Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Summary Judgment Granted in Lackawanna County Food Fight Slip and Fall Case


Summary Judgment was granted in the recent Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas decision of Rovinsky v. Lourdesmont, No. 2011-CV-2304 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 19, 2013 O’Brien, S.J.) by senior visiting Judge Peter O’Brien in a slip and fall case that arose out of a cafeteria food fight.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was present at the Lourdesmont facility as a business invitee.   She was performing as a lunch monitor in the cafeteria area when a food fight broke out.   As the Plaintiff was exiting the cafeteria after the food fight, she allegedly slipped on a clearest/reddish fluid and was allegedly injured.  

After discovery, the Defendant filed a Motion for Summary Judgment arguing that the Plaintiff’s deposition testimony demonstrated that the Plaintiff was aware of the risk created by the food fight and that she voluntarily chose to encounter such risk.  According to the record before the Court, the Plaintiff admitted that, prior to slipping, she saw food, water, and juice on the floor of the cafeteria.   However, immediately before she fell, she did not look at the ground in front of her when she slipped on the clearest/reddish fluid.  

Relying primarily on the assumption of risk case of Carrender v. Fitterer, 469 A.2d 120 (Pa. 1983), Judge O’Brien found that summary judgment should be granted as the Plaintiff was aware of the opening obvious condition of the debris on the cafeteria floor.   He also noted that the record revealed that the Plaintiff proceeded to exit the cafeteria without looking at the floor in front of her which resulted in her fall.   Judge O’Brien emphasized that the Plaintiff’s testimony demonstrated that she was aware of the danger and nevertheless chose to voluntarily navigate through it. 

Under Carrender, a possessor of land does not owe a duty of care to an invitee when the danger or hazardous condition is known or obvious and invitee continues despite the presence of the condition.   Judge O'Brien granted summary judgment on the basis of that precedent in this Rovinsky case. 

It is noted that summary judgment was entered as to less than all of the defendants.  A claim against the culinary management company that ran the cafeteria is ongoing.

I send thanks to Attorney Lauren Dobrowalski of the Scranton law firm of Cipriani and Werner for forwarding this Opinion to my attention.   The defense was handled by Attorney Daniel Stofko in her office. 

 Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
 
 
Source of photo:  John Belushi from Animal House (1978).

 

Monday, September 9, 2013

Article Summarizing Recent Trend of Cell Phone/Auto Accident Cases


Here is a LINK to a September 9, 2013 article by Max Mitchell of the Legal Intelligencer entitled "Distracted-Driving Cases Are on the Rise in Pa." which outlines the recent trend of cell phone cases in Pennsylvania and other jurisdictions and ends with a somewhat saucy quote from myself.  Please pardon my language. (And if you have trouble accessing the article online, please let me know).

To review all of the Tort Talk posts on Cell Phone cases, you can always visit Tort Talk at www.TortTalk.com and scroll all the way down the right hand column of the blog to the "Labels" section and click on the Label for "Cell Phone Use."  Here's a quick LINK to that page for your easy reference now.

Judge Williamson of Monroe County Allows Punitive Damages Claim to Survive Pleadings Stage in Slip and Fall Case

In his recent decision in the case of Ulrich v. Bracey’s Mount Pocono, Inc., PICS Case No. 13-1524 (C.P. Monroe Co. May 28, 2013 Williamson, J.), Judge David J. Williamson of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas addressed Preliminary Objections filed by Defendant in a slip and fall case.

Of note, the court denied the Defendant’s demurrer to the Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages after concluded that a jury could find that the Defendants allegedly acted with reckless disregard for customer safety by failing to stop ice from forming next to a gas pump at the Defendant’s gas station. 
Judge David J. Williamson
Monroe County


According to a summary of the Opinion, the Plaintiff was allegedly injured when she slipped and fell on a patch of ice next to a gas pump that was position beneath an overhang at the mini-mart location.   The Plaintiffs alleged that the Defendants knew or should have known that defects in the overhang allowed ice to form next to the gas pump such that it created a serious and dangerous condition to business invitees.  

The Court refused to allow a demurrer to the punitive damages count based upon these allegations as, accepting the Plaintiff’s allegations as true as required by the applicable standard of review, a jury could conceivably find that the Defendants acted in reckless disregard for the safety of their customers if they allegedly knowingly allowed water to accumulate into the dangerous condition that allegedly existed at the time of the accident. 

Accordingly, foreshadowing that the issue could be readdressed after discovery, Judge Williamson found that it was premature to dismiss this particular claim at this early pleadings stage point of the litigation.

As such, the Court overruled the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections to the Plaintiff’s claim for punitive damages.  

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact the Pennsylvania Instant Case Service of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly by calling 1-800-276-7427 and providing the above noted PICS Case No. along with a payment of a small fee.  

 
Source:  “Digest of Recent Opinions," Pennsylvania Law Weekly (August 20, 2013).

Household Exclusion Found Ambiguous in Blair County Case

In her August 5, 2013 Opinion and Order from the Court of Common Pleas of Blair County in Riley v. Harleysville, No. 2013 GN 19 (C.P. Blair Co. Aug. 5, 2013 Doyle, P.J.), President Judge Elizabeth A. Doyle addressed the application of the household exclusion in an underinsured motorist (UIM) case. 

At the time of the accident, the injured party was operating a vehicle owned by a plumbing company and a co-purchaser who was her husband.  The plaintiff recovered against the tortfeasor and under the UIM policy covering the vehicle she was in at the time.  

She then turned her personal auto policy with Harleysville for excess UIM coverage.  Harleysville denied the claim under the household exclusion in the policy.

Judge Doyle ruled that the exclusion did not apply in this case because it was ambiguous under the circumstances presented.  More specifically, the court found that the definition of "you" in the Harleysville policy was deemed to be ambiguous under the facts of the case.  The injured party was therefore permitted to recover UIM benefits.

A review of the Opinion itself will clarify why the court found the definition of “you” in the context of this case.  Anyone wishing to review the Riley opinion may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg, PA law firm of Schmidt Kramer for bringing this case to my attention.

 

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Postscript to Yesterday's Post on NJ Decision and Van Halen Reference


In yesterday's post, I reviewed the decision out of New Jersey allowing the sender of a text message to be potentially held liable in a distracted driver case and, in doing so, suggested that that extension of the law was a bit of a stretch.

In offering this opinion, I made a reference to an extreme example of distracted driving possibly caused by blasting "Panama" by Van Halen and playing air guitar.

It has come to my attention that a number of readers were not aware that, if you clicked on the word "Panama" in that post, it would take you to that video and on a trip down memory lane back to the 80s.  I have edited the post to prompt people to click on that link.

Anyone wishing to review the post again and experience the post in full by taking that trip back to the 80s by clicking on "Panama," can click this LINK to go back to that post.

Thanks and enjoy (just make sure the volume's not too loud on your computer before you click!).



Article Analyzes Large Bad Faith Verdicts Out of Northeastern Pennsylvania

Here's a link to a September 3, 2013 article by Zack Needles in The Legal Intelligencer entitled "For Northeastern Pa., Large Bad-Faith Verdicts Common" in which I was able to provide a quote.

Here's the LINK.

To review recent bad faith decisions from around the Commonwealth analyzed here on Tort Talk, you can always go to www.TortTalk.com and scroll all the way down the right hand column of the Blog to the "Labels" section and, under that, click on "Bad Faith" to take you to all of the posts on that topic.

Here's a quick LINK to that Bad Faith Label on Tort Talk for your easy reference now.

NJ Case Opens Door (in NJ) For Liability of Text Message Sender in Distracted Driver Auto Accident Cases


Previous cases on cell phone use here in Pennsylvania have focused on the liability of a defendant driver allegedly causing an accident by being distracted from the road ahead by some form of cell phone use (dialing, answering, talking, texting, etc.).

Now comes a New Jersey Appellate Division decision in the case of Kubert v. Best, No. A-1128-12T4 in which the court held that the sender of a text message may be held liable in New Jersey for injuries caused by the distracted driving of the text recipient if the plaintiff can prove that the sender of the text knew or had special reason to know that the recipient would view the text while driving and would be distracted by it.

I usually try to remain objective and keep my opinions out of Tort Talk posts as being irrelevant but I can't resist here.

In Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. 99 (N.Y. 1928), Justice Cardozo defined the concept of proximate causation by stating "the risk reasonably perceived defines the duty to be obeyed and risks imports relation;  it is to another or others within the range of apprehension." 

This Kubert opinion out of New Jersey appears to stretch Justice Cardozo's concept of foreseeability from the Palsgraf decision that we all learned in law school to unrecognizable bounds.

What's next--the ability to sue the telecommunications company for allowing us to all the ability to send text messages?  

How about allowing an injured plaintiff to sue Van Halen because the band knew or should have known that a defendant driver would take his hands off the wheel to play air guitar while blasting "Panama?

Why not then the ability to sue a gas station or a major gas company for selling gas to a defendant driver because the owners of the gas station or gas company knew or should have known that the driver could some day be in a car accident?

More realistically, will the slippery slope someday be extended to allow an injured plaintiff's to sue a passenger in a defendant driver's car because the defendant driver looked over at a passenger while the passenger was talking and, as a result, rear-ended the car ahead?

The above examples are a bit extreme, but where can the line be drawn in a concrete and workable fashion after decisions like this?

(Now you see why I keep my opinions out of it....where else could you find a reference to Justice Cardozo and Van Halen in the same context?)

Anyone wishing to review the decision of the New Jersey Appellate Division in the case of Kubert v. Best may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Paul Oven, Esq. of the Moosic, PA law firm of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this case to my attention.