Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Judge Amesbury of Luzerne County Addresses Post-Koken Bad Faith Discovery

In a November 6, 2012 detailed Order, Judge William H. Amesbury addressed an insurance carrier's motion to sever and stay bad faith discovery in the Post-Koken UM/Bad Faith combined claim of Schuckers v. Penn National, No. 9080 - CV - 2011 (C.P. Luz. Co. Nov. 6, 2012 Amesbury, J.)

Judge William H. Amesbury
Luzerne County
In so ruling, Judge Amesbury cited Gunn v. Automobile Ins. Cos. of Hartford, 971 A.2d 505 (Pa.Super. 2009) for the proposition that, since the trial of the UM claim would be by jury and the trial of the bad faith claim would be by a bench trial (under state law), there is a severance of the claims for trial purposes by operation of law.

In terms of discovery on the UM and Bad Faith claims, Judge Amesbury took a page out of the playbook recommended by Judge Wettick in the trial decision in Gunn, supra., and held that, since there was a bad faith claim presented, the carrier's values and its opinions and conclusions on the strengths and weaknesses of the uninsured motorist claim would not be disclosed in an unredacted form until after jury deliberations begin on that initial claim. Judge Amesbury also noted that, at that point, the Plaintiff could request a stay of the trial of bad faith claim if time was needed to review the carrier's file and develop the case further.

I send thanks to Attorney Stephen Fendler of the Kingston, PA office of Fendler & Associates, P.C. for advising me of this decision.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order in Schuckers v. Penn National may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Judge Nealon Addresses Discoverability of Plaintiff's Prior Alcohol Abuse and Mental Health Records

In his recent November 1, 2012 Opinion in the case of Ferguson v. Ghigiarelli, No. 2011-CV-6033 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 1, 2012 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed the discoverability of a Plaintiff’s records related to his alcohol abuse and mental health treatment in a medical malpractice matter.

The Plaintiff contended that his alcohol abuse treatment records were protected from discovery by §108 of the Drug and Alcohol Abuse Control Act, 71 P.S. §1690.108. The Plaintiff also asserted that his mental health records were not discoverable due to the psychiatrist-patient privilege set forth in 42 Pa. C.S. §5944.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County
Relying, in part, upon the case of Kraus v. Taylor, 710 A.2d 1142 (Pa. Super. 1998), appeal dismissed, 743 A.2d 451 (Pa. 2000), Judge Nealon held that a Plaintiff impliedly waives the statutory protection afforded to drug and alcohol treatment records by filing a personal injury lawsuit claiming a permanent injury and thereby placing the Plaintiff’s life expectancy at issue.

With respect to the separate mental health records, the Court in Ferguson concluded that the Plaintiff did not similarly waive the psychiatrist-patient privilege by generally alleging “mental and emotional anguish” as elements of the pain and suffering claim. The Court noted that the Plaintiff did not specifically make any claim for damages in this matter for anxiety, severe emotional trauma requiring treatment, or some other specifically recognized mental disorder.

Accordingly, Judge Nealon held that the alcohol abuse treatment records were discoverable but that the mental health treatment records were not under the facts of this case.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Optional E-Filing Now Allowed in Pennsylvania Supreme Court



According to a November 13, 2012 article entitled "Pennsylvania Supreme Court Starts Optional E-Filing" by Amaris Elliott-Engel of The Legal Intelligencer, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court started to allow optional e-filings last week.  The article also notes that e-filing may also start in the Pennsylvania Superior Court and Commonwealth Court at some point in 2013.

Here is a link to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court Order issued back on October 24, 2012 allowing for the electronic filing of appellate documents as of November 1, 2012:


http://www.pacourts.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/389jad.pdf



Source of image: www.associates3g.com

Monday, November 12, 2012

HOLIDAY HAPPY HOUR THIS WEDNESDAY (11/14/2012)

Northeast Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association


and


The Pennsylvania Defense Institute

are hosting a

 
Holiday Happy Hour



Wednesday November 14, 2012

5:00pm to 7:00pm

 
at

 
Breakers

Mohegan Sun Casino at Pocono Downs

Wilkes-Barre, PA




Please RSVP to David Cole


1-800-734-0737


Members of NEPATLA or PDI: FREE

Non-Members/Guests: $25



ALSO CONSIDER ATTENDING PRE-EVENT CLE


Contact Dave Cole above for details and to register

Thursday, November 8, 2012

Subpoenas To IME Vendor Companies Upheld in Luzerne County

Luzerne County Courthouse
Two recent discovery orders out of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas upheld a Plaintiff’s Motion for Enforcement of a Subpoena sent by the Plaintiff to an IME vendor company for a copy of their file pertinent to the cases presented.

In each of the Orders, the Court ordered the IME vendor company to comply with the Plaintiff’s subpoena to produce the information requested.

However, the Orders did provide that correspondence and content referencing communications by and between defense counsel and the IME vendor was excluded from the Order of production (presumably in deference to the current status of the law under Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital, which is currently pending before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court).

Those cases involving these Orders, without any opinion, were issued in the following cases:

Dunsmuir v. Tredennick and State Farm, No. 12077-Civil-2010 (C.P. Luz. Co. Nov. 22, 2012 Hughes, J.)

Polacheck v. Mullay, No. 12657-Civil-2009 (C.P. Luz. Co. Aug. 17, 2012 Gelb, J.)



I send thanks for the prevailing attorney, Ann O. Farias of the Kingston, Pennsylvania O’Donnell Law Offices for forwarding these Orders to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of these Orders (no Opinion) may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Summary Judgment for Defendant Denied in Store Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Siffel v. Best Buy, No. 11-3713 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 3, 2012), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a department store slip and fall case.

In this matter, the Plaintiff allegedly slipped on an advertising circular which was allegedly located on the floor of the store.

The court denied the Motion for Summary Judgment based upon issues of fact after the Plaintiff produced evidence to create a factual question as to whether the condition of advertising circulars on the floor was “pervasive and obnoxious.”  The record before the court established that three employees saw the brochures on the floor near where the Plaintiff fell. Evidence was also produced that another employee explained that the brochures would typically fall onto the floor. Yet another employee recalled prior customer complaints of debris littering the store floor.

Based upon the record before the court, summary judgment in favor of the defendant store was denied.

I do not have a copy of this case.

Source: “Court Summaries” by Timothy L. Clawges in the November 5, 2012 Pennsylvania Bar News.


Source of image(unrelated to this matter): www.documentscanningsolutionsltd.co.uk.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

HOLIDAY HAPPY HOUR - NEXT WEDNESDAY - NOVEMBER 14th

Northeast Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association

and

The Pennsylvania Defense Institute

are hosting a


Holiday Happy Hour


Wednesday November 14, 2012

5:00pm to 7:00pm

at

Breakers

Mohegan Sun Casino at Pocono Downs

Wilkes-Barre, PA


Please RSVP
to David Cole

1-800-734-0737
coled01@padefense.org



Members of NEPATLA or PDI: FREE

Non-Members/Guests: $25


ALSO CONSIDER ATTENDING PRE-EVENT CLE
Contact Dave Cole above for details and to register