Thursday, December 20, 2018

Motion To Amend Complaint to Correct Allegation on Where Incident Occurred Denied Where Statute of Limitations Has Expired


In the Lehigh County case of Hamsher v. Shook, 58 Leh. L.J. 139 (C.P. Leh. Co. Aug. 2, 2018 Johnson, J.), the court ruled, in a slip and fall case, that a Motion to Amend a Complaint To Reflect Correct Address of Subject Accident after the statute of limitations had expired in order to allege a different place of the incident was denied as such an amendment was deemed not to cure a merely technical defect, but was actually found to constitute a different occurrence.

More specifically, the court found that an amendment that would change the location of the incident from one where the Defendant owed no duty to a location where the Defendant did owe a duty, changes the occurrence pled, which is not a permissible amendment once the statute of limitations has expired.

In conjunction with denying the Plaintiff's Motion to Amend, the court also granted the Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment.

Anyone wishing to review this Opinion may click this LINK.

Wednesday, December 19, 2018

Preliminary Objections Denied in Premises Case on Issues of Agency, Recklessness, and Specificity

The Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed Preliminary Objections to a personal injury Complaint in the case of Rossi v. School Side Builders, Inc., No. 2017-CV-2731 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 15, 2018 Nealon, J.).   This matter arose out of a premises liability claim.   

The Plaintiff contends that she was a residential tenant on the Defendant’s premises.   The Plaintiff was in the process of cooking french fries in a pan with grease on an electric stove when the pan suddenly caught on fire.   

The Plaintiff alleged that the flames from the fire activated the automatic sprinkler system in the building and water was emitted from the sprinkler head which then allegedly caused a fireball explosion when the water contacted the boiling grease.  This allegedly caused the boiling grease to splash from the pan and burn the Plaintiff on various parts of her body.  

The case came before the court by way of Preliminary Objections filed by the Defendant seeking to strike the Plaintiff’s vicarious liability claim based upon the Plaintiff’s failure to identify the Defendant’s alleged agents by name.    

The Defendants also preliminarily objected to the Plaintiff’s allegations of recklessness and the related claim for punitive damages on the grounds that the Plaintiff has not alleged sufficient facts to support those claims.   

The Defendants additionally asserted a “Connor” objection with regards to the Plaintiff’s references to the Defendant’s alleged failure to comply with certain requirements of the International Building Code and the National Fire Protection Association requirements without specifying which code provisions or requirements were allegedly violated.  

With regards to the Preliminary Objections to the vicarious liability claim, the court addressed various appellate decisions which have repeatedly held that a plaintiff's failure to identify the Defendant’s agents by name, or the designation of those individuals as a unit, does not justify striking agent allegations in a Complaint.   Judge Nealon noted that these appellate court decisions have led to a number of similar decisions in the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas rejecting efforts by Defendant to strike agency claims for failure to identify the actual or ostensible agents by name [usually in the medical malpractice context].   

The court in Rossi also noted that, to rule otherwise, would result in numerous requests for pre-Complaint discovery in virtually every case in order to pre-empt the filing of these types of Preliminary Objections by Defendants.   Accordingly, these Preliminary Objections to the vicarious liability allegations in the Complaint were denied.  

Relative to the allegations of recklessness and the claim for punitive damages, the court reviewed the requirements for this type of cause of action and held that, based upon a review of the allegations in the Complaint, the Plaintiff had sufficiently pled these claims under the current status of the law.  As such, these Preliminary Objections were denied as well.  

With regards to the Defendant’s Connor objections regarding the Plaintiff’s allegations pertaining to violations of co-provisions and requirements, the court ruled that the Plaintiff alleged sufficient facts to implicate the Code provisions and noted that the issue of which sections of the application Codes were applicable could be developed and determined during the course of discovery and thereafter addressed and resolved in Pre-Trial Motions In Limine.   As such, these Preliminary Objections were denied by the court as well.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, December 18, 2018

Lehigh County Court Rules that One Spouse Not Liable for Assault on Third Person By Other Spouse

In the Lehigh County case of Mantone v. Laughlin, 58 Leh. L.J. 145 (C.P. Leh. Co. Aug. 7, 2018), the court ruled that a cause of action does not exist against a spouse of a person who violently assaulted a third party. 

The court ruled that, since the spouse owed no duty of care to protect that third party from actions by her husband, the spouse had no liability towards that party. 

The court ruled in this regard despite allegations of knowledge on the part of the Defendant spouse that her husband, who had assaulted the Plaintiff, had engaged in past violence and had failed to take his psychiatric medication. The court also rejected the allegation that the spouse failed to assist her husband in recommencing taking medication.  

In light of its rulings that one spouse owed no duty to third parties to protect them from negligent conduct by the other spouse under the facts presented, the court granted the Defendant's Preliminary Objections and dismissed the Plaintiff's Complaint.


Anyone wishing to review this Opinion may click this LINK.



Monday, December 17, 2018

Friday, December 14, 2018

A HOLIDAY GIFT FROM TORT TALK: COMPLIMENTARY COPY OF THE TORT TALK 2018 CIVIL LITIGATION UPDATE BOOKLET

Here is a LINK to a complimentary copy of the 119 page Tort Talk 2018 Civil Litigation Update booklet that I created for use at the recent Luzerne Bench Bar Conference.

The Tort Talk 2018 Civil Litigation Update was created from the Tort Talk posts pertaining to notable decisions handed down over the past year or so and is offered here free of charge for the readers of Tort Talk.

To the extent you may have a desire to pay it forward as they say, I would politely propose considering a small donation to the Children's Advocacy Center in Scranton, your local Pro Bono Office, or perhaps another charity of your choice in this Season of Giving.
 
The Children's Advocacy Center in Scranton is a private non-profitable charitable organization whose mission is to provide services in the assessment and treatment in abuse and neglect case involving children.  The Children's Advocacy Center is located at 1710 Mulberry Street, Scranton, PA 18510.  Here is a LINK to their website.  Just a thought.

Thanks for reading Tort Talk and and thank you for providing me with notable cases to highlight on Tort Talk.  All is much appreciated.

I wish you Warm and Happy Holidays


 


 

Tuesday, December 11, 2018

PA Supreme Court Reaffirms Rule that Workers' Compensation Carrier May Not Directly Enforce Its Subrogation Rights Against Tortfeasor

In the case of Hartford Ins. Grp. v. Kamara, No. 24 EAP 2017 (Nov. 21, 2018) (Op. by Baer, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether a workers’ compensation carrier could bring a third-party action against an alleged tortfeasor on behalf of an injured employee in order to recover the amount of money paid out in workers’ compensation benefits where that injured employee did not independently sue the tortfeasor, did not join in the carrier’s action, and did not assign her cause of action to the carrier.  

This matter arose out of an incident during which the Plaintiff was struck as a pedestrian while the Plaintiff was in the scope and course of her employment.   The Plaintiff had recovered workers’ compensation benefits through the Hartford Insurance Group.

When the Plaintiff herself did not seek to recover damages against the third party tortfeasors, the workers’ compensation carrier sought to recover on its subrogation rights under the workers’ compensation act by filing a suit against the tortfeasors.  

After this case worked its way up to the appellate ladder, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in this case reaffirmed the “well-settled proposition that the right of action against the tortfeasor remains in the injured employee.”   The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that, unless the injured employee assigns her cause of action or voluntarily joins the litigation as a party Plaintiff, the workers’ compensation carrier may not enforce its statutory right to subrogation by filing an action directly against the tortfeasor.  

As such, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania vacated the Superior Court’s judgment and reinstated the decision of the trial court which had sustained the Preliminary Objections filed by the tortfeasor which serve to dismiss the carrier’s Complaint with prejudice.  

Anyone wishing to review the Majority Opinion by Justice Baer may click HERE.

The Dissenting Opinion by Chief Justice Saylor can be viewed HERE.

The Dissenting Opinion by Justice Todd can be viewed at this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, Pennsylvania law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, December 10, 2018

Raising Too Many Issues On Appeal Will Dilute a Good Case and Will Not Save a Bad One

In the case of Berks Counseling Center v. Community Care, No. 898 MDA 2017 (Pa. Super. Nov. 7, 2018 Panella, J., Olson, J., Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Panella, J.)(Non-Precedential), the court chastised the appellant for “throwing in every conceivable point” in its appellate’s filings.  This case arose out of a dispute by the Plaintiff with one of its contractors.  

This case again provides the lesson that the appellate court frowns upon appeals containing many issues.   Here, the appellant raised eight (8) issues on appeal.

Judge Panella noted that the appellate court judges’ receptiveness of issues raised on appeal “declines as the number of assigned errors increases.”  

Judge Panella additionally noted in his opinion that “experience on the bench convinces [him] that multiplying assignments of error will dilute and weaken a good case and will not save a bad one.”   It was additionally noted that throwing in every possible point on appeal is distracting to judges and gives support to a presumption that none of the arguments raised has any merit whatsoever.  

Ultimately, the Superior Court ruled in favor of Berks Counseling Center and held that none of the issues raised on appeal by Community Care merited any relief.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source:  Article by PJ D’Annunzio entitled “Court Chastising Appellant for ‘Throwing In Every Conceivable Point,’”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 13, 2018).  

Commentary:  The Superior Court cautions in this Opinion that multiplicity of claims on appeal hints a lack of confidence in any one of the claims.  How ironic that the Court would issue this Opinion as a "Non-Precedential" Opinion as a listing of an Opinion as "Non-Precedential," as opposed to a published Opinion of precedence, also hints that perhaps the Court is not as confident in its Opinion.

It is respectfully submitted that, in this day and age of digital publication, the time has come for the Superior Court to publish all of its Opinions.  A concern that the publication of too many Opinions will fill too many books is not as strong of a concern anymore as the use of books is (unfortunately) becoming a thing of the past.  

Here's to hoping that the Superior Court changes its internal rules and opts to publish all of its Opinions so that the bench and bar may have more and more excellent appellate guidance on a wide variety of issues for the benefit of all.


What do you think?