), the court sustained in part and denied in part various Preliminary Objections filed by Defendant Wal-Mart in a case involving allegations relative to a slip and fall matter that allegedly resulted in injuries that allegedly led to the Plaintiff’s death.

More specifically, the Plaintiff alleged that the decedent sustained multiple fractures during the course of his slip and fall injuries, as well as traumatic brain injuries, all of which required hospitalization. It was further alleged that the decedent was exposed to the COVID-19 virus during his hospitalization and in-patient treatment which allegedly caused and/or contributed to his death.

In one of its Preliminary Objections, Wal-Mart sought to strike, as scandalous and impertinent, allegations in the Complaint related to the Plaintiff’s alleged exposure to the COVID-19 virus during his post-incident treatment.

The court noted that the validity of these types of allegations turned on the issue of whether or not the Plaintiff had stated illegally cognizable claim of negligence against Wal-Mart. The court noted that, if the decedent’s death could not be attributed to Wal-Mart’s negligence as a matter of law, then the allegations that the decedent died, in part, due to exposure of the COVID-19 virus would be inappropriate and immaterial to the claims presented.

Judge Linhardt noted that, in this early stage of the litigation, the court could not conclude, as a matter of law, that Wal-Mart’s alleged negligence was not the legal cause of the decedent’s eventual death from COVID. As such, the court found that, at least at this stage of the litigation, allegations regarding the circumstances of the decedent’s death were neither scandalous nor impertinent.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Gary L. Weber, who is the Editor of the Lycoming Reporter and a member of the Williamsport, Pennsylvania law firm of Mitchell Gallagher, for bringing this case to my attention. 

Thursday, May 25, 2023

New Trial Granted After Jury Awarded Zero Damages


In the case of Giko v. Calgiano, No. 1262 EDA 2022 (Pa. Super. March 29, 2023 Lazarus, J., Nichols, J., and McCaffery, J.) (Op. by Lazarus, J.) [non-precedential], the Pennsylvania Superior Court concluded that a jury’s award of $0 damages was against the weight of the evidence and, as such, the appellate court remanded the case for a new trial limited to damages.

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of a rear-end motor vehicle accident.

At trial, the jury found that the Plaintiff had sustained injuries in the accident and that the Defendant was 75% liable. However, the jury awarded $0 in damages.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff declined treatment at the scene and proceeded to work. Later that day, however, the Plaintiff’s supervisor suggested that the Plaintiff leave work early and get treatment for complaints of neck and back pain.

The Plaintiff reported to an Urgent Care Center and was prescribed medication and advised to use ice and heat. Shortly thereafter, the Plaintiff began a course of physical therapy.

The Plaintiff also eventually underwent bilateral sacroiliac joint injections. She additionally had EMG and MRI testing for complaints of neck and back pain. The Plaintiff’s overall medical bills were noted to be in excess of $26,000.00.

Based upon the evidence in the record, the Superior Courtfound that the jury’s finding that the Plaintiff’s harm was not compensable was against the weight of the evidence. The court held that the award of $0 damages bore no reasonable relationship to the alleged losses suffered.

While the court recognized that not every injury results in compensable pain and that a jury may decline an award of compensation for pain and suffering if the jury determines that the discomfort suffered by the Plaintiff was the sort of “transient rub of life” for which compensation is not warranted, here, the court found that the record confirmed that the Plaintiff had indeed sustained pain and suffering and that the general proposition that victims of accidents must be compensated for all that they suffer from the tort of another warranted the granting of a new trial.

Accordingly, the Superior Court found that the jury’s award of $0 damages was against the weight of the evidence. As such, the court reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded the case for a new trial limited to damages only.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this non-precedential decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Dale G. Larrimore of the Philadelphia law firm of Larrimore & Farnish, LLP, for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, May 24, 2023

Information From GPS System Found Not to be Hearsay (Criminal Court Decision)

 

In the case of Commonwealth v. Wallace, No. 93 MAP 2021 (Pa. Feb. 22, 2023)(Op. by Todd, C.J.)(Wecht, J. Concurring), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a global positioning system (GPS data) is not inadmissible hearsay under Pa. R.E. 803 (setting forth hearsay exceptions).

Such information was found not to be hearsay because that information does not constitute a statement made by a declarant as outlined in Pa. R.E. 801 and/or is not an assertion (or the nonverbal conduct) by a person.

As this decision may prove useful in a civil litigation matter, it is highlighted here on Tort Talk.    

Here is a LINK to the Court's Majority Opinion.  The Concurring Opinion by Justice Wecht can be viewed HERE,

Source of image:  Photo by Tamas Tuzes-Katai on www.unsplash.com.

Tuesday, May 23, 2023

Trial Court Follows Mione and Upholds Household Exclusion


In the case of Erie Insurance Exchange v. Burnsworth, No. 325-CV-2021 (C.P. Somerset Co. March 29, 2023 Geary, P.J.), the court upheld a household exclusion under an Erie Insurance policy and confirmed that the carrier did not have any obligation to provide underinsured motorist benefits to the Plaintiffs.

The court additionally found that the Plaintiff had no obligation to provide UIM benefits to the Plaintiff based upon the Plaintiff’s rejection of UIM coverage for the motorcycle involved in the subject accident.

At the time of the accident, the Plaintiffs were on a motorcycle when they were rear-ended.

That motorcycle was insured by Progressive Insurance Company. Under that policy, the Plaintiff had rejected UM and UIM coverage for the motorcycle.

The Plaintiff also had a separate automobile insurance policy with Erie Insurance that covered their automobiles. That policy had a household vehicle exclusion. The motorcycle was not insured under the Erie Insurance policy.

After settling the personal injury claim against the tortfeasor arising out of the accident during which the Plaintiffs were on their motorcycle, the Plaintiffs filed a claim for UIM benefits under their Erie Insurance policy that covered the other vehicles in their household.

Erie rejected the claim and filed this declaratory judgment action requesting that the court find that the Plaintiffs were not entitled to UIM benefits for the motorcycle accident given that the motorcycle was not covered under the Erie Insurance policy and given that the Plaintiff had rejected UIM coverage under the separate policy that covered the motorcycle.

The decision in this case was the result of a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings filed by the carrier.

Judge Geary of the Somerset County Court of Common Pleas noted that, although the Plaintiffs were relying upon the case of Gallagher v. Geico, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had recently resolved the same types of issues as presented in this matter in its decision in the case of Erie Insurance v. Mione, No. 89 MAP 2021 (Pa. Feb. 15, 2023).

Essentially, this trial court judge agreed with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Mione that the Plaintiffs are not entitled to UIM coverage in cases where UIM coverage cannot be stacked given that UIM coverage was rejected with respect to the vehicle involved in the accident.  The court found that, in this regard, the requirements under 75 Pa. C.S.A. §1738 regarding securing a waiver of stacking are “simply not implicated.” See Op. at 2. quoting Mione.

Judge Geary emphasized in this Erie v. Burnsworth Opinion that, as “made clear” by Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the case of Mione, “when an insured seeks UM/UIM benefits under a household policy but does not have UM/UIM coverage on the vehicle that he or she was occupying at the time of the collision…the household vehicle exclusion serves as an unambiguous preclusion of all UM/UIM coverage (even unstacked coverage) for damages sustained while operating an unlisted household vehicle."

In short, the court ruled that UIM coverage under the Erie policy could not be stacked onto the motorcycle because the motorcycle was not a covered vehicle under the Erie Insurance policy and given that the Plaintiffs had waived UM/UIM coverage for the motorcycle under the Progressive policy.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Joseph Hudock of the Pittsburgh law firm of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Rauch P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by MateuszDach on www.pexels.com.