Monday, April 11, 2011

Former Luzerne County Judge Michael Toole Sentenced

Here is a link to an April 9, 2011 article by Terrie Morgan-Besecker of the Times Leader regarding the sentencing of former Luzerne County Judge Michael Toole to 30 months (Two and a half years) in federal prison:

http://www.timesleader.com/news/Ex-judge_rsquo_s_new_chambers__A_cell_04-08-2011.html?searchterm=Toole

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Post-Koken Decision Out of Warren/Forest Counties in Favor of Severance of UIM/Bad Faith Claims

On April 6, 2011, Judge Gregory Hammond of the 37th Judicial District in Pennsylvania (Warren and Forest Counties combined) issued an Order in the post-Koken case of Burr v. Erie Ins. Exchange, No. 008-Civil-2011/Forest County Branch (Warren and Forest Co., April 6, 2011, Hammond, J.), in which he ruled that a combined UIM and Bad Faith lawsuit would be severed and that the discovery and trial in the Bad Faith aspect of the case could only occur after the resolution of the UIM case by verdict or settlement.

According to a review of the Post-Koken Scorecard, which you can always view by scrolling down the right hand column of this blog and clicking on the date noted under "Post-Koken Scorecard,"  Judge Hammond's ruling is consistent with the majority rule in this Commonwealth (8 counties in favor of severance of UIM and Bad Faith claims [counting this decision as covering 2 counties] and 4 counties in favor of consolidation).

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Preliminary Objections Granted in Luzerne County Post-Koken Case

Another post-Koken decision on a pleadings issue has come out of Luzerne County. On February 28, 2011, in the case of Price v. Price, Auto Glass Unlimited, Inc., and State Farm, No. 13625-Civil-2010, Judge Tina Polachek Gartley, issued an Order on various Preliminary Objections filed by both State Farm and the Plaintiff.

In Price, a post-Koken Complaint was filed by the Plaintiff where the Plaintiff joined the tortfeasor and the UIM carrier, State Farm under one caption.

State Farm filed Preliminary Objections solely on the basis that the Plaintiff’s breach of contract cause of action against them was really a claim for bad faith.

In response, Plaintiff filed Preliminary Objections to State Farm’s Preliminary Objections, arguing that State Farm Preliminary Objections were vague in that they failed to state specifically the grounds for the Preliminary Objections in violation of the requirements of Pa. R.C.P. 1028(b).

Judge Gartley sided with the Plaintiff and granted the Plaintiff’s Preliminary Objections to State Farm's Preliminary Objections and also denied State Farm's Preliminary Objections.

I am uncertain as to how State Farm or its defense counsel has followed up since.


I send thanks to Attorney Ann Farias of the O'Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, Pennsylvania for forwarding this decision to my attention.

I note that this decision was by Order only without much any explanatory rationale. However, should you wish to obtain a copy of this Order, please do not hesitate to contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Friday, April 8, 2011

Recent Articles on the Status of the Fair Share Act

Here are links to recent articles, one by John L. Micek of the Allentown Morning Call and one by Mark Scolforo of the Philadelphia Inquirer on the status of the Fair Share Act in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives.

The Fair Share Act, which will essentially mandate that, in most cases, defendants in civil litigation matters will only be responsible for their share of percentage liability as assessed by a jury, is expected to pass in the House and move onto the Pennsylvania Senate.

Under the current law, if a defendant is found even only 1% liable, that defendant is on the hook for 100% of the verdict and can try to recoup his or her overpayment from the co-defendant(s).  As such, if the Fair Share Act passes, it will represent a dramatic shift in how civil litigation matters are handled.

Here are the links to the articles:


http://www.mcall.com/news/nationworld/pennsylvania/mc-pa-legal-reform-20110404,0,1795953.story


http://articles.philly.com/2011-04-07/news/29392816_1_amendment-minority-leader-frank-dermody-fair-share-act

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Propriety of Punitive Damages Claims in Med Mal Context

On March 31, 2011, Judge Terrence R. Nealon issued an Opinion in the medical malpractice case of Lasavage v. Smith, et.al., No. 10-CV-2183 (Lacka. Co. March 31, 2011 Nealon, J.), pertaining to Preliminary Objections filed by Defendant against allegations of “reckless,” “outrageous, wanton and grossly indifferent conduct” and “reckless indifference to the rights of Plaintiff’s decedent” as contained in the Complaint. Essentially, the Defendants filed Preliminary Objections against the claim for punitive damages in the Plaintiff’s Complaint.

In his ruling, Judge Nealon overruled the Preliminary Objections filed in this regard by one of the individual Defendants but sustained the objections filed by the Defendant, Scranton Heart Institute, P.C. to the allegations of reckless indifference and any vicarious liability claim for punitive damages asserted against that Defendant.
In so ruling, Judge Nealon noted that the recovery of punitive damages in medical malpractice litigation is governed by §505 of the Medical Care Availability and Reduction of Error (MCare Act), 40 Pa. C.S. §1303.505.

Judge Nealon emphasized that the medical malpractice statute provide that a healthcare provider maybe vicariously liable for the reckless conduct of its doctors/agents only if the principal (a) knows of the wrongful conduct and (b) nevertheless allows it to occur and/or continue.

Judge Nealon stated that “[b]y virtue of this heightened standard of proof for vicarious liability “a patient must now aver and establish that the healthcare principal was cognizant of the agent’s willful, wanton or recklessly indifferent treatment and allow that conduct to proceed unabated.” [citations omitted] [emphasis in original].

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion by Judge Nealon the Lasavage case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Judge Minora of Lackawanna County Addresses Parameters of Discovery of Expert Information

In a recent March 10, 2011 Opinion, by Judge Carmen D. Minora of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas in the case of AJT Property vs. Lexington Ins. Co., No. _______ (Lacka. Co. March 10, 2011, Minora, J.), in which the Court permitted the Defendants to take the deposition of the Plaintiff’s expert witnesses, limited to information obtained not in anticipation of litigation.

This matter arises out of an insurance dispute pertaining to flood damage to the Plaintiff’s property. The issue is whether or to the Plaintiff’s property was covered under its flood insurance policy with the Defendant, Lexington Insurance Company.

Following the loss, the Plaintiff retained the services of an insurance expert and a public adjuster to assist the Plaintiff in the recovery on its claim. The public adjuster investigated events surrounding the Plaintiff’s loss. Both the public adjuster and the insurance expert evaluated the Plaintiff’s claims and reported to third parties on these issues.

At some point, the Plaintiff retained both the insurance expert and the public adjuster as experts in anticipation of litigation. However, the date of the retention of these individuals as experts was in dispute.

The Defendant, Lexington Insurance Company, served the Plaintiff with notices of intent to serve subpoenas upon the insurance expert and the public adjuster. The Plaintiff objected. A special trial master on discovery issues in the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas overruled the Plaintiff’s objections and allowed the insurance company to schedule the depositions of the experts. The Plaintiff then filed the Motion at issue to prevent the depositions.

The Plaintiff contended that the depositions would violate Pa. R.C.P. 4003.5(a)(1) and (2). The Defendant insurance company asserted that the experts had knowledge of facts surrounding the Plaintiff’s claims and that they were subject to discovery in that regard.

Judge Minora noted that experts who know facts or hold opinions not required or developed in anticipation of litigation are subject to discovery under the general rules of discovery. The Court found that these experts were originally hired to determine the value of Plaintiff’s losses and to assist in a possible amicable resolution of the matter, and were not initially retained in anticipation of litigation.

Although the experts were, at some point, retained as expert witnesses for trial, there was no clear evidence as to when this decision was made.

In accordance with relevant case law and the Rules of Civil Procedure, Judge Minora determined that the information obtained by the insurance expert and the public adjuster not in anticipation of litigation was discoverable by the Defendant insurance company. The Court allowed the carrier to depose the experts as to dates the experts perceived that they were retained as experts. Once that date was established, the Defendants were permitted to continue the depositions of both experts pertaining to the information they obtained prior to their retention as experts that was not in anticipation of litigation.

Judge Minora further clarified that information prepared by the insurance expert and public adjuster in their role as expert witnesses, including their expert opinions for use at trial, was not subject to discovery by deposition except as may be permitted under Pa. R.C.P. 4003.5(a).

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


Source:  Case Digests of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly

Med Mal Jury Verdict Out of Lackawanna County

Here's a link to an April 7, 2011 article in the Scranton Times Tribune regarding a sizeable jury verdict entered by a Lackawanna County jury in a medical malpractice case: 

http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/scranton-law-firm-wins-550-000-medical-malpractice-case-1.1129283#axzz1Is9XDAe4