According to a press release issued today by Hank Grezlak and Leo Strupczewski of the Legal Intelligencer, on July 30, 2009, Judge Edwin Kosik, the Pennsylvania Middle District Federal Court Judge overseeing the criminal proceedings involving former Luzerne County Judges Michael T. Conahan and Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr., issued an Order rejecting the guilty pleas that were entered into by the Judges back in February, 2009. Those guilty pleas called for the Judges to serve 87 months in prison.
In his Order, Judge Kosik stated that he could not accept the plea agreements in light of the judges’ post-guilty plea conduct and statements which seemed to contradict their admissions of guilt to certain crimes charged.
In his Order, Judge Kosik noted that a hearing would be scheduled, during which the U.S. Attorney or Conahan or Ciavarella will have the opportunity to either withdraw their guilty pleas, or accept a potentially stiffer sentence from Kosik. In addition, Kosik said the parties had ten days to waive the hearing in writing.
Judge Kosik's Order can be found online at http://media.timesleader.com/documents/kosik.pdf.
For more articles on the Luzerne County Judicial Scandal you can visit the archives in the websites of some of the local newspapers. Check out www.timesleader.com and click on their link for "County Judges." Another site is www.citizensvoice.com, where you can click on their link for "Corruption Probe."
Friday, July 31, 2009
Conahan and Ciavarella Guilty Pleas Rejected by Court
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Over 100 Email Subscribers - THANKS VERY MUCH
I have just gone over the 100 number in terms of subscribers to this blog. I thank all of you for signing up and hope you are finding the blog useful and/or interesting. I will try to keep the updates coming.
If any of you are willing to do so and have the time, I would appreciate it if you could please click on the box to the right entitled "Blogged" and take a few moments to "rate this blog." This may help me to get a wider exposure in the long run. I welcome any suggestions you may have to improve the blog or in terms of different topics you might like to see addressed.
I would also appreciate it very much if you could spread the word about the blog if you know of others who may benefit from it.
Thanks again,
Dan Cummins
If any of you are willing to do so and have the time, I would appreciate it if you could please click on the box to the right entitled "Blogged" and take a few moments to "rate this blog." This may help me to get a wider exposure in the long run. I welcome any suggestions you may have to improve the blog or in terms of different topics you might like to see addressed.
I would also appreciate it very much if you could spread the word about the blog if you know of others who may benefit from it.
Thanks again,
Dan Cummins
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Another Recent Post-Koken Decision in Favor of Consolidation
A recent April 9, 2009 Order in a Lehigh County post-Koken case was brought to my attention by Attorney Evan Kline, a former classmate of mine at the Dickinson School of Law and a current member of the York, Pennsylvania law firm of Katherman, Briggs & Greenberg . I thank Evan for this tip.
As a reminder, "post-Koken" cases are those cases arising after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued an opinion in a case commonly referred to the "Koken" case (the name of one of the parties)--in that case, the PA Supreme Court ruled that carriers could do away with the arbitration clause and allow for UM/UIM cases to be litigated by way of a jury trial.
Ever since, the carriers have issued new policies without an arbitration clause and many auto accident cases have been filed with the cause of action against the defendant driver and the UIM claim being pursued in one lawsuit. Some defendants are objecting to being lumped in a case with an insurance company defendant. So far, the trial courts are keeping the cases together.
In her Order issued in the case of Serulneck v. Kilian and Allstate Fire and Cas. Ins. Co., 2008-C-2859 (Lehigh Co. April 9, 2009), Judge Carol K McGinley follows the trend of allowing post-Koken third party and UIM cases to proceed under the same caption. The Judge denied the tortfeasor defendant's Motion for Severance and, in her footnote to the Order, the Judge wrote:
"The entire cause of action, whether sounding in tort or contract, arises from the same set of facts. Defendant Allstate will be prejudiced if excluded in any litigation which fixes its liability."
Anyone wishing to receive a copy of this Order may contact me and I will be happy to email it to you. I am also in possession of a number of other post-Koken decisions from other counties as well.
As a reminder, "post-Koken" cases are those cases arising after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued an opinion in a case commonly referred to the "Koken" case (the name of one of the parties)--in that case, the PA Supreme Court ruled that carriers could do away with the arbitration clause and allow for UM/UIM cases to be litigated by way of a jury trial.
Ever since, the carriers have issued new policies without an arbitration clause and many auto accident cases have been filed with the cause of action against the defendant driver and the UIM claim being pursued in one lawsuit. Some defendants are objecting to being lumped in a case with an insurance company defendant. So far, the trial courts are keeping the cases together.
In her Order issued in the case of Serulneck v. Kilian and Allstate Fire and Cas. Ins. Co., 2008-C-2859 (Lehigh Co. April 9, 2009), Judge Carol K McGinley follows the trend of allowing post-Koken third party and UIM cases to proceed under the same caption. The Judge denied the tortfeasor defendant's Motion for Severance and, in her footnote to the Order, the Judge wrote:
"The entire cause of action, whether sounding in tort or contract, arises from the same set of facts. Defendant Allstate will be prejudiced if excluded in any litigation which fixes its liability."
Anyone wishing to receive a copy of this Order may contact me and I will be happy to email it to you. I am also in possession of a number of other post-Koken decisions from other counties as well.
Labels:
Automobile Insurance,
Automobile Law,
Civil Litigation,
Insurance Defense,
Koken,
Litigation Tips,
UIM,
UM,
Underinsured Motorists Claims,
Uninsured Motorists Claims
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Assumption of Risk Defense Remains Viable in Pennsylvania
My most recent article in the Pennsylvania Law Weekly updates the current status of the the assumption of risk doctrine and concludes that it remains a viable defense under Pennsylvania law. You may view the article, entitled "Alive and Well: Assumption of risk doctrine remains a valid defense," by clicking this LINK.
Labels:
Assumption of Risk,
Automobile Law,
Civil Litigation,
Litigation Tips,
Notice Defense,
Premises Liability,
Products Liability,
Slip and Fall
Saturday, July 25, 2009
Upcoming August 27, 2009 CLE Presentation at Mohegan Sun Casinos in Wilkes-Barre, PA
I will be presenting a civil litigation update/IME law update at an upcoming August 27th CLE to be held at the Mohegan Sun Casinos at the Pocono Downs in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. You may click on the title of this post to be sent to the Mohegan Sun Casino's website to check it out.
The seminar is geared to provide updates to plaintiff's counsel, defense counsel, and claims professionals. The details of the seminar and a registration form are set forth below. Hope to see you there:
THE PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE
and
NORTHEAST PENNSYLVANIA TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Proudly Present a Continuing Legal Education Program On
and
NORTHEAST PENNSYLVANIA TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Proudly Present a Continuing Legal Education Program On
“CIVIL LITIGATION DEVELOPMENTS 2009”
at the
MOHEGAN SUN CASINO at POCONO DOWNS
Thursday August 27, 2009
1 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Followed by Cocktail Hour
1:00 – 1:30 PM Registration
1:30 – 2:30 PM “Ethical Considerations in the Insurance Relationship”
Mathew Keris, Esq., Marshall, Dennehey, Moderator
John Aponick, Esq., Marshall, Dennehey
Frank Brier, Esq., Geisinger Legal Services
Carl Gaugliardo, Esq., Selingo & Gaugliardo
Mathew Keris, Esq., Marshall, Dennehey, Moderator
John Aponick, Esq., Marshall, Dennehey
Frank Brier, Esq., Geisinger Legal Services
Carl Gaugliardo, Esq., Selingo & Gaugliardo
2:30 – 2:45 PM Break
2:45 – 3:45 PM Breakout Sessions:
"Civil Litigation Update/ABC's of IME's
Daniel E. Cummins, Esq., Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins
or
“Avoiding Medicare Disasters When Settling Your Case”
James Pocius, Esq., Marshall, Dennehey
3:45 – 4:00 PM Break
4:00 – 5:00 PM Breakout Sessions:
“Auto Law Update”
Robert Panowicz, Esq.
or
“Who Will Be Deciding Your Case: Suggestions for Voir Dire and Jury Selection”
Jill Huntley Taylor, Ph.D.
Director, Dispute Dynamics
2 Substantive & 1 Ethics CLE Credits
The program will be immediately followed by a reception for
Jill Huntley Taylor, Ph.D.
Director, Dispute Dynamics
2 Substantive & 1 Ethics CLE Credits
The program will be immediately followed by a reception for
the Judiciary serving Northeastern Pennsylvania
Costs for the events:
• Program for claim representatives/risk managers $25.00
• Program for paralegals $25.00
• CLE program for lawyers $125.00
• Cocktail Reception additional $65.00
For reservations, please print and complete the form below and return to PDI or e-mail us at coled01@padefense.org
Costs for the events:
• Program for claim representatives/risk managers $25.00
• Program for paralegals $25.00
• CLE program for lawyers $125.00
• Cocktail Reception additional $65.00
For reservations, please print and complete the form below and return to PDI or e-mail us at coled01@padefense.org
Name(s)_______________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
Firm/Company__________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
Address_______________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
Make checks payable to:
PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE
P.O. Box 697, Camp Hill, PA 17001-0697
For more information, contact PDI at 800-734-0737
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
Summary Judgment for Defense in Pike County Trip and Fall Case
On June 19, 2009, Judge Gregory H. Chelak of the Pike County Court of Common Pleas issued an opinion granting summary judgment in favor of the defense in a case involving a plaintiff who tripped and fell allegedly due to the raised edge of a concrete pad at a gas station being a mere one inch above the surrounding asphalt. Melchiorre v. Lords Valley Xtra Mart, No. 1358-2006-Civil (June 19, 2009).
Relying upon, Rocklin v. Hartmann, No. 248-2003-Civil (June 22, 2006) aff'd No. 1673 EDA 2006 (Pa.Super. Feb. 13, 2007), a prior Pike County decision in favor of the defense in a case involving a 1.5 inch elevation, Judge Chelak held that, under the "trivial defect" doctrine, the one inch discrepancy involved in the case at hand was "so trivial that, as a matter of law, Defendants were not negligent in permitting it to exist." The court based its decision, in part, on photographs of the defect supplied in the motion for summary judgment materials.
In so ruling, Judge Chelak rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the trivial nature of the defect should be disregarded on account of the fact that the Defendants had notice of the defect prior to the incident. Judge Chelak held that "[p]ursuant to the trivial defect doctrine, the existence of such defects does not give rise to a negligence claim, with or without notice."
The Plaintiffs filed an appeal on July 1, 2009 and the case is currently pending before the Superior Court of Pennsylvania.
Relying upon, Rocklin v. Hartmann, No. 248-2003-Civil (June 22, 2006) aff'd No. 1673 EDA 2006 (Pa.Super. Feb. 13, 2007), a prior Pike County decision in favor of the defense in a case involving a 1.5 inch elevation, Judge Chelak held that, under the "trivial defect" doctrine, the one inch discrepancy involved in the case at hand was "so trivial that, as a matter of law, Defendants were not negligent in permitting it to exist." The court based its decision, in part, on photographs of the defect supplied in the motion for summary judgment materials.
In so ruling, Judge Chelak rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the trivial nature of the defect should be disregarded on account of the fact that the Defendants had notice of the defect prior to the incident. Judge Chelak held that "[p]ursuant to the trivial defect doctrine, the existence of such defects does not give rise to a negligence claim, with or without notice."
The Plaintiffs filed an appeal on July 1, 2009 and the case is currently pending before the Superior Court of Pennsylvania.
Atlantic Second Citations for Recent Cases of Note
Atlantic Second citations for the following recent cases of note have been identified:
Gunn v. Automobile Ins. Co. of Hartford, 971 A.2d 505 (Pa.Super. 2009)
(Denial of insurer's motion to stay bad faith claim until UIM claim was resolved was not an appealable order)
Freed v. Geisinger Medical Center, 971 A.2d 1202 (Pa. 2009).
(A competent and qualified nurse is not prohibited from giving expert opinion regarding causation issues in medical malpractice case)
Erie Ins. Exchange v. Baker, 972 A.2d 507 (Pa. 2009)
(Household exclusion upheld to preclude insured from recovering UIM benefits)
Gunn v. Automobile Ins. Co. of Hartford, 971 A.2d 505 (Pa.Super. 2009)
(Denial of insurer's motion to stay bad faith claim until UIM claim was resolved was not an appealable order)
Freed v. Geisinger Medical Center, 971 A.2d 1202 (Pa. 2009).
(A competent and qualified nurse is not prohibited from giving expert opinion regarding causation issues in medical malpractice case)
Erie Ins. Exchange v. Baker, 972 A.2d 507 (Pa. 2009)
(Household exclusion upheld to preclude insured from recovering UIM benefits)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

