Thursday, September 30, 2010

Plaintiff Files Petition for Reargument En Banc in Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital

Plaintiff's counsel has filed a Petition with the Superior Court for Reargument en banc in the case of Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital.

You may recall that this was the case in which the Superior Court held that Plaintiff's counsel must turn over their letters to their medical experts in discovery. For more details to the Superior Court's original decision, click this link to my former blog post on the matter:

http://www.torttalk.com/2010/09/amicus-curiae-position-advocated-for.html

I will keep you advised as to whether the Plaintiff's Petition for Reargument en banc is granted.

Ciavarella Re-Indicted In Luzerne County Judicial Scandal Case

According to a September 29, 2010 article in the Legal Intelligencer by Leo Strupczewski entitled "Grand Jury Re-Indicts Ciavarella in Luzerne County Fraud Case," in response to the recent United States Supreme Court decision overruling the honest services fraud statute, a federal grand jury has handed down a superseding indictment against former Luzerne County Common Pleas Judge Mark A. Ciavarella Jr.

Under the new indictment and with the removal of the honest services charges and certain tax fraud charges, the number of charges against the former Luzerne County judge has been reduced from 48 to 39.

The new indictment still charges Ciavarella with fraud, racketeering, money laundering, and tax violations. The indictment further alleges that Ciavarella received "millions of dollars in illegal payments," along with fellow former Luzerne County Common Pleas Judge Michael T. Conahan.

The indictment seeks forfeiture of more than $2.8 million, which was allegedly the amount of money generated as a result of the judges' criminal activity.

On a related note, although he has previously pled guilty, former Judge Conahan has yet to have his sentencing date set.


Here's a link to a Times Leader article on this developing story:

http://www.timesleader.com/news/Ciavarella_facing_new_indictment_09-29-2010.html

Monday, September 27, 2010

Pennsylvania House Bill 2246 Pulled From Consideration by Pennsylvania Legislature

House Bill 2246, a bill that would have, in part, allowed the arguing of specific dollar amounts for non-economic damages to the jury in automobile accident matters has been pulled by Senate leadership from consideration, effectively killing the bill.

The Pennsylvania Defense Institute was part of a coalition of insurance and business groups opposed to the bill.

Montgomery County Bar Association CLE Seminar Later Today (9/28/10)

Avoiding Appellate Pitfalls for the Trial Lawyer

A CLE Opportunity Presented by the Montgomery Bar Association Trial Lawyers Section

On September 28, 2010, please consider joining the Montgomery Bar Association's Trial Lawyers Section and a very distinguished panel of appellate judges, former judges, and appellate experts for an informative discussion of the many appellate and waiver pitfalls awaiting the unsuspecting trial lawyer.

Take advantage of the astute observations of our illustrious panel, including:

- The Hon. Jane Cutler Greenspan, former Justice, Pennsylvania Supreme Court

- The Hon. Susan Peikes Gantman, Judge, Pennsylvania Superior Court

- The Hon. Anne E. Lazarus, Judge, Superior Court of Pennsylvania

- Karen Reid Bramblett, Prothonotary, Superior Court of Pennsylvania

- Leonard R. Blazick, Esq., Assistant Chief Staff Attorney, Central Legal Staff, Superior Court of Pennsylvania

- Alicia Hickok, Esq., Assistant Counsel to the PA Supreme Court's Appellate Rules Committee

Moderator: Joseph P. Walsh, Esq., Walsh Pancio, LLC



And, enjoy a wine & cheese reception with panel members immediately following the presentation.


Register online at: http://www.montgomerybar.org/events/event.php?eventID=3240&tab=calAll


Details below.


CLE Seminar - Avoiding Appellate Pitfalls for Trial Lawyers

Tuesday, September 28, 2010
3:00 pm to 5:15 pm
MBA CLE Room

LESSONS FROM THE GODFATHER Article Available in PDF Form

Should anyone desire a copy, I now have a copy of my "Lessons From the Godfather" article as it appeared in the Defense Research Institute's For the Defense magazine in PDF form. If interested, shoot me an email at dancummins@comcast.net and I will send a copy. Thanks.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

How To Register for Upcoming Telephone CLE Seminar on the Barrick v. Holy Spirit Decision

As previously reported here, on Sept. 16th, the state Superior Court issued a decision in Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital, et al. regarding the disclosure of medical records. In a 15-page opinion written by Judge Olson, the court held that either side is allowed discovery of written communications/correspondence to his/her expert witness. This applies to both plaintiffs or defendants. In this case, the defense was seeking the plaintiff lawyer’s communications to the plaintiff expert and it was ordered disclosed.

The Pennsylvania Association for Justice is holding a one-hour, one CLE credit, phone seminar on Oct. 19, 2010 from Noon to 1 p.m. to address the implications of this decision. I am participating as a presenter, presumably based upon the fact that I participated in the matter as the proponent of the amicus curiae position of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute.

To register, call 215 546-6451 or click here:
http://eseries.pajustice.org/source/Events/Event.cfm?Event=EW101910

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Petition for Re-Argument in Sacket III Denied by Superior Court

Yesterday, September 22, 2010, the Superior Court denied Nationwide's Motion for Reargument/Reconsideration in Sackett v. Nationwide (Sackett III).

The opinion in Sackett III held that the trial court correctly decided on remand that a vehicle was not added under a newly/after acquired vehicle clause in an insurance policy and that the insurer therefore should have had the insured sign a new rejection of stacking form in order for non-stacking to apply when adding an additional car to a two car policy.

It remains to be seen whether the carrier will attempt to bring this matter up to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.

I thank Attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic, PA office of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this development to my attention.