Thursday, February 1, 2018

Expert Testimony Required to Proceed on Malpractice Claim Against a Physical Therapist

In the case of Bassill v. Main Line Hospitals, Inc., No. 16-01575 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 11, 2018 Pappert, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court of Pennsylvania entered summary judgment in favor of a Defendant after finding that a claim of negligence against a physical therapist involves a claim for professional negligence for which expert testimony is required to establish the standard of care for the jury.  

In this decision, the court also noted that expert testimony establishing causation is also mandatory under Pennsylvania law.  

Given the pro se Plaintiff’s failures in this regard, the court granted summary judgment in favor of the defense. 

The Bassill court's Opinion can be viewed HERE.  The accompanying Order can be viewed HERE

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia law office of Reed Smith for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, January 30, 2018

PLEASE CONSIDER SERVING AS A JUROR AT HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL COMPETITIONS



The High School Mock Trial Competition is heating up in counties across the Commonwealth.  Please consider serving as a Juror to score the high school students competing in the tournament as attorneys and witnesses. 

For more details on the benefits of participating as a Juror in the competition please see my recent Pennsylvania Lawyer Magazine article on the topic at this LINK.  I am beginning the process of working with the Young Lawyers Division of the Pennsylvania Bar Association to draft a recommendation to the Board to urge the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and the CLE Board to consider allowing a CLE credit or credits for participation as a Juror.  The hope is that this will become a reality in future years.

Locally, the Lackawanna County Mock Trial Competition gets underway tonight at 6 pm in the state and federal courthouses in Scranton, PA.   Jurors are still needed to fill the Jury boxes.

To Sign Up to Serve as a Juror
 
Contact

  LBA at 570-969-9161 
or

Ryan P. Campbell, Esq. at HRLaw04@gmail.com  
 


LACKAWANNA COUNTY
MOCK TRIAL COMPETITION
 

- Round 1 - 

 Tuesday, January 30 at 6:00 p.m.

6 Trials

(3) William J. Nealon Federal Courthouse

(3) Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas
 



 

Jurors also needed for Round II
Wednesday, February 7, 2018
6:00 p.m.




Magistrate Judge Carlson of Federal Middle District Offers Up Guiding Principles for Social Media Discovery


In the case of Landau v. Lamas, 3:15 – CV - 1327 (M.D. Pa. Dec. 15, 2017 Carlson, M.J.)(Mem. Op.), Federal Magistrate Judge Carlson discussed "Guiding Principles" for social media discovery under the general mandates of F.R.C.P. 26 pertaining to permitted discovery efforts. 

This case arises out of a Section 1983 civil rights suit by a prison inmate.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff motioned to compel what the court described as "extremely intrusive inquiry" into the Defendant's social media pages. 

The Court denied the motion to compel to the extent the motion sought "wholesale access to electronic social media.”  However, the Court allowed the Plaintiff to attempt to craft more specifically tailored discovery requests.

The Court also directed the defense to preserve all social media content from the relevant time period and to make inquiries regarding any social media that may have been deleted.  The defense was also told to voluntarily produce relevant social media content in accordance with the requirements of F.R.C.P. 26.  The defense was also ordered to specify what content was being withheld and to state why it was being withheld.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision, may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Brian Murren of the Camp Hill, PA office of Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, January 29, 2018

Amazon.com Found Not to Be A "Seller" for Purposes of Pennsylvania Strict Liability Claim (UPDATE: Reversed on Appeal)


In the case of Oberdorf v. Amazon.com, Inc., No. 4: 16-CV-01127 (M.D. Pa. Dec. 21, 2017 Brann, J.) Judge Matthew W. Brann of the Middle District Federal Court of Pennsylvania granted summary judgment in favor of the Defendant after finding that an online marketer, such as Amazon.com, is not liable for defects in products purchased through its website from third party vendors.  

The case arose out of an incident during which the Plaintiff was injured when a retractable leash she was using while walking her dog allegedly malfunction, snapped back, and caused permanent injury to the Plaintiff's eye.

The court generally noted that the online marketer is not a seller of third-party products as required by §402A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts.  

Rather, the court found that the Amazon.com website was a merely a means of marketing products by a third party seller who chose what products to market and how.   The court noted that, due to the enormous number of third party sellers and their products, the Defendant, Amazon.com, was not in a position to pass upon the quality of the innumerable products available on its website.  

Rather, the Amazon Marketplace was deemed by the court as a sort of newspaper classified ad section that puts potential consumers in touch with sellers.

As such, given that the court found that Amazon.com is not a seller in the context of Section 402A, the Plaintiff's strict liability claims asserted against this online marketer were dismissed.

Judge Brann's Opinion in Oberdorf can be viewed at this LINK.  The Court's accompanying Order can be viewed HERE.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia law office of Reed Smith for bringing this case to my attention. 

UPDATE:  On July 3, 2019, the Third Circuit Court of Appeal reversed this decision in an Opinion issued under docket No. 18-1041.  Type "Oberdorf" into the Search Box to access the Tort Talk blog post on that decision along with a Link to the Third Circuit's Opinion.



UPDATE:  According to a September 23, 2020 article in the Pennsylvania Law Weekly, this case was settled and, therefore, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court would not be addressing the question presented.

Wednesday, January 24, 2018

Punitive Damages Claim Allowed to Proceed in Cell Phone Use Car Accident Case



Another Northampton County Court of Common Pleas case allowing claims for punitive damages to proceed beyond the preliminary objections stage in a case where the Plaintiff was rear ended by a defendant in an auto accident case during which the defendant was allegedly talking and/or texting on a cell phone while operating his vehicle at an excessive rate of speed.

To view this case of Lopez v. Wilson, 59 Northampton 812 (C.P. Northampt. Co. 2017 Murray, J.), click this LINK.

In this decision from the early part of last year (2017), the court provides a nice summary of the early cases on this particular issue.


Source: "Court Summaries" by Timothy L. Clawges in The Pennsylvania Bar News Vol. 28 No. 1 (Jan. 1, 2018).

Tuesday, January 23, 2018

ARTICLE: The Benefits of Participation in the Mock Trial Competition

Here is a LINK to my recent article in the January/February 2018 edition of The Pennsylvania Lawyer magazine entitled "The Benefits of Participation in the Mock Trial Competition."

The article touts the benefits of offering your time and expertise to this excellent program for high school students run by Young Lawyer Divisions all across the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

Hoping you might consider helping out the program by volunteering your time as a juror in a local mock trial competition in your county.  As noted in the article, you may be surprise by how much you can learn simply by sitting in the jury box and watching a simulated trial play out before.  Perhaps most enlightening is the fact that an effective Opening Statement and a forceful Closing Argument can be presented within the confines of a mandatory five minute time limit.

The educational benefits of participating as a juror in the mock trial program are so great that the CLE Board should consider revising its guidelines or bylaws to allow for at least one substantive credit per year per attorney for participation as a juror.  Surely, more is learned by an attorney actively participating as a mock trial juror than by passively sitting and watching a CLE video.

Participation in the mock trial program as a juror or otherwise is a great way to give back to the community and serves to mentor some of those high school students who may make up the next generation of the bar.

The local Lackawanna County Mock Trial Competition gets underway a week from today on January 30, 2018 -- please consider contacting the Bar Association to volunteer your time as a juror.

Friday, January 19, 2018

Writing Tips

I came across the below good tips for writing and, finding them amusing, thought I would share them with you here on Tort Talk: