Tuesday, March 10, 2020

No UIM Stacking Allowed Where Daughter No Longer Resided in Insured's Household (Non-Precedential)



In the case of Grix v. Progressive Specialty Ins. Co., No. 312 MDA 2019 (Pa. Super. Feb. 10, 2020 Dubow, J., Nichols, J., and Colin, J.) (Mem. by Dubow, J.) (Nichols, J., concurring in the result) (non-precedential decision), the court affirmed the lower court’s entry of summary judgment in favor of the carrier in this declaratory judgment action involving a stacking issue.

According to the Opinion, the insured’s daughter sustained fatal injuries in a motor vehicle accident. 

At the time of the accident, the insured’s daughter was in a vehicle owned by the insureds and covered under a policy issued by the Defendant carrier. The carrier insured five (5) vehicles owned by the insureds and the insured’s policy carried stacked limits of underinsured motorist coverage of $250,000.00 each person. The insureds sought to recover stacked UIM benefits from the carrier relative to the accident.

The carrier denied the claim for stacked benefits under an argument that the insured daughter, who had signed a lease at another address approximately six (6) weeks prior to her death, was not a “resident” of the insured’s household. 

The insureds filed this declaratory judgment action. 

After completing a detailed analysis of the numerous facts presented by both sides as to the residency of the insured’s decedent at the time of the accident, the appellate court affirmed the trial court’s entry of summary judgment in favor of the carrier. 

The trial court had ruled that, as a matter of “physical fact and presence,” the decedent’s daughter was not a resident of the insured’s household at the time of the accident. 

The policy language was also found to be unambiguous as to the relevant time of residency. 

The appellate court affirmed and noted that, under Pennsylvania law, the term of “resident” or “residency” requires, at a minimum, “so measure of permanency or habitual repetition.” See Op. at 10.  The court noted that most cases interpreting the “resident” analyzed the issue with regards to the quantity of contacts that an individual has with an insured’s household. 

In this case, although the insured’s daughter still received mail at her parent’s house, kept personal belongings at her parents’ house and continued to use her parents’ address as her address of record, the daughter could not be considered to be a “resident” of the insured’s household where, among other things, the daughter slept elsewhere every night. See Op. at 12. 

The court noted that there was no evidence to suggest that the daughter spent any night at her parents’ home after she moved into her rental premises prior to the accident.  As such, the Superior Court the court affirmed the lower court’s entry of summary judgment in favor of the carrier in this declaratory judgment action on the stacking issue. 

Any wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney David R. Friedman of the King of Prussia, PA office of Forry Ullman for bringing this case to my attention.

Superior Court Addresses Validity of UTPCPL Claims



In the case of Wenk v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Ins. Co., No. 2020 Pa. Super. 26(Pa. Super. Feb. 7, 2020) (Shogan, J., Lazarus, J., and Olson, J). (Op. by Shogan, J.), the court affirmed in part and vacated in part a trial court’s decisions in a bad faith and Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL) claims against a contractor.

According to the Opinion, the case arose out of a Plaintiff’s lawsuit against a carrier and a contractor over repairs to the Plaintiff’s house. The Plaintiff alleged that another contractor poured gasoline into the framework of their house to destroy a bee’s nest.   The house was damaged as a result and the Plaintiff submitted a claim to his carrier.

The Plaintiff then agreed to let another contractor, who was approved by the carrier, to perform remedial work.

The Plaintiff alleged that there were issues with the remedial work. The Plaintiff sued the carrier and the contractor for breach of contract, breach of warranty, and violations of the UTPCPL.

On appeal, the appellate court agreed with the trial court that the Plaintiff’s bad faith and Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law claims against the carrier had to be dismissed.

The appellate court also found that the trial court properly exercised its discretion with respect to the damages awarded in the UTPCPL claims against the contractor. However, the appellate court found that the trial court erred in dismissing the carrier’s and the contractor’s claims for a setoff.

The court noted that a setoff should have been allowed to the extent that the Plaintiff’s settlement with the other contractor covered any damages that the Plaintiff sought in this case including compensation for damages to the home and personal property so as to prevent any duplication of recovery.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this case may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Feb. 25, 2020).

Monday, March 9, 2020

Can You Help the Mock Trial Competition?




Attorney Chynna Beisel, MCBA member and Mock Trial Regional Coordinator is seeking volunteers for the Regional competition! The competition will be next Wednesday, March 11, 2020 at 6:00 PM the Lackawanna County Courthouse.

You can help make the event a success. Please signup today to be a Juror!

To volunteer, please email Chelsi Roberts-Williams at info2@monroebar.org.


Hoping all Tort Talkers can keep an eye out to help out as Jurors at any Mock Trial competitions that may be still taking place in your region.

Also, Jurors will be needed for the State Finals of the Mock Trial Competition set to take place in Harrisburg on March 27-28, 2020.   If you have any questions about the 2020 Mock Trial Competition, please contact PBA/YLD Coordinator Maria Engles at 1-800-932-0311 ext. 2223 or maria.engles@pabar.org.

ARTICLE: Judgeless Jury Selections: A Troublesome Trend



Here is a LINK to an article of mine that has been published in the March/April 2020 edition of The Pennsylvania Lawyer Magazine entitled "Judgeless Jury Selections:  A Troublesome Trend."

The article analyzes the relatively recent troublesome trend of judges routinely leaving the bench during jury selection after giving a short speech to the jurors about the trial process and then allowing the attorneys to conduct voir dire by themselves.

A number of cases that have gone up on appeal over issues surrounding the fact that the trial judge left the bench for voir dire.  In one such case, the Pennsylvania Superior Court recommended that trial court judges should remain on the bench.  In another case, the Pennsylvania Superior Court noted that it is not required that the trial court judge remain on the bench for voir dire but that, if the judge left the bench during that process, a different standard of review would have to be utilized on appeal to address any issues raised with respect to jury selection. 

This issue is now poised to be decided by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the Trigg case, which is currently pending before that Court.  The parties in that case argued the issues presented back on October 19, 2019 and await a decision.

The article reviews a number of reasons in favor of trial court judges remaining on the bench during the course of jury selection in order that certain appellate issues could be avoided as a result.

I send thanks to Patricia Graybill, the Editor of The Pennsylvania Law Weekly, for agreeing to publish this piece.


Thursday, March 5, 2020

ARTICLE: Pa. Supreme Court Has Yet to Move on Mock Trial Program Rule Change

What are they waiting for?

Below is a copy of my article that came out earlier this week in the Pennsylvania Law Weekly entitled "Pa. Supreme Court Has Yet to Move on Mock Trial Program Rule Change."

Lest it is not clear from the article itself, this is an article I wrote for the Pennsylvania Law Weekly and not in any way on behalf of the Pennsylania Bar Association or the PBA's Young Lawyer's Division.  Those entities had nothing to do with the writing of this article and did not contribute in any way to it.


Pa. Supreme Court Has Yet to Move on Mock Trial Program Rule Change


By Daniel E. Cummins | March 3, 2020

Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law

A year has passed since the Pennsylvania Bar Association issued its report and recommendation to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court requesting consideration of a proposed rule change to allow for limited continuing legal education (CLE) and continuing judicial education (CJE) credits for participation in the mock trial program run by the young lawyers’ division of the Pennsylvania Bar Association. The hope of some affiliated with the mock trial competition was that the Supreme Court would act promptly on an easy decision with respect to the PBA’s recommendation and that the court would allow for the requested change to the CLE and CJE rules to allow for such credits.

Unfortunately, 12 months have now passed and another mock trial competition has already begun in the state. Yet, the judicially active Supreme Court has been uncharacteristically judicially inactive with its hands apparently tied by red tape such that the court seems powerless to simply say yes and approve the proposed rule change that seems to be a no-brainer on all fronts. As a result, high school students and college students who have worked hard on the mock trial problem all around the commonwealth of Pennsylvania face another year of nearly empty jury boxes for almost all of their competitions.

It appears that the Supreme Court referred the PBA’s recommendation in favor of CLE credits for mock trial participation, which was approved unanimously in the PBA on behalf of the entire Pennsylvania Bar Association, to the Continuing Legal Education Board of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. The Continuing Legal Education Board, which consists of 10 members, rejected the recommendation in October 2019. There has been no further action since.

For full disclosure purposes, it is noted that the author of this article is also one of the authors of the report adopted by the Pennsylvania Bar Association and a longtime supporter of, and participant in, the high school mock trial competition, and he is not writing this article on behalf of the bar association.

The goal of the PBA’s report and recommendation for the simple rule change was to fill the jury boxes with CLE credit-seeking attorneys so that all of those high school and college kids who work so hard can present their case to a full jury each time they compete. The hope is that the court will find a way to cut through the red tape and that has held up the process for a year now and allow for this rule change.

A Great Program That Can be Made Better

The mock trial competition run by the young lawyers’ division of the Pennsylvania Bar Association is considered to be one of the largest in the United States. It is a great program, if not the best offered by the PBA, and benefits high school students all across the state of Pennsylvania. With nearly 300 high school teams participating in the program in Pennsylvania and with each team having, on average, 14 students on the team, there are nearly 4,000 kids across the commonwealth who put hours and hours of their time into the competition. Many students also participate in mock trial at the college level.

The mock trial competition allows these thousands of high school student teams from across the commonwealth to play the roles of attorneys and witnesses in civil or criminal trial settings before a judge and a panel of jurors who score the competing teams. Lawyers volunteer to assist students as attorney advisers, as judges to preside over the trials and as the jurors who score the competing teams.

Prevailing teams advance through district trials competitions, onto regional trials, and finally to a March Madness-like state finals tournament in Harrisburg. The high school team winning the state competition then goes onto compete in the national mock trial competition.

As noted, these dedicated high school students involved in the competition spend hours and hours preparing for each trial. Some of these students will someday become members of the Pennsylvania Bar Association.

A Need for ‘Jurors’

The greatest need for bar member involvement in the mock trial competition is with respect to attorneys serving as jurors for the trials. Lawyers serving as jurors evaluate and score the competing teams as opposed to rendering any verdict on the merits of the case. Jurors are continually needed to score the many trials at the district, regional and state levels of the competition.

In past years, the competition has struggled at times to have any more than several jurors sitting in a 14-seat jury box at all levels of the competition. Even at the state mock trial championships every year, several of the last few trials were completed with only three jurors in the box, which is an embarrassingly poor showing by a bar consisting of thousands of members. Imagine how many more attorneys would show up if they knew they could earn a CLE credit for helping out the competition by serving as a juror.

An Excellent Learning Experience

In addition to being a truly rewarding experience by helping others, participation in mock trial will also actually serve to help attorneys improve their litigation skills and courtroom presence by observing a simulated trial from the entirely different perspective of sitting in a jury box.

Seeing a trial play out while sitting in a jury box is a whole new and enlightening experience in and of itself. Watching two student-attorneys argue an objection back and forth and interacting with the judge on the argument, or following along with a direct or cross-examination, may educate practicing attorneys on what works and what does not work. Seeing a great opening statement, or a forceful closing argument, both of which are limited to five minutes in length, from the jury box will also give attorneys sitting as jurors a new perspective for the presentation of their own openings and closings in a real trial. Moreover, seeing and realizing that an entire case can be argued in a five-minute summation is enlightening for attorneys in and of itself.

Surely much more is actively learned by an attorney participating in a mock trial as a juror and seeing a trial play out in front of him, than an attorney earning CLE credits by passively sitting through a long video playback of a prior CLE seminar on a TV while doing work or reading a newspaper for hours at a time.

CLE Credits

It is well known that CLE credits have been approved for many types of courses and activities.

CLE credits are currently even allowed for courses that have nothing to do with the law or learning any updates on the law, or practice tips. For example, CLE credits have been approved for a CLE course titled “Balancing Work and Wellness” at which attendees can secure CLE credits simply by engaging in bike riding and yoga.

More recently, a CLE-approved course titled “CLE@The Gym 2020,” at which attendees can earn two hours of CLE credits while participating in one hour of exercise at the gym, and presumably other instructions on exercising. If attorneys are permitted to earn CLE credits in this regard, then surely they should be allowed to earn credits by way of their active participation in the mock trial program and learning from watching a trial play out with strict compliance to court procedures and evidentiary rules.

Last year, the movement for CLE credits for mock trial participation was put on the back burner by the Pennsylvania Bar Association to allow for rule changes to allow for CLE credits for pro bono work to move forward and be approved. Now that CLE credits have been approved for pro bono participation and now that over a year has passed, the hope is that the court will approve the rule changes, as recommended by the PBA, to allow for CLE and CJE credits to be earned by attorneys and judges who assist with the mock trial competition.

By approving this rule change, Pennsylvania could then join other states such as New York, New Jersey, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, Indiana, Kentucky, Minnesota, Oregon and Washington, all of which allow their attorneys and judges who participate in mock trial programs to earn CLE and CJE credits.

To the extent the apparent red tape holding up this approval somehow involves the loss of money (i.e., the placement of monetary concerns over the ability to help high school and college kids and to improve the reputation of lawyers as contributors to the community), then the attorneys seeking such CLE credits could be simply required to fill out the standard CLE credit request forms and send in the required check of only $4.50 per credit.

Hopefully, the Supreme Court might have the power to be able to cut through the red tape and allow for and approve the amendment of the rules pertaining to CLE and CJE credits proposed and recommended by the PBA as soon as possible. The hope was to have the rule change in place even in time for the 2019-2020 mock trial competition so that high school and college students all across the commonwealth can begin to present their cases to jury boxes full of credit-seeking attorneys along with a real judge up on the bench.

Are You Willing to Help?

While we wait for the Supreme Court to finally act on this easy decision, attorneys and judges across the commonwealth are encouraged to please give a couple of hours to participate in the mock trial competition. You won’t regret this rewarding experience.

By participating in the mock trial competition, you may even improve your own litigation skills by witnessing a trial from the different perspective of a jury box. You may be surprised how different the courtroom looks from the box. The experience can help you to see how jurors might view your case in the future.

At the same time, you will be providing your expertise, feedback and encouragement to young individuals for the betterment of the bar association’s mock trial competition.

In the end, your participation will ultimately show the potential future members of the bar, as well as the courtroom of family members who come to watch their children compete, that the members of the Pennsylvania Bar Association are a welcoming and collegial group of individuals dedicated to the practice of law and committed to mentoring the next generation of lawyers. The Supreme Court can add to that good will by approving the rule change and allow for CLE credits and CJE credits for participation in mock trial competitions. What are they waiting for?

Daniel E. Cummins is a partner in the Scranton law firm of Cummins Law where he focuses his practice in the defense of automobile and trucking accident, premises liability, and products liability litigation matters.  Cummins is also active as an Attorney Advisor for the Abington Heights High School mock trial team.


Copyright 2020. ALM Media Properties

Jurors Needed For Mock Trial Regionals Competition




Attorney Chynna Beisel, MCBA member and Mock Trial Regional Coordinator is seeking volunteers for the Regional competition! The competition will be next Wednesday, March 11, 2020 at 6:00 PM the Lackawanna County Courthouse.

You can help make the event a success. Please signup today to be a Juror!

To volunteer, please email Chelsi Roberts-Williams at info2@monroebar.org.

.

Summary Judgment Granted in Snow Tubing Case Based on No-Duty Rule



In the case of Hamber v. CBH2O, LP t/a Camelback Mountain Resort, No. 8778-CV-2017 (C.P. Monroe Co. Jan. 9, 2020 Harlacher Sibum, J.), the court granted the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment and dismissed the Complaint with prejudiced in a case involving allegations of injuries allegedly sustained by the Plaintiff while snowtubing at Camelback Mountain Resort.

The Plaintiff alleged that, while nearing the end of a snow tube run, his tube came into contact with a deceleration mat and became airborne, causing the Plaintiff to be ejected from the snow tube and to land on his neck in an adjacent snow tubing lane. The Plaintiff alleges that the accident was caused by the improper placement of the deceleration mat.

The court ruled that the use of a deceleration mat was directly related and inherent to the sport of snow tubing as it would be a common, frequent and expected part of the activity to encounter some decelerating agent at the end of the run.

Given that contact with the deceleration mat was an inherent part of the snow tubing activity, and given that the risk of being thrown from the snow tube as an inherent part of snow tubing, the court held that the Defendant had no duty to protect the Plaintiff under Pennsylvania law from contact with the deceleration mat or the general risk of being thrown from the tube.

As such, the court found that the Plaintiff’s negligent claim was barred under the “no-duty” doctrine.

Judge Harlacher Sibum more specifically stated that, under Pennsylvania law, “the assumption of risk defense, as applied to sports and places of amusement, has also been described as a ‘no-duty’ rule, i.e., as the principle that an owner or operator of a place of amusement has no duty to protect the user from any hazards inherent in the activity.” In this regard, the court quoted the case of Chepkevich v. Hidden Valley Resort, LP., 2 A.3d 1174, 1186 (Pa. 2010).

The court further stated, again citing Chepkevich, that “where there is no duty, there can be no negligence, and thus when inherent risks are involved, negligence principles are irrelevant… and there can be no recovery based on allegations of negligence.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Feb. 5, 2020).