Sunday, June 29, 2014

Northeastern Pennsylvania Attorney Malcolm L. MacGregor Takes Over as President of the Pennsylvania Association for Justice

Malcolm L. MacGregor, Esq.

In notable legal news out of Northeastern Pennsylvania, Attorney Malcolm L. MacGregor of the Scranton Law Firm of McDonald & MacGregor was installed as the President of the Pennsylvania Association for Justice at their recent Annual Meeting at the Bedford Springs Resort in Bedford Springs, PA.  Attorney MacGregor is also currently ably serving as the President of the Lackawanna Bar Association.

Congratulations to a great lawyer and a great person.  Both of those organizations are lucky to have him at the helm.

LINK to the One Where the Plaintiff Rear-Ended the Defendant and Sued and Court Entered Summary Judgment For Defendant


Tort Talkers may recall that I highlighted the case of Marchese v. Jacobs out of Lycoming County - you know, the one where the Plaintiff motorcyclist rear-ended the Defendant and then sued the Defendant and the Defendant secured a summary judgment.

Many were interested in the case and a number sent me a copy to disseminate.  Here is a LINK to the Marchese decision if you'd like to read it.

I send thanks for sending me a copy or a link to the case to Gary Weber of the Williamsport office of Mitchell Gallagher, Anthony J. Gabriel of the Harrisburg office of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer, Attorney Joseph Kulesa of Mount Pocono, Attorney Walt McClatchy, Jr. out of Philadelphia, and another who wished to remain anonymous.


Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Summary Judgment for Defendant Who Was Rear-Ended by Plaintiff



In a recent Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas decision in the case of Marchese v. Jacobs, PICS Case No. 14-0795 (C.P. Lycoming Co. May 1, 2014, Anderson, J.), the court granted summary judgment in favor of a Defendant driver who was rear-ended by the Plaintiff’s motorcyclist.

[Yes, you read that correctly - a plaintiff rear-ended a stopped vehicle and then sued that person - where there's a will, there's a way].

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was riding with other motorcyclists and following the Defendant’s car. The Defendant stopped because the car in front of him had stopped while waiting to turn left. The Plaintiff then collided with the Defendant’s stopped vehicle.

In a Motion for Summary Judgment, the Defendant argued that the accident was solely caused by the Plaintiff’s negligence in failing to keep an assured clear distance between his motorcycle and the Defendant’s vehicle ahead.

The Plaintiff countered with the argument that the Defendants came to a sudden stop and it was the sudden stop that caused the accident, all of which allegations allegedly fell within an application of the sudden emergency doctrine.

The Marchese court noted that the appellate courts of Pennsylvania have found that a sudden braking is deemed to be a foreseeable occurrence on the roadways of Pennsylvania.

Accordingly, the trial court ruled here that the facts of this matter fell within the assured clear distance ahead doctrine rather than the sudden emergency doctrine particularly where the sudden emergency doctrine only applies to "moving instrumentalities" thrust into driver’s path.

Here, the court found no evidence that the Defendant’s vehicle was thrust into the Plaintiff’s path of travel. There was also evidence that the Defendant’s vehicle was at a stopped position, and not moving, at the time of the accident.

Since the court ruled that the sudden emergency room doctrine did not apply and that there was no other evidence of negligence on the Defendant’s part, the Defendants were granted summary judgment.

I do not have a copy of this one.  Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact the Pennsylvania Instant Case Service of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly by calling 1-800-276-7427 and providing the above noted PICS Case No. along with a payment of a small fee.  

Source: "Case Digests," Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 27, 2014).

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Pennsylvania Superior Court Revisits Waiver of Stacking Issue

Here is a LINK to the Pennsylvania Superior Court's latest decision on the issue of stacked UM coverage in the case of Bumbarger v. Peerless Ins. Co., 2013 Pa.Super. 47 (Pa.Super. June 6, 2014)(en banc)(Gantman, J., concurring)(Opinion by Lazarus, J.).


In this case, the Plaintiff was involved in an accident with an uninsured driver and filed suit against her own carrier for uninsured motorists benefits.  An issue arose as to whether or not the Plaintiff was entitled to stacked coverage.


The Plaintiff had waived stacked coverage when she originally purchased the policy for coverage on two vehicles.  She eventually later separately added two more vehicles to the policy but the carrier never obtained additional waivers of stacked coverage from the Plaintiff insured.  One of the additional vehicles was added under an endorsement to the policy and, when the fourth vehicle was added to the policy, it was not by way of an endorsement.


The Plaintiff contended that pursuant to the Sackett decisions, the carrier was required to obtain additional waivers of stacking from its insured when the third and fourth vehicles were added to the policy.  The Plaintiff asserted that the carrier breached the policy by failing to allow for stacked coverage.


If it was deemed by the court that the coverage need not be stacked, the Plaintiff would be entitled to $25,000 in coverage.  If stacked coverage was found to be warranted, the stacked coverage would have been $100,000.


After reviewing the law on the issue as applied to the particular facts presented, the Superior Court ruled on its first take on the issue that new waiver of stacking forms were required and that the failure to secure the waivers resulted in the Plaintiff being entitled to stacked coverage.


Reargument en banc was requested and granted by the Superior Court.  In its most recent en banc decision in Bumbarger, the Superior Court ruled in the same fashion noted above, i.e., that new waiver of stacking forms were required and the failure of the carrier to secure them meant that the Plaintiff was entitled to stacked coverage.


As this issue is somewhat convoluted, I have provided a link to the opinion above if you wish to study the court's analysis and rationale.


Suffice it to say, a review of the Sackett decisions and this Bumbarger opinion support a position that a waiver of stacking form should be secured whenever a new vehicle is added to an automobile insurance policy to avoid the issue being raised in the first place.




I send thanks to Attorney Brian Bevan of the Pittsburgh, PA law firm of DiBella, Geer, McAllister & Best, P.C. for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Attorney's Fees Still Available If Peer Review Process Found Invalid


In their recent May 2, 2014 Opinion in the case of Doctor’s Choice Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Center, P.C. v. Travelers Personal Insurance Co., No. 1419 MDA 2013, 2014 Pa. Super 92 (Pa. Super. May 2, 2014 Dononhue, J., Allen, J., and Mundy, J.) (Opinion by Mundy, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed a case involving attorney’s fees awarded after a peer review process. 

Overall, the court ruled that an insurance company’s reliance upon a peer reviewer’s recommendation to deny claims does not protect that carrier from liability for attorney’s fees if the peer review is ultimately found to be invalid.  

Stated otherwise, the Superior Court ruled that by simply instituting a peer review process before denying a claim did not serve to guarantee that an insurance company would not be liable for attorney’s fees under the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law.   Rather, the Superior Court construed the relevant language of §1797(b)(4) of the MVFRL to mean that a completed, compliant, and valid peer review determination would be required.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Joe Thomas of the Panowicz Law Office in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania for bringing this case to my attention.  

Monday, June 16, 2014

Judge Burke of Luzerne County Allows Punitive Damages Claims To Proceed in Cell Phone(s) Distraction Auto Accident Case


In his recent Luzerne County decision in the case of Gugliotti v. O'Rourke, No. 2012-CV-15133 (C.P. Luzerne Co. 2014 Burke, P.J.), President Judge Thomas F. Burke, Jr., by Order only, denied a Defendant's Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's allegations of reckless conduct in support of compensatory and punitive damages claims in the Complaint concerning the Defendant's use of not one, but two, cell phones at the time he rear-ended the vehicles ahead.

According to the briefs filed in the matter, the police report indicated that the defendant driver allegedly admitted at the scene that "both of his cell phones began ringing and that he leaned over to answer them...[he] failed to see the stopped traffic ahead of him due to cell phone distraction and he struck the rear of Unit #2."

The defense asserted that the pleadings of the Complaint failed to conform to rule or law of court in that they included scandalous or impertinent allegations.  The defense also asserted that the allegations failed to have sufficient facts plead in support of the claims presented.

The defense asserted in its brief that punitive damages were not supported where the claims did not establish that the defendant was not talking on his cell phones at the time of the accident but merely stated that they had begun to ring.  The defense also noted that, in any event, use of a cell phone during the course of the accident in and of itself was insufficient to support allegations of reckless conduct or a claim for punitive damages.

The Plaintiff asserted in his brief that the conduct alleged of a defendant driver being distracted by leaning over to answer two cell phones that were simultaneously ringing and crashing into a car ahead and causing a four vehicle chain reaction accident was the type of conduct the cases to date have suggested may be sufficient to allow the claim to proceed.

As noted, Judge Burke overruled the defendant's Preliminary Objections.  Anyone wishing to review the Court's simple Order of denial may contact me at dancummins@Comcast.net.


I send thanks to the prevailing Plaintiff's attorneys Joseph Price, Esq. and Colleen Kearney, Esq. of the Moosic, PA law firm of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this case to my attention.

Hoping You Might Please Consider Registering For the Tort Talk Expo 2014

PLEASE SAVE THE DATE
 
September 26, 2014
 
TORT TALK EXPO 2014
 
Mohegan Sun Casino and Hotel
Wilkes-Barre, PA
 
(3 Substantive, 1 Ethics Credit)
 
 
 
 
 
TENTATIVE PROGRAM TO INCLUDE:
 
 
12:00 pm - 1:00 pm 
"Back to School"
A TORT TALK AUTO LAW/CIVIL LITIGATION UPDATE
by
Daniel E.  Cummins, Esq.
FOLEY, COMERFORD & CUMMINS
 
 
 
1:00 pm - 2:00 pm 
BAD FAITH UPDATE
by
 
Timothy G. Lenahan, Esq.
LENAHAN & DEMPSEY
 
Scott B. Cooper, Esq.
SCHMIDT KRAMER 
 
Neil T. O'Donnell, Esq.
O'DONNELL LAW OFFICES

Moderator: Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
FOLEY, COMERFORD & CUMMINS
 
 
 {BREAK: 2:00 pm - 2:15 pm}
 
 
  2:15 pm - 3:15 pm
MEDICAL HOUR
with
 
Dr. Lucian Bednarz  - Physiatrist - on RSD
and
Dr. Paul Horchos  - Physiatrist - on Post-concussion Syndrome
NORTHEASTERN REHABILITATION ASSOCIATES
 
 
 {BREAK:  3:15 pm - 3:30 pm}
 
 
 3:30 pm - 4:30 pm
VIEW FROM THE BENCH
Ethical Considerations
for
Settlement Conferences
and
Jury Selection
 
Moderator:  Paul Oven, Esq.
Dougherty, Leventhal & Price
 
 
JUDICIAL PANELISTS
 
Supreme Court Justice Correale F. Stevens 
Pennsylvania Superior Judge Court David N. Wecht
Luzerne County Judge Richard M. Hughes,
Lackawanna County Judge A. James Gibbons
U.S. Federal Middle District Court Judge Malachy E. Mannion
U.S. Federal Middle District Magistrate Judge Karoline Mehalchick
 
 
 
 
 4:30 pm - 6 pm
POST-SEMINAR COCKTAIL RECEPTION
 
 
THIS YEAR'S CLE SEMINAR WILL BE HELD IN A BALLROOM IN THE NEW HOTEL and SPA AREA AT THE MOHEGAN SUN


TABLE VENDOR SPONSORS TO DATE (Alphabetical):
 
At The Scene

 
Courtside Documents


 
Exhibit A
 
 
 
LexisNexis



Medical Legal Reproductions
 
 


Network Deposition Services




Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates




RecordTrak

 

The MCS Group


 
As in the past, there will again be door prizes and raffle prizes.
 
 
Vendor tables are still available on first-come, first-serve basis.  Other sponsorship/advertising opportunities available for service providers in the CLE written materials for service providers.  (contact Dan Cummins at dancummins@comcast.net for more details).
 
 
NEW this year will be the availability of a block of HOTEL ROOMS at the NEW Mohegan Sun Casino Hotel and Spa located on the property. 
 
 
CLICK HERE TO REGISTER ONLINE
or mail check made out to "Tort Talk" and below form to:
Daniel E. Cummins
Foley, Comerford & Cummins
507 Linden Street
Suite 700
Scranton, PA 18503

NAME: ___________________________________________________

FIRM/COMPANY: _________________________________________

EMAIL: ___________________________________________________



CLICK HERE TO BOOK A HOTEL ROOM
In the meantime, please consider marking your calendar to attend the Tort Talk Expo 2014 on the afternoon of:
 
SEPTEMBER 26, 2014