Tort Talkers may recall that the Post-Koken case of Wissinger v. Brady, out of Luzerne County, went up on appeal to the Superior Court and was submitted on briefs for the court to address the issue of proper venue for Post-Koken cases where there is no forum selection clause in the UIM policy at issue.
There has been no decision handed down in this matter to date. By way of status report, I also note that the Plaintiff in this matter recently filed with the Superior Court a Motion to Discontinue, Dismiss, and Remand the matter to the Luzerne County on account of the fact that the Plaintiff has entered into a settlement with the third party tortfeasors (and thereby apparently eradicating any venue issues under an argument that an insurance carrier can be sued anywhere in Pennsylvania since the carrier conducts business everywhere in Pennsylvania.). It remains to be seen how the Court will respond to this motion.
In any event, this same issue remains before the Superior Court in the separate case of Sehl v. Neff which was argued last week on April 27th.
I wrote the amicus brief on behalf of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute in favor of the defense position in both of these matters. I will report on any court action that happens in these cases.
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Duty to Defend/Indemnify in Context of "Non-Owned Autos" Provision of Automobile Insurance Policy
Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas issued an April 25, 2011 decision in the case of Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Esgro, 2007 Civil 4862 (Lacka. Co., April 25, 2011, Nealon, J.), addressing a coverage question involving a “non-owned autos” provision of an automobile insurance policy.
In this case, the insureds personally owned a vehicle that was involved in a single vehicle accident that was fatal to the one of the occupants of the vehicle. After having recovered under other policies, including the policy that specifically covered the vehicle involved in the accident and UIM coverage from the decedent's own insurer, the plaintiff pursued a recovery under the business' auto policy with Nationwide that had been separately purchased by the owner of the vehicle involved in the accident. The plaintiffs [the decedent's estate] asserted that, at the time of the accident, an insured’s defendant's personal vehicle was being used in furtherance of the insured's business and therefore implicated the Nationwide policy.
Nationwide’s policy obligated it to “pay all sums an ‘insured’ must legally pay as damages” for injuries “caused by an accident and resulting from the ownership, maintenance or use of a covered ‘auto’.”
An “insured” includes the named insured as well as “[a]nyone else while using with your permission a covered auto you own, hire or borrow.”
“Covered autos” are comprised of three categories of vehicles: (1) “specifically described autos;” (2) “hired autos;” and (3) “non-owned autos.”
The claimants asserted that coverage should be afforded under the “non-owned autos” provision. According to Judge Nealon’s Opinion, that provision defines “non-owned autos” as:
Only those “autos” you do not own, lease, hire, rent or borrow that are used in connection with your business. This includes “autos” owned by your “employees,” partners (if you are a partnership), members (if you are a limited liability company), or members of their households but only while used in your business or your personal affairs.
Nationwide filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a judicial declaration that it did not owe any duty to defend or indemnify the tortfeasor defendants. The carrier argued that a sole proprietorship business could not be viewed independent of the owner of the business for insurance coverage purposes. Under this argument, since the insured actually owned the vehicle involved in the accident, that vehicle could not be viewed as a "non-owned auto" under the Nationwide policy at issue.
The party seeking coverage asserted that the business at issue was actually a partnership and that the policy provided coverage separately for that type of business. The party seeking coverage also relied upon the “reasonable expectations doctrine.’
After reviewing the parties’ respective positions and analyzing the law on the issue presented, Judge Nealon ruled, as follows:
"A partnership’s automobile insurer has filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a declaration that it owes no duties to defend or indemnify one of the named partners and his relatives in a pending wrongful death action since the vehicle involved does not qualify for liability coverage under the “non-owned autos” provision of the partnership’s policy. A reasonable, alternative interpretation of the relevant policy language supports the conclusion that the policy affords liability coverage for vehicles owned by individual partners or members of their households while the vehicles are being used for partnership business or a partner’s personal affairs. Accepting as true the averments of the amended complaint filed in the underlying tort action, issues of fact exist as to whether the subject vehicle was being used in furtherance of the partnership’s business interests and one partner’s personal affairs at the time of the accident. Therefore, the tort claims filed against that partner and the permissive user of the vehicle may potentially fall within the scope of the policy’s liability coverage, and as such, the insurer’s motion for summary judgment will be denied with respect to those individuals. However, since two other relatives do not qualify as named insureds or permissive users of a “covered auto,” the motion for summary judgment will be granted as to those tort defendants."
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision, which has a nice recitation on the law surrounding the duty to defend and/or indemnify, may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
In this case, the insureds personally owned a vehicle that was involved in a single vehicle accident that was fatal to the one of the occupants of the vehicle. After having recovered under other policies, including the policy that specifically covered the vehicle involved in the accident and UIM coverage from the decedent's own insurer, the plaintiff pursued a recovery under the business' auto policy with Nationwide that had been separately purchased by the owner of the vehicle involved in the accident. The plaintiffs [the decedent's estate] asserted that, at the time of the accident, an insured’s defendant's personal vehicle was being used in furtherance of the insured's business and therefore implicated the Nationwide policy.
Nationwide’s policy obligated it to “pay all sums an ‘insured’ must legally pay as damages” for injuries “caused by an accident and resulting from the ownership, maintenance or use of a covered ‘auto’.”
An “insured” includes the named insured as well as “[a]nyone else while using with your permission a covered auto you own, hire or borrow.”
“Covered autos” are comprised of three categories of vehicles: (1) “specifically described autos;” (2) “hired autos;” and (3) “non-owned autos.”
The claimants asserted that coverage should be afforded under the “non-owned autos” provision. According to Judge Nealon’s Opinion, that provision defines “non-owned autos” as:
Only those “autos” you do not own, lease, hire, rent or borrow that are used in connection with your business. This includes “autos” owned by your “employees,” partners (if you are a partnership), members (if you are a limited liability company), or members of their households but only while used in your business or your personal affairs.
Nationwide filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a judicial declaration that it did not owe any duty to defend or indemnify the tortfeasor defendants. The carrier argued that a sole proprietorship business could not be viewed independent of the owner of the business for insurance coverage purposes. Under this argument, since the insured actually owned the vehicle involved in the accident, that vehicle could not be viewed as a "non-owned auto" under the Nationwide policy at issue.
The party seeking coverage asserted that the business at issue was actually a partnership and that the policy provided coverage separately for that type of business. The party seeking coverage also relied upon the “reasonable expectations doctrine.’
After reviewing the parties’ respective positions and analyzing the law on the issue presented, Judge Nealon ruled, as follows:
"A partnership’s automobile insurer has filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a declaration that it owes no duties to defend or indemnify one of the named partners and his relatives in a pending wrongful death action since the vehicle involved does not qualify for liability coverage under the “non-owned autos” provision of the partnership’s policy. A reasonable, alternative interpretation of the relevant policy language supports the conclusion that the policy affords liability coverage for vehicles owned by individual partners or members of their households while the vehicles are being used for partnership business or a partner’s personal affairs. Accepting as true the averments of the amended complaint filed in the underlying tort action, issues of fact exist as to whether the subject vehicle was being used in furtherance of the partnership’s business interests and one partner’s personal affairs at the time of the accident. Therefore, the tort claims filed against that partner and the permissive user of the vehicle may potentially fall within the scope of the policy’s liability coverage, and as such, the insurer’s motion for summary judgment will be denied with respect to those individuals. However, since two other relatives do not qualify as named insureds or permissive users of a “covered auto,” the motion for summary judgment will be granted as to those tort defendants."
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision, which has a nice recitation on the law surrounding the duty to defend and/or indemnify, may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
ARTICLE: Mastering the Great (But Lost) Art of the Return Phone Call
You may also be able to click on the title of this post to get to that article online.
Source of photo: Idea go / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Image: Idea go / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Sunday, May 1, 2011
SAVE THE DATES - UPCOMING CLE SEMINARS OF NOTE
PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE
“Tort Reform in Pennsylvania: Is it Really Going to Happen This Time?”
Hollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course
Grantville, Pennsylvania
Thursday, May 19, 2011
1:00 – 1:30 PM Registration
1:30 – 2:30 PM “Tort Reform:
A View from the Pennsylvania Insurance Department”
Hon. Michael Consedine, Acting Insurance Commissioner
2:30 – 2:45 PM Break
2:45 – 3:45 PM “Tort Reform: Is it Really Going to Happen This Time?”
Gene Barr,
Vice President, Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry
Karen Coates,
Director of Legislative Affairs, House Majority Leader
David Tideman, Esq.,
Counsel, State Farm Insurance
Timothy Bittle,
Bigley & Blikle
3:45 – 4:00 PM Break
4:00 – 5:00 PM “Tort Reform: The Next Round?”
Civil Practice & Procedure:
Wesley Payne, Esq.,
White & Williams
Scott Millhouse, Esq.,
Meyer, Darragh, Buckler, Bebenek & Eck
Products Liability:
C. Scott Toomey, Esq.,
Littleton, Joyce, Ughetta, Park & Kelly
Medical Malpractice:
Daniel Grill, Esq.,
Thomas, Thomas & Hafer
Insurance Bad Faith:
R. Bruce Morrison, Esq.,
Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin
Charles Haddick, Jr., Esq.,
Dickie, McCamey &Chilcote
5:00 PM Cocktail Reception
To Register Contact:
David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI
(coled01@padefense.org)
__________________________________________________
43rd Pennsylvania Defense Institute Annual Conference
BEDFORD SPRINGS RESORT
Bedford Springs, Pennsylvania
July 21-22, 2011
GREAT SEMINAR AND MORE!
“Modern Litigation”
• Effect of Social Networking on Litigation
• E-Discovery Law Update
• Current Insurance Fraud Schemes
• Civil Practice, Auto, Products Liability and Med Mal Law Updates
and more…
Registration material is coming soon!
Contact David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI for more info
(coled01@comcast.net)
____________________________________________
PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUE
and
NORTHEASTERN PENNSYLVANIA
TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Continuing Legal Education Seminar
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
August 24, 2011
12:30 pm - 4:30 pm
Cocktail Reception to Follow
Course Planners Matthew Keris, Esquire and Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
are currently working on the program which will at least include the following topics:
Civil Litigation Practice Tips
Social Media and the Law
A View From the Bench
More details to follow....
Contact David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI for more info
(coled01@comcast.net)
“Tort Reform in Pennsylvania: Is it Really Going to Happen This Time?”
Hollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course
Grantville, Pennsylvania
Thursday, May 19, 2011
1:00 – 1:30 PM Registration
1:30 – 2:30 PM “Tort Reform:
A View from the Pennsylvania Insurance Department”
Hon. Michael Consedine, Acting Insurance Commissioner
2:30 – 2:45 PM Break
2:45 – 3:45 PM “Tort Reform: Is it Really Going to Happen This Time?”
Gene Barr,
Vice President, Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry
Karen Coates,
Director of Legislative Affairs, House Majority Leader
David Tideman, Esq.,
Counsel, State Farm Insurance
Timothy Bittle,
Bigley & Blikle
3:45 – 4:00 PM Break
4:00 – 5:00 PM “Tort Reform: The Next Round?”
Civil Practice & Procedure:
Wesley Payne, Esq.,
White & Williams
Scott Millhouse, Esq.,
Meyer, Darragh, Buckler, Bebenek & Eck
Products Liability:
C. Scott Toomey, Esq.,
Littleton, Joyce, Ughetta, Park & Kelly
Medical Malpractice:
Daniel Grill, Esq.,
Thomas, Thomas & Hafer
Insurance Bad Faith:
R. Bruce Morrison, Esq.,
Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin
Charles Haddick, Jr., Esq.,
Dickie, McCamey &Chilcote
5:00 PM Cocktail Reception
To Register Contact:
David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI
(coled01@padefense.org)
__________________________________________________
43rd Pennsylvania Defense Institute Annual Conference
BEDFORD SPRINGS RESORT
Bedford Springs, Pennsylvania
July 21-22, 2011
GREAT SEMINAR AND MORE!
“Modern Litigation”
• Effect of Social Networking on Litigation
• E-Discovery Law Update
• Current Insurance Fraud Schemes
• Civil Practice, Auto, Products Liability and Med Mal Law Updates
and more…
Registration material is coming soon!
Contact David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI for more info
(coled01@comcast.net)
____________________________________________
PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUE
and
NORTHEASTERN PENNSYLVANIA
TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Continuing Legal Education Seminar
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
August 24, 2011
12:30 pm - 4:30 pm
Cocktail Reception to Follow
Course Planners Matthew Keris, Esquire and Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
are currently working on the program which will at least include the following topics:
Civil Litigation Practice Tips
Social Media and the Law
A View From the Bench
More details to follow....
Contact David Cole, Executive Director of the PDI for more info
(coled01@comcast.net)
Friday, April 29, 2011
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Hands Down Split Decision on Household Exclusion Issue
On April 28, 2011, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court handed down a 3-3 plurality decision, with Justice Orie Melvin have recused herself from the matter, in the case of GEICO v. Ayers which decision serves to affirm the Superior Court's decision that an insured was barred from collecting stacked UIM benefits to compensate him for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident.
Here's a link to the Tort Talk posting providing more background on the case presented and the exact issue addressed by the Court: http://www.torttalk.com/2010/07/pennsylvania-supreme-court-agrees-to.html
Here's a link to the Supreme Court's Order issued in GEICO v. Ayers:
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-21-2011pco.pdf
Here's the link to the Supreme Court's Opinion by Justice Saylor in support of Affirmance:
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-21-2011aff.pdf
I send thanks to Attorney Thomas McDonnell of the Pittsburgh law firm of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Skeel for bringing this decision to my attention. Attorney Joe Hudock from the same office handled the matter for GEICO.
Here's a link to the Tort Talk posting providing more background on the case presented and the exact issue addressed by the Court: http://www.torttalk.com/2010/07/pennsylvania-supreme-court-agrees-to.html
Here's a link to the Supreme Court's Order issued in GEICO v. Ayers:
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-21-2011pco.pdf
Here's the link to the Supreme Court's Opinion by Justice Saylor in support of Affirmance:
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-21-2011aff.pdf
I send thanks to Attorney Thomas McDonnell of the Pittsburgh law firm of Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Skeel for bringing this decision to my attention. Attorney Joe Hudock from the same office handled the matter for GEICO.
Thursday, April 28, 2011
Written Materials from Tort Talk Expo Are Now Available as a PDF
To the extent you may be interested in the same, I have the written materials from the recent Tort Talk Expo available as a PDF. The materials include a civil litigation update, articles on litigating neck and back injuries, and articles on tips for improving chances for success at a Mediation or Arbitration. Note that the materials are over 80 pages long and may take some time to download and/or print.
Anyone desiring a free copy of the written materials from the recent Tort Talk Expo 2011 may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net to let me know and I will email them to you.
Anyone desiring a free copy of the written materials from the recent Tort Talk Expo 2011 may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net to let me know and I will email them to you.
Sunday, April 24, 2011
Tort Talk Expo 2011 Well Attended
The Tort Talk Expo 2011 took place last Wednesday, April 20, 2011 at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. There were 107 people in attendance, made up of plaintiff's attorneys, defense attorneys, and claims professionals.
In the first half hour, I presented the Tort Talk Top 10 (or so) Cases. I followed that with a half hour presentation called "Take Me Out to the Ballgame: Little League Tips for Big League Lawyers" in which I took common baseball coaching tips and applied them to the practice of law ("Hustle!", "Keep your eye on the ball!", etc.).
In the second hour, Dr. Lucian Bednarz, a physiatrist provided an Anatomy for Lawyers presentation focusing on neck and back injuries. Also, Dr. Thomas Allardyce, an orthopedic surgeon, performed an IME on me for all to see how that process works.
The last hour was a View From the Bench. During the first hour, retired Judge Thomas Raup and retired Judge Thomas Wallitsch, both of ADR Options, Inc., provided tips on how to improve one's chances for success at at mediation or an arbitration.
The second half hour had Judge Robert Mazzoni, and, appearing for the first time together ever on any CLE stage, Judge Terrence R. Nealon and his father, Judge William J. Nealon, providing the audience with tips on how to approach pre-trial settlement conferences.
The event was followed by a cocktail reception at the Breakers Bar in the Mohegan Sun Casino that was well attended as well.
I thank everyone who attended and hope you enjoyed the event. I also thank the following table vendors who appeared at the Tort Talk Expo:
In the first half hour, I presented the Tort Talk Top 10 (or so) Cases. I followed that with a half hour presentation called "Take Me Out to the Ballgame: Little League Tips for Big League Lawyers" in which I took common baseball coaching tips and applied them to the practice of law ("Hustle!", "Keep your eye on the ball!", etc.).
In the second hour, Dr. Lucian Bednarz, a physiatrist provided an Anatomy for Lawyers presentation focusing on neck and back injuries. Also, Dr. Thomas Allardyce, an orthopedic surgeon, performed an IME on me for all to see how that process works.
The last hour was a View From the Bench. During the first hour, retired Judge Thomas Raup and retired Judge Thomas Wallitsch, both of ADR Options, Inc., provided tips on how to improve one's chances for success at at mediation or an arbitration.
The second half hour had Judge Robert Mazzoni, and, appearing for the first time together ever on any CLE stage, Judge Terrence R. Nealon and his father, Judge William J. Nealon, providing the audience with tips on how to approach pre-trial settlement conferences.
The event was followed by a cocktail reception at the Breakers Bar in the Mohegan Sun Casino that was well attended as well.
I thank everyone who attended and hope you enjoyed the event. I also thank the following table vendors who appeared at the Tort Talk Expo:
At the Scene, Inc.: http://www.atthescene.com/
Cleverfish: http://www.cleverfish.com/
Courtside Documents: http://www.courtsidedoc.com/
Digital Justice: http://www.digitaljustice.net/
Exhibit A: http://www.exhibitadigital.com/
Innovative Nursing Consultants, Inc.
Love Court Reporting: http://www.lovecourtreporting.com/
Minnesota Lawyers' Mutual: http://www.mlmins.com/
Optimo-iT: http://www.optimo-it.com/
Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates:
Strategic Financial Planners: http://www.strategicfinancialplanners.com/
Surveillance Professionals Investigations:
THANKS TO ALL PRESENTERS, ATTENDEES, VENDORS, AND SPONSORS
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



