Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Tips for Status Reports by Attorneys to Claims Professionals

I received permission from Marc Lanzkowsky of the blog The Claims SPOT (www.the claimsspot.com) to republish the below posts from that blog here on Tort Talk as a guest post providing worthwhile tips for reporting updates on cases to claims professionals.


5 Elements That Reports From Outside Counsel Should Have


By James Pattillo – March 15, 2011


Outside looking in:
Give what they need and you will make them happy!


Our last SPOT on Legal article looked at the five things counsel should leave out of a report. I’m sure most of you thought of more than five. This article looks at five things that must be included. It’s amazing how many times these basic items are overlooked. Providing the essential information in the correct format will help make claims professional’s jobs easier and will help to move the case in the appropriate direction.


1. An Overview – Although you don’t want to repeat yourself, a little background is helpful. Give an enough of an overview to give the new information some context. This is especially important if the reports are every 60 days or more.


2. Enough Detail – I know one of the warnings in the previous post was to not include too much detail. Well that is a double-edged sword. Bottom line: there shouldn’t be any unanswered questions after reading the report. It always needs to address the effect on damages and liability whether or not there has been a change on those estimates. Again, the lesson here


3. Direct Advice/Recommendations – The report needs to have a point. What needs to be done in light of this new information? If nothing, then state it. If additional questions have come up that need to be addressed with more discovery or depositions, then state it. If now is the time the try to resolve the case in light of the new information, then recommend it.


4. Plan Your Work and Work Your Plan – Every report should state what the expected activity is before the next report is sent. Have a plan moving forward and work that plan. Any deviations from the expected activity in previous report should be explained.


5. The Bottom Line is the Bottom Line – Always have a solid liability and damage estimate. Liability estimates are most easily expressed in a percentage chance of a certain verdict. A damage estimate is always harder to come up with but a range is usually appropriate (e.g. “any verdict in favor of the plaintiff will most likely be between $350,000 and $400,000). It’s ok to change your estimate, but only if it is based on case developments that couldn’t be anticipated. A looming trial date is never a good reason to change a liability or damage estimate.


5 Things Claims Handlers DON’T NEED In A Report From Counsel


By James Pattillo – March 10, 2011


Outside Looking In:
Claims professionals are pretty busy. Sometimes less is more!


Time is of the essence. Isn’t it always? Claims handlers have the near impossible task of assimilating a large volume of information to make an accurate assessment of a claim. And they have to do it on a daily basis for a pending file list much larger than most of the defense counsel they work with.


Of course every bit of information in litigation is important. You’ll never hear a lawyer say “let’s just leave that out.” But at some point, the case has to boiled down into a report or summary.
This article looks at the top five things defense counsel include in reports that are not essential.


To be fair, my next post will examine the top five things that are essential to those reports. (Of course, I’m sticking my neck out here on some level. As soon as something is labeled as “non-essential”, it will become the key piece of information upon which a claim turns. Good judgment is always the rule at the end of the day).


1. Repeating Your Last Report – No one wants to read the same thing they read 30, 60 or 90 days ago. Each report should have 75% new information. The remaining 25% should be background from the case as a whole that provides context to the new information.


2. Duplicative information in the Same Report – No need to repeat the same information multiple times in a report. If you don’t need to repeat it from a previous report, don’t repeat it several times in the same report. A brief overview or summary in the beginning is o.k. but generally try not repeat yourself. Also, you should not repeat yourself.


3. Information About You – Claims handlers don’t need to know your trial history or bullet points from a curriculum vitae. However, if you have experience with a particular judge or plaintiff’s counsel, that is valuable information.


4. Billing Tasks – An explanation of your billing or why a particular task took a certain amount of time is outside the scope of a litigation report. Follow the billing guidelines and get approval where required. But leave it out of the report.


5. Too Much Detail – This is difficult because every claim handler wants something a little different. Most often, defense counsel are criticized for giving too much (e.g. the 40 page summary of the 80 page deposition transcript doesn’t do much good). Everyone has a different workload depending on the type and complexity of claims. The key here is to communicate about the level of detail that is wanted.

Monday, March 21, 2011

Consolidation Denied in Federal Middle District Post-Koken Case

Recently, on March 16, 2011, Judge Sylvia H. Rambo of the Federal District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania has issued an Opinion in the case of Christian v. Liberty Mutual, No. 1:10-CV-125 (M.D.Pa. March 16, 2011, Rambo, J.) , denying a Plaintiff's request to consolidate the Plaintiff's negligence lawsuit against the tortfeasors with the Plaintiff's separately filed uninsured (UM) claim against the Plaintiff's own carrier under an allegation that a phantom vehicle was also involved in the accident.

In her Opinion, Judge Rambo noted the split of authority on the issue of consolidation vs. severance in the state court system and emphasized that, in the case before her, "the concerns of potential prejudice against Defendant arising from the introduction of insurance information are significant, and the benefit of cost avoidance would be felt only by Plaintiffs in the instant case, Plaintiffs...."

Accordingly, Judge Rambo decided to deny the Plaintiff's motion to consolidate.

I thank Attorney Carl J. Guagliardo of the Kingston law firm of Selingo & Guagliardo for bringing this case to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules on Reduction of UM/UIM Coverage Forms

On March 14, 2011, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a 5-2 decision in the case of Orsag v. Farmers New Century Insurance, 2011 WL 856367 (Pa. 2010 Eakin, J.) holding that an insured's signature on an application for automobile insurance was sufficient to allow the insurance carrier to enforce the insured's request for uninsured/underinsured ("UM/UIM") coverage limits lower than the bodily injury liability limits of the same policy.

The majority found that the application language was sufficient under the written requirements found under 75 Pa.C.S. 1734 for the selection of reduced UM/UIM coverage even if the application was not accompanied with a written Section 1791 "Important Notice" of coverage options.

For more details, the actual opinions can be viewed online at these links:

Majority Opinion:
http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-37-2010mo.pdf


Concurring Opinion:
http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-37-2010co.pdf


Dissenting Opinion:
http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-37-2010do.pdf


I send thanks to Attorney Pete Speaker of the Harrisburg, PA office of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer as well as to Attorney Craig Murphey from the Erie, PA office of MacDonald Illig for bringing this case to my attention.

Forum Selection Clause Upheld in Allegheny County Post-Koken Case

I recently came across an Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas decision in the case of Lowry v. Aliquo and Erie Insurance Exchange, 159 PLJ 35 (Alleg. Co. 2010, Strassburger, J.), in which the Court enforced the carrier’s forum selection clause for a UIM claim and transferred the action to Butler County.

In this case matter, Erie filed Preliminary Objections based upon venue to the Plaintiff’s Complaint. The Erie policy provided that the insured was required to file suit against Erie in the county in which the insured resided. In this case, the insured resided in Butler County.

The Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas determined that Erie’s forum selection clause was valid. Accordingly, the case was transferred to Butler County.

The Allegheny Court also noted that the trial courts in Butler County have ruled that a UIM claim should be severed from the claim against the tortfeasor. As such, the Court in Allegheny County also severed the UIM claim from the claim against the tortfeasor and transferred only the UIM claim to Butler County.

I send thanks to Attorney Tom McDonnell of the Pittsburgh law firm of Summers McDonnell for bringing this case to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Judge Wettick Addresses Parameters of Neurospsych IMEs

I was recently provided with a December 1, 2010 Order and Opinion of Court issued by Judge R. Stanton Wettick of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in the case of Rotunda v. Petruska, No. GD08-018798 (Alleg. Co., 2010, Wettick, J.) in which the Court held that a neuropsychological IME could not be performed in the absence of Plaintiff’s counsel if an objection to that was lodged by the Plaintiff.

Defense counsel had objected that the presence of another persons for the psychological testing would alter the results and may influence the test scores.

Judge Wettick held that the wording of Rule 4010 “is clear” and allows a party the right to have counsel present during the examination. Judge Wettick also allowed the Plaintiff to record the proceeding as allowed by the Rules.


I thank Attorney Andrew L. Braunfeld of the law firm of Masterson, Braunfeld, LLP in Conshohocken, Pennsylvania for forwarding this Opinion to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Issue of Discovery of Prior Similar Incidents

On March 7, 2011, Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas issued an Opinion and Order in the premises liability case of Walsh v. Generations Management Services, LLC, et.al., No. 2009-Civil-5715 (Lacka. Co. March 7, 2011, Nealon, J.) in which the Court ruled on various issues pertaining to the discovery of evidence of prior falls at an assisted living residence.

An action was brought on behalf of a resident who fell at an assisted living residence on several occasions. The claim was that the facility had allegedly not provided proper supervision of its residents and/or training for its staff.

The Plaintiff had inquired whether there have been other similar incidents at the same location as well as at other locations owned by business in the surrounding counties. The Defendant objected to these discovery requests on the grounds that the “information requested is not reasonable calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant evidence.”

When this matter was initially before the Lackawanna County Special Trial Master, the Defendants were ordered to produce responses to these discovery requests for a time frame of seven (7) years prior to the incident and up to the present time.

On appeal up to Judge Nealon, the court reviewed the law pertaining to the discovery of prior incidents and held that the Defendant should be required to produce information relating to prior falls. The Court ruled in this fashion after the Plaintiff’s attorney agreed to narrow the discovery request to prior falls at the facility which required the residents to receive outside medical attention.

Judge Nealon did, however, overrule that part of the discovery order issued by the Special Trial Master requiring the production of information concerning falls which occurred after the date of the Plaintiff’s last fall and up to the present as evidence of subsequent falls could not be used to demonstrate any prior notice or knowledge of any allegedly dangerous condition.

The Court also sustained the defense objection to the Interrogatories seeking information regarding prior falls at other facilities owned by the same Defendants.

In his Opinion, Judge Nealon also addressed the discovery dispute over the requested production of the facility’s quality management plan, emergency medical plan and staff training relative to proper care for residents with dementia or cognitive problems. After noting that the Pennsylvania Code requires these types of facilities to maintain such documentation, the Court held that such information was discoverable regardless of whether the facility at issue was licensed as a personal care home or an assisting living residence.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Judge Polacheck Gartley of Luzerne County Allows Deposition While Preliminary Objections Pending

On March 2, 2011, Judge Tina Polachek Gartley of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas issued an Order in the case of Dunsmuir v. Tredinnick, No. 12077-Civil-2010 (Luz. Co., March 2, 2011, Polachek Gartley, J.) in which the Court addressed the issue of whether or a deposition of a Defendant should be allowed to proceed while Preliminary Objections filed by the Defendant were pending before the Court.

In this decision, the Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel the Defendant’s deposition and the same was granted by the Court. Notably, the Preliminary Objections at issue were not case dispositive.

The prevailing Plaintiff’s attorney in this matter was Michael O’Donnell of the O’Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, Pennsylvania.

As noted, this Decision was by Order only, without any Opinion. However, should anyone desire a copy of this Order, you may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.