Friday, May 4, 2018

TORT TALK IS 9 YEARS OLD TODAY




Today the Tort Talk Blog turns 9 years old.  I thank you for reading the blog and also thank all those who have sent me cases or tips on cases and trends--it is all greatly appreciated.


 
 
 

CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES



I welcome the opportunity to assist you in settling your case through CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES.

To schedule a Mediation, please contact me at dancummins@comcast.net or at 570-346-0745.

Resume and fee schedule available upon request.


ARTICLE: OUT OF CONTROL: Self-Driving Vehicles Will Change the Insurance and Litigation Industries


In an effort to position myself, Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire, and my law firm, Foley, Comerford & Cummins, and I as a go-to choice for the defense of auto accident and products liability matters involving Self-Driving Vehicles (SDVs) in Pennsylvania, I have continually updated my research on the technological advances as well as the impending liability issues in this emerging area of technology and law.

Part of that continuing research was utilized to put together an article of mine which has been published in the May/June 2018 edition of the Pennsylvania Lawyer Magazine.

Here is a LINK to my article entitled "Out of Control: Self-Driving Vehicles Will Change the Insurance and Litigation Industries" for your easy reference.

Please do not hesitate to contact me regarding any issues you may wish to discuss pertaining to the rise of Self-Driving Vehicles and the liability and insurance issues attendant with the use of these vehicles.  I can be reached at dancummins@comcast.net or at 570-346-0745.

Please also let me know if you hear of any Pennsylvania court decisions involving SDVs in order that they may be publicized here on Tort Talk for the benefit of all Tort Talkers who read the blog.

My firm and I are also monitoring the issues surrounding accidents involving Uber or Lyft vehicles and the insurance issues surrounding those types of accidents.  Here is a LINK to a recent article I wrote on that topic with my associate attorney Steve Kopko.  We are available to review any issues with you in this regard as well.

Thanks for reading Tort Talk.



Thursday, May 3, 2018

Court Upholds Carrier's Right to Deny Coverage For Material Misrepresentations After Fire Loss

In the Western District Federal Court case of American National Property and Casualty Co. v. Felix, No. 3:16-cv-147 (April 11, 2018 Gibson, J.), the court granted the carrier Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment as to all claims of bad faith asserted.

According to the Opinion, this case arose out of the carrier’s denial of the insured’s claim under a homeowner’s policy after the insured’s home was damaged by fire.  

Part of the issues raised in this matter included an allegation that the insured had submitted material misrepresentations to the carrier after the fire loss in that he, in part, asserted that diamond stud earrings and a Louis Vuitton purse were lost in the fire.  During the carrier’s investigation, the carrier consulted with the insured’s ex-fiancĂ© who confirmed that she was in possession of the diamond stud earrings and the Louis Vuitton purse that the insured claimed had been lost in the fire.  

After securing a legal opinion on whether the policy could be voided due to an alleged material misrepresentation by the insured, the carrier decided to deny the claim and to file a lawsuit against the insured for a Declaratory Judgment to seek judicial confirmation that the carrier was not required to provide coverage to the insured based upon alleged material misrepresentations.   The carrier also included a claim against the insured for civil insurance fraud in the Complaint.  

The insured responded by filing an Answer and Counterclaims for breach of contract and statutory bad faith. 

The case later came before the court on cross-Motions for Summary Judgment.  

After reviewing the current status of Pennsylvania law pertaining to Pennsylvania’s Bad Faith Statute and applying the same to the record before it, the court granted the carrier’s motion and denied the insured’s motion.  

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. 


I send thanks to Attorney Joseph Hudock of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Rauch, along with Attorneys Richard McMonigle and Brian Shay of Post & Schell for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, May 2, 2018

Federal Middle District Court of Pennsylvania Allows Bad Faith Claim To Proceed Where Carrier Allowed Same Claims Rep to Handle Both Third Party and UIM Claim



In the case of Vella v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., Civil Action No. 17-1900 (M.D. Pa. Apr. 23, 2018 Rambo, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part a Motion to Dismiss a Bad Faith claim arising out of the handling of a UIM claim.
According to the Opinion, the insured submitted a UIM claim to its insurer following a motor vehicle accident.
The tortfeasor in the accident happened to also be insured by the same carrier for liability purposes.
The carrier assigned the same claim representative to manage both the first-party UIM claim and the third-party negligence claim. The insured eventually sued for bad faith as to the handling of both claims.
The insurer moved to dismiss aspects of the bad faith claim on the basis that Pennsylvania law precludes a third-party claimant from bringing a cause of action for bad faith against a tortfeasor’s insurer.
The Court denied the motion in part and granted in part. More specifically, the Court found the insured sufficiently pleaded facts regarding the interplay between the claims handling of first-party UIM and third-party negligence claims to make out a plausible bad faith claim.
However, the Court dismissed those allegations in the Complaint pertaining to claims asserted by the insured for bad faith against the insurer solely on the basis of the carrier’s actions regarding the handling of the third-party claim.
Anyone wishing to review this decision in the Vella case may click this LINK.
I send thanks to Attorney Lee Appelbaum of the Philadelphia bad faith defense firm of Fineman, Krekstein & Harris, and writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law Blog, for bringing this case to my attention.
 

SAVE THE DATE - JUNE 11, 2018 - LACKAWANNA PRO BONO'S GOLF TOURNAMENT


Monday, April 30, 2018

Spoliation Sanction Granted in Med Mal Case


In his recent decision in the case of Hughes v. Wilkes-Barre Hospital Company, No. 16-CV-6463 (C.P. Lacka. Co. April 18, 2018 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed a Motion In Limine seeking to impose spoliation sanctions against the Defendant healthcare providers in an effort to secure an adverse inference instruction based upon the alleged failure of one of the Defendant doctors to collect an umbilical cord blood gas sample at the time of the birth of the child in this obstetrical medical malpractice claim.  

After review the record before the court and comparing the same to the current status of Pennsylvania law pertaining to sanctions for alleged spoliation of evidence, the court ruled that the Plaintiffs were entitled to an adverse witness jury instruction that the Plaintiff’s counsel would be permitted to cross-examine the defense experts regarding the failure to collect the blood gas sample and its impact upon determining the timing and cause of the minor’s alleged brain injury.   The court denied the Plaintiff's request for greater sanctions as not warranted by the record before the court.
 
Anyone wishing to review this decision, may click this LINK.