Wednesday, October 31, 2018

DO YOU HAVE A CASE THAT SCARES YOU?


Do you have a case or cases that scares you?  Why not try settling it?

I welcome any opportunity to assist you in settling your cases through CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES.

In addition to my own personal experience of sitting through innumerable settlement conferences as a law clerk for Judge Harold A. Thomson, Jr. of Pike County at the beginning of my career, I have also participated in successful Mediations over the past 17 years as both a litigator and as a Mediator in the Federal Middle District Court Mediation Program.  I have additionally attended many continuing legal education courses in an effort to further hone my skills and tools related to fostering ongoing negotiations at Mediations.  I have continued to develop these skills at numerous successful Mediations scheduled through Cummins Mediation Services.

To schedule a Mediation, please contact me at dancummins@comcast.net or at 570-346-0745.

Resume and fee schedule available upon request.




Tuesday, October 30, 2018

Motion for Remittitur of Punitive Damages Granted


In the case of Jester v. Hutt, No. 1:15-CV-00205 (M.D. Pa. Aug. 29, 2018 Kane, J.), the court granted a Motion for Remittitur of Punitive Damages.  

According to the Opinion, the court found that an award of $90,000.00 for punitive damages in a defamation case was constitutionally excessive where the jury only awarded $1.00 in actual damages.  

The court also noted that the level of reprehensibility with regards to the Defendant was low under the facts presented.   The court also emphasized that there was no risk of physical injury or danger to the safety of others relative to the underlying event. 

The court cut the punitive damages down to $5,500.00.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck, of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm and the writer of the excellent Drug and Device Law blog for bringing this case to my attention.

UPDATE:  The trial court's decision in this case was overturned by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in a decision handed down by that Court on August 28, 2019.  Click HERE to view that decision.

Recoverability of Future Medical Expenses in an Auto Accident Case Addressed


A number of civil litigation trial issues were reviewed in the case of Farese v. Robinson, No. April Term 2015 1084 (C.P. Phila. Co. Sept. 6, 2018 Kennedy, J.), including the issue of how to handle a claim for future medical expenses in a motor vehicle accident matter.  

The case arose out a rear-end motor vehicle accident.   The case proceeded to trial and a jury entered a verdict in excess of $2.5 million dollars in favor of the Plaintiff.   The Defendants filed post-trial motions which brought about this Rule 1925 Opinion by the trial court judge.  

With respect to the Plaintiff’s claims for future medical expenses, defense asserted that a new trial on damages was necessary given that the Plaintiffs introduced evidence concerning future medical costs without reducing those costs in accordance with the cost containment provisions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (“MVFRL”), or Act 6.  

The trial court rejected the Defendant’s position as well as the defense’s reliance upon the case of Pittsburgh Neurosurgery Assoc’s v. Danner, 733 A.2d 1279 (Pa. Super. 1999), as the court found that that case was limited by the Superior Court to an application to past medical bills that had already been incurred by an injured party for treatment that had already been provided.  

Instead, the trial court relied upon the case of Moorehead v. Crozer Chester Medical Center, 765 A.2d 786 (Pa. 2001).  Also, the trial court also noted that the medical bills in this case that were presented to the jury had apparently already been subjected to the cost containment provisions of the MVFRL.   

The trial court in this case of Farese noted that its Opinion was that future medical costs are not considered “payable” within the meaning of §1722 or §1797 of the MVFRL.    The court believed that to claim that bills for medical services not yet performed should be considered “capable of being paid” in this context, “creates an unpersuasive logical fallacy.”   The court noted that, to rule otherwise, would create confusion as any medical service not yet performed would be considered “payable.”  

This particular court believed that future medical costs can only exists as being “not payable” under §1797.  

Practically speaking, the trial court found that the Plaintiff’s expert life care planner had properly opined as to the future cost of medical care under the “usual and customary charge(s)” mandated by 75 Pa. C.S.A. §1797(a).   The expert offered his opinion at trial that life care planners base protections on future medical care upon the usual and customary costs going into future because it is too speculative to know what reimbursements will be from month-to-month.

In entering its ruling, the Farese court pointed to the Federal Middle District Court decision of Kansky v. Showman, No. 3:09-cv-1863, 2011 WL 1362245 (M.D. Pa. April 11, 2011 Munley), in which that Federal District Court held that future medical bills are not “payable” as future medical payments are not currently outstanding and able to be paid and given that Defendants cannot guarantee that any future medical expenses will in fact be paid.    That court ruled that the payment of future medical expenses is merely speculative as a carrier could become bankrupt or could deny future medical bills for a variety of reasons.  [However, neither the Farese court nor the Kansky court pointed out that whether a Plaintiff will actually undergo future medical treatment once they settle their case or secure a verdict is speculative as well].   

The Kansky court held that, because the insurance benefits are not necessarily due and owing at the time of a trial and given that nothing could compel a carrier to pay a lump sum for future medical expenses, a Plaintiff’s future medical bills cannot be considered to be “payable” under Act 6.  

The Farese court followed this reasoning in its own decision and denied the defense’s request for a new trial based upon the handling of the future medical expenses claim at trial.  

Here is a LINK to the "Future Medical Expenses" Label, which can always be freely access down the right hand column of the Tort Talk Blog at www.TortTalk.com to access blog posts on this particular troublesome and unsettled topic.

The Farese decision is also notable in that the trial court held that the expert testimony offered by the Plaintiff from a neuro-radiologist was not considered to be cumulative when compared to the other expert medical evidence offered by the Plaintiff.   The court felt that the expert’s expertise in the area of neuro-radiology allowed that doctor to provide a nuanced opinion of the injuries sustained by the Plaintiff that better explained the injuries to the jury in a manner different then that from the Plaintiff’s other medical experts.  

The Farese court also addressed the issue of Defendant’s Motion for Remittitur against the Plaintiff’s substantial verdict.   In this regard, the court provided a detailed analysis of the current state of Pennsylvania law in addressing claims that a jury’s verdict is allegedly excessive.  

In the end, this court found that the jury’s award for damages was not excessive and did not shock the judicial conscience.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  

Source:  “Digest of Recent Opinions” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Oct. 16, 2018).   

Monday, October 29, 2018

A Primer on Joining and Serving Additional Defendants

Lackawanna County Courthouse

In the medical malpractice case of Mayer v. Delserra, No. 17–CV-03968 (C.P. Lacka.  Co. Oct. 5, 2018 Nealon, J.), the trial court in Lackawanna County addressed objections to a Defendant’s service of a third party Complaint upon an Additional Defendant. 

More specifically, the Additional Defendant who was served with the Joinder Complaint filed Preliminary Objections challenging the service of original process of the Joinder Complaint as improper after the original Defendant-hospital attempted to serve that Additional Defendant via certified mail at an incorrect office address.  

The joined Additional Defendant also asserted that the Joinder Complaint should be dismissed since the statute of limitations had expired.  

The non-moving original Defendant-hospital argued in response that the service of process by certified mail was proper and that the Additional Defendant had waived the right to object to the allegedly defective service by virtue of the Additional Defendant’s attorney’s attendance at the two (2) depositions that have been conducted in the case to date.  

After reviewing the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure pertaining to the service of a Joinder Complaint upon a Pennsylvania Additional Defendant, the court noted that these Rules required that such service be effectuated by the Sheriff hand-delivering the original process to the Additional Defendant or an appropriate person at that Defendant’s residence or business.  An exception to those Rules was that service could be completed by the Defendant's attorney agreeing to accept service.

Here, the court set aside the improper service in this matter and directed the Defendant-hospital to reinstate the Joinder Complaint and serve the same properly.  

In so ruling, Judge Nealon found that the attendance of the Additional Defendant’s attorney at previously scheduled depositions, which depositions occurred after the Preliminary Objections at issue had already been filed, did not constitute such action on the merits of the case by that Additional Defendant so as to waive the right to object to defective service.  Rather, the court noted that such attendance at the deposition instead served to cure any prejudice that may have resulted from the improper service and the Additional Defendant’s belated entry into the case.  

The court further ruled that, since the applicable statute of limitations period relative to the Defendant-hospital’s contribution and indemnification claims had not yet begun to run, the proper remedy for the defective service was to simply set it aside and allow the joining party to attempt to properly serve that Additional Defendant.

Anyone wishing to review this case may click HERE.

Superior Court Rules on Scope of Obligation of First Party Carriers to Pay Chiropractors for Treatment Rendered by Staff


In the recent Superior Court decision in the case of State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Cavoto, 2018 Pa. Super. 285 (Pa. Super. Oct. 17, 2018 Gantman, P.J., Shogan, J., and Blatt, J.) (Op. by Shogan, J.), the court addressed an appeal from a declaratory action filed by State Farm seeking a judicial declaration that it was not obligated to pay the chiropractor for treatments and procedures delegated to, and perform by, chiropractic support personnel without special licenses or certifications.  

The Superior Court held that the chiropractor cannot be expected to be paid by a first party carrier for such services performed by unlicensed support personnel.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Scott B. Cooper of the Harrisburg, Pennsylvania law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.  

Friday, October 26, 2018

LACKAWANNA PRO BONO GALA SET FOR NEXT THURSDAY NOVEMBER 1, 2018


Summary Judgment Granted in Slip on Grape Case



In the case of Pace v. Wal-Mart Stores, No. 17-1829 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 18, 2018 Baylson, J.), the court granted summary judgment to the Defendant was unable to show that the Defendant had actual or constructive notice of a hazardous condition in an alleged slip and fall on grapes or grape juice.  

Notably, where the Defendant produced an affidavit confirming that there was no video of the location where the Plaintiff fell and that no videos had been destroyed, the Plaintiff’s request for an inference of spoliation of evidence was denied.  

A nice overview of the current status of Pennsylvania premises liability law can be seen in this Opinion.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.”  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (October 2, 2018).