Monday, February 28, 2011

FEDERAL MIDDLE DISTRICT JUDGE WILLIAM J. NEALON Joins Panel of Judicial Presenters at Upcoming Tort Talk Expo

I am pleased to report that Federal Middle District Court Judge William J. Nealon has agreed to join the panel of judicial presenters at the upcoming April 20, 2011 Tort Talk Expo at the Mohegan Sun Casino. Judge William J. Nealon will assist the other members of that panel in the presentation of tips for litigants to improve their chances for success at a Pre-Trial Settlement Conference.

That presentation will follow the portion of the program in which Judge Thomas Raup and Judge Thomas Wallitsch will present their tips on ways to improve chances for success at a Mediation or Arbitration.

Seats are being filled up quickly by Plaintiff's attorneys, Defense counsel, and Claims Professionals. If you are interested in attending this seminar/networking event, please use the Registration Form below.



TORT TALK EXPO 2011

Seasons Ballroom
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania

April 20, 2011
1 p.m. - 5 p.m.
[Registration 1 p.m. - 1:30 pm]

(2 SUBSTANTIVE CREDITS, 1 ETHICS CREDIT)


Followed by a Cocktail Reception at the
Breakers Nightclub
in the Mohegan Sun Casino


The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 is designed to be a CLE Program that will be as entertaining and informative as the posts regularly sent out from the Tort Talk blog.

The seminar will be immediately followed by a cocktail reception at which attendees can network with fellow lawyers, insurance professionals, and members of the federal and state judiciary from around Northeastern Pennsylvania.

The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 will include door prizes for every attendee and chances to win raffle prizes (gift cards, sporting event tickets, etc.). There will also be vendor tables for attendees to visit with a variety of service providers in the legal field.

Also, a portion of the proceeds from this event will be donated to the Janet Weis Children's Hospital in the Geisinger Health System in Danville, Pennsylvania.



The CLE Program will include the following topics and presenters:


THE TORT TALK TOP TEN (or so) CASES
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire


LITTLE LEAGUE TIPS FOR BIG LEAGUE LAWYERS
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
(Will utilize baseball video clips to provide tips for the practice of law)


ANATOMY FOR LAWYERS: NECK AND BACK
(Also, witness a live simulation IME by an Orthopedic Surgeon)
Presenter: Dr. Lucian Bednarz, Physiatrist - Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates
Presenter: Dr. Thomas A. Allardyce, Orthopedic Surgeon


A VIEW FROM THE BENCH:
Ethical Issues in Legal Writing and Advocacy Before the Court
Moderator: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire

Presenters: Judge Thomas Raup and Judge Thomas Wallitsch
of ADR Options -- Tips for Mediation/Arbitration

Presenters: Federal District Judge William J. Nealon, Lackawanna County Judge Robert A. Mazzoni and other members of judicial panel to be identified - Tips for Pre-Trial Conferences


Networking Cocktail Reception Follows at Breakers
5 p.m. - 6:30 p.m.



Costs to cover both CLE Seminar and Cocktail Reception:

Claims professionals/representatives and risk managers
$25.00

Lawyers who are Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$145.00

Lawyers who are not Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$165.00



Make checks payable to "Tort Talk."

For reservations, please complete the requested information below and return it to the address noted below or e-mail it to dancummins@comcast.net.


Name(s)____________________________________



Firm/Company_______________________________


MAIL REGISTRATION FORM AND PAYMENT TO:



TORT TALK
c/o Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins
507 Linden Street
Suite 700
Scranton, PA 18503


For more information, contact Dan Cummins at 570-346-0745 or at dancummins@comcast.net.






HOPE TO SEE YOU THERE!

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Judge Carmen Minora of Lackawanna County Addresses Amendment of Pleadings and Summary Judgment Based Upon General Release

Judge Carmen D. Minora of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas recently issued an opinion in the case of Zummo v. City of Scranton, No. 2005- CV - 1369 (Lacka. Co., Feb. 10, 2011, Minora, J.) in which he granted (1) the Defendant's Motion to Amend its Answer and New Matter to include the defense of release and (2) the Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment based upon the same General Release that was previously entered into by the parties on the same issues presented in this case.

The underlying facts of this case involved alleged damages to the Plaintiffs' property as result of storm water runoff allegedly caused by a storm water drainage system owned by the City of Scranton.

The Defendant's Motion to Amend the New Matter five years after the action was commenced was granted under the liberal Rules of Civil Procedure pertaining to the amendment of pleadings. The court rejected the Plaintiffs' allegations that they would be "prejudiced" by the allowance of the amendment at this stage of the litigation.

The Motion for Summary Judgment was granted after the court rejected the Plaintiffs' contention that the the prior Release entered into by the parties after a previous litigation on similar issues did not cover future damages. The Plaintiffs also attempted to argue that current case was a claim for a different recovery for a nuisance of a progressive nature allegedly caused by the City's alleged failure to abate the storm water runoff as promised in the previous Release.

Rather, Judge Minora found that the terms of the General Release were "clear and unambiguous" in that the Plaintiffs had agreed to "forever discharge" the City of Scranton "of and from any and all claims" the Plaintiffs "will have or ever had" regarding the storm drainage system.


Anyone desiring a copy of this Zummo v. City of Scranton decision by Judge Minora may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Upcoming Pennsylvania Defense Institute CLE Seminar

The Pennsylvania Defense Institute is offering a new 3 CLE credit program this year entitled “Perspectives on Women in the Law: An Insurance Defense Symposium” on March 24 at the Hollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course near Harrisburg.




“PERSPECTIVES ON WOMEN IN THE LAW:
AN INSURANCE DEFENSE SYMPOSIUM”

MARCH 24, 2011
HOLLYWOOD CASINO AT
PENN NATIONAL RACE COURSE


PDI proudly presents “Perspectives on Women in the Law: An Insurance Defense Symposium” for lawyers to hear from successful women lawyers from the bench, private practice, and from the insurance industry. Women lawyers face unique challenges, particularly in the insurance defense industry. This program is educational and enriching and also presents as an opportunity to network with others in the profession. And it is fun, too, with all the amenities of the Hollywood Casino!

Reasons to attend: Get perspectives from successful women on the bench, in private practice, and in the insurance industry while earning 3 CLE credits.


The agenda:

8:15-9:00 Registration and Continental Breakfast

9:00-9:45 View from the Bench – Women in the Judicial System
Honorable Justice Joan Orie Melvin, Pennsylvania Supreme Court

9:45-10:00 Break

10:00-10:45 View from the Bar – A Managing Partner’s Perspective
Marie Milie Jones, Esquire
Meyer, Darragh, Buckler, Bebenek & Eck
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

10:45-11:00 Break

11:00-12:30 View from the Industry – Women in Insurance (Panel Discussion)

Karen Yarrish, Vice President, Secretary & General Counsel
Penn National Insurance
Beth Persun, Director of Claim Administration, MCare Fund
Angela Pinker, Director of Commercial Lines Underwriting,
Nationwide Insurance
Lisa Katterman, Associate Counsel & Director, Government
Relations, Penn National Insurance

12:30-1:30 Lunch

REGISTRATION FORM


PERSPECTIVES ON WOMEN IN THE LAW:
AN INSURANCE DEFENSE SYMPOSIUM


March 24, 2011
Hollywood Casino at
Penn National Race Course
777 Hollywood Boulevard
Grantville, PA 17028


CLE Program, Continental Breakfast and Lunch: $100.00

Name(s)_____________________________________

Firm/Company________________________________


Make checks payable to:
PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE
P.O. Box 697, Camp Hill, PA 17001-0697



Hotel Accommodations: For those intending to stay overnight, the Holiday Inn Harrisburg - Hershey is directly across from the Hollywood Casino. You may contact the Holiday Inn at 717-469-0661.




For more information, contact PDI at 800-734-0737
FAX 800-734-0732
coled01@padefense.org

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Pennsylvania Supreme Court: Attorney-Client Privilege Works Both Ways

Yesterday, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court published its 5-2 decision in the case of Gillard v. AIG Insurance Company, 2011 WL 650552 (Pa. Feb. 23, 2011, Saylor, J.)(McCaffery, J. and Eakin, J. dissenting) ruling that the attorney client privilege not only applies to communications from the client to the lawyer, but also to communications from the lawyer to the client.

In so ruling, the Court eradicated the uncertainty on the issue presented created by the Court's previous plurality decision in the case of Nationwide v. Fleming.

Writing for the Court in Gillard, Justice Saylor unequivocally stated, "We hold that, in Pennsylvania, the attorney-client privilege operates in a two-way fashion to protect confidential client-to-attorney or attorney-to-client communications made for the purpose of obtaining or providing professional legal advice." Majority op. at 23.

Justice Saylor was joined in his majority decision by Chief Justice Castille, and Justices Baer, Todd, and Orie Melvin. Justices McCaffery and Eakin each wrote dissenting opinions.

Here's the link to view the majority Opinion written by Justice Saylor: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-58-2010mo.pdf


Here's the link to view Justice McCaffery's dissent: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-58-2010do2.pdf


Here's the link to view Justice Eakin's dissent: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-58-2010do1.pdf

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Post-Trial Motions in Sedor v. Community Medical Center

On February 22, 2011, Judge Terrence Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas issued a 69 page opinion addressing the post-trial motions filed in the case of Sedor v. Community Medical Center, et al., No. 2005 CV 2143 (Lacka. Co., Feb. 23, 2011, Nealon, J.).

Judge Nealon aptly summarized his holdings in the first few pages of the Opinion, as follows:

"In the wake of a $3,250,000.00 personal injury award, the solely liable defendant hospital has filed a motion for post-trial relief under Pa. R.C.P. 227.1 and the prevailing plaintiffs have presented a motion for delay damages and post-judgment interest. The hospital requests judgment in its favor and argues that the opinions expressed by the plaintiffs’ experts on causation were so irreconcilably inconsistent that they should be declared legally incompetent to support the jury’s verdict. The hospital alternatively seeks a new trial on the grounds that the verdict was against the weight of the evidence, prejudicial evidentiary errors were committed at trial, and improper jury instructions and special interrogatories were submitted to the jury.

Although two of the plaintiffs’ experts differed as to whether an infection in the male plaintiff’s foot was already present on the date that he was struck with a hospital bed, the hospital is not entitled to JNOV based upon the Mudano rule since all three of the plaintiffs’ causation experts agreed that the male plaintiff’s necrotizing fasciitis and resulting amputation were caused by the bed trauma. Nor was the verdict against the weight of the evidence inasmuch as (a) there was ample evidence to support the conclusion that either CMC or its employee was exclusively liable, and (b) the jury’s compromise verdict on damages reflects that it did consider the male plaintiff’s apparent failure to reasonably mitigate his damages.

As for the evidentiary rulings, it was not an abuse of discretion to allow: (1) plaintiffs’ corporate liability expert to address the hospital’s negligent maintenance of beds since the hospital was not prejudiced by any discrepancy between that expert’s testimony and the plaintiffs’ pleadings; (2) Dr. Sedor to make limited reference to his own medical knowledge when explaining his mitigation conduct; (3) the presentation of a hypothetical question to a defense expert that was based upon an assumption which was supported by the evidence; and (4) the treating physiatrist to testify concerning causation in accordance with his pre-trial reports. The hospital has also failed to establish reversible error in excluding evidence of the male plaintiff’s prior suspension of privileges at another hospital and the ensuing Luzerne County litigation regarding that suspension. Any such evidence was properly precluded pursuant to Pa. R.E. 403 since the defense experts did not opine that the earlier suspension adversely affected the male plaintiff’s employability or future earning capacity and the introduction of that evidence would have injected collateral issues, unnecessarily delayed the trial and potentially caused the jury to decide this personal injury action on an improper basis.

In light of the conflicting evidence submitted by the parties with respect to the cause of the male plaintiff’s harm, the jury instructions on concurring causes and pre-existing conditions were appropriate. Furthermore, the separate damage interrogatories submitted to the jury were authorized by appellate precedent. However, the hospital provided no authority or plausible reason for three special interrogatories on mitigation of damages and it was not an abuse of discretion to deny that request. Therefore, the hospital’s motion for a new trial will be denied. In addition, the plaintiffs’ motion for delay damages and post-judgment interest will be granted to the extent that the plaintiffs will be awarded pre-judgment interest in the amount of $886,953.00 and post-judgment interest of $680.05/day from October 8, 2010 until the date of payment by the hospital."



Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Nealon's Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Superior Court En Banc Re-Argument Scheduled in Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital

As the writer of the amicus brief on behalf of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute in favor of the defense position, I just received notification from the Pennsylvania Superior Court that the Re-Argument en banc in the case of Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital has been scheduled to take place on April 5, 2011.

You may recall that Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital is the case in which the Superior Court originally held that communications from an attorney to the medical expert retained on behalf of that attorney's client were discoverable, particularly where, as in this case, the trial court judge found that the Plaintiff's attorney's communications to his expert would have "materially impacted" that expert's opinion in the matter. The Superior Court later withdrew its Opinion when it granted the Plaintiff's Petition for Re-Argument en banc.

Interestingly, the Superior Court has scheduled the argument to take place at the MMI Preparatory School, 154 Centre Street in Freeland, Pennsylvania.

Here is a link to a prior Tort Talk post offering more background on the case:

http://www.torttalk.com/2010/09/amicus-curiae-position-advocated-for.html


Here's a link to the amicus curiae brief I filed on behalf of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute:

http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=13d479ae-68e2-41c2-8279-492075821e68

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Pennsylvania Superior Court: Intoxication Evidence Inadmissible Where Liability Conceded (And No Puntive Damages Claim Asserted)

In a February 15, 2011 decision of first impression in the case of Knowles v. Levan, 2011 WL 522784 (Pa.Super. Feb. 15,2011, Stevens, Shogan, and Mundy, JJ.)(Opinion by Shogan, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that evidence of a defendant's drug and alcohol use prior to a two-vehicle accident should not have been admitted where the defendant's estate conceded liability and the trial was only over the issue of the plaintiff's damages.

According to the Opinion, this matter arose out of a motor vehicle accident that occurred on May 28, 2007 on Interstate 81 north in Dauphin County. At that time, the Defendant, who was fatally injured in the accident, entered the northbound lane of highway while traveling south and was then involved in a head-on collision with the Plaintiffs’ vehicle.

The Court emphasized in its Opinion that the Plaintiffs’ Complaint did not seek punitive damages.

Prior to trial, the defense conceded liability and negligence on the Defendant’s behalf and the case proceeded to trial in the Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas on the issues of damages only.

The defense filed a pre-trial motion in limine to preclude testimony regarding the defendant's decedent's use of cocaine and alcohol prior to the accident.

The trial court denied the motion ruling that the evidence would be admissible to tell the plaintiff's story and illustrate how the accident occurred.

The jury was informed at trial of the defendant's decedent's consumption of cocaine and that her blood alcohol concentration (“BAC”) was .227.

The trial court also instructed defense counsel to inform the jury that a person with a BAC over .08 exceeded the legal limit for driving, and further instructed that if defense counsel did not inform the jury of this fact, then the trial court would.

At the conclusion of the trial, the jury awarded Mr. Knowles $250,000.00 in damages and awarded Mrs. Knowles $4,000.00 in damages.

The trial court denied the Defendant’s post-trial motions seeking a new trial on the basis that the trial erred in denying the pre-trial Motion In Limine.

On appeal, the Superior Court found that the trial court erred on the admissibility of evidence issue but felt that the error was harmless in light of the cautionary instructions given by the trial court judge and therefore allowed the verdict to stand.

In footnote 3 of its Opinion, the Pennsylvania Superior Court noted that neither the litigants nor the Court’s own independent research revealed any binding precedent on the evidentiary issue presented and, therefore, the question of the admissibility of intoxication to illustrate how an accident occurred, in a case where negligence is conceded, appeared to the court to be an issue of first impression before the Superior Court.

As such the Knowles v. Levan decision stands for the proposition that where liability is conceded (and where no punitive damages claims are at issue), evidence of a defendant driver's intoxication at the time of an accident is not admissible.

I send thanks to Attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic, PA office of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this case to my attention.